Hospital security bill soars to R2.5bn amid patient care crisis
The Democratic Alliance (DA) has voiced concern over soaring security costs at Gauteng public hospitals, which have skyrocketed from R655 million in 2022 to R2.54 billion in 2025 — nearly quadrupling in just three years.
According to DA Gauteng Shadow Health MEC Jack Bloom, the rising security expenditure is diverting much-needed funds from critical healthcare services.
'This squeezes out money needed to improve patient care,' said Bloom in a statement on Monday.
Multi-million rand contracts under scrutiny
Gauteng Health MEC Nomantu Nkomo-Ralehoko revealed in a written reply to the provincial legislature that the increase is due to 'additional points of service provision' and higher rates regulated by the Private Security Industry Regulatory Authority (PSIRA).
However, Bloom questioned the justification, noting that PSIRA's annual rate increase stands at only 7.38%, far below the near six-fold rise in overall security spending.
'As a percentage of the total Gauteng health budget, security costs have gone up from 1.1% in 2022 to 3.8% of this year's allocation of R66 billion,' he pointed out.
Security bills for major hospitals are among the highest. Chris Hani Baragwanath, Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg, and Bertha Gxowa hospitals are paying R77 million, R72 million, and R26 million respectively to private security firms each year.
In response to Bloom's inquiry, the department stated: 'The security assessment report conducted justifies the additional increase in the number of guards, and it is in line with the PSIRA rates.'
ALSO READ: Mpumalanga primary school pupils treated for food poisoning after eating oranges
Guards unpaid despite soaring costs
Despite these massive outlays, some security workers are not being paid on time. At Tembisa Hospital, guards have gone on a go-slow, protesting after not being paid for three months.
At George Mukhari Hospital, Mafoko Security Patrollers recently lost a court case over failing to pay provident fund contributions.
Similar allegations have surfaced at Bertha Gxowa Hospital, where workers claim deductions are not reaching the required funds.
Although the department insists it uses 'a monthly performance monitoring tool to ensure that security workers are paid on time and according to legislation,' Bloom said, 'this does not appear to be effective.'
ALSO READ: Hospital horror: Cops in frantic search for two premature babies snatched from incubators
Calls for accountability
Bloom suspects widespread corruption.
'Many security companies seem to be grossly over-charging while underpaying their workers,' he said.
The DA has vowed to continue pushing the provincial health department to review the escalating costs.
'Hospital patients suffer because of a lack of budget to fix staff shortages, long queues, and broken equipment,' Bloom warned.
The Citizen has contacted the Gauteng Department of Health for further comment but had not received a response at the time of publication.
NOW READ: Suspect allegedly confesses to Tembisa Hospital fire
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
11-07-2025
- The Citizen
Polokwane wastewater crisis: E. coli levels 1000x above limit
Quick read: The Polokwane Municipality's wastewater treatment plants are discharging dangerously high levels of untreated sewage into the Sand and Blood rivers. E. coli levels recorded at 385,000 CFU/100ml, nearly 1,000 times above the acceptable limit. Infrastructure overload: The Polokwane WWTW is designed for 26ML/day but receives 65ML daily, with over 70ML of non-compliant effluent released into rivers. Vegetation die-off and decomposed fish are now common along the riverbanks. Upcoming Sand River North Project may worsen the crisis by adding 18ML more wastewater to an already overwhelmed system. The Regional Wastewater Treatment Works (RWWTW) site has been abandoned, with contractors unpaid since April. The DA has lodged criminal charges and engaged the Human Rights Commission, calling for urgent national intervention. Full story POLOKWANE – The ongoing discharge of dangerously high levels of untreated wastewater into the Sand and Blood rivers from the Polokwane Municipality's wastewater treatment works (WWTW) has now escalated to a stage where dying vegetation on the banks of the river and decomposed fish are a common sight. This crisis, caused by failing municipal wastewater treatment infrastructure, poses a severe threat to public health, the environment and local livelihoods as some of the more than 200 boreholes that the municipality utilises to augment its water resources, are fed from the underground water coming from the rivers. You might also want to read: Commission labels Polokwane's wastewater plants defunct According to DA caucus leader in the municipality, Johan Retters, they recently submitted water samples from both rivers to independent, accredited laboratories for analysis following