River City campaign claims Scots will lose 15 hours of drama
Read more:
It has highlighted how 33 hours of River City have been made across three blocks of production on the show in the space of 12 months in recent years.
BBC Scotland has said it will be 'moving' the £9 million it currently spends on River City into the three new commissions as part of plans to spend £95 million on Scottish drama over the next three years.
BBC Scotland has announced plans to bring River City to an end in the autumn of 2026. (Image: BBC)
Counsels, Grams and The Young Team were announced after the BBC had already confirmed a number of new made-in-Scotland shows, including the crime family drama Mint, Baby Reindeer creator Richard Gadd's new series Half Man, which he will star in opposite Jamie Bell, and psychological thriller, which will see Outlander and Karen Pirie star Lauren Lyle in the lead role.
Equity has hit back at the BBC after being accused of spreading 'mistruths' over the potential impact of the loss of River City.
The actors' union had claimed that the long-running soap had attracted more than half a million viewers on average for each episode and is outperforming other drama series.
BBC Scotland insisted the actual audience figure for River City was just 200,000, and pointed out this is well below the numbers who watched other shows like Shetland, Vigil and Granite Harbour last year.
They have also criticised Equity for suggesting that cast and crew would be imported from England to make the new shows, and insisted they would all involve Scottish writers reflecting Scottish culture and voices.
However Equity Scotland official Marlene Curran said BBC Scotland's response to the campaign had merely highlighted a 'refusal to engage with the real issues at play.'
She added: 'Equity's decision to protect jobs, training opportunities and careers in the entertainment industry does not hinge on viewing figures alone.
As we have said from the start, the cancellation of River City will have a disproportionately negative impact on Scottish performers.
'It provides pathways and training opportunities, as well as longer term work, for those who would not be able to enter or sustain a career in an otherwise precarious, London-centric, and often exclusionary industry.
'What's more, the hours of programming proposed for the new drama series that are to 'replace' River City pale in comparison.
'On our calculation, a season of River City comprises 33 hours in total (66 episodes x 30 minutes). In contrast, the hours slated for the three proposed new series combined is 18 (6 episodes x 1 hour x 3 series).
'People in Scotland who pay the BBC license fee are therefore losing at least 15 hours of drama – with no guarantee as to what comes after these series end.'
BBC Scotland has criticised Equity for making 'damaging' claims about the new drama series it had announced and insisted it was 'fully committed' to ensuring that Scottish talent would be hired to work on them.
However Equity has highlighted how two of the three companies making the new dramas are based in London.
Ms Curran said: 'We have had no guarantee from BBC Scotland that they will provide a similar number of training opportunities or jobs as the current level offered by River City.
'As part of its public broadcasting duties, as outlined in the Royal Charter, the BBC has a duty to 'to reflect, represent and serve the diverse communities of all of the United Kingdom's nations and regions.'
'We fail to see how the closure of River City lives up to this duty.'
A spokesperson for BBC Scotland said: "As we have always made clear, the decision to end River City is a creative one driven by changing audience habits and declining viewing figures, which have dropped to an average of 200,000 per episode, considerably lower than other BBC dramas.
"Audience patterns have shifted away from long-running serials to short-run dramas so that is where we will be moving our drama investment.
'We are clear that we will be making fewer hours of drama, despite spending more on it.
"However, this is in line with audience expectations - making shorter-run, higher-impact content which attracts larger audiences than long-running formats like River City.
"Due to the complex production requirements of these dramas, the number of weeks cast and crew are employed are often similar – and sometimes greater - as the longer-running formats.
'The BBC in Scotland is open for business and remains committed to reflecting Scottish voices in drama. This is about value for money for the audience. We are not cutting our drama spend in Scotland – in fact, we will increase it to around £95m over the next three years.
'As previously stated, River City training opportunities will remain active for another year until we cease production in April 2026.
"We are actively working with BBC colleagues, the independent companies making our newly announced dramas and others in the industry on future training opportunities.'
BBC Scotland said it was "standard practice" for dramas to be commissioned on a series-by-series basis.
Its spokeswoman added: "The ambition is always to have a returning brand should the audience demand it.
"All companies producing our three new dramas – Counsels, Grams, The Young Team - have Scottish bases and Scottish based senior editorial figures. All shows have Scottish senior creatives.
"Many Scottish companies have HQs elsewhere including BBC Studios who make River City who have their HQ in London. All lead writers on our new dramas are Scottish.
