DHL ordered to pay redundancy over transfer requiring five-hour work commute
The
Workplace Relations Commission (WRC)
has upheld a complaint under the Redundancy Payments Act 1967 against DHL Supply Chain Limited by stock picker Oscar Solano Fernandez, who lost his job of 15 years after bosses decided to shut down and sell off a warehouse in Clondalkin.
A senior HR manager in DHL had denied keeping workers 'nominally in employment' when the warehouse closed in a bid to 'avoid' paying staff their statutory redundancies.
Mr Solano told a hearing the alternative job offered by the company at a Tesco distribution centre near Donabate in north county Dublin was a two-bus journey which could take between 90 minutes and 2.5 hours each way from his home in the Coombe.
READ MORE
He had previously been able to get to his former workplace at Oak Road in Clondalkin by bus in 15 to 20 minutes, he told the WRC, adding the new commute required of him would interfere with his family life.
'I don't have nothing against DHL; they gave me a chance to work with them but I didn't want to be spending two, three hours per day going to and back from work,' Mr Solano said.
Mr Solano, originally from Madrid, said he came to Ireland in 2005 with a former girlfriend.
Peter Spencer, a DHL human resources manager, said in evidence that when client Argos announced it was pulling out of Ireland shortly after DHL announced the sale of the Clondalkin site
, it became 'unviable to look for a property in south Dublin'.
DHL moved to make 37 out of 40 warehouse staff 'wholly or mainly associated' with the Argos contract redundant, he said.
Following negotiations with trade union Siptu, others, including Mr Solano, were offered transfers to locations within 50km of the Clondalkin site and a relocation package consisting of a bonus payment of €1,000 and €5,000 worth of Perx vouchers spread over three years, he said.
Barrister Paul Maier, for Mr Solano put it to Mr Spencer that 'part of the motivation for keeping people nominally in employment was to avoid paying redundancy'.
'We'd absolutely dispute that point,' Mr Spencer said.
Niamh Ní Cheallaigh of Ibec, for DHL, argued that the company did not breach Mr Solano's contract of employment.
'No redundancy situation arose and there was suitable alternative work; that's demonstrated by the fact that 112 people did relocate. Everyone was treated the same – of those who transferred, 52 had children,' she said.
Adjudication officer Brian Dalton found the relocation proposed for Mr Solano was 'not reasonable' and ruled his complaint under the Redundancy Payments Act 1967 to be 'well founded'.
Mr Solano was 'entitled to a redundancy payment' based on his weekly wages of €580 and more than 15 years' service. Mr Maier had told the tribunal the statutory redundancy package due to his client was worth over €18,000.
Two other complaints were dismissed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a minute ago
- Irish Times
More than half of Irish estate agents see house prices levelling off soon
Irish home prices are expected to rise by a further 5 per cent over the next 12 months, amid ongoing supply shortages, according to a survey of estate agent members of the Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland (SCSI). Joe Brennan reports on the predicted growth. However, 60 per cent of those polled see prices levelling off soon, with a further 18 per cent saying that they have already peaked – after a dozen years of continuous growth. Joe Brennan also reports on Goodbody Stockbrokers making a number of senior hires in a bid to boost the business. A number of staff left the organisation's investment banking area in late 2023, during and after a redundancy programme. Among the appointments is Stephen Kane, a former corporate finance director with the firm, who left in October 2023 for householder Cairn Homes. READ MORE In her latest column, Pilita Clark writes about the really concerning thing about the Coldplay concert scandal. This scandal, of course, concerns the former CEO of tech company Astronomer, who was caught with his arms wrapped around the company's head of human resources. Their embrace was captured on the big screen at the band's concert in Boston and has gone viral. Pilita Clark addresses the barrage of fabricated online statements purporting to be from those with insight. 'Some governments are trying to legislate against this muck, notably in the EU. The Coldplay couple — and the misleading maelstrom that followed their exposure — are a reminder that many more authorities need to join them,' she says. The co-founder of Dublin restaurant group Kinara and president of the Restaurant's Association of Ireland, Seán Collender, revealed the details of the impact of rising input costs that are leaving hospitality businesses on 'an extremely fine line'. 'These are huge, huge costs and we don't sell gold bars, we sell food,' he told Hugh Dooley. We need to enact a specific legal mandate, in the overriding national interest, to drive forward critical projects and avoid the endless round of planning applications, appeals and judicial reviews. Had we done that for the metro, it would have been finished a decade ago, writes John FitzGerald in his weekly column. 'But unless the planning system is reformed, I'm unlikely during my lifetime to ride the metro or drink Shannon water from my tap,' he says. How will the updated National Development Plan shape Ireland in years to come? Listen | 35:59 In 2025, it is both remarkable and disappointing that progress in tackling the gender gap in leadership is taking a backwards step in Ireland, with a 24.8 per cent year-on-year drop in women hired into top jobs here. There are no women leading any of the major Irish companies listed on stock markets, writes Sue Duke , vice-president of global public policy at LinkedIn, in our Business Opinion slot. If you would like to read more about the issues that affect your finances, sign up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
