Pro-Duterte posts misrepresent ICC chief's comments on court's jurisdiction
The clip shows ICC President Tomoko Akane saying the court does not have jurisdiction if "crimes occur on the soil of non-state parties by non-state parties or persons".
Tagalog-language text on the video, using a popular nickname for Duterte, reads: "This is it! The ICC president herself said it. Father Digong can go home early."
The post surfaced following Duterte's arrest on March 11; he was then put on plane to the ICC in the Netherlands to face a crimes against humanity charge tied to his drug war in which thousands were killed (archived link).
The 79-year-old is awaiting a confirmation of charges hearing scheduled for September 23 where he will have the opportunity to contest the accusations against him (archived link).
The clip also circulated in other social media posts alongside the same claim, racking up over 150,000 views in total.
But the clip does not show the ICC president speaking about Duterte's case or whether it falls within the court's jurisdiction.
While Duterte pulled the Philippines out of the ICC's founding treaty, the Rome Statute, in 2019 after the tribunal began looking into allegations of systematic extrajudicial killings during his term, the court ruled that alleged crimes committed prior to the withdrawal remained under its jurisdiction (archived link).
The ICC reiterated this position after Duterte's arrest, saying the case "falls within the jurisdiction of the Court as the alleged crimes occurred during the period when the Philippines was a State Party to the Rome Statute" (archived link).
A keyword search on Google found the falsely shared clip corresponds to a longer video posted on the website of the European Parliament (archived link).
Akane was addressing a joint meeting of the European Parliament's human rights subcommittee and legal affairs committee on March 19 (archived link).
The clip used in the false posts shows part of Akane's response to a question raised by Dainius Zalimas, a member of the European Parliament from Lithuania.
At the video's 11:13:40 mark, Zalimas asks Akane whether there is any need to adjust the Rome Statute to include crimes such as ecocide or other crimes against the environment.
She begins her response at the 11:30:30 mark by stating that ecocide is not in the statute, and it is "up to the state parties to amend the Rome Statute if you feel it is necessary to incorporate it, likewise with other crimes as well".
The clip used in the false posts follows at the 11:31:40 mark, where she lays out the limits of the ICC's jurisdiction.
She does not mention Duterte's case in the answer, or in response to any other questions at the European Parliament meeting.
AFP has previously debunked a similar false claim spread by Duterte's supporters suggesting the ICC lacks jurisdiction to charge the former president here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
2 hours ago
- Politico
5 questions for Danielle Citron
Danielle Citron is a University of Virginia School of Law professor. As a leading expert in online privacy and harassment, she has advised Facebook (now Meta), Twitter (now X), Bumble, Spotify and TikTok on issues like trust and safety. She also served on then-California Attorney General Kamala Harris' task force to combat online exploitation and abuse of women between 2014 and 2016. Citron won the MacArthur Foundation's 'Genius Grant' in 2019 in recognition of her work on sexual privacy on online platforms. Citron talks to us about how tech companies have dismantled many of the safety features in their systems, and how the country itself has strayed from its once-bipartisan wariness of data collection. The following has been edited for length and clarity. What's one big, underrated idea? That data collection is not an imperative and not a given. Since the late 1950s, with the advent of data banks, we have essentially presumed that data collection is a good, almost in some religious way. We have long ignored this important inclination that collection itself is endangering our privacy and civil liberties. We've had moments of agreement in Congress in the 1970s that we shouldn't be collecting data unless we have congressional authorization and a really good reason. These are Democrats, Republicans — we were really worried that amassing of information was control, and would lead to really dangerous power in the government and private sector What technology right now do you think is overhyped? What we overhype is the magical idea that AGI [artificial general intelligence] will synthesize information in a way that's close to thinking. Normatively it is so troubling, because humanity is messy and wonderful. It's the joy and love and grief. There's some things I think are under hyped. The promise for me of all this data is health. Let's cure Type 1 diabetes, let's work on cancer. We're underleveraging where it most matters, and we're over leveraging on fake promises. What do you think the government could