"It's too early to talk about production teams as they haven't crewed up, but these shows will meet the Ofcom criteria.
"The Scottish drama scene and Scottish drama crews are hugely respected both locally and globally so the plan will be to draw on that local expertise for these new shows.
"Scotland makes multiple drama series a year employing multiple Scottish freelancers and this will continue through the new and returning titles."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
a few seconds ago
- The Guardian
MasterChef contestant edited out after asking for new series not to be broadcast
A contestant from the latest series of MasterChef has been edited out of the programme, after telling its producers she did not want the show to be broadcast after sustained allegations made against presenters Gregg Wallace and John Torode. Sarah Shafi, from Leeds, said she had made it clear to the show's producers that airing it would send the wrong message about the treatment of women and the lack of challenge to powerful men behaving inappropriately. The presenters feature almost throughout the series, which was filmed at the end of last year. Both have since been dropped from the programme. Shafi said she initially rejected an offer by MasterChef's producers Banijay to edit her out of her episode. The 57-year-old agreed to be removed once the BBC announced they had decided to broadcast the series from 6 August. 'I didn't say edit me out,' she said. 'I said: 'Axe the show, don't air the show. I'm asking you not to air the show.' Prominent figures have been abusing their power. What message does that send out to women? 'For me, it's about the enabling environment. It's that complicity. Those individual powerful men do not [act] in isolation. There is an enabling environment, turning a blind eye … It's about years of these institutions not being accountable.' Wallace was dropped by the BBC after an independent report substantiated 45 allegations made against him, including claims of inappropriate sexual language and one incident of unwelcome physical contact. He has apologised 'for any distress caused', but said the report cleared him of 'the most serious and sensational accusations'. John Torode was also dropped as a presenter after he said he was the subject of a substantiated complaint over the use of racist language, which he believes never happened. Shafi, a leadership and management development partner for St John Ambulance, said she came from a 'family of foodies' and had entered the programme as a tribute to her late mother, who was a pioneering Indian cookery teacher. Once the allegations against Wallace emerged, Shafi told Banijay she was against the programme being broadcast. It culminated in 'quite a heated conversation' with a producer. She said she was urged to think about the life-changing opportunity the show provided to some contestants. Shafi was then told about the 'potential solution' to edit her out of the programme. 'I was flabbergasted, because in what way was that a solution – and a solution for whom?' Shafi said. 'My point was not about me not being associated with it. My point was about the institutional enabling environment. I said I am completely against this airing of the show. I object to it strongly. This is the principle I'm standing by. I'm objecting to the show being aired, not about me being in it.' She agreed to be edited out once the BBC publicly confirmed the series would be shown. When the BBC announced the decision to press ahead with the series, it acknowledged 'not everyone will agree' and that doing so 'in no way diminishes our view of the seriousness of the upheld findings against both presenters'. Shafi said: 'While the BBC are signalling how life changing, for the better, this could be for some contestants – I'd say top 10 at most – where is the respect for how life changing, for the worse, it has been for the victims? 'What I suggested to them was: 'Why don't you do a special show dedicated to these people that excludes those prominent figures – but it focuses on the talent?'' The BBC reiterated its decision to air the series was not an easy one. 'Banijay consulted with all the contestants before that decision was made and there was widespread support for it going ahead,' it said. 'We are sorry that this contestant does not support the decision and we are grateful she raised this with both the BBC and Banijay.' A Banijay UK spokesperson said: 'We are sorry that Sarah does not support the decision to air this series of MasterChef. We carefully considered her concerns about broadcasting the series and discussed them with the BBC. However, having consulted with all contributors in the series ahead of the decision being made, the resounding feeling from those taking part was support for airing the series.'
