WHO: Covid-19 origins still unknown, all theories remain open
GENEVA: All hypotheses on how the Covid-19 pandemic began remain open, the World Health Organization said Friday, following an inconclusive four-year investigation that was hamstrung by crucial information being withheld.
The global catastrophe killed an estimated 20 million people, according to the WHO, while shredding economies, crippling health systems and turning people's lives upside-down.
The first cases were detected in Wuhan in China in late 2019, and understanding where the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes Covid came from is seen as key to preventing future pandemics.
However, a lengthy investigation launched by the UN's health agency said that pending further data, the origins of Covid and how it first spread would remain inconclusive.
"As things stand, all hypotheses must remain on the table, including zoonotic spillover and lab leak," WHO chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus told a press conference, referring to the two main hypotheses as to how the pandemic began.
After much delay, a WHO team of experts went to Wuhan in January 2021 to look into the origins of the virus in cooperation with their Chinese counterparts.
Their March 2021 joint report concluded that the most likely hypothesis was that the virus jumped from bats to humans via an intermediate animal.
They also deemed the theory that it might have escaped from Wuhan's virology laboratories "extremely unlikely."
However, that investigation faced harsh criticism for lacking transparency and access, and for not evaluating the lab-leak theory seriously.
Tedros launched another investigation, setting up the Scientific Advisory Group for the Origins of Novel Pathogens (SAGO) in July 2021.
The report by the group of 27 experts was published on Friday.
"Until further requests for information are met, or more scientific data becomes available, the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and how it entered the human population will remain inconclusive," SAGO chair Marietjie Venter said at the press conference.
She added that it was "not yet clear" if the Wuhan seafood market was where the virus first spilled over into humans.
As for lab leak theories, she said much of the information needed to assess this hypothesis had not been made available, so it "could not be investigated, or excluded."
"Over the past five years, we have learned a lot about Covid-19 but there is one crucial question about the pandemic that we have not yet answered: how it started," Tedros said.
He said SAGO had advanced understanding of the origins of Covid-19 but much of the information needed to evaluate fully all the hypotheses had not been provided.
"Despite our repeated requests, China hasn't provided hundreds of viral sequences from individuals with Covid-19 early in the pandemic, more detailed information on animals sold at markets in Wuhan, and information on work done and biosafety conditions at laboratories in Wuhan," he said.
"WHO is also aware of intelligence reports performed by other governments around the world on the origins of Covid-19. We have also requested access to those reports."
US President Donald Trump's administration has officially embraced the lab leak theory.
Tedros said finding out how Covid-19 started was a moral imperative for the sake of those who lost their lives in the pandemic.
He also said the virus was continuing to evolve, take lives and leave people suffering with post-Covid conditions, or so-called long Covid.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Barnama
7 hours ago
- Barnama
COVID-19 Death Toll In Bangladesh Reaches 22 So Far This Month
DHAKA, June 29 (Bernama-Xinhua) -- Bangladesh on Saturday recorded two new COVID-19 deaths during the past 24 hours, taking the death toll to 22 so far this month, reported Xinhua. The country on June 5 recorded its first COVID-19 fatality this year when a man died from the infectious disease in the capital Dhaka. The country also reported seven new COVID-19 cases, with the daily test positivity rate jumping to 3.87 per cent in the 24 hours till 8:00 am local time Saturday. Official data showed that 174 samples were tested in the last 24 hours.
