logo
The six shocking questions that remain about the Trump assassination attempt in Butler one year later

The six shocking questions that remain about the Trump assassination attempt in Butler one year later

Daily Mail​a day ago
A year after a historic assassination attempt on Donald Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania, there are still scores of questions left unanswered, including why Thomas Matthew Crooks shot the president-to-be.
In the immediate aftermath of the tragedy, which left Trump with a bloody ear, two men with life-altering injuries and the death of father and firefighter Corey Comperatore, investigations began into how such a deadly lapse could've occurred.
The House of Representatives launched a task force to probe the shooting, but their report published late last year did not focus at all on Crooks or his motive, instead it highlighted the failures of the Secret Service which led to the disaster.
The FBI similarly began a probe, but the agency has yet to deliver a public update on the case. The last press FBI press release on the matter came last August, nearly 11 months ago.
On year on, America is still in the dark and left to wonder how such a brazen attack was so nearly able to kill the most identifiable U.S. politician.
Here the Daily Mail breaks down the top questions that remain about Trump's Butler shooting.
What was Thomas Matthew Crooks' motive?
The FBI has still to determine why 20-year-old Crooks, a young man from the Pittsburgh suburbs decided to shoot the Republican.
'The FBI has not identified a motive for the shooter's actions, but we are working to determine the sequence of events and the shooter's movements prior to the shooting, collecting and reviewing evidence, conducting interviews, and following up on all leads,' the agency wrote in a press release on July 14, 2024.
Since then, there has been no public update about Crooks' motive.
When pressed on how little is known about the shooter during a May interview with Fox News' Bret Baier, FBI Director Kash Patel poured cold water on the host's question.
'I don't know that there's more to know, but you're going to know everything we know,' he responded, downplaying the existence of additional information on Crooks and his motivation.
'We take assassination attempts, especially of the president of the United States, extremely seriously,' Patel said in the interview. 'And we don't feel that the American people have been given the information they need on that. And we're digging through the files, and we're getting them a more robust picture of what happened and whether or not there were any connections.'
Lawmakers have been irked by the lack of new information, too.
'I'm mostly unsatisfied,' Pennsylvania Republican Sen. Dave McCormick told the Daily Mail in an exclusive interview. 'Motive is just one part of the many questions I think that we still have.'
Crooks did not leave behind notes or social media posts explaining his decision to shoot at the president and rally attendees.
Did Crooks have a handler or accomplice?
Authorities have yet to state publicly whether they have determined if Crooks had any co-conspirators.
'While the investigation to date indicates the shooter acted alone, the FBI continues to conduct logical investigative activity to determine if there were any co-conspirators associated with this attack,' the FBI's July 14 release stated.
Florida Republican Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, who oversees the House's Task Force on Declassification of Government Secrets, wrote this week she still wonders who Crooks was talking to at the time of the shooting.
'Our president was nearly assassinated. We still don't know what happened to the shooter's burner phones. Who was he corresponding with? Did he have a handler?' she posted on X.
'After investigating the corrupt handling of the JFK assassination with my Task Force, there are far too many questions that still need answers about Trump's assassination attempt.'
What was Crooks's mental condition at the time?
Reports indicate that the 20-year-old's parents, Matthew and Mary Crooks, are licensed professional counselors.
Just before the shooting occurred on July 13, the parents reportedly called authorities worrying about the whereabouts of their son.
In their call they expressed concern about their son's wellbeing, a source familiar with the matter told Fox News in the days after the assassination attempt.
In the year before Crooks shot Trump, his father noticed his son exhibiting strange behaviors, like talking to himself while waving his arms and dancing late into the evening, the New York Times reported.
His father noted that mental health issues run in the family, and before the shooting Crooks had searched 'major depressive disorder' and 'depression crisis' online.
Matthew and Mary Crooks have not spoken publicly about their son and what led to his decision to open fire.
What was found on Crooks's phones?
The FBI discovered the gunman had two phones at the time of the shooting, but exactly what is on those devices remains a mystery.
In the days following the Butler shooting FBI agents briefed members of Congress on some of the contents of the devices.
Federal agents found searches of President Donald Trump, former President Joe Biden and more on the shooter's devices.
Reports indicate Crooks also looked up former FBI Director Chritopher Wray, information on the Republican and Democratic national conventions and the Oxford High School shooting, including a photograph of the shooter Ethan Crumbley on his phone.
What happened to Crooks's body?
A member of the House task force to investigate the Butler shooting, Rep. Clay Higgins, R-La., a former sheriff, expressed dismay at how quickly the shooter's body was cremated.
Some of his biggest concerns have centered on Crooks' autopsy and the swift release of his body to the family for cremation - just 10 days after he was shot dead by snipers.
Kelly's report noted that the postmortem came up negative in tests for alcohol, illegal drugs and other controlled substances.
But Higgins says he still wants to know why tests weren't carried out to test for prescription drugs in Crooks's system.
'It's reasonable to suspect some kind of psychotic break. There are many longstanding studies worldwide that connect the dots between antidepressants and anti-psychotic drugs and bizarre behaviors that develop after someone has started ingesting these drugs,' he told the Daily Mail earlier this year.
'My effort to examine Crooks' body on Monday, August 5, caused quite a stir and revealed a disturbing fact… the FBI released the body for cremation 10 days after J13,' Higgins's independent report reveals. 'On J23, Crooks was gone. Nobody knew this until Monday, August 5, including the County Coroner, law enforcement, Sheriff, etc.'
Why are federal agencies stonewalling?
The last update from the FBI on the investigation into Crooks was on August, 28, 2024, according to records on their website's press release portal.
The FBI did not respond to the Daily Mail's request for an update on the case.
Speaking to Fox News earlier this year in a joint interview FBI Director Patel and FBI Deputy Director Dan Bongino shared that there are four cases related to the Butler attack, noting that two of them are closed due to the individuals being deceased.
'Two of the investigations are obviously closed because the individuals are dead, but there's two live prosecutions,' Patel said. 'And so the we can't get ahead of the federal court case.'
'A lot of that information will come out in the federal court cases, but we have personally invested our time in making sure that we have looked at all the any possible international connections to terrorism and adversaries alike.'
'And we've both been down to Quantico. We've both done the laboratory testing, we've both seen the explosives analysis, we've both seen the firearm physically held, and we are all in on these investigations,' the FBI director shared.
In the interview Bongino also doused hopes for an explosive development in the cases.
'I'm not going to tell people what they want to hear. I'm going to tell you the truth. And whether you, whether you like it or not, is up to you. If there was a big explosive there, there, right? Given my history as a secret service agent and my personal friendship as a director does with the President, give me one logical, sensible reason we would not have,' he disclosed.
'If you can think of one there, isn't there, isn't there in some of these cases, that there you're looking for is not there.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Live Italy issues tariff threat to Trump after EU climbdown
Live Italy issues tariff threat to Trump after EU climbdown

