Bill to amend medically assisted suicide law draws emotional debate from Maine lawmakers
The fate of the bill is unclear after the Senate voted the proposal down 18-17.
It passed 74-64 in the House of Representatives last week and faces another round of votes in each chamber before it could be sent to Gov. Janet Mills for her signature.
The bill would amend a 2019 law known as the Death with Dignity Act, which legalized physician-assisted suicide in Maine. It allows certain terminally ill patients to have the option to receive life-ending medication so they have control over their death.
Maine's law currently requires a 17-day waiting period from when a person requests the medication to when they can receive the prescription. The change under consideration, LD 613, would allow a doctor to waive all or a portion of the waiting period if they determine it would be in the patient's best interest.
Mills supported the original Death with Dignity Act, but it's unclear if she would support the change. Spokespeople for the governor did not respond Monday to questions about whether she has taken a position on the bill.
The proposal allowing for the waiting period to be waived drew emotional debate from lawmakers who spoke about how they've personally been affected by illness and death.
"This is not an abstract issue for me," said Rep. Kathy Javner, R-Chester, who has metastatic breast cancer, during last week's House debate. "I am living this reality and stand before you today, not in despair, but in hope that we can preserve the dignity and meaning of life, even in the shadow of death."
Javner, who was against the change, said removing the waiting period would take away the time that families and physicians currently have to reflect and consider alternative options. "Let us not respond to suffering with surrender," Javner said. "Let us respond with compassion, with presence, with resources for pain management, with palliative care, with love."
Senate Minority Leader Trey Stewart, R-Presque Isle, talked about his mother, who died at age 50 from colorectal cancer, during Monday's Senate debate. Stewart said his mother "broke out" of hospice care in order to be at home with her family at the end of her life. "I will always be grateful for that extra month we got," Stewart said.
"I worry about the scenarios about what if they don't get it right and what opportunities are we forestalling through this," he added. "This was the promise that was made originally with this policy, that there wouldn't be that knee-jerk opportunity because of this protection."
Maine is among 10 states and Washington, D.C., where physician-assisted suicide is legal for people with terminal illnesses, according to Death With Dignity, an organization in Portland, Oregon, that advocates for the laws as a means of improving how people with such diagnoses die.
Waiting periods for medication vary state to state and can range from one day to more than two weeks, according to Death With Dignity. Some states do allow waiting periods to be waived if the patient is unlikely to survive.
Maine's Death with Dignity Act has been used by 218 people since it was enacted, according to Michele Meyer, D-Eliot, the sponsor of LD 613. But another nine people have died during the waiting period because their illnesses progressed too rapidly, Meyer said last week.
She said the bill does not change the law's criteria that the patient be terminally ill with a six-month prognosis confirmed by two doctors and that they have the capacity to make informed decisions.
"This is simple and straight forward," Meyer said. "It corrects a rare situation that never should have existed in the first place. Some of us will not know the gift of a long, healthy life. ... Medical aid in dying offers decisionally capable adults an option to avoid prolonged suffering."
In the Senate Monday, Sen. Tim Nangle, D-Windham, talked about his father's lung cancer and the pain he suffered. Nangle said he didn't know if his father, who lived in another state, would have used the Death with Dignity Act, but he said the option for the time waiver should be there.
"This is about their choice," Nangle said. "What do they want to do?"
