Will Michigan AG retry Christopher Schurr in death of Patrick Lyoya?
When Prosecutor Chris Becker said Thursday he the criminal case against Schurr, he was asked about the possibility of Attorney General Dana Nessel taking over the prosecution herself.
'Technically, the attorney general could,' Becker said. 'She never has before. But technically I think that's always a possibility.'
Becker said he hadn't heard from Nessel's office about that possibility. Now that Becker is done with the case, Lyoya family advocates are pressing Nessel to take it on.
Lyoya family hurt, Schurr relieved by prosecutor's decision not to retry, advocates say
The Greater Grand Rapids NAACP and the Urban League of West Michigan have both reached out to her office urging her to prosecute the case.
'We are imploring her to file charges to pick this up so the Lyoya family as well as our community can have the justice it so rightly deserves,' said Eric Brown, the president and CEO of the Urban League of West Michigan. 'We are all in support to carry this as far as it can be carried out.'
After Schurr shot and killed in April 2022, Attorney General Dana Nessel that she would take up the murder case against Christopher Schurr if she was asked to.
At an event in Kalamazoo back then, Nessel said she often invites local prosecutors to refer these types of cases to the AG's office. She argued that prosecuting officer-involved shootings can create friction between the prosecutor and the police department, so it's often better for the AG to handle it.
'The Department of the Attorney General is best suited to handle these cases,' she said in 2022.
Of course, Becker ultimately took on the case himself. Earlier this month, his case ended in a hung jury and the judge .
Explaining his decision not to retry the case, Becker argued the jury overwhelmingly leaned toward acquittal with a 10 to 2 vote in the end. He said most of the time, another trial doesn't end differently.
Prosecutor will not retry Christopher Schurr in Patrick Lyoya's death
'What it boils down to is I don't think we reach a different verdict if I do a retrial … the jury came back deadlocked,' he said.
It's an open question what Nessel will do. News 8 has reached out to Nessel asking if her office will get involved.
Nessel's on the case came amid jury deliberations on May 6. She responded to a social media commentator who claimed Nessel wanted her 'own ,' the former Minneapolis police officer who was convicted of murdering George Floyd.
'Christopher Schurr was charged and tried by Chris Becker, the Republican Kent County Prosecutor,' Nessel wrote in a response on social media. 'My department had no involvement.'
Now it's her call whether she wants to get involved.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time Magazine
an hour ago
- Time Magazine
GOP-Led House Panel Subpoenas Epstein Files and Testimony From Clintons
The Republican-led House Oversight Committee subpoenaed the Justice Department on Tuesday for files related to the late convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, despite resistance from House GOP leadership and growing unease within the Trump Administration over the political and legal implications of such disclosures. The subpoena calls for the Justice Department to turn over all investigative materials related to Epstein's decades-long sex trafficking operation, with victims' identities redacted. The Committee also issued a broad array of subpoenas for deposition testimony from high-profile figures across both Democratic and Republican administrations—among them former President Bill Clinton, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, former FBI Directors James Comey and Robert Mueller, and six former U.S. attorneys general, including Merrick Garland and William Barr. The latest activity from the Committee follows Justice Department officials interviewing Epstein's former associate Ghislaine Maxwell, and then Maxwell being moved to a minimum-security facility in Texas. "While the Department undertakes efforts to uncover and publicly disclose additional information related to Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell's cases, it is imperative that Congress conduct oversight of the federal government's enforcement of sex trafficking laws generally and specifically its handling of the investigation and prosecution of Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell," Rep. James Comer, the Oversight Chair, wrote in a subpoena to Attorney General Pam Bondi. The subpoenas come nearly two weeks after one of the panel's subcommittees voted to compel the Justice Department to release the files, just before the House left for its summer recess. House Speaker Mike Johnson publicly resisted the effort, arguing the Administration needs 'room to act' before Congress intervenes. But the committee's decision to subpoena the Justice Department shows that interest in the Epstein files remains high among Republicans, even as President Donald Trump has repeatedly tried to move past the Justice Department's decision not to release a full accounting of the investigation. A July memo from the Justice Department stated that Epstein died by suicide and that no 'client list' of abusers had been recovered—a conclusion that has only deepened suspicion among conspiracy-minded conservatives and Democrats alike. Democrats first pushed to subpoena the Justice Department for its files on Epstein, and were joined by three Republicans to initiate the subpoena in July. The Justice Department will have until Aug. 19 to hand over the requested records. The committee is also requesting that the former government officials appear for depositions between August and October, concluding with Hillary Clinton on Oct. 9 and Bill Clinton on Oct. 14. While former Presidents have often been subpoenaed, none have ever appeared before lawmakers under compulsion. Clinton's association with Epstein has been publicly known for years and included travel on his plane after he left office, according to court records. The Wall Street Journal reported last month that a book assembled for Epstein's 50th birthday in 2003 included a message from Clinton, as well as Trump and others. Both Clinton and Trump were listed as 'friends' in the book. Trump has denied writing the letter and sued the Wall Street Journal. A spokesperson for Clinton said in 2019 that he cut off ties with Epstein prior to his 2019 arrest and was unaware of Epstein's alleged crimes.