Telegraph

time15 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Live Italy issues tariff threat to Trump after EU climbdown

The European Union is prepared to unleash a €21bn (£18.2bn) retaliation against Donald Trump after the US president announced new tariffs, Italy has said. The euro has fallen and European stocks are on track to open lower after Mr Trump on Saturday said he would impose a 30pc tariff on imports from Mexico and the EU from August 1. Italy's foreign minister Antonio Tajani said the EU had prepared a list of tariffs on US goods if the two sides fail to reach a trade deal. 'Tariffs hurt every one, starting with the United States,' he told the Il Messaggero newspaper. 'If stock markets fall that puts at risk the pensions and the savings of the Americans.' The comments came as Brussels backed down at the eleventh hour from plans to impose retaliatory tariffs. The EU's tariffs on US steel and aluminium exports were due to come into effect after midnight on July 14, but Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission president, said these will now be put on hold until early August. Mr Tajani also said the European Central Bank should consider cutting interest rates to boost the economy, as well as implementing a new 'quantitative easing' bond-buying-programme. Germany's Dax was down 1pc in premarket trading amid the tariff turmoil, with France's Cac 40 down 0.9pc. The euro fell to a three-week low against the dollar after Mr Trump's letter to European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen, which was posted on his Truth Social platform. Both the European Union and Mexico described the tariffs as unfair and disruptive, while the EU said it would extend its suspension of countermeasures to US tariffs until early August and continue to press for a negotiated settlement.

