No immersion in water bodies: Bombay HC permits only manufacturing of PoP idols, seeks state's policy decision on their immersion
The HC noted that in view of clarification issued by CPCB that its revised guidelines were only pertaining to idol immersion and not for making of PoP idols or other purposes, the bench was inclined to permit the same and modified its earlier order. However, the Court said that the PoP idols shall not be immersed in natural water bodies as per CPCB revised guidelines and they shall not be immersed without leave of the high court.
The revised guidelines of the CPCB issued on May 12, 2020, stipulate that idols made of natural, biodegradable and eco-friendly raw materials be encouraged, allowed and promoted, while idols made of Plaster of Paris be banned.
A division bench of Chief Justice Alok Aradhe and Justice Sandeep V Marne was hearing a batch of pleas by associations of Ganesh idol makers challenging the CPCB guidelines banning the use of idols made of PoP and their immersion, alleging that the same flouted their fundamental rights
On January 30, two days prior to Maghi Ganesh Utsav, a bench led by CJ Alok Aradhe had issued directions to civic authorities in Maharashtra to ensure the CPCB guidelines are strictly followed and had questioned idol makers why they were not stopping making of PoP idols despite repeated court orders over the last few years.
On Monday, the CPCB said that it has issued clarifications that the revised guidelines are for idol immersions and not for their making. The CPCB added that its expert committee earlier this month, after perusing Maharashtra government's recommendations had agreed that such guidelines are 'always advisory in nature' and the state governments may decide for allowing immersion of PoP idols subject to conditions.
The said conditions include provision of designated temporary artificial ponds or tanks for immersion and the same shall not be allowed in rivers, lakes, natural tanks/ponds and sea.
The expert panel of CPCB further said that after immersion, the authorities shall remove material deposited in artificial ponds or tanks and the collected material be 'stored in environmentally sound manner till it is lifted for regeneration and reuse' and follow other measures given in 2020 revised guidelines for idol immersion in eco-friendly and sustainable manner. The petitioner sought early decision by the state government citing urgent need for the same as the Ganesh Utsav would begin after two months.
Advocate General Birendra Saraf for the state government sought time to take a decision and said that while there are large idols made of PoP, the festival has become 'part of our culture' and there may be difficulties to immerse such idols in artificial ponds or tanks during upcoming Ganesh Utsav. The court also suggested that the stakeholders can consider having the same large idol permanently on the lines of practice adopted in Pune.
It noted, 'In view of the stand taken on behalf of CPCB as well as the recommendations made by the Expert Committee constituted by CPCB, we permit the members of the petitioners associations as well as any other artisans to make idols of PoP.' The HC said the same will be subject to the artisans complying with directions in 2012 directions of the Nagpur bench of HC which directed marking of PoP idols.
'However, it is directed that such idols shall not be immersed without leave of this Court.' The court modified its January 30 order based on CPCB's recommendations and posted further hearing to June 30.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
11 hours ago
- Indian Express
Hundreds of maps ‘forged' for illegal bungalows: Bombay HC rejects bail of four officials, says manipulation not possible without their participation
Over three months after the Mumbai Police made arrests in a case of alleged forgery of hundreds of maps for illegal construction of bungalows on Madh Island, the bail pleas of four officials were rejected by a magistrate court which said that such manipulation was not possible without their participation. The Mumbai Police crime branch had arrested the officials in April, following the formation of a Special Investigation Team, on the orders of the Bombay High Court. The magistrate court last week rejected pleas of Anil Dabhole, who held the additional charge of record keeping of the maps; Kailas Dhomse and Shantaram Shinde, who worked as maintenance surveyors and Shamburaja Wable, who headed the city surveyor office in Goregaon. 'There is manipulation in the government map. Constructions of houses and bungalows have been shown as having being constructed prior to 1964. Said manipulation was done during the period of the applicant/accused (Dabhole)… The manipulation in the original record of the government is not possible unless and until the participation of the person incharge of the said office as well as the record keeper,' the court said in its order on July 8, rejecting the bail plea of Dabhole. The official had said that there was ongoing digitisation of records and hence the documents may not have been properly maintained. He also claimed that he was not the sole custodian of the map records as they were kept in a cupboard in the record room, which others also had the keys and access to. The accused also said that there was no proof that he was involved in the alleged forging of the maps or had been a beneficiary. The case had come to light following documents sought by a local, Vaibhav Thakur, under the Right to Information Act, after he noticed encroachment on the coast, in violation of the Coastal Zone Regulations. The police claim that since construction on the land on the coast there was permitted before 1960s, the maps at the Goregaon City Survey Office were forged to claim that the illegal constructions were already in existence. The accused in their pleas also cited that others had been granted bail by the sessions court but the court said that those granted bail were on different posts and were not the authority to maintain the records. On the pleas of Dhomse and Shinde, the court said they have long retired and had nothing to do with the offence. 'The applicants being surveyors are experts in verification of map. It was their duty to verify the original map along with tracing cloth sheet while issuing copies. Therefore, the point raised on behalf of the applicants that they do not have any knowledge regarding the manipulation of original map is not proper,' the court said. On Wable, it said that he was the head of the office and had ignored to take action despite receiving a complaint. 'His conduct itself is sufficient to infer that the manipulation has been done with the consent of the accused. Moreover, he avoided to give proper information to the investigating officer. It was legitimate expectation from the office incharge that after receipt of any complaint he should inquire properly and not to ignore,' the court said.