be doing now about tech that it isn't? [Implementing] the precautionary principle. I thought we'd learned our lessons. We built cars without seat belts, and a lot of people died. And then the car industry faced liability. They then had to internalize the costs. We have learned time and time and again that when you build things just because you can, you don't think about the risks and the harms that aren't in view, and you don't test for them. We really ought to think hard about regulation that requires, especially when it comes to certain technologies, that we just don't build [things] unless we've got not only a proven use case, but also an assessment of harms. What has surprised you most this year? Having worked on trust and safety for the last 20 years voluntarily — pretty much no one paid me to help them on nonconsensual intimate imagery and stalking and threats and harassment — what surprises me is the gutting of both trust and safety staff at these big companies and their ripping apart of their commitments. I really bought into the story that there was some virtue to what we were doing. I feel like I got snookered into thinking this was genuine. I thought they had seen that people were feeling safer on the platforms. It's just the eyeballs are much more worth it to them, because the salacious sells better. What book most shaped your conception of the future? 'Databanks in a Free Society' by Alan Westin and Michael Baker. It's a report for the National Academy of Sciences. It's like 600 pages in which they show how many data banks we have. We get a sense for counties, localities, states, the federal government amassing information and sharing it. If we looked at this book and took it seriously, we would've really in earnest said, 'Hold on, we've got to do something.' This isn't new, this is not unregulable, this isn't something we don't understand. We've been building databases of information effectively since the mid-1960s, and we've been sharing it through network systems since the early 1970s. Intel cancels chipmaking plans in the EU Intel is canceling billion-dollar projects in Germany and Poland, which POLITICO's Pieter Haeck reports will have major consequences for the European Union. During an earnings call late on Thursday, Intel said that it was nixing plans to build a €30 billion chip-manufacturing complex in Magdeburg, Germany, and a €5 billion plant in Wroclaw, Poland. The facilities were set to begin production in 2027, and national governments had pledged to contribute large subsidies to the efforts. In a note tied to the earnings call, Intel announced that it also expects to cut 15 percent of its employees this year. Intel's moves are spoiling the EU's ambitions to boost its domestic infrastructure for manufacturing semiconductors. The bloc has pledged to increase its share in the global microchips value chain to 20 percent by 2030. Yet the EU reported last year that it has only raised its share to 10.5 percent. California's AI rules could set a new national standard After much dissension, California privacy regulators have finalized rules on automated decisionmaking tools, POLITICO's Tyler Katzenberger reports. On Thursday, the California Privacy Protection Agency's (CPPA) board passed the regulations in a unanimous vote. The nation-leading protections enable consumers to opt out of some automated systems that make decisions on everything from college admissions to hiring. However, California's Office of Administrative Law still has to approve the policy plan. Labor and privacy advocates, business groups and Big Tech companies such as Apple and Google have been bickering over the scope of the rules. Tyler reports that none of them are happy with the final result, as many of their recommendations didn't make it into the final plan. While companies handling personal data do have to submit to regular audits and risk assessments, the regulations won't apply to generative AI systems and first-party behavioral advertising. post of the day THE FUTURE IN 5 LINKS Stay in touch with the whole team: Aaron Mak (amak@ Mohar Chatterjee (mchatterjee@ Steve Heuser (sheuser@ Nate Robson (nrobson@ and Daniella Cheslow (dcheslow@
Boston Globe
2 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Hong Kong police offer rewards for tips leading to the arrest of 19 overseas activists