Irish Times
31 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Every Irish person contributes €53.20 a month to the EU. We should be prepared to pay more
The European Commission's publication of its draft of the union's €2 trillion 2028-2034 budget, the Multiannual Financial Framework ( MFF ), once again opens up a tortuous two years of likely acrimonious budget negotiations. Twenty seven states and the European Parliament must unanimously agree – in talks as complicated as four-dimensional chess – a new package of political imperatives, from defence, immigration, climate change, industrial innovation and inflation to safeguarding historic programmes such as CAP and cohesion. By all appearances, this will be an utterly impossible reconciliation. Helping to steer a path towards it will be the onerous central challenge of next year's Irish presidency . And complicating that challenge for cash-strapped Dublin negotiators will be a plethora of threats to programmes that are particularly important to us to us – CAP; changes to delivery mechanisms; new demands such as defence; and arguments about the scale of increasing burdens on budget net contributors. In truth, according to Zsolt Darvas from think tank Bruegel , MFF spending needs to double to finance the climate transition and pay off its Covid-19 debts. His views echo those in an important report last year from former Italian prime minister Mario Draghi, calling for an additional €800 billion a year of private- and public-sector investment to revive Europe's economic competitiveness. READ MORE The commission's budget is more modest, some €1.816 trillion (plus €165 billion in pandemic recovery debt repayments), up from the current 1.1 per cent of union gross national income to 1.15 per cent. And all at a time when member states are all adamant they will not pay a penny more, although commission president Ursula von der Leyen insists unconvincingly their contributions do not need to go up. [ The Irish Times view on the EU budget: major barriers to getting an agreement Opens in new window ] Irish farmers should be pleased to see direct income payments to farmers ring-fenced. However, agricultural economists here worry that rural development and environmental support payments are to be hived off into a broader regional fund pot and are likely to be squeezed – similar to the cohesion fund for poorer regions, which was once an important Irish staple. MEPs from the regions are also already screaming blue murder at the 'renationalisation' or centralisation of regional funding – 27 national plans would replace more than 500 current programmes. They are alarmed it would substantially reduce regional autonomy and funding which makes up more than one-third of the current budget. Von der Leyen's juggling trick also involves fancy footwork in respect of expanding the union's 'own resources' – or funding from non-member state sources. Such taxation needs to be targeted so that it does not impinge on the domestic tax base and revenues of governments. Most controversially this time is the suggestion of levying a tax on companies with a net annual turnover of at least €100 million. This is expected to generate only €6.8 billion but is already facing determined opposition. Speaking like an Irish finance minister, Germany's chancellor Friedrich Merz has warned that 'there is no question of the EU taxing companies, as the EU has no legal basis for this'. Other proposed new 'own resources' include taxes targeting electric waste (around €15 billion annually), tobacco products/companies (€11.2 billion), a carbon border tax (€1.4 billion), and a tax on revenues generated by emissions trading (€9.6 billion). EU capitals will also worry how the new budget would affect the politically sensitive difference between national contributions and receipts. [ Proposed €2tn EU budget would increase funding for defence Opens in new window ] From 1973 to 2018 Ireland was a net recipient, in nominal terms, of more than €40 billion in EU funds. By 2023, 10 countries, including Ireland, were net contributors, and 17 were net beneficiaries. Top of the net contributors were Germany (€19.8 billion), France (€9.3 billion), with Ireland in eighth place (€1.3 billion). Poland was the top net beneficiary, receiving €7.1 billion. Ireland was second in net contribution per head, at €240 per person. Courtesy of our growing relative wealth (measured dubiously by 'GDP per cap') we displaced Luxembourg in 2024 in paying the most to the EU budget on a gross per capita basis – with every Irish person contributing some €53.20 a month to the union's coffers compared to the EU average of €25.20 and Germans' €29.70. Bulgarians contributed €10.70 a month. Net cash contributions have been seized on by many national politicians and the press as evidence that the countries of the supposedly indolent south are unfairly milking the system at the expense of fiscally responsible northerners. But the real benefits of membership to the countries of the north amount to far more than can be measured by such direct transfer figures. Apart from the progressive aims of redressing EU-wide economic imbalances, helping poorer neighbours and levelling the playing field, the EU provides huge indirect and non-cash benefits disproportionately to net contributing members such as Ireland. These include financial rewards from the European Central Bank in maintaining financial stability and financial returns, valuable access to the single market and research grants through the Horizon programme. Making the political case for increasing our contribution yet again will not be easy but it must be done.