Fox News
2 hours ago
- Fox News
GOP showdown: South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson accuses Rep. Nancy Mace of 'ranting and raving'
EXCLUSIVE – As she launched her campaign for South Carolina governor, Republican Rep. Nancy Mace took aim at what she called "weak leadership" in the state. The statement from Mace, which was reported first by Fox News Digital on Monday, appeared to be a subtle dig at the state's Republican leaders, including longtime South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson, who is a top rival for the Republican gubernatorial nomination. Mace and Wilson are considered the front-runners in a crowded GOP primary field in the 2026 race to succeed term-limited Republican Gov. Henry McMaster, who is the Palmetto State's longest-serving governor. Wilson, in an exclusive national interview with Fox News Digital a couple of hours after Mace announced her candidacy, argued that "Mace has been ranting and raving for the last six months about running for governor without actually saying it." Mace told Fox News a week and a half ago, ahead of her campaign launch, "I will fight to the finish, and I will take out South Carolina's Attorney General, because he's turned a blind eye on women and on children and on the state for a lot of reasons. He might force me to do this." Mace, in a bombshell speech on the U.S. House floor in February, alleged that Wilson ignored evidence of sexual assault against her and other women. In her hour-long speech, Mace accused four men, including her ex-fiance, of sexual crimes and said she was among the victims. Wilson vehemently denied Mace's accusations, saying at the time "that allegation was never made to me — no one in my office." Wilson, in a recent statement to Fox News, argued that "Mace is a liar who will do anything to get attention to distract from her liberal voting record. I've served our country and dedicated my civilian career to protecting children." And pointing to Mace, Wilson said on Monday that "it's obvious to me that she thinks about me more than I think about her. I've been very busy doing my job here in South Carolina and I really don't pay that much attention to this person." "I'm not running against anybody," he added. "I'm running for the people of South Carolina." Wilson said as he campaigns for governor, he's "trying to have a message that is uplifting, a message that is aspiration, and I'm trying to demonstrate to the people of South Carolina that I have a record of accomplishment, a record of success and I would be a stable hand on the wheel of South Carolina." And in what appeared to be a jab at Mace, he added, "I believe that you can be an agent of change and reform for our state without being an agent of chaos." Wilson showcased what he called his "real record of accomplishment, supporting and defending victims of crime in South Carolina as well as going after public officials who commit corrupt acts." And pointing to an issue that Mace regularly spotlights, Wilson said "when it comes to standing up to women and girls in sports and protecting women in private spaces, I'm the only candidate who's been in court defending South Carolina's laws." Mace kicked off her gubernatorial campaign with an event at Charleston's Citadel, which is South Carolina's military college and her alma mater. Mace made history as the first female graduate of the Citadel's Corps of Cadets. But Wilson, in his Fox News Digital interview, highlighted his long military career. "The governor of South Carolina is the commander-in-chief of the South Carolina National Guard," he noted. "I've got nearly 30 years in the military. I have served a combat tour in Iraq. I'm currently a colonel in the national guard. And I'm the only person in this race with real combat experience." And pointing to his support from law enforcement, Wilson said that he's been endorsed by 26 sheriffs across the state, including all five in Mace's congressional district in South Carolina's Lowcountry. Wilson said his priorities as governor would be "focusing on reforming our education system, investing in our infrastructure, getting rid of fraud, waste and abuse, eliminating the income tax, and being more accountable to the people of South Carolina will be my priorities." Mace and Wilson are facing off in the Republican gubernatorial primary along with Lt. Gov. Pamela Evette, Rep. Ralph Norman, and state Sen. Josh Kimbrell. President Donald Trump remains neutral so far in the primary. Trump's grip over the GOP, thanks to his 2024 victory to win back the White House, is stronger than ever, and his endorsements in GOP nomination races are extremely influential. Asked if she could land the president's endorsement, Mace told Fox News Digital recently that "I'll be working very hard if I get in to earn his support." And in her campaign launch video, Mace used clips of Trump calling her a "fighter" in a speech, and adding that "when she sets her sight on something, she's tough." But Wilson emphasized he's "supported President Trump as attorney general since his first term…I have defended the president in court. I have defended his agenda in court. I have a great relationship with the president." Wilson added, "I intend to earn his endorsement and earn his support the way he has earned mine. And I've had his back for the last eight or nine years."