Hindustan Times
18 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Mumbai blasts lawyer, ex foreign secretary among 4 new nominees to Rajya Sabha
President Droupadi Murmu has nominated four individuals to the Rajya Sabha, according to a notification issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs on Saturday. The nominees include former diplomat Harsh Vardhan Shringla, public prosecutor Ujjwal Deorao Nikam, historian Meenakshi Jain, and teacher-politician C. Sadanandan Master. Ujjwal Nikam served as the special public prosecutor in the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks case.(HT File) Ujjwal Nikam served as the special public prosecutor in the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks case. He represented the prosecution in the sessions court, the Bombay High Court, and the Supreme Court in the case against Ajmal Amir Kasab, the only terrorist captured alive during the attacks. Kasab was sentenced to death in 2010, a decision later upheld by the higher courts. Harsh Shringla is a former Indian Foreign Service officer who has held senior positions in India's diplomatic missions, including Ambassador to the United States, and served as Foreign Secretary. He has also held postings in Bangladesh and Thailand during his diplomatic career. Dr. Meenakshi Jain is a historian whose work focuses on medieval and colonial Indian history. She is a former Associate Professor at Gargi College, University of Delhi, and a former Fellow of the Nehru Memorial Museum and Library. She has authored several books, including Rama and Ayodhya, The Battle for Rama, and Flight of Deities and Rebirth of Temples. She was awarded the Padma Shri in 2020. C. Sadanandan Master is a schoolteacher from Thrissur district in Kerala. He has taught social science at Sree Durga Vilasam Higher Secondary School in Peramangalam since 1999 and holds degrees from Gauhati University and Calicut University. On January 25, 1994, he was attacked near his residence in Kannur, a district known for political violence. The incident resulted in the amputation of both his legs. 'The attack was allegedly carried out by members of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) and was reportedly linked to his political shift away from the Left,' said officials familiar with the case. He was 30 years old at the time. According to Article 80 of the Indian Constitution, the President may nominate up to 12 members to the Rajya Sabha for their expertise and contributions in fields such as literature, science, art, and social service. These nominations are made on the recommendation of the central government and are intended to bring domain knowledge into parliamentary debates.
News18
a day ago
- News18
Who Is Harsh Shringla, Ex-Foreign Secretary Who Became President's Nominee To Rajya Sabha?
Last Updated: Harsh Vardhan Shringla was among the four nominees by the President of India to Rajya Sabha. Other eminent name on the list was Ujjwal Nikam, who helped prosecute Ajmal Kasab. The President of India nominated four members to the Rajya Sabha, which includes an accomplished diplomat and former foreign secretary, Harsh Shringla. Others who were nominated to the Upper House of the Parliament include eminent lawyer Ujjwal Nikam, who led the prosecution case against 26/11 attack terrorist Ajmal Kasab in the sessions court and the Bombay High Court. 'In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-clause (a) of clause (1) of article 80 of the Constitution of India, read with clause (3) of that article, the President is pleased to nominate to the Council of States the following persons to fill the vacancies caused due to retirement of nominated members:- Ujjwal Deorao Nikam, C Sadanandan Master, Harsh Vardhan Shringla and Dr Meenakshi Jain," the MHA notification said on Saturday. Who Is Harsh Vardhan Shringla? Shringla is an ex-Foreign Secretary of India. He joined the IFS in 1984 and was the youngest in his batch. He has been described by his peers as 'no nonsense" and 'sharp". He graduated from Delhi University's St. Stephen's College. He published papers on economic diplomacy, Indian diaspora, conflict prevention, and India-Bangladesh relations. He has also published op-eds in outlets such as The New York Times. Before diplomatic service, he worked briefly in India's corporate and public sectors. He served as an Ambassador to Thailand (from 2014 to 2016), High Commissioner to Bangladesh (from 2016 to 2019), and then as Ambassador to the United States (from January 2019 to January 2020). He served as the 33rd Foreign Secretary from January 29, 2020, to April 30, 2022. He also served as the Chief Coordinator during India's Presidency of the G20 Summit in 2023. He oversaw the successful organisation and adoption of the Delhi Declaration on Day One of the summit in New Delhi. Shringla has held key roles at the Ministry of External Affairs in New Delhi, including Joint Secretary for Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Myanmar, and the Maldives. He also led the UN Political and SAARC divisions, and earlier handled Nepal, Bhutan, and Western Europe affairs. As Ambassador in the US, he was the man behind organising the biggest event of Prime Minister Narendra Modi with Indian-Americans in the country – Howdy Modi – in which President Donald Trump had also participated. Though the event was organised by Texas India Forum, it had been in close coordination with the Indian Embassy in Washington, then led by Shringla. view comments First Published: July 13, 2025, 10:11 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