ongoing concerns from local communities and environmental stakeholders. The results have now confirmed what residents have long feared – the Polokwane, Seshego and Mankweng WWTW have recorded E. coli levels at an alarming 385,000 CFU/100ml – nearly 1 000 times the acceptable limit of 400 CFU/100ml. The Polokwane WWTW is designed to process 26 megalitres of effluent per day but this is currently overloaded with an inflow of 65 megalitres daily, surpassing July 2023's readings by 20 megalitres. Investigations have further revealed that more than 70 megalitres of non-compliant sewage effluent are being discharged into these rivers daily. You might also want to read: Water pollution: Complaint filed The situation is exacerbated by the impending commissioning of the Sand River North Project, expected to introduce an additional 18 megalitres of wastewater into a system that is already critically overburdened and non-compliant, according to Retters. 'The environmental consequences are dire. The Sand River's biodiversity has been decimated, with reports of mass fish die-offs and contaminated borehole water. What makes matters worse is during an oversight visit conducted on July 1, DA councillors discovered that the construction site of the Regional Waste Water Treatment Works (RWWTW), located approximately 10km north of the city along the Sand River, was completely abandoned. The site, intended to address critical wastewater challenges in the region, showed no signs of activity. Upon further enquiry, it was revealed that contractors had not been paid since April and consequently vacated the project,' Retters said. He added that this revelation is deeply concerning, as the prolonged delay in completing this essential infrastructure poses a severe environmental and public health risk. Wastewater from the city continues to place pressure on an already overwhelmed system, threatening to contaminate water sources such as the Sand River. You might also want to read: Wastewater: DA approaches the Human Rights Commission The DA has escalated the matter to the South African Human Rights Commission in July 2022 and lodged criminal charges in March 2023 against city manager, Thuso Nemugumoni, for failing in her statutory duty to prevent the continued pollution. On June 22, DA provincial leader Lindy Wilson, met with the Deputy Minister of Water and Sanitation, Isaac Seitholo in Polokwane to raise alarm over the dire state of water and sewerage services in the municipality. This intervention follows months of persistent neglect by the Polokwane Municipality, and the DA has called on national government to step in to prevent a full-scale environmental and humanitarian disaster. In a related event, a group of concerned residents along the Sand River, on Friday held a meeting to raise their concerns about the situation and resolved to escalate the matter to higher authorities. The event was coordinated by TLU (SA) Limpopo. The municipality was requested to comment but no response was available at time of going to print. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
The Citizen
09-07-2025
- The Citizen
No operational air monitors in KZN, confirms EDTEA
The KwaZulu-Natal government has admitted that none of the province's six air quality monitoring stations are currently operational. In a startling revelation on July 1, the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Economic Development, Tourism and Environmental Affairs (EDTEA) confirmed that all six of the province's air quality (AQ) monitoring stations – including the one at the iLembe Auditorium in KwaDukuza – are offline. The disclosure came in response to formal parliamentary questions submitted by the Democratic Alliance (DA), raising serious concerns about public health and environmental governance. EDTEA said the stations have been non-functional for an extended period due to a lack of funding. According to the DA, this leaves communities exposed to unmonitored air pollution. Even more troubling, the department also admitted it has not conducted any studies or assessments on the health impacts of poor air quality on residents. The DA condemned this as a 'gross dereliction of duty,' accusing successive administrations of allowing the monitoring system to collapse. Neither EDTEA nor the iLembe District Municipality provided comment. 'Without data, there can be no accountability, and without accountability, communities will continue to suffer needlessly,' said DA KZN spokesperson on environmental affairs, Hannah Lidgett. According to EDTEA, only three of the six monitoring stations – including iLembe – are scheduled for repair in the 2025/26 financial year. The remaining three will not be addressed until 2026/27. The department has pointed to its newly approved Air Quality Management Plan as a framework for future health impact assessments. However, the DA argues the timeline is too slow and the damage already done is immeasurable. The Dolphin Coast Residents and Ratepayers Association (Docrra) has gone further, describing the failure as a breach of citizens' Constitutional rights. Docrra environmental subcommittee chairperson Brian Pottinger said the association had previously alerted iLembe to the situation. 