Copy the Story Link
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
a few seconds ago
- NBC News
Texas Democrats leave the state in an extraordinary move, and a slow trickle of Gaza aid: Weekend Rundown
In an extraordinary move to counter Republican redistricting in Texas, dozens of Democrats in the state House of Representatives headed to Illinois to deny a necessary quorum for the GOP to move forward with those efforts. The roughly 30 Democrats are expected to stay for the week in a plan brokered with Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker, who met with the Texas caucus late last month and has directed his staff to provide logistical support for their stay. 'We're leaving Texas to fight for Texans,' Texas House Democratic Caucus Chair Gene Wu said in a statement. 'We will not allow disaster relief to be held hostage to a Trump gerrymander. We're not walking out on our responsibilities; we're walking out on a rigged system that refuses to listen to the people we represent. As of today, this corrupt special session is over.' Last week, Texas Republicans released a proposed congressional map that would give the GOP a path to pick up five seats in next year's midterm elections. It followed President Donald Trump's public pressure for a new map in the state as he works to retain a majority in Congress in what historically is a difficult year for the party holding the White House. The proposed map would shift district lines in ways that would target current Democratic members of Congress in and around Austin, Dallas and Houston, as well as two already endangered Democrats representing South Texas districts that Trump carried last year. Food trickles into Gaza, but not enough to stop a famine, aid groups say Humanitarian organizations say the amount of aid that has entered Gaza since Israel said it would pause military action in some areas is insufficient to stop a growing number of Palestinians dying from hunger. Israel has allowed only a limited amount of aid to enter the enclave since it lifted a total blockade this year. Most of the aid has been distributed by the Israel-backed group known as the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, and other humanitarian organizations have said Israeli restrictions have hampered their efforts to distribute aid. 'This is not an adequate response,' Jeanette Bailey, the International Rescue Committee's global practice lead and director of research for nutrition, said in a phone interview. A gradual entry of aid 'here or there,' she said, 'is not going to be adequate to prevent us from entering into a full-blown famine where the numbers of deaths go way, way up.' Hamas sparked outcry in Israel over the weekend when it released video appearing to show a visibly gaunt Israeli hostage alongside images of emaciated Palestinian babies. Meet the Press White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett defended President Donald Trump's decision to fire Bureau of Labor Statistics Commissioner Erika McEntarfer, as well as Trump's claim that weaker-than-expected jobs reports were 'rigged,' but he failed to produce any evidence to support the claim. Hassett said on NBC News' 'Meet the Press' that installing Trump's 'own people' will help achieve more 'transparent and reliable' jobs reports in the future. 'What we need is a fresh set of eyes over the BLS,' Hassett, the director of the National Economic Council, told moderator Kristen Welker. Several Republicans, including Sen. Rand Paul, of Kentucky, questioned the firing. 'We have to look somewhere for objective statistics. When the people providing the statistics are fired, it makes it much harder to make judgments that, you know, the statistics won't be politicized,' Paul told NBC News on Friday. Meanwhile, Sen. Alex Padilla, D-Calif., accused Trump of trying to 'weaponize' labor statistics for his own agenda. Padilla said the Senate would evaluate the 'independence' of a new BLS commissioner when it comes time to confirm a new one. 'When [Trump's] trying to weaponize the Bureau of Labor Statistics, that tells you a lot about their insecurity about the economy and the state of economic affairs,' Padilla told Welker. Politics in brief On a break: As members of Congress prepare to head home for summer recess, Republicans will look to sell the unpopular 'big, beautiful bill' in their home states, while Democrats are working on their big brand problem. Windy City warning: New York mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani's team hopes to avoid the missteps of Chicago's progressive Mayor Brandon Johnson as it works to win in November. Impeached again? The Smithsonian's National Museum of American History will once again mention Trump in an exhibit about presidential impeachments after the removal of a placard noting his two Senate trials sparked concerns. It's a good time to be a nostalgic millennial The Backstreet Boys are playing to sold-out crowds. Lindsay Lohan is starring in a new 'Freaky Friday' movie. And former 'Dawson's Creek' co-stars and exes Katie Holmes and Joshua Jackson were recently spotted filming a new project in New York City. No, it's not the early 2000s — but millennials feel like they're so back. A recent surge in millennial-focused pop culture serves as 'the next level of escapism' for an uncertain generation, said Kate Kennedy, author of 'One in a Millennial: On Friendship, Feelings, Fangirls, and Fitting In.' 