Capping rates rises would make things 'worse not better'
Photo:
RNZ / Mark Papalii
Capping local council rates would make the problem of paying for pipes and other infrastructure "worse not better", Labour leader Chris Hipkins says.
Cabinet will year consider options to control rate rises, including capping, later this year.
Finance Minister Nicola Willis told
Morning Report
on Monday the government wanted councils to stick to the basics and not waste ratepayers money.
"We are concerned that the rates bill is a big part of the cost of living for many households, and rates have been going up very fast and are set to keep going up very fast across many councils," she said.
"Councils don't always do a great job of spending your money like you would spend it. There are wasteful projects - there is evidence of that.
"We want councils focusing on the things people expect them to do, which is the rubbish, the roads, the pipes, the basics - and not all the fanciful projects.
"There will be pushback because when you take candy away from kids in a candy store, they don't really like it. But at the same time, we are on the side of ratepayers."
Willis said councils should also look at making greater use of other funding and financing tools to pay for infrastructure.
Labour Party leader Chris Hipkins.
Photo:
RNZ / Mark Papalii
Labour Party leader Chris Hipkins said the reason rates were going up at the rate they was because the government abolished reforms.
"The biggest contributor to rates going up around the country is the fact that our water infrastructure is in such a state of disrepair, capping the rates, in order to say well we want you to not do water infrastructure, just pushes the problem further into the future," he told
Morning Report
on Tuesday.
"If you look at my area, Wellington .... basically in the summer you can walk around and see all the leaky pipes because it's the only green spots on the grass at the side of the road.
"Simply saying 'well just don't spend money on that' is going to make that problem worse not better."
Hipkins was asked if he agreed with Willis, who likened a restriction on rates to taking candy away from kids, saying there was wasteful and fanciful spending going on in councils.
He said this was patronising.
"Having created a situation where councils are being forced to put up the rates to pay for things like water infrastructure, the government's now trying to blame them for doing something that they really don't have a choice but to do.
"Ultimately if the government don't want councils to increase rates, they've got to find another way of funding the water infrastructure that we need."
Local Government New Zealand
president and Selwyn District mayor Sam Broughton said rates capping could be "disastrous for communities" and leave councils without the means to fund essential infrastructure.
He said international examples showed the policy that "sounds cool and might win some votes" had unintended consequences on pipes and roads.
"My council, we spend 80 percent of our capital on roads and pipes. On top of that, you add in the rubbish, you add in the parks, you add in the pools that kids learn to swim in - all those things add up and are expensive."
In the past three years there had been a 38 percent increase in the cost of maintaining bridges, he said.
He said communities did need to look at borrowing, but also needed other tools such as the return of mineral royalties, congestion charging, road tolling, the return of a portion of GST on new builds in the district.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
6 hours ago
- RNZ News
Enrolments banned while international flight school fixes 'serious shortcomings'
A statutory clampdown requires Whanganui's beleaguered international pilot academy to stop enrolling new students or issuing new offers of place. Photo: Tuakana Te Tana Enrolments of new learners at Whanganui's international pilot academy have been halted until "serious shortcomings" are addressed. The New Zealand Qualifications Authority (NZQA) has placed statutory conditions on the troubled New Zealand International Commercial Pilot Academy (NZICPA) while an action plan is put in place. The council-owned academy's fleet has been grounded since May 23 because of a safety investigation by the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA). That probe followed safety concerns raised anonymously. Now the NZQA clampdown requires the academy to stop enrolling new students or issuing new offers of place. The academy must also develop and implement an action plan, to NZQA's satisfaction, to improve governance and management oversight of all training operations. It must improve quality management systems to comply with obligations under private training establishment rules, and ensure training is properly planned for and delivered. The ratio of instructors to learners must improve to 1:5, and individual training plans must be developed for learners, with scheduling to help ensure timely achievement of training milestones. Primary instructors must be assigned to ensure continuity for individual learners. "The statutory actions will be in place until we are satisfied that NZICPA has reduced the ratio of instructors to learners, improved planning and scheduling, and increased governance and management oversight of training operations," said NZQA deputy chief executive of quality assurance, Eve McMahon. "I would like to thank NZICPA's learners for raising their concerns, staff and management for supporting NZQA's investigation, and CAA for their advice and expertise in aircraft training best practice." McMahon said NZQA would stay "actively engaged" with the academy and continue to work closely with the CAA and other agencies. The investigation found that student accommodation and food broadly reflected their contracts with the academy, with NZICPA voluntarily taking action where improvements were needed, McMahon said. "NZQA will now be focusing on monitoring NZICPA's progress against the conditions and ensuring the necessary improvements are made." The flight school is owned by the Whanganui District Council, operating under its commercial arm Whanganui Council Holdings Limited (Holdings). It has been operating since 2017 and has its own board and management team. In 2023, it agreed a deal with Indian airline IndiGo to train 200 cadet pilots through to December 2026. Whanganui mayor Andrew Tripe said last month the council was working to ensure the best outcome for students and staff and to ensure the long-term interests of ratepayers were protected. He said the council aimed to minimise financial exposure and retain a safe and effective international flight training facility in Whanganui so that it could continue to provide economic benefits to the region. "The academy, at full