Borneo Post
12 hours ago
- Borneo Post
When going viral becomes fatal
She may be too young to read comments, but not too young to be watched by thousands. Is this consent, or coercion in cute disguise? IN chasing for more clicks, shares, likes, gifts and monetary returns of their social media posts, a young woman lost her life. Pan Xiaoting, a 24-year-old Chinese social media influencer made famous by her 'Mukbang' livestreams, died after a 10-hour livestreaming in the pursuit of eating up 1kg of food in front of her fans and audiences. It was not an accidental death or suffering from illness, it was by her own voluntary act of performing for her audience. I dread to say that the audiences are craving for excess. Are we one of them? If there is no audience, there is no performer, and it is cruel to say that. Autopsy performed on her revealed that her stomach had ripped open, severely deformed and filled with undigested food. Yes, it is shocking; it is tragic. 'Mukbang' is a social media trend where individuals broadcast themselves eating large quantities of food, often interacting with their audiences. It originated in South Korea – the word 'mukbang' is Korean for 'eating' and 'broadcast'. Yes, it is entertaining, but the negative effects may influence viewers to overeat and develop unhealthy eating habits. It is the result of social media trends where attention is money, and going to extremes is rewarded. Only days after reading this news, my social media feeds were bombarded with viral videos of mothers feeding their very young children an excessive amount of food. Probably, the quantity is more than what an adult can eat in one day. Chubby cheeks, bright eyes, sweet smiles, baby talks are all that could attract viewers. Who can resist such harmless innocence in this hectic world? But as a mother who has raised two children, I cannot help but feel uneasy. How can a child so small be possibly expected to consume that much food in one sitting? I am worried that these parents are crossing the line by sharing innocent family moments to performing for strangers on the Internet. The children enjoying a meal becomes moments of weaponising food just for clicks, likes and shares. Social media has opened the door for ordinary people to become celebrities. And with that, it has also unleashed a powerful, but also dangerous, drive to entertain. Social media, which began as a space for creativity and for people to share their talents and connection with friends, has sadly turned into a stage where such uncomfortable excessive acts cost lives. The various social media algorithms don't care about your well-being. It doesn't know whether a child is genuinely hungry, or being pushed to eat more than they should. It doesn't distinguish between authentic joy and dangerous pressure. It only amplifies what gets the most reactions. The tragedy of Pan Xiaoting is not an isolated case. It is a part of a larger problem that arose from monetisation of extremes for the sake of audiences. And now, it is alarming that this mindset applies even to children. We justify this by calling them 'family moment creators' or 'parenting influencers'. But let's face the reality. Children are not participating; they are forced to perform by the parents. They are too young to say no. They are too trusting to consent, and they become the victims of the adults' pursuit for fame and fortune. You may argue: 'What's wrong with a cute baby eating on camera?' Yes, I read some of the comments of the viewers. Once someone raises the question 'how could the baby be eating such amount of food', there will be voices reprimanding the commenter that 'the baby is eating healthy food'. As viewers, we are sending messages to support such videos by rewarding the acts with likes, monetary rewards and sponsorship deals. Social media may be new, but the need for limits is not. We have laws and reforms to protect the young in the real world. But nobody stops the act of asking a child to eat 10 bowls of noodles in front of a live audience. Is it acceptable when it is happening on a screen? It is time for social media platforms to take greater responsibility. Algorithms need to be recalibrated to favour health, honesty, and humanity – not harmful spectacle. But even more importantly, we, as the audience, need to pause and reflect. Every click is a vote. Every share is an endorsement. We must ask ourselves: are we engaging with content because it is meaningful; or because it is outrageous? Are we supporting creators who build communities; or those who risk their lives and exploit their families for a fleeting moment of 'virality'? Let Pan Xiaoting's story be a wake-up call. She died not because she was poor or hungry, but because she was performing for an audience that demanded more and more and gave nothing back when the curtain fell. Let us not applaud until it is too late. Let us, instead, choose to follow, support and share content that uplifts and educates, not endangers – especially when children are involved. We do not need another tragedy to realise that likes are not worth lives. fatal live-stream Mukbang social media viral
Borneo Post
12 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Chinese scientists join classrooms to inspire teenagers to become innovators