'It returns us to a time when our biggest worry was getting in line for a CD, not whether we would be able to afford a house,' Kennedy said. 'I think we're a more lonely and isolated generation as adults than we ever anticipated that we would be in our youth,' she said, adding that millennials 'straddle two very different eras in terms of technology and information.' Notable quote I can't be doing this forever, just waiting for the dust to settle and things to kind of normalize again — I need a job. no match for sluggish hiring — with a bleak labor market, ghosting employers and a 'black hole' into which 1,000 applications can fall unanswered. In case you missed it Amid an ongoing manhunt, authorities warned that Michael Paul Brown, the suspect accused of killing four people Friday in a Montana bar, could return to the town of Anaconda, where the shooting occurred. Officials in Tennessee found 14 improvised explosive devices in a man's home while they were arresting him last week on suspicion of threatening officials. A record crowd of 91,032 for a regular-season Major League Baseball game got to see all the pomp and pageantry with the MLB Speedway Classic before the rain washed out the game itself Saturday. The game resumed Sunday, with the Atlanta Braves beating the Cincinnati Reds 4-2. Two men described as 'associates' of the suspect in a quadruple homicide in Tennessee have been arrested on suspicion of helping the fugitive. Yu Zidi, a 12-year-old Chinese swimmer, has become a global sensation with her history-making times, even as observers and fans back home caution against overhyping the young athlete. Ukraine's anti-corruption bodies say they have uncovered a major graft scheme that procured military drones and signal jamming systems at inflated prices. Reigning 100-meter world champion Sha'Carri Richardson was arrested on allegations that she assaulted her boyfriend at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport.
Politico
16 minutes ago
- Politico
Senators leave Washington without Trump nominees deal
Thune and Minority Leader Chuck Schumer discussed the path forward on the floor before it was formalized, a person granted anonymity to disclose the private conversation said. In a Truth Social message Saturday evening, Trump accused Schumer of 'political extortion' for demanding the release of agency funding that the White House has held back in return for the swift confirmations. Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.) — who, like Mullin, has been involved in the negotiations — said there 'was no deal' and that senators are going to 'work through our [nominees] that we hadn't done yet' and then leave. The decision came after Thune and Schumer made a final round of offers late Saturday afternoon. Republicans accused Democrats of changing their negotiation demands, which Democrats refuted, while Democrats claimed Trump foiled Senate GOP leaders' attempts to reach an agreement. Schumer took his own swipe at Trump, saying in a news conference Saturday night that the president 'threw in the towel, sent Republicans home and was unable to do the basic art of negotiating.' 'He went home with nothing,' he added. Trump held multiple calls with a key group of GOP senators on Saturday, and senior staffers for Thune were in close touch with White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles. 'There were lots of offers being made back and forth, and there were several different times where I think both sides maybe thought there was a deal — but you've got to be able to close it out,' Thune said Saturday night, adding that 'the asks evolved on both sides quite a bit over time.' Shortly before senators decided to leave town, Trump not only offered the scathing critique of Schumer but also signaled to Senate Republicans that they should not accept the contours of the deal senators have been discussing — speeding up dozens of nominations in exchange for the administration unfreezing certain agency funding. The money at the heart of the negotiations circled around foreign aid and the National Institutes of Health, according to two people granted anonymity to disclose private conversations. Democrats had also made a separate offer that would clear the way for confirmations of a second tranche of nominees later this year in exchange for Republicans agreeing not to do another rescissions package clawing back previously approved funding. GOP senators warned they couldn't commit to eschewing additional rescission packages, which only require a simple majority to get through both the House and Senate, and Trump made clear on social media he was not interested in the trade. 