'We pointed out to iLembe that the non-functioning AQ monitors breach citizens' Constitutional rights. They say they are waiting for funds,' said Pottinger. 'That is why we support private initiatives like Communities Against Pollution, which monitor air quality to identify sources of pollution and bring them to the authorities' attention. We have sponsored two monitors and approved two more.' Stay in the loop with The North Coast Courier on Facebook, X, Instagram & YouTube for the latest news. Mobile users can join our WhatsApp Broadcast Service here or if you're on desktop, scan the QR code below. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
The Citizen
04-07-2025
- The Citizen
Missing and suspended HODs cripple Mpumalanga government
Senior Mpumalanga officials face allegations of fraud, mismanagement and unauthorised absences. A view of the landscape on road R532 near Sabie in Mpumalanga. Picture: Grobler du Preez / iStock The Mpumalanga provincial administration has been hit by a series of absences by heads of departments (HOD) – several of whom are on suspension while at least one HOD absconded for almost two months without trace. The absence of HODs, who are responsible for running the day-to-day administration of each department, may cripple the province and render it unable to deliver services to communities. Instead of abating, the situation is getting worse as two HODs are on suspension pending disciplinary processes, while one official is apparently afraid to come to work because of threats from union members. Experts warn of governance collapse Experts are concerned about the situation, saying if Mpumalanga is serious about fighting corruption and improving service delivery, it must deal with corrupt and unruly HODs. Political analyst Goodenough Mashego said the Mpumalanga government is on autopilot because the HODs are accounting officers. Call for lifestyle audits, accountability Annerie Weber, a DA member in the Mpumalanga legislature, said yesterday for the fact three HODs are being investigated for corruption – while two are accused of staying away from work without permission – indicates that something needs to be done to prevent the province from collapsing. 'The HOD of agriculture has been at home for more than seven weeks without a proper doctor's letter. But the salary doesn't stop being paid for no work done,' said Weber. ALSO READ: Mpumalanga silent on 21 000 missing HIV patients She said the officials are responsible for the health of the province and to care for the people. 'Their mandate is to deliver services. Personal issues cannot and should not have an impact on the delivery of services to the most vulnerable people,' she said. 'The HOD of education Lucy Moyane is also on suspension. She is being investigated over procurement irregularities. The HOD of sport, arts and culture Godfrey Ntombela has also been suspended due to the alleged mismanagement of Covid funds.' Weber said other affected departments are public works, human settlements, community safety and liaison. She said during a recent sitting of the legislature, the DA introduced a debate calling on premier Mandla Ndlovu and his administration to urgently conduct lifestyle audits on all departmental and municipal officials. Longstanding culture of 'cronyism' and 'corruption' Senior politician Themba Godi said the Mpumalanga government has a 'longstanding reputation of having officials who are utterly corrupt'. 'For the longest of times we haven't heard the premier of Mpumalanga condemning corruption or talking about ethical governance,' said Godi. ALSO READ: 13 killed, scores injured in Mpumalanga and KZN accidents 'Cronyism has been embedded at all levels of government in this province; recent findings of the public protector on the employment of officials in the Bushbuckridge municipality are merely the tip of the iceberg. 'There has been no culture of good governance in Mpumalanga, going back to the times of Ndaweni Mahlangu. A fish rots from the head. 'The current premier is politically and intellectually weak, inspires no confidence and has no track record as a fighter against corruption.' Godi said the conduct of officials reflect on their political bosses who appointed them. He said Mpumalanga is a good example of how 'the more things change the more they stay the same'. Government admits to pending disciplinary processes Mpumalanga provincial government spokesperson George Mthethwa said he could only comment about Moyane and Ntombela's suspension. 'The HODs have been subjected to investigations. They will be going through disciplinary processes.' NOW READ: Mpumalanga school principal suspended for alleged sexual assault
