TD says €12 dole rise in Budget 'not feasible' as social welfare row deepens
It comes as the coalition is on yet another collision course over whether to increase pension rates and the social welfare rates to the same extent during Budget 2026.
John Paul O'Shea, a Fine Gael TD and Chairman of the powerful Oireachtas Social Protection Committee, stated a €12 dole rise 'will not be feasible' in October's budget as he said there is 'no reason' why people should be on the payment for more than 12 months.
Last week, Tánaiste Simon Harris suggested that he was 'not convinced that you need to see as significant a rise in the dole as you do on the pension, for example, at the time when our country's in full employment and there's lots of supports out there for people getting into work'.
However, speaking in Japan, Taoiseach Micheál Martin warned against creating distinctions and said that Fine Gael had never proposed the idea of differing increases.
This is despite senior Fine Gael sources confirming to the Irish Mirror that it was put forward by then Social Protection Minister Heather Humphreys as an option.
New figures provided to the Irish Mirror by the Department of Social Protection confirmed that 46,940 people had been on Jobseeker's Allowance for more than one year.
Some 9,809 people have been receiving the payment for between two and three years, while 5,066 people have been on Jobseekers for three to four years. Another 2,784 people have been receiving the weekly payment for four to five years.
In total, 13,391 people have been on Jobseekers for more than five years. Of these, 8,487 people have been in receipt of it for more than five years, while 4,904 have been classified as unemployed for a decade or more.
Deputy O'Shea, Fine Gael TD for Cork North-West and chair of the Oireachtas Social Protection Committee, told the Irish Mirror that 'there is no reason why people should be on Jobseekers for longer than 12 months'.
When asked if he agreed with the Tánaiste's suggestion that social protection rates and pensions did not need to be increased at the same rate as part of Budget 2026, he said, 'Absolutely'.
He continued: 'We obviously went and gave everyone on social welfare benefits €12 of [an] increase last year. I don't think that is feasible this year, given the conversations we've had only last week in terms of trying to fund the [third level] student contribution fee as part of Government next year.
'A €1 increase [to social welfare payments] would actually pay for the whole of the entire student contribution fee that's required.
'I don't [know] why we should be prioritising job seekers who are on Jobseekers for over 12 months, and not to mention five years or 10 years, on the basis of the other requirements we have to fund within budget.'
At a press conference on Monday following the Government's Competitiveness Summit, Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers declined to wade into the potential budget clash between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.
He said: '[Social Protection] Minister [Dara] Calleary will obviously examine the different supports that exist in the social protection system and how best to prioritise that in the context of Budget 2026.
'One component is obviously Jobseekers. There's Disability Allowance, Carers and obviously pension supports as well.
'It's within that context that he'll have to assess what the relative increases will be as part of next year's budget.
'But it will be in a different fiscal context than we've seen in previous years, and that means every minister will have to prioritise the increased supports they want to see for different areas that they're responsible for.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
22 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Anti-immigration protest gathers at Leinster House 'demanding' access
A large anti-immigration protest has gathered outside Leinster House and are demanding to be allowed to address the chamber. The protest, organised by failed Kerry election candidate Michelle Keane, marched from the GPO. The front gates to Leinster House have been closed, with protesters gathering right up to where the vehicular entrance is. Workers in Leinster House were encouraged to remove their access badges when leaving the building and advised not to exit via the Kildare Street entrance. Ms Keane wrote to all TDs and Senators on Monday evening advising them of the protest and demanding that it be allowed into Leinster House. The letter, seen by the Irish Mirror, called for 100 people to be let into Leinster House to address politicians. The letter read: 'On Tuesday, July 8 2025, over 100 Irish citizens will march peacefully from the GPO to Leinster House under the banner 'The People's Right to Dissolve the Dail'. 'We are writing to formally demand that you facilitate our entry into Dáil Éireann to allow representatives of the Irish people to speak directly before parliament. 'This is not a symbolic gesture - it is a democratic action grounded in the principle that: 'The Irish Government was established by the Irish people, and it can only be 'disestablished or reformed by the Irish people. "As elected members of the Oireachtas, you have the power and duty to request access through the Superintendent of the Houses of the Oireachtas, and to stand with the people you were elected to serve. We ask that you do so without delay. 'If the Dail is truly the house of the people, it must not be locked against them in their hour of national concern 'A refusal to allow a peaceful, constitutional address by citizens would be a direct violation of the spirit of the Republic, and an abdication of democratic responsibility. 'Let history record where each member of the Oireachtas stood on this day. "We respectfully demand your immediate action to ensure we may enter Leinster House and speak peacefully as citizens of Ireland — united across 32 counties, regardless of background or tradition, in one common goal: national renewal.' On a livestream of the protest, Ms Keane told the crowd that they wanted 'to do this peacefully'. She added: 'We are Irish citizens and we are not going to let ourselves down here today.' She also suggested that a Garda had gone into Leinster House to ask the Superintendent to come out and speak to the crowd. A man could be heard on the video saying, 'There are people ready to go through these gates.' Barriers are usually set up around Leinster House when protests take place to push groups back onto Molesworth Street. However, no barriers were constructed on this occasion.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Local property tax rate in Wicklow decided for 2026
