Ordnance Survey settles in ‘David and Goliath' design dispute with family
Rubbaglove, started by husband-and-wife team Guy and Megan Eaton in 2015, has made its trademark-protected Pacmat blanket with maps printed on them since 2017, initially in partnership with Ordnance Survey.
Designed with their autistic son in mind, to help entertain him during breaks in long walks, their Pacmac blankets are made in the UK using recycled fabrics and feature scenes from across the country, including the Lake District, Cornwall and Dartmoor.
But in 2021, Ordnance Survey launched its own competing range, which the Eatons described as 'almost identical'. The government agency opted to make its rival product in China instead of the UK.
The Eatons took legal action but had little success — until recently, when they enlisted the help of Dids Macdonald, chair and co-founder of Anti Copying in Design, a campaigning group for the design and creative industries.
Macdonald, who described the legal battle as 'a typical David and Goliath' case, advised the couple to contact their local MP, Dame Meg Hillier. She subsequently wrote to Peter Kyle, the technology and science secretary. The Department for Science, Innovation and Technology, which Kyle runs, is the owner of Ordnance Survey.
The company said: 'Ordnance Survey and Rubbaglove have reached an amicable resolution to a dispute between them regarding the designs of OS's picnic blankets. The terms of the settlement are confidential to the parties and their advisers.'
It is thought the Eatons have received £44,000 as part of the settlement but that their legal costs exceeded £70,000. While lost sales are difficult to quantify, sources familiar with the matter suggested that they could run to 'hundreds of thousands of pounds' as Pacmat sales stalled after the rival products were launched.
Ordnance Survey also agreed not to sell a competing product for ten years.
While relieved that the dispute has come to an end, Guy Eaton, 59, is deeply affected by the events of the past four years. 'It was absolutely unbelievable. It's like, 'How could you have the audacity to do this?' '
It hit all the harder for the Eatons because, as keen walkers, they are lifelong fans of the work of Ordnance Survey. 'I've grown up understanding that Ordnance Survey is the best geographic data collector in the world, and they're a great British institution. For this to happen was just appalling at every level,' said Guy Eaton. He added: 'We had no choice but to try and fight.'
His wife, Megan, 56, said she 'felt sick' when she saw the rival products listed for sale online on the Ordnance Survey website in the autumn of 2021. It couldn't have been worse timing for the family; Guy had sustained head injuries in a serious cycling accident in London just weeks before and been prescribed three months of 'complete rest'. So he was limited to joining his wife on calls with Ordnance Survey to discuss the 'situation'. He has since made a full recovery.
Megan said that despite the conclusion of the row, she feels 'jaded' by the experience. 'Years of fighting this has made me so cross. The financial impact on the family has been horrific, as has all the arguing and constant talking about it.
'People say, 'Just move on and do something else,' but that wasn't an option. All our money was in this — I even had to borrow money from my mum. We couldn't move on and do something else; we don't have anything to fall back on.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Embarrassment for Keir Starmer's top aide who told PM he had to smash smuggling gangs - as it is revealed his father's firm was handed £6m to house asylum seekers
Nobody understands the electoral cost of failing to tackle the migrant crisis more than Sir Keir Starmer 's powerful right-hand man Morgan McSweeney. Hailed as a genius strategist, he was bending his boss's ear about it more than a year ago. We need to be tough from the start, the Irishman told the future Prime Minister in a memo. Regain control of borders, he said, smash the gangs, tackle small boats – noble exhortations Sir Keir would later parrot. Failure to address these issues, McSweeney warned, risked handing future victory to Nigel Farage 's Reform UK. Softly spoken and little known outside Westminster, McSweeney, 48, masterminded Labour's election victory, though with Labour lurching from crisis to crisis his stock has shrunk of late. His immigration warnings seem hollow now. Legal and illegal migration is spiralling out of control. Failure to stop the small boats is one thing but much public anger is reserved for the scandalous gravy train of outsourcing companies and middlemen making a small fortune from a broken system. Among them a former caravan park owner from Essex who became a billionaire after housing asylum seekers for the government. For Sir Keir and McSweeney, the headlines were embarrassing. And The Mail on Sunday can reveal there is something closer to home that might cause McSweeney, if not outright embarrassment, then surely a twinge of unease. His father Tim McSweeney, a County Cork-based accountant, has his part to play in the asylum gravy train causing resentment in his homeland. Sharply rising immigration coupled with a housing crisis has fuelled protest across the Irish Sea. As in the UK, there is much criticism of those who have got rich quickly on the back of the influx of new arrivals. Mr McSweeney, 73, helped set up a company that received £6million from the Irish state to house asylum seekers. He incorporated Togail Veilbhit Glas Teoranta in February 2023. He and wife Carmel are the only