A teacher instructs as a student uses a computer in a programming class at a primary school in Yuhu District of Xiangtan City, central China's Hunan Province on April 11, 2024. – Xinhua photo BEIJING (June 29): Peking University life sciences professor Zhang Yan, who has been researching Alzheimer's disease for two decades, has taken on a new mission this semester: educating young teens. Beyond lectures and experiments, Zhang is committed to giving her young students an authentic glimpse into the world of scientific research. She believes such hands-on learning should begin early in basic education, and as a scientist, she sees it as her responsibility to contribute. Zhang is one of thousands of researchers to be appointed as a 'vice principal of science' – a position introduced by China's Ministry of Education two years ago, in an initiative aiming to ensure every primary and secondary school engages the services of at least one scientific researcher from a university, research institute or technology company to strengthen science education. Scientist-led classes Dressed in a T-shirt and jeans, sipping milk tea and switching seamlessly between Chinese and English, Zhang teaches her middle school students much like she does her doctoral candidates in university labs. This casual approach is the first message she hopes to convey: scientists are not always solemn, bookish or eccentric. During her first lecture at Beijing Guangqumen Middle School in late May, she said that in reality, many scientists have diverse interests, lead balanced lives and possess both intellectual and emotional intelligence. Similarly, Zhang seeks to dispel another common misconception about careers in science: success comes solely from hard work, much like scoring high in college entrance exams. 'You may spend years with few breakthroughs, and that is the first challenge scientists must face – learning to deal with frustration,' she said in English during a recent class. Her students listened carefully, not distracted by phones or computers. They are preparing to enter senior high school after their summer vacation, and in three years, they will choose a university and a major. 'The earlier they learn, the more they benefit,' Zhang said, noting that understanding scientific careers as teens will help them make choices in the future. Using examples ranging from the discovery of penicillin to the gene-editing of white mice in labs, Zhang also encouraged her young students to develop habits of critical thinking, questioning authority and pursuing lifelong learning. Next month, she plans to take them to her university lab, where they will observe and conduct basic scientific experiments. 'They will experience real scientific work,' she said. Students learn about spacecraft models at the fourth live class of the 'Tiangong Class' series in Yan'an Science and Technology Museum in Yan'an, northwest China's Shaanxi Province on Sept 21, 2023. – Xinhua photo National push To make classes more engaging, researchers nationwide are adopting diverse approaches. Besides lab experiments, some organise field expeditions or showcase models of scientific facilities such as lunar probes, submarines and large telescopes. The study of emerging technologies like AI and humanoid robots has also made its way into classrooms, becoming part of the content being taught by scientists. Tasked with more than teaching, these vice principals of science also help schools with science curriculum planning, teacher training and bringing in scientific resources, forming part of the country's broader picture of science education. Since 2023, under a national 'double reduction' policy launched in 2021 to ease the burdens of excessive homework and off-campus tutoring that students face in their compulsory education years, greater emphasis has been placed on enhancing science education and nurturing young people with both the potential to become scientists and aspirations to dedicate themselves to scientific research. According to a January report by the state broadcaster CCTV citing the latest data from the Ministry of Education, 45 per cent of primary and secondary schools have appointed a vice principal specialising in science over the past two years. Schools are also striving to nurture their own science teaching staff. Beijing Haidian Aerospace Tuqiang Primary School, for example, employs 15 full-time or part-time science teachers. The number of science teachers in the country's junior high schools has increased by more than 8,400 nationwide, and by over 28,000 in senior high schools. And technology firms are also joining this national push for improved science education. Leading AI company iFlytek has launched study tour programmes to showcase its voice-recognition tools and robots to students, and carmaker Geely has opened its workshops to students, allowing young people to learn about the manufacturing process of new energy vehicles. Students have a class in a prefabricated classroom in Guanting Town, Minhe Hui and Tu Autonomous County, northwest China's Qinghai Province on March 1, 2024. – Xinhua photo Duty of educators However, serving as a school educator does not offer extra pay or benefits for her research work, Zhang said. 'It is purely driven by a sense of duty.' China has intensified efforts to encourage scientist participation in science education. A revised Science and Technology Popularisation Law came into effect last year and introduced concrete measures, such as those on professional recognition and evaluation, to reward researchers for public engagement. Zeng Fankui, a researcher at the Lanzhou Institute of Chemical Physics under the Chinese Academy of Sciences, is passionate about popularising his potato studies and serves as vice principal of science at three local schools. He applauds the progress the country has made in science education, but points to some problems: many rural schools lack proper science equipment and specialised teachers, and traditional mindsets that prioritise rote learning over scientific thinking remain. Xiong Bingqi, dean of the 21st Century Education Research Institute, said that the goal of the vice principal of science role is to cultivate true scientific literacy. 'If science classes only assign mechanical exercises, AI could replace them,' he warned, adding that science education should shift focus from knowledge delivery to the cultivation of self-directed learning and nurturing innovation. Students crammed with scientific knowledge alone will find it difficult to adapt to the rapid changes of the future, Xiong said. – Xinhua China education schools scientists Xinhua