'Do not accept the offer, go home and explain to your constituents what bad people the Democrats are, and what a great job the Republicans are doing, and have done, for our Country,' Trump said on Truth Social about the agency funding. 'Have a great RECESS and, MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!!!' Instead, Thune teed up seven final nominees for confirmation votes Saturday night before the recess — starting with Jeanine Pirro, the former New York state judge and Fox News host whom Trump nominated as U.S. attorney in D.C. Pirro was confirmed on a 50-45 party-line vote. The decision to abandon confirmations for a larger portion of the 150-plus pending nominees represents a U-turn from just hours before when Republicans said they wanted a resolution by the end of the day. They were considering whether to cut a deal with Democrats, change the rules to confirm groups of nominees more quickly or adjourning to allow Trump to make temporary 'recess appointments.' Inside a closed-door lunch, Republican senators discussed deploying the 'nuclear option' — that is, changing the rules by a simple majority vote — or formally adjourning, which would let Trump make recess appointments. 'We're stuck on stupid,' said Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas), when asked about the mood. Recess appointments were long considered a nonstarter with much of the Senate Republican conference because it would allow Trump to leapfrog the chamber's advise-and-consent role. But it came back into the conversation as frustrations mounted with the slow pace of confirmations this Congress — and Democrats' demands for allowing more Trump picks through. Thune abandoned the idea Saturday, locking in brief 'pro forma' sessions for the next month, which will prevent Trump from making recess appointments. Republicans now expect to pursue rules changes that would cut down on the amount of time needed to confirm Trump's picks, but only after the summer break ends after Labor Day. It's not clear whether Republicans will pull the trigger as soon as they return in September or wait until after a Sept. 30 government funding deadline, lest the the standoff complicate spending talks. In any case, several GOP senators said they believe an eventual rules change is inevitable. Ideas under discussion include allowing for 'en bloc' votes on groups of nominees, reducing the amount of debate time for mid- and lower-level nominees or possibly getting rid of procedural votes for those lower-level nominees. Republicans are also discussing reducing the number of nominees subject to Senate confirmation. 'What Schumer has done, he's forced this. It's ridiculous that he's doing this,' Mullin said. 'Every action requires an equal reaction.' Schumer, in a floor speech Saturday, defended his party's strategy on Trump's picks, saying that 'historically bad nominees deserve historic levels of scrutiny.' 'I saw the majority leader bring out a chart again today, comparing the situation right now to past nominees from past administrations. What he fails to mention is that we have never seen nominees as flawed, as compromised, as unqualified as we have right now,' Schumer added. Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois, Schumer's No. 2, recounted on Saturday how Republicans have held up Democratic nominees, including leaving a Supreme Court seat vacant. 'When we talk about balance and fairness and reforming the Senate,' he said, 'it goes both ways.'
The Hill
29 minutes ago
- The Hill
Puzder confirmed as US ambassador to EU
Andrew Puzder, a former fast-food chain CEO, was confirmed by the Senate on Saturday as the U.S. ambassador to the European Union (EU). Puzder's confirmation went through in a 53-44 vote, with New Hampshire Sens. Maggie Hassan (D) and Jeanne Shaheen (D) crossing the aisle to vote with most Republicans in support of Puzder. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) voted against Puzder. 'CONFIRMED: @AndyPuzder as Representative of the United States of America to the European Union,' the White House said in a post on the social platform X Saturday. Trump picked Puzder as his selection for ambassador to the EU in January, praising him as steering fast-food chains like Carl's Jr. and Hardee's away from 'serious financial difficulty' and claimed that Puzder will 'do an excellent job' as ambassador. The president's selection of Puzder was the second time that Trump has tapped him for a top role in his administration, following the former restaurant chain executive withdrawing as nominee for Labor secretary during Trump's first term in the face of backlash from Republicans. In 2017, Puzder withdrew his nomination to lead the Labor Department prior to a confirmation hearing, with multiple Republican senators at the time seeming ready to oppose him amid allegations of past spousal abuse and his employment of an undocumented immigrant as a housekeeper. He denied the resurfaced allegations and his former wife retracted the claims.