listed directors and it is registered at the same address in Macroom as his accountancy firm. Macroom is where his son was raised before moving to England as a 17-year-old, initially working on building sites and later joining Labour after university. He now earns between £155,000 and £160,000 as Sir Keir's Chief of Staff. Public records show Togail received £6million for provision of 'international protection accommodation and/or related costs'. Typically, accountants advise on company structure and handle registration and incorporation obligations. But Mr McSweeney senior dismissed a suggestion he was benefiting directly from the contracts. He said: 'Do I look like a wealthy man? I don't think so. It is just a job I have. It is not unusual for accountants to fulfil roles like this.' It is not easy to fathom who gets the money. The company's owners are hidden behind a labyrinthine corporate structure. It leads – via two other Irish shell companies, both linked to Mr McSweeney – to a web of Cyprus-registered companies. Asked how he became involved, Mr McSweeney said it was 'nobody's business'. In addition to its ties to No 10, the McSweeney family is linked to the upper echelons of the Irish government. Morgan's cousin Clare Mungovan is a special advisor to the Deputy Prime Minister Simon Harris. In June, thousands took part in an anti-immigration protest in Dublin, some wearing hats with the slogan 'Make Ireland Great Again'. Others held banners declaring: 'Ireland is full'. Ireland's spend on accommod- ating migrants hit £900million last year – up 54 per cent on the £569.14million cost in 2023. The country's Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan wants to see more of the 25,000 hotel beds occupied by Ukrainian refugees returned to the tourism sector, calling it 'hugely important' to the Irish economy. Back in the UK, Mr McSweeney's son looked on helplessly last week as Sir Keir's pledge to 'smash the gangs' blew up in his face after a new record was set for Channel crossings. More than 25,000 migrants have now arrived in the UK in small boats this year, the earliest that this milestone has been reached. It has been said of McSweeney that 'nobody without elected office wields as much power in British politics' – but he prefers life in the shadows. The highest form of praise at Labour HQ has been said to be: 'Morgan loves it.' But he is a bogeyman on the Left after leading the think-tank Labour Together to purge the party of Jeremy Corbyn's influence. He divides his time between Scotland and Westminster. His wife Imogen Walker is Labour MP for Hamilton and Clyde Valley and the couple have a son. Having been director of the centrist Labour Together, McSweeney ran Sir Keir's successful leadership campaign in 2020 before becoming director of campaigns as he plotted the party's rise to power last year. He was initially appointed head of political strategy in Downing Street in July but soon clashed with then Chief of Staff Sue Gray. There were briefings that he was at the head of a 'boys' club' inside No 10, along with Cabinet Office Minister Pat McFadden, with Ms Gray on the other side. Amid jostling for position between the sides, it was even reported that she had moved McSweeney's desk further away from the PM's office. One Cabinet minister was prompted to say: 'One or both of them will have to go. It's not going to be Morgan.'
The Sun
4 minutes ago
- The Sun
Dragon's Den star stripped of MBE after judge slams high-flyer as ‘selfish & untrustworthy' over £200k in unpaid bills
A FORMER Dragon's Den star has been stripped of her MBE after refusing to pay £200,000 in legal fees. Julie Meyer was slammed by a judge for being "selfish" after she failed to pay her lawyers or attend court hearings. 4 4 4 In 2022, the 58-year-old venture capitalist became embroiled in a legal row with law firm Farrers & Co. She claimed she had received a poor service and refused to pay £197,000 after they represented her during a case in Malta. An arrest warrant was issued for the entrepreneur after she failed to turn up to court and provide documents for the case. Meyer claimed she was unable to travel from Switzerland as she was suffering with conjunctivitis and didn't have a Covid vaccine. But it was decided her reasoning was insufficient to avoid attending hearings in person. Meyer was later slapped with a six-month sentence after she was ruled to be in contempt of court. And last night, the Cabinet Office revealed that the businesswoman had been stripped of her MBE. Her name appeared on a recently updated list of shamed individuals who have forfeited their honours since 2023. Disgraced former Post Office CEO Paula Vennells also features on the list, after she was formally stripped of her CBE by the King. She had already committed to relinquish the gong following fury at her role in the Horizon postmaster scandal. The document said that Meyer's gong had been taken away after she brought "the honours system into disrepute". She was awarded the MBE in 2012 for services to entrepreneurship. Sara Davies breaks silence on shock Dragon's Den exit as star says she struggled to 'juggle' her busy career Meyer was chosen to star on the online version of Dragon's Den in 2009. After her appearance on the BBC Two show, she was appointed as David Cameron 's Government a year later. She has previously supported huge tech brands such as and Skype. Handing her the six-month suspended sentence three years ago, Mr Justice Kerr slammed Meyer as "selfish and untrustworthy". He added: "I am satisfied there is every prospect that the defendant will continue to flout