Steve Bannon, Megyn Kelly slam Trump admin over Epstein case
Steve Bannon, Megyn Kelly slam Trump admin over Epstein case

The Herald Scotland

time18 minutes ago

  • The Herald Scotland

Steve Bannon, Megyn Kelly slam Trump admin over Epstein case

While New York's chief medical examiner ruled in 2019 that Epstein died by suicide, Trump on the 2024 campaign trail said he would declassify federal files on the man. A new report released last week by the FBI and Department of Justice said officials found no such list or proof that Epstein was murdered in custody. Timeline: Trump's team promised transparency on Epstein. Here's what they actually delivered. The findings quickly prompted pushback among members of Trump's inner circle and voters alike, who alleged the president's administration wasn't living up to its promises of transparency with the American people. "Please understand the EPSTEIN AFFAIR is not going away," Trump's former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn wrote in a post directed to the president. He warned that unanswered questions means that "moving forward on so many other monumental challenges our nation is facing becomes much harder." Well-known MAGA figures have been publicly airing their grievances with Attorney General Pam Bondi for days following the release of the government's memo. She drew particular criticism over an interview with Fox News in February during which she was asked a question about the so-called client list. "It's sitting on my desk right now to review," Bondi said at the time. But in a July 8 Cabinet meeting, Bondi clarified she was referring to the files in totality. The Epstein case fallout reached a fever pitch July 11, with even those inside the administration reportedly perturbed. FBI Deputy Director Dan Bongino, the second-highest official at the bureau, did not come into work and was weighing resignation, according to CNN and Semafor. But major Republican voices have also said the management of the case has to go beyond Justice Department officials - reaching the president himself. "It's deeper than Epstein," former White House strategist and podcaster Steve Bannon told a crowd of young conservatives at Turning Point USA's Student Action Summit July 12. He went on to predict real electoral consequences for Republicans in the near future. "For this to go away," Bannon said, "you're going to lose 10 percent of the MAGA movement. If we lose 10 percent of the MAGA movement right now, we're going to lose 40 seats in (2026), we're going to lose the presidency." Another public figure typically in Trump's corner, Megyn Kelly also voiced skepticism about law enforcement's recent review of the Epstein files. "There are really only two options," Kelly, a political commentator who identifies as an independent, wrote on X July 12. "There's no huge undisclosed there there on Epstein, Bondi misled on it (until she didn't) & Trump is quick to forgive a loyal soldier for being desperate to get on TV," she said. Or, "There is a scandal that's being covered up & it's at his direction."

Trump assassination attempt still reverberates one year later
Trump assassination attempt still reverberates one year later

