'They were trapped': Bumble Bee 'benefitted' from forced labor, lawsuit alleges
Show Caption
Hide Caption
Canned tuna recall due to risk of botulism, big name grocery stores involved
Tri-Union Seafoods of California is recalling tuna cans that were sold in Trader Joe's and Costco, among other locations, due to the risk of botulism.
Straight Arrow News
Bumble Bee Foods is facing allegations that it "knowingly benefitted" from forced labor and other abuses in its supply chain, according to a lawsuit filed in federal court in California.
Four Indonesian fishers allege that they faced similar patterns of abuse on three different boats that supplied Bumble Bee, including physical abuse, long stretches of work without rest days and denial of medical care.
"These men were looking for good jobs so they could provide for their families and build a future," Agnieszka Fryszman, a lawyer for the plaintiffs said in a press release accompanying the March 12 filing. "Instead, they allege, they were trapped – isolated at sea, beaten with metal hooks, not getting enough food, working around the clock – and facing financial penalties if they tried to leave."
Lawyers for the plaintiffs said that they believe the suit is the first forced labor at sea case against an American company under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act.
Bumble Bee holds the largest market share of canned and pouched tuna, according to the Seafood Stewardship Index and was purchased by Taiwanese fish conglomerate FCF Co. Ltd. for $925 million following a bankruptcy in 2019. The company declined comment on the litigation Monday.
What does the lawsuit allege?
Muhammad Sahrudin, one of the plaintiffs, said that conditions on the boat he worked on were "harsh."
"The captain would slap the crewmen with his hand, hit them about the head, and, worse, stab themwith a needle," the filing states. "One time, the captain chased him with the needle, while Sahrudin begged to be spared."
Muhammad Syafi'i, a separate plaintiff, alleged among other abuses that he was severely burned by hot cooking oil while onboard a fishing vessel.
"He screamed in pain, but when the crew rushed to see what had happened, the captain told them to leave him be and to get back to work. Syafi'i was left lying on the kitchen bench, alone," the complaint states.
The plaintiffs allege that they were unable to leave the ships they were working on and routinely denied medical treatment. The men allege that once at sea, the ships would not sail back to port, transferring catches to cargo ships.
The complaint states that the ships the four plaintiffs worked on were a part of the "trusted network of boat owners" that supplied Bumble Bee.
"Bumble Bee knowingly received or attempted to receive financial and other benefit from the sale of tuna harvested with forced labor, including profits from those sales and access to a steady supply of tuna from its trusted fleet," the complaint alleges.
Fryzman said in the press release that her clients are seeking a result that would prevent further abuse.
"Our clients are seeking justice not only for themselves but to implement changes that will protect other fishers, including men at sea right now on the same boats," Fryman said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
26 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Donald Trump's key sector tariffs look firm, Mark Carney says, as trade talks could go past Friday's deadline
OTTAWA — Prime Minister Mark Carney suggested Wednesday that U.S. tariffs on key sectors like autos, steel and aluminum will likely remain, since Donald Trump's White House views them as necessary for the national security of the United States. Two days before Trump's latest deadline to increase tariffs on Canadian goods , Carney told reporters on Parliament Hill that it is possible trade talks between his government and the U.S. administration will drag on past Friday. While Carney called the talks 'constructive' and 'complex,' he said there are certain sectors Trump views as 'strategic' for national security reasons. He named automobiles and steel — significant employers in Ontario — as well as aluminum, pharmaceuticals, lumber, and semiconductors. All those sectors in Canada are either already grappling with significant American tariffs imposed under Trump, or face the possibility of higher duties to export to the U.S. The U.S. also kept 50-per-cent tariffs on steel and aluminum in recent agreements on trade with the European Union and Japan, the same level imposed on the Canadian sectors earlier this year. Asked whether a deal is possible without tariffs on those sectors, Carney said that the United State's 'revealed approach' is to keep some level of import duties in those areas. 'In any broader deal, there are gives and takes, and there's various factors,' Carney said Wednesday. 'But I think we have to recognize that, in the strategic sectors — again, as defined by the United States: what's strategic to them — that they have tariffs.' The head of the Canadian Steel Producers Association, Catherine Cobden, told the Star this week that her sector will push for stronger Canadian counter-tariffs to match Trump's import duties on steel and aluminum if no deal is reached before Friday. Flavio Volpe, the president of the Automotive Parts Manufacturers' Association, said he wants tariffs on his sector reduced to zero, citing how the industry is highly integrated across the Canada-U.S. border. Meanwhile, in Washington Wednesday, cabinet minister Dominic LeBlanc was among the senior government officials who travelled to the U.S. capital in search of a deal before Friday. That's when Trump has threatened to increase tariffs on Canadian goods to 35 per cent, as part of his global policy to raise