Local authorities have the power to vary the basic LPT rate on residential properties in their area, by increasing or decreasing the local adjustment factor by up to 15pc. The rate in Wicklow has remained unchanged for the past four years. Councillors were informed that retaining the LPT at its 6pc variation rate would provide an additional €1.4m in discretionary funding, with Wicklow, Greystones, Arklow and Baltinglass Municipal Districts due €263,901 each and Bray Municipal District receiving €351,868. The funding is then ring-fenced for discretionary use by the elected members of the five Municipal Districts which help to support a variety of local projects including footpath repairs, public realm initiatives and supporting local community organisations. Some of these projects include Ferrybank footpath repairs in Arklow, the construction of footpaths in Blessington Graveyard the repair of the Esplanade bandstand roof and painting of Victorian seatback at Bray Seafront and the refurbishment of toilets at Wicklow Seafront. The issue was a source of heated debate among councillors during their monthly meeting on Monday, when Wicklow County Council chief executive Emer O' Gorman told members the tax intake helps to cover the cost of hiring new staff and providing a range of local council services, including libraries, public lighting, housing and community grant schemes. 'The council is not awash with money and the current model of local government does not empower local representatives to serve their constituents as we'd expect in other countries.' 'The current model of local government that was adopted in 2014 is here to stay. Call me cynical but I believe it's not going away, and I don't expect it to change anytime soon.' 'The public are always judging us on our performance. Extra outdoor staff will make the council more visible amongst the community. They will help us to fill gaps that exist in each of the districts.' Fine Gael's Cllr Sylvester Bourke was the first member to support the motion, calling for the rate to stay put. ADVERTISEMENT 'Given the high cost of living, I believe maintaining the current rate is the right move although I acknowledge this may pose a challenge for the council to draft future budgets'. Echoing those sentiments Social Democrats representative Cllr Danny Alvey said now is not the right time to raise the rate. 'I welcome the fact that some of these funds are being allocated to fund MD activities. Some of these activities have been very important for local communities in my district.' In the end, 19 councillors voted in favour of keeping the same rate, 10 voted against it, while three were not present for the vote. Independent voices in the chamber took aim at Fine Gael and the Social Democrats for supporting the motion, with Cllr Joe Behan branding the LPT as an 'outrageous form of double taxation'. 'Before 2014 exchequer funding helped to cover the costs of running the council. The move is wrong and unfair, I believe the deal was already done before today's debate.' Fellow independent Cllr Tom Fortune said he doesn't agree to taxing the family home in principle. He said he felt that the LPT has destroyed families since it was introduced in 2013. 'This vote isn't going to change anything,' he said. 'Councillors are being used but are entitled to their view. LPT is not a sustainable way to help fund the work of the council. The National Transport Authority already controls a lot of the money that will be ringfenced with no real say in how it's used.' 'The proposal is crazy, we're playing silly games and arm-wrestling with council officials This debate is a complete waste of time, the way local government is being run is disgraceful.' he added. Cllr Peir Leonard acknowledged the council needs money to operate but singled out people in Wicklow who are struggling with the cost of living, 'some of them in silence'. 'How sustainable is the model of LPT going forward with the current housing market?' she asked. 'Especially with the lack of supply in Arklow.' Her district colleague Cllr Miriam Murphy expressed her disappointed that only three submissions were received during a public consultation on the matter. Cllr Gerry O'Neill queried why there was no mention of where money could be saved, believing that funds have been 'wasted' on certain projects, using the stalled Blessington Greenway as an example. Meanwhile Cllr John Snell criticised using an ordinary council meeting to review the situation saying, 'there are now winners here today, people are already suffering.' Separately Sinn Féin's Cllr Dermot 'Daisy' O'Brien said people don't see the benefit of how the LPT is used, describing the levies imposed as extortionate. 'LPT is more like a bailout from central government, the move is very convenient as there is already quite a healthy government surplus.' 'The proposal to fund public sector pay is out of this world, I'm asking here today to reduce rate by 15 pc.' Nobody seconded his proposal. Following some testy exchanges, Labour's Cllr Paul O'Brien took the floor to restore some calm to proceedings. 'I commend Cllr Bourke and Cllr Alvey for their stance on the matter in council chamber here today. We all need to work together. During my year as chair, I always tried to make sure that everyone's voice was heard. Of course, everyone's entitled to their view but that doesn't mean we shouldn't treat each other with respect. 'All this cynical talk is nonsense. The LPT is a tax on the wealthy, and it's making a difference. 'The reality is that if LPT is reduced, local services in our county will suffer as a result.' he added. Last week Wicklow County Council received word it will be allocated an additional €4,458,940 annually starting in 2026, allowing more flexibility and investment in local services and infrastructure. The funding increase comes because of changes made to how LPT funds are allocated. The changes are part of a broader Government reform of the LPT system, which also includes a revaluation of properties in November 2025 and a new requirement that additional retained funding be directed in part toward urban regeneration and local infrastructure improvements.