The Herald Scotland

time18 minutes ago

  • The Herald Scotland

Trump assassination attempt still reverberates one year later

"It is very hard not see the hand of Providence on his life, and on the life of our nation," said Ralph Reed, a prominent religious conservative who recounted to USA TODAY that he texted Trump after the U.S. military bombed Iran last month to share his view that the president's life was saved for that historic foreign policy moment. Trump has embarked on one of the most consequential and controversial opening stretches of any presidential term in modern memory - striking Iran's nuclear facilities, overhauling the federal government and pursuing mass deportations. Allies believe his near-death experience on July 13, 2024, has colored this approach to the presidency and made him even more motivated than the last time Trump ran the country. "When you have one of these moments, you realize every day counts ... and that you need to have a profound, lasting impact," said Sean Spicer, who was the White House press secretary during Trump's first term. "And I think that's why he is so mission-driven right now." A dramatic turning point for the 2024 campaign The assassination attempt wasn't just a pivotal moment for Trump. Historians say the shooting continues to reverberate nationwide a year later. "I think it was a dramatic turning point," said presidential historian Douglas Brinkley, who described Butler as "extremely important in U.S. presidential history." He noted Trump quickly gained new support after the shooting, expanding his coalition. Trump got a political boost in the immediate aftermath of Butler, which came shortly after a disastrous debate for then-President Joe Biden, which helped force the Democratic incumbent - then 81 years old - out of the race. Republicans rallied around their wounded standard-bearer, who famously appeared at the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee two days later with a large white bandage on his ear. It quickly caught on at the GOP gathering as attendees donned ear bandages in solidarity. The shooting added to a sense among Trump supporters that he is a persecuted figure, which was fueled by the four criminal cases filed against him during the campaign. "It sort of suddenly rang true, like, 'Holy smokes, they really are trying to get him,'" Spicer said. Musk's endorsement and how Butler is part of Trump 'lore' Billionaire Elon Musk endorsed Trump on the day of the assassination attempt, and later he appeared onstage with him when the Republican defiantly returned to Butler in October for a rally about a month before Election Day. Musk spent nearly $290 million on the 2024 campaign to help Trump and other Republican candidates, which made him the largest donor, by far, of the election cycle. Reed, founder and chairman of the Faith & Freedom Coalition, called the Butler shooting "an inflection point in the campaign." "It made a real difference in his own supporters feeling like they needed to go the extra mile for him and leave it all on the field after he had been willing to step into the arena at the risk of his own life," Reed said. A year later, Butler has become part of Trump's "lore," Brinkley said. It will be featured in his presidential library someday. Its physical effects still linger for Trump, who talks about still experiencing a "throbbing feeling" in his ear. Another reminder of that day went on display in April on the White House State Floor. The presidential residence now features a large painting of Trump pumping his right fist in the air with blood streaked across his face after being shot. The scene captures Trump as he stood onstage, wounded, and defiantly shouted "fight, fight, fight" into the mic before being whisked away by Secret Service agents. It instantly became an iconic image, emblazoned on T-shirts and "indelibly sealed in the American imagination forever," Brinkley said. There also is a statue depicting the moment in the Oval Office. 'I was saved by God to make America great again' As lawmakers and other dignitaries gathered in the U.S. Capitol Rotunda to launch a new administration, Trump recalled how "an assassin's bullet ripped through my ear," imbuing him with a sense of divinely ordained purpose. "I felt then, and believe even more so now, that my life was saved for a reason," Trump said in his inaugural address in January. "I was saved by God to make America great again." The first five months that followed in Trump's second administration have been a tumultuous time. The president has moved aggressively by pushing legal boundaries and testing the limits of executive power. Many conservatives have cheered his actions. Opponents have protested and accused Trump of acting like an authoritarian. In a statement to USA TODAY on the anniversary of the assassination attempt, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt noted foremost the death of Corey Comperatore, the 50-year-old volunteer firefighter at the Butler rally "who selflessly laid down his life to protect those around him." "President Trump will never forget Corey and his beautiful family," Leavitt wrote, adding: "On that dark day, God spared President Trump's life by a miraculous millimeter. Now one year later, President Trump is standing stronger than ever as he continues to 'fight, fight, fight' for the American people." Trump's 'divine right' narrative Trump's rhetoric about being saved by God to carry out his agenda plays into what Jennifer Mercieca, an expert on political rhetoric who teaches at Texas A&M University, describes as a narrative the Republican reality-TV-star-turned-politician has cultivated for years. Kings once ruled by "divine right," the professor noted, a claim that meant they were "placed in the world by God to rule over others, as God's ambassador on Earth." "Trump has been creating his own 'Divine Right' narrative since 2015, but has especially leaned into it since the assassination attempt," Mercieca wrote in an email response to questions from USA TODAY. As he works to expand the power of the presidency in his second term, she said, "Trump's embrace of a mandate from God is rhetorical framing that, if accepted, gives Trump unlimited power." Evangelical Christians have always been an important part of Trump's base. The shooting in Butler, and Trump's deeper embrace of religious language in its aftermath, may also have special resonance for them. Politically, Brinkley said, that has allowed Trump "to be seen as some kind of avenging angel by the Evangelicals who wanted to drain Sodom and Gomorrah." Trump's allies see a leader grappling with a near-death experience - and changed by it. "I believe it has forever impacted him," Spicer said, "in a very personal way." Contributing: Joey Garrison

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store