orders of the court unless coerced into obeying them." Later the same year, Meyer lost an appeal to overturn her suspended prison sentence. Three disgraced former submarine captains were also stripped of their OBEs by the King. Top brass urged ministers to withdraw the prestigious gongs from the trio over sex and bullying scandals. One had made an X-rated film on HMS Victorious and a second, nominated for an OBE during his misconduct probe, licked a female officer's ear, blew on her neck and punched her on HMS Vigilant. The third was found guilty of bullying on nuclear-powered attack sub HMS Trenchant. All three were commanders — James Bond 's rank — and led crews of more than 130. The Navy asked the Cabinet Office Forfeiture Committee to strip the men of their awards and King Charles gave final approval. Last year, Grime artist Wiley was stripped of his MBE after he posted anti-Semitic comments on social media. The Met confirmed they were investigating the tweets after he was dropped by his manager and banned from the website. 4
Times
17 minutes ago
- Times
Angela Rayner, the housing tycoon and his £100m cladding bailout
Housing secretary Angela Rayner is poised to throw a lifeline to controversial housebuilding tycoon Jeff Fairburn as his troubled company's bill to fix Grenfell Tower-style cladding balloons beyond £100 million. Fairburn, famed for pocketing £75 million in 2018 while running Persimmon Homes when it was profiting from the taxpayer-funded Help-to-Buy programme, now chairs Avant Homes. The debt-laden and lossmaking business, one of Britain's biggest housebuilders, has seen its costs for replacing potentially lethal cladding soar. Much of the money spent came from loans from the taxpayer to the housebuilding industry which were meant to be repaid rapidly, but it has emerged today that Rayner's department is close to permitting Avant to postpone repayments. Avant's cladding bill has jumped from £68.4 million last year to £106.9 million, accounts revealed last week. That came on top of spiralling losses and debts at the company, backed by Wall Street hedge fund Elliott Management. The cost of remediation was initially footed by taxpayers through the Building Safety Fund (BSF), which then recouped the money from the developer responsible for building the property. More recently, housebuilders have committed to assessing potentially dangerous properties and then paying for remedial works. Avant's £106.9 million is a mix of money owed to taxpayers through the BSF and an estimate of the cost to ensure the remaining buildings are safe. Bosses at Avant have been in talks with officials from Rayner's housing department for more than a year to agree to delay the reimbursement of taxpayers for funds due to the BSF. Payments will be 'deferred and spread over a number of years' under a deal that is 'now reaching a conclusion', Avant said. However, fears that the company could run out of cash persist. The company's 'liquidity risk' rose in the year to June 2024, the balance sheet date for the accounts. Avant has £250 million of borrowing from a group of lenders led by HSBC. It was due to repay the group on July 24, but is understood to have been granted a short-term extension while it negotiates a refinancing of its bank loan. The company is in advanced talks to extend its bank loan to the end of October 2026 — although only £180 million of the debt would be refinanced, reducing to £150 million by the end of March next year. Avant Homes Group Limited generated an £83 million pre-tax loss in the 12 months to June 30, 2024, the accounts disclose. The previous year the company turned a £1.5 million pre-tax profit. Avant's auditor KPMG flagged a 'material uncertainty' over Avant's ability to continue trading for the foreseeable future. KPMG said that Avant's ability to finalise a refinancing and a forbearance deal with the housing department as well as reducing spending on new plots of land would determine whether the company could stay afloat. A spokeswoman for Avant said: 'The group is overseeing the remediation of buildings constructed since 1992. All of the buildings which are potentially in scope were developed whilst the group was under previous ownership and management. 'Avant is making every effort to remediate the building defects created by others in response to the building safety obligations, but the scale and complexity of these obligations have required extensive technical and legal evaluations. 'We have sought to work with MHCLG [the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government], lenders, and independent experts to ensure the remediation, which is a priority for management, is delivered responsibly, sustainably and in as an accelerated timescale as possible.' Fairburn established Avant as one of the UK's biggest regional housebuilders, with significant developments across Yorkshire, northeast England, the Midlands and Scotland. Elliott is the majority owner of the business with Fairburn also owning a major stake. Shareholder loans, which attract 12 per cent interest that is added to the total borrowing, rose from £356 million to £422 million. The government said: 'Viva Midco, parent company of Avant Homes, are one of 54 developers who signed a Developer Remediation Contract with government and we expect all signatories to comply with their contractual commitments. 'We are taking decisive, tough action and going further than ever before to speed up the unacceptably slow pace of remediation, drive accountability across the sector, and provide an end in sight for residents who have suffered for too long.'