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Scott Mills helps drag Radio 2 to record low listening figures
Radio 2's breakfast show has lost more than 600,000 listeners since Scott Mills took over from Zoe Ball, new figures show. The decline has contributed to the BBC station falling to its lowest audience since records began, dipping below 13 million overall listeners for the first time. When Ball presented her final breakfast show at the end of last year, her audience was 6.8 million. And according to the latest set of figures from RAJAR, the industry body, Mills now has 6.2 million listeners. Radio 2's overall audience for the second quarter of 2025 has fallen to 12.6 million – 487,000 down on the previous quarter and 699,000 down on the same period last year. The year-on-year drop equates to more than 5 per cent of the station's listenership. Meanwhile, independent Boom Radio, set up four years ago to cater for listeners who no longer felt served by Radio 2, now has 711,000 listeners, up 14 per cent on this time last year and a new record for the station. Despite the drop in audience figures, Radio 2 remains Britain's most popular radio station, and its controller said she was happy with the latest figures. Helen Thomas, the head of Radio 2, said: 'I'm hugely proud that in a quarter where Radio 2 shone a light on Eurovision, celebrated Elaine Paige's 60 years in show business, launched the RHS Radio 2 Dog Garden at the Chelsea Flower Show, and presented a VE Day 80 concert, Radio 2 firmly remains the UK's most listened-to single radio station, with an audience of 12.6 million each week. 'Congratulations to Scott Mills, whose Breakfast Show remains the number one breakfast show in the country with 6.2 million listeners, and to Vernon Kay, whose weekday mid-morning show continues to be the most listened-to programme on UK radio, with a weekly audience of 6.6 million.' Kay's 6.6 million listeners still represent a big fall from the 8.2 million who tuned in when the mid-morning slot was occupied by Ken Bruce. Ball once earned over £1m Mills began hosting Radio 2's breakfast show in January after Ball quit, saying that after six years it was time 'to step away from the very early mornings and focus on family'. Ball was second only to Gary Lineker in the BBC pay list, taking home £955,000 in her final year on breakfast. She was originally paid £1.36m but took a pay cut following a public outcry. Mills' last reported salary was £360,000, but that figure is expected to be higher next year when it takes into account a full 12 months on the breakfast show. While the audience for Radio 4 and its flagship Today programme remain stable, Radio 3 has registered a startling decline. Since April, when the schedule was shaken up, the total audience has fallen from 2.1 million to 1.9 million. The audience for Radio 3's breakfast show fell by 20 per cent after veteran presenter Petroc Trelawny left and was replaced by Tom McKinney, who previously hosted Sunday Breakfast. The ratings for the morning show have fallen from 798,000 to 639,000 in three months.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Destination X review: Rob Brydon's star vehicle is a bus
*** It has been called the new Traitors, but what hasn't? The BBC hit has generated so many wannabes, I half expect Songs of Praise to be next for a Traitors makeover. In the meantime, here's Destination X, a blend of game show, coach trip and geography lesson. What will they think of next, sighs the viewer. Rob Brydon took the Claudia role, welcoming the 13 contestants to an airport in Baden-Baden. After a Traitors-style quick fire elimination round, the ten remaining were introduced to the luxury coaches that will be their home for the duration. Though kitted out nicely enough, a coach is a coach (with an inevitably small, shared toilet). Not quite The Traitors HQ at Ardross Castle. Players are given a series of clues and at the end of each episode have to guess where they are. The person furthest away is sent home. Whoever is left at the end of the ten weeks scoops a very nice £100,000. Take that, Race Across the World with your measly 20 grand. It sounds easy enough given a basic knowledge of geography, but there's a catch. Of course there is. Producers control what the players see via goggles that go on and off and coach windows that switch from opaque to clear. There's some faffing in a big box besides, plus shoals of red herrings, and a dash of Traitors-like skulduggery. To be fair, Destination X, a hit in its native Belgium, is not just The Traitors on wheels. There are so many other competitive reality shows referenced, from Race Across the World and Coach Trip, to Big Brother and Challenge Anneka, it would be wrong to single out just one. Every reality show relies on a few 'characters' emerging from the mix. Among the contenders here are a London cabbie who has climbed Kilimanjaro and rowed the Atlantic but who took 14 years to do The Knowledge; a nuclear engineer; a pilot; a historian; and a multiple-marathon runner. No Scottish accents in case you were wondering. Read more Deborah the crime writer, 62, was looking good till it emerged she doesn't like lying. Once the friendliness of the first week is over, that could prove a drawback. Dawn, a 34-year-old care assistant from Northern Ireland, whose prep for the series was buying a children's atlas from TK Maxx for a fiver, could be one to watch. It wasn't much of a vote of confidence in the show when one of the younger contestants, Mahdi, quit because he was missing his home-cooked meals back in Tottenham. Will there be others? Not if Brydon has anything to do with it. Though sporting a navy blazer, the Gavin & Stacey star went full Butlins Redcoat early doors and did not let up. He's a naturally friendly sort, so there are no mountains of likability to climb. How different it would be if the producers had opted for Steve Coogan, Brydon's oppo in the sublime The Trip. Now that would be a trip.