Irish Times
31 minutes ago
- Irish Times
I got braces for €3,800 in 2018 - looking back, it still was worth it
Are you a saver or a spender? Some months of the year, I am a saver, but other months, like summertime and around Christmas, I end up on more of the spender side. I am good at organising my money for upcoming things such as holidays, birthdays and allocating €100 here and €100 there. What was the first job you ever received money for, and how much were you paid? I started working in a fast-food chain when I was 16. I worked Saturday and Sunday, taking on more hours during the summer and school holidays. I believe I started at €7.50 per hour, and I think I worked about six hours per shift. Do you shop around for better value? Absolutely. I am better at shopping around for services rather than goods. I monitor my electricity and phone/wifi bill, but with year-long contracts or sometimes two-year contracts, it's not as often. READ MORE I would always check car insurance and review insurance policies annually. With shopping around, I would generally review three to four places for services before purchasing, if I had the time to weigh up the cost. With goods like clothing, shoes, and so on, I find I am usually last minute, which leads me to pay the first price I see. What has been your most extravagant purchase ever, and how much did it cost? I got braces in 2018, and the cost was €3,800. The instalment payment plan didn't have any additional charges, so I didn't have to hand over a lump sum. I look back now, and I still think it was worth it. I mind my teeth and love my smile, so I can still justify the price. What purchase have you made that you consider the best value for money? My car. I have a Ford Focus, and it wasn't an extravagant purchase, relatively speaking. I've had the same car for three years and don't have the desire to upgrade. I'm happy to keep the Focus going until she stops. [ All's fair in love, war and the Rose of Tralee Opens in new window ] Is there anything you regret spending money on? Back in 2018, I bought a particular phone brand new. I think it cost me over €800. I got caught up with having the newest model, and I think I justified it to myself because I used my phone for both personal and work use. I remember paying for it online and instantly thinking, 'Oh, I don't think I should have done that.' Do you haggle over prices? The only time I'm likely to haggle is on holidays at markets. I've got nice deals that way in the past, and I feel less self-conscious about it because it's all good fun. Do you invest in shares and/ or cryptocurrency? I don't invest in individual shares or cryptocurrency. I invest through a savings or pension plan as part of an investment fund. Even with long-term planning, cryptocurrency is too volatile and hard to predict. I prefer to have a clear view of where my money is going and what my expected return will be. Do you have a retirement or pension plan? I started paying into a pension at the beginning of my career. I am fortunate to also have an employer contribution, which helps to increase the amount going in. I think starting a pension at a younger age takes a lot of pressure off when it comes to busier stages in life. Once you get used to the initial amount you are saving, and your net balance is for everything else, it's easy to increase by small amounts. [ 'How we saved €100k in four years' Opens in new window ] What was the last thing you bought, and was it good value for money? It was food from a supermarket. I bought a chicken to cook for a roast dinner. It was €6 and I made roast potatoes, carrots, broccoli and stuffing. It probably wasn't the greatest value, because there was a cooked chicken on sale in the same shop for €7. Had I purchased it, I would have saved on time and electricity. That said, it was delicious! Have you ever successfully saved up for a relatively big purchase? I am currently in the middle of saving for a wedding. It's crazy when you sit down and look at all the things that you need, the things you don't need but would like, and the things that people tell you are needed. I've set a budget that I am determined not to exceed. Have you ever lost money? I don't think I have ever lost a large sum of money. Are you a gambler, and if so, have you ever had a big win? I wouldn't call myself a gambler – now and then for the craic, but it wouldn't form part of my normal routine. [ Are you living beyond your means? You may have money dysmorphia Opens in new window ] What is your best habit when it comes to money? And your worst? My best habit is budgeting. I know what it costs each month to run my household, and I consider the one-off expenses that happen every now and then. I use Revolut Pockets for petrol and groceries, so the money goes in there and I can keep track. I am very organised when it comes to budgeting, and at this stage it feels like second nature. In the beginning, it was hard to remember, but it just takes practice. My worst money habit is what I spend on takeaways. There are some weeks when I could spend €100 on takeaways. I get cross with myself because I know it's a waste and comes about through moments of laziness. How much money do you have on you now? In my pocket I have €23.45, which is change from getting milk, bread and essentials in the shop. Leah McMahon will represent Limerick at this year's Rose of Tralee festival. The event takes place from Friday, August 15th to Tuesday, August 19th and will be broadcast on RTÉ One.