San Francisco Chronicle
2 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
House committee issues subpoenas for Epstein files and depositions with the Clintons
WASHINGTON (AP) — The House Oversight Committee subpoenaed the Justice Department on Tuesday for files in the Jeffrey Epstein sex trafficking investigation and is seeking depositions with the Clintons and former law enforcement officials, part of a congressional probe that lawmakers believe may show links to President Donald Trump and former top officials. The Republican-controlled committee issued subpoenas for depositions with former President Bill Clinton, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and eight former top law enforcement officials. The committee's actions showed how even with lawmakers away from Washington on a monthlong break, interest in the Epstein files is still running high. Trump has denied prior knowledge of Epstein's crimes and claimed he cut off their relationship long ago, and he has repeatedly tried to move past the Justice Department's decision not to release a full accounting of the investigation. But lawmakers from both major political parties, as well as many in the Republican president's political base, have refused to let it go. Rep. James Comer, the Republican chairman of the oversight committee, noted in letters to Attorney General Pam Bondi and the former officials that the cases of Epstein and his former girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell 'have received immense public interest and scrutiny.' 'While the Department undertakes efforts to uncover and publicly disclose additional information related to Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell's cases, it is imperative that Congress conduct oversight of the federal government's enforcement of sex trafficking laws generally and specifically its handling of the investigation and prosecution of Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell,' Comer said. Since Epstein's 2019 death in a New York jail cell as he awaited trial for sex trafficking charges, conservative conspiracists have stoked theories about what information investigators gathered on Epstein — and who else could have been involved. Republican lawmakers on the House Oversight Committee nodded to that line of questioning last month by initiating the subpoenas for the Clintons, both Democrats, as well as demanding all communications between President Joe Biden's Democratic administration and the Justice Department regarding Epstein. The committee is also demanding interviews under oath from former attorneys general spanning the last three presidential administrations: Merrick Garland, William Barr, Jeff Sessions, Loretta Lynch, Eric Holder and Alberto Gonzales. Lawmakers also subpoenaed former FBI Directors James Comey and Robert Mueller. However, it was Democrats who sparked the move to subpoena the Justice Department for its files on Epstein. They were joined by some Republicans last month to successfully initiate the subpoena through a subcommittee of the House Oversight Committee. 'Today was an important step forward in our fight for transparency regarding the Epstein files and our dedication to seeking justice for the victims," said Democratic Reps. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the committee, and Summer Lee, who initiated the subpoena, in a joint statement. 'Now, we must continue putting pressure on the Department of Justice until we actually receive every document.' The subpoenas give the Justice Department until Aug. 19 to hand over the requested records, though such records requests are typically open to negotiation. The committee is also asking the former officials to appear for the depositions throughout August, September and October, concluding with Hillary Clinton on Oct. 9 and Bill Clinton on Oct. 14. While several former presidents, including Trump, have faced congressional subpoenas, none has ever appeared before lawmakers under compulsion. The committee had previously issues a subpoena for an interview with Maxwell, who had been serving a prison sentence in Florida for luring teenage girls to be sexually abused by the wealthy financier but was recently transferred to a Texas facility.