import duties to increase economic activity in the U.S. and promote sectors the White House deems essential to national security. Another example came Wednesday when Trump released a proclamation that made official his previous threat to impose 50 per cent tariffs on imported copper products. The proclamation said the tariffs will kick in just after midnight Friday morning. Trump has also threatened tariffs on pharmaceutical imports that could go as high as 200 per cent. Ahead of Friday's deadline, Canadian business groups and Ontario's envoy to Washington have said Canada must preserve the exemption to Trump's tariffs for goods that comply with 2018's Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA). That exemption, in place since March 7, means roughly 86 per cent of Canadian exports to the U.S. could continue to flow tariff-free, according to an estimate from RBC Economics . Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Hamilton Spectator
26 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
‘Do not roll over,' Doug Ford urges Mark Carney as Donald Trump's trade deal deadline nears
Premier Doug Ford is urging Prime Minister Mark Carney to stand his ground against U.S. President Donald Trump's tariff assault on Canada. 'I told the prime minister, do not roll over. Hit that guy back as hard as we possibly can. And that's what we need to do — and we can do it,' Ford told reporters Thursday in Thunder Bay. As Trump's Friday deadline for increasing levies on Canadian products loomed, the Ontario premier stressed 'we can kick back' against the mercurial American president. 'Prime Minister Carney is trying his best, but this guy (Trump) will say something one day, and he'll wake up — and the cheese slips off the cracker — and then all of a sudden he goes the other way,' said Ford. 'And you're thinking, 'How do you deal with a guy like this?'' The premier said Canada has no choice but to 'on-shore' more products that it currently imports from the U.S. in order to become less reliant on its largest trading partner. 'Are we hoping that we can get a deal with zero tariffs? Yes, but I always say how can we kick back — and it's not the American people — kick back at President Trump,' he said. 'Let's start on-shoring absolutely everything we possibly can, like … those big steel I-beams (used in building construction) … and aluminum cans.' Noting 'we're the kings of aluminum in Quebec,' Ford said Canadian companies are soon going to be manufacturing beverage cans here, using domestic raw materials. 'They're going to lose a billion dollars worth of a business in the U.S. We don't have to take a back seat to anyone in the world, and we sure as heck don't have take a back seat to President Trump,' he said. 'He needs to remember we're … their number one customer.' Ford also had some choice words for businesses that try to skirt the 'Buy Canadian' labelling push in grocery stores. 'You know a company called Campbell Soup? They told me that Campbell Soup is putting a Canadian flag on their cans. They closed their plants here. They moved everything down to the U.S., and they put 'recipe made in Canada,'' he thundered. 'What sort of nonsense is that? Don't let them hoodwink you. I'm going to call them out again. I'm going to show you one of their cans. It's unacceptable that they do that. Don't try to pull one over people's eyes,' said the premier. 'Canadians are too smart for that. So please, when you go shopping — I know it's not always possible — buy Canadian as you as much as you can.' Ford and Carney have become close political allies thanks to Trump's threats. Both leaders won elections this year promising to stand up against American tariffs. Last week, the prime minister not only accepted the premier's invitation to attend the Council of the Federation meeting at Deerhurst Resort, but he also ended up staying at Ford's cottage south of Huntsville.
Business Insider
27 minutes ago
- Business Insider
The Fed's latest decision is leaving open a window of opportunity that many Americans may be ignoring
The Fed kept rates steady this week as it waits for more clarity on inflation. While markets are clamoring for cuts, there's an opportunity for consumers amid higher rates. A study shows that US households might missing out on big savings. Fed Chair Jerome Powell confirmed what markets already suspected on Wednesday, leaving the benchmark rate unchanged, despite pressure from President Donald Trump. With no Fed meeting scheduled for August, all eyes are on the possibility of a September rate cut. But the time between now and then may be the last opportunity for consumers to take advantage of an opportunity created by elevated interest rates. A study from savings marketplace Raisin said that 84% of Americans do not actively search for better savings rates, even if they could be saving substantially by opting for a different annual percentage yield. The study found that many American households have the potential to save substantially. "The average APY on Americans' savings accounts is .58% but they could be earning upwards of 4% APY — which amounts to nearly 7x more in interest each year," the study said, adding that the difference for a household with $10,000 in savings amounts to earning $400 versus $58. Put simply, if every American household were to opt for higher-yield savings, it could lead to as much as $396 billion per year for consumers. "Rates really start to come down once we get into the fall," Shana Hennigan, chief business office at Raisin, told Business Insider. "With that backdrop, while consumers still have the opportunity, this might be the time to strike." If Powell and the central bank cut rates in September, the window to see that kind of yield on savings accounts could be closing.