Advertisement According to a Facebook statement by the group on June 30, its election drew some 15,700 valid votes through mobile app and online voting systems. It said the candidates and elected members came from various regions, including Taiwan, Thailand, Australia, the US, Canada, and Britain. While the group calls itself Hong Kong Parliament, its electoral organizing committee was founded in Canada and its influence is limited. Among the 19 activists, police have already offered 1 million Hong Kong dollars ($127,400) for information leading to the arrest of Yuen, Ho, Fok, and Choi when previous arrest warrants were issued against them. For the remaining 15 people, rewards of 200,000 Hong Kong dollars ($25,480) were offered, urging residents to provide information about the case or the people. Advertisement 'The investigation is still ongoing. If necessary, police will offer bounties to hunt down more suspects in the case,' police said. They also called on those wanted to stop their actions while they still can, saying that they hoped the activists 'will take this opportunity to return to Hong Kong and turn themselves in, rather than making more mistakes.' Yuen said in a Facebook live broadcast that the election was not quite successful in drawing active participation, and that the police campaign would help the group rally support for the resistance movement. 'It helps us with a lot of advertising,' Yuen said. During the live chat with Yuen on Facebook, Sasha Gong, another person targeted by the bounties, accused Hong Kong of becoming a police state. She said she is US citizen and would report her case to the US authorities and lawmakers. Over the past two years, Hong Kong authorities have issued arrest warrants for various activists based overseas, including former pro-democracy lawmakers Nathan Law and Ted Hui. They also canceled the passports of some of them under a recent security law introduced in the city last year. The moves against overseas-based activists have drawn criticism from foreign governments, especially given the former British colony was promised that its Western-style civil liberties and semi-autonomy would be kept intact for at least 50 years when it returned to Chinese rule in 1997. In March, the United States sanctioned six Chinese and Hong Kong officials who it alleged were involved in 'transnational repression' and acts that threaten to further erode the city's autonomy. But Beijing and Hong Kong insist the national security laws were necessary for the city's stability. Hong Kong police have maintained that the Beijing-imposed law applies to permanent residents in Hong Kong who violate it abroad. Advertisement In retaliation for the US move, China in April said it would sanction US officials, lawmakers, and leaders of non-governmental organizations who it says have 'performed poorly' on Hong Kong issues.
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
No 'criminal conduct' in death of Wisconsin graduate student, police say
Local authorities say there was likely no foul play in the death of a Wisconsin graduate student who was found dead in the Mississippi River after leaving a bar. Eliotte Heinz, 22, was last seen on July 20 after she left a bar in downtown La Crosse, near the Minnesota border about 150 miles southeast of Minneapolis. Her body was found three days later in the Mississippi River. 'Based on the preliminary autopsy results, we do not believe there was any criminal conduct related to Eliotte's death,' La Crosse police said in a news release July 25. 'Final autopsy results will not be completed for several months.' The investigation is ongoing, police said, adding that they're grateful for the assistance of authorities who helped with the search, as well as Viterbo University staff, students and families. When police confirmed that Heinz had been found deceased, La Crosse Police Chief Shawn Kudron said in a news release that this was 'not the outcome' the department hoped for. When USA TODAY asked about Heinz's cause of death on Thursday, July 24, the La Crosse County Medical Examiner said they could not release information. Eliotte Heinz last seen walking from bar Heinz was last seen walking in downtown La Crosse around 3:22 a.m. on July 20, police said. According to Viterbo University, where she attended graduate school, she had just left a bar called Bronco's. As authorities searched for her, they asked downtown businesses and residents to check their properties and cameras; authorities suspected someone may have captured her on footage between 2 a.m. and 9 a.m. on July 20. Three days after she was last seen, the Houston County Sheriff's Department in Caledonia, Minnesota, contacted La Crosse police about a body in the Mississippi River near Brownsville, Minnesota. The body was eventually identified as Heinz's. Death of Eliotte Heinz has been 'heavy' for Viterbo University community Viterbo University said it plans to hold a memorial for her this fall. Heinz was part of the university's graduate mental health counseling program, her mother, Amber Heinz, told Fox News. She said her daughter was kind with "big blue eyes." She was the oldest of three children, her mother said. Viterbo University said the past few days have been "heavy for our campus and our hearts." 'As we begin to gently return to the rhythms of campus life, we do so with a deepened sense of connection and care for one another,' the university wrote in a Facebook post on Thursday, July 24. 'May this place continue to be one where kindness, faith, and hope guide us forward.' Saleen Martin is a reporter on USA TODAY's NOW team. She is from Norfolk, Virginia – the 757. Email her at sdmartin@