strength, is estimated to inject more than $9.5 million annually into our economy," Tripe said. Former chief executive Gerard Glanville resigned in June. NZQA's statutory conditions have been imposed under Section 348 of the Education and Training Act 2020 and take effect today (Tuesday). "This gives NZICPA the opportunity to operate in a limited way, while addressing serious shortcomings in their management, planning and systems," said McMahon. The New Zealand International Commercial Pilot Academy in Whanganui has been grounded because of a safety investigation by the Civil Aviation Authority. Photo: The Whanganui council is expected to consider selling the flying school "in the next few weeks". A joint statement from the council and academy on Friday said sale negotiations were underway with five interested parties. Holdings chair Carolyn van Leuven said it had received offers from five different parties and was working through them. "Progress is promising at this stage, and we expect to go back to councillors for a decision in the next few weeks. "We are working very hard to ensure the best outcome for Whanganui ratepayers from a difficult situation. "A key focus is on continuation of a flight school in Whanganui, for the benefits it brings to the Whanganui airport and economy." Van Leuven said Holdings was also looking at what would provide the most efficient pathway to get students back on track with their training. Their food and accommodation was being covered by the academy while the fleet was grounded. Weekly costs were being monitored carefully, and the academy was operating from an existing council funding package of $10.3 million signed off in 2023. "Any interim support for students is being funded from this envelope," van Leuven said. NZICPA chair Matthew Doyle said the academy was continuing work to lift the suspension of its Part 141 certificate that enabled it to train aviation students. "Several assurance documents have been sent to CAA, and we await their response." Doyle said ground training was continuing at the school and its first aircraft, ZK-CTQ, had cleared inspection. "This is an important milestone. The supporting documentation will be submitted to the Civil Aviation Authority this week and we expect other aircraft to follow soon after." Academy director Craig Compain has stepped into an executive role to oversee the running of the academy. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
Covid inquiry hearings: No decisions yet on which politicians will appear
Former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern led the country through the first response to Covid-19, but the Royal Commission will not confirm if she will appear at the inquiry. Photo: 2021 Getty Images The Royal Commission investigating New Zealand's Covid-19 pandemic response has not made any decisions about which leaders and politicians will appear for a public healing. The inquiry is looking into the government's response to the pandemic and its effects. This week's hearings have concentrated on the impact of the extended lockdown in Auckland and Northland in 2021 and on vaccine mandates and safety. RNZ previously reported that the commission had requested former prime minister Dame Jacinda Ardern to give evidence at a public hearing in August. But the commission said no decisions had been made about who would appear at the hearing. "The witness list is still under consideration, and it is not appropriate to make further comment about it at this stage," they said in a written statement. "The Inquiry will share the witness list and more information about the planned August public hearing in due course." They also noted that people giving evidence would not necessarily be required to do so in a public hearing. "Public hearings are just one way the Inquiry can gather evidence, in addition to private interviews, written correspondence, stakeholder engagements, public submissions and document analysis." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
Working from home: 'Flexibility regret' vs long-term arrangements
Photo: RNZ Employees with casual agreements to work from home may still have a case for not coming into the office, despite a recent employment ruling on the issue, but employers are also showing signs of "flexibility regret". The Employment Relations Authority (ERA) recently ruled against a worker who took a constructive dismissal case against their employer where they were ordered back into the office three days a week, when they had been working from home four out of five days. The authority found the worker was not unjustifiably disadvantaged or constructively dismissed because there was no permanent arrangement, so there was no duty to continue it. Meanwhile the PSA is still waiting for an ERA hearing over the government's directive that work from home for public servants is not a right and should not compromise performance. But James Cowan, an employment lawyer at Anderson Lloyd, told Checkpoint that workers with a casual arrangement to work from home should not be particularly worried about the recent ERA ruling. "If it is something they want to get formalised, then I would suggest that they might be wanting to speak to their employers to get it put into writing or at least more formally agreed. "Where it has been discretionary or perhaps more informally agreed, then many times in that situation an employer is just going to be able to say 'actually, we would like you to come back to the office now, and either we're giving you a direction to do so or we're going to talk to you about agreeing how many days you'll be back in the office each week'." He said employers who have had a casual agreement for years could still argue their arrangement had been formalised through custom and practice. "By the time it has become an arrangement, the employee there would have a good argument that this has gone beyond being something informal, it has actually ben formalised by that time period." If it needed to be put in writing, Cowan said it would be safest for employees to be as specific as possible. "If employees and employers sit down and say lets agree a framework, lets agree how many days you'll be in the office, how many days you're at home. "It doesn't necessarily have to be the set days of the week, but you would want to get a level of detail there so that both parties knew what was happening." But Cowan did warn workers that his firm was fielding more inquiries from employers over whether they could direct their employes to work from the office. "I think some of that might be called 'flexibility regret' where some flexibility on working from home has been agreed, particularly post-Covid, and maybe some employers feel the dial has shifted too far." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