The Journal
3 hours ago
- The Journal
Tariffs pause is 'clear indication' that Trump understands need for deal, Tánaiste says
TÁNAISTE SIMON HARRIS has said the EU and the US must work 'intensively' to get a deal on tariffs in place before the deadline for increased rates, but added he has concerns for the pharma industry. It comes after the Trump administration announced that the deadline for tariffs to come into place has been pushed back to 1 August. Countries had been working to a Wednesday deadline to make a new deal with the Trump administration. The White House confirmed that US President Donald Trump would be delaying an increase to the baseline 10% tariff rate to next month. Speaking on his way into Cabinet this morning, Harris said the pause is a 'clear indication' that Trump understands the need to have a trade deal in place. 'We are far too interdependent not to have one. Every single day, more than €4 billion-worth of goods and services are traded across the Atlantic Ocean,' Harris said. Advertisement 'We need to work now intensively to get an agreement ideally in advance of 1 August, because we've been consistent in Ireland. The more quickly we can bring certainty, the better that is for jobs, and the better that is for investment, the better that is for economic sentiment.' However, Harris said he was concerned in relation the pharmaceutical sector. The White House confirmed that Trump would be delaying an increase to the baseline 10% tariff rate to next month. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo 'I think there's a lot of work to be done here in relation to pharma. We obviously have a very big pharma sector in this country. We've been a very good home to the pharma industry. They need access to the EU, a market of more than 460 million people.' The Fine Gael leader said that he has told the Trump administration that 'there is a way forward that could be good for the EU and good for the US and pharma'. He said that while it is 'disappointing' no trade agreement has been reached, the decision by Trump shows he is up for making a deal, adding that he wants to see zero-for-zero tariffs in as many areas as possible. 'In all my conversations with European counterparts and my conversations with the US administration, I know there are very, very intense talks under way to get to a point of agreement,' Harris concluded. 'We need to get as many carve outs, I think, in terms of zero for zero in as many areas as possible, and particularly from an Irish perspective, but also from an European economic perspective, we need to see a lot more engagement and clarity around pharma.' Related Reads Trump to push Wednesday tariff deadline out to 1 August Taoiseach 'hopeful' EU can reach a trade deal with US after update from von der Leyen Taoiseach Micheál Martin said he is 'hopeful' the EU and the US will reach a landing zone before the deadline passes. Speaking outside Government Buildings, Martin said: 'First of all, we don't want tariffs, but the United States clearly have issues. 'I welcome the fact that there's a pause in respect of the European Union, and clearly the European Union, as I suggested when I spoke to President (Ursula) von der Leyen, the European Union is on track for a framework agreement with the United States.' Martin said that other countries have already received letters, referencing the fact that Trump has informed Japan and South Korea that the US is going to impose 25% tariffs o on both countries. He expressed hope that 'a landing zone' can be reached between the US and the EU due to the 'enormous' trade between the two. He also said that any failure to get a headline agreement would have 'a disruptive impact on the markets and on the manufacturers of goods in particular'. 'What it suggests really is that there was substantial negotiations on the way, have happened between the US and the EU. They're not there yet, and we're not there yet, but I think there's a prospect that we could be there by 1 August.' With reporting from Jane Moore
