Rs415 billion in losses raise alarms over tobacco enforcement
They pay nothing, follow no rules, and yet continue to grow. The law is chasing what is visible, not what is dangerous.
The formal industry, despite contributing nearly Rs270 billion in taxes each year, now controls only 46 percent of the market. The remaining share belongs to illegal operators selling cigarettes at a fraction of legal prices.
This thriving black market is causing an annual loss of over Rs415 billion revenue that could have supported healthcare, education, or debt relief.
Instead, it is being lost to unchecked trade networks and lack of enforcement. Much of the blame lies with those who claimed to champion public health.
Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids and Vital Strategies ran campaigns targeting the regulated industry while staying silent on the illicit trade that now dominates the market.
Last year, the government shut down both INGOs for operating without registration, funding local entities without approvals, and engaging in policy circles unlawfully. Their work, once seen as advocacy, is now under scrutiny for policy interference and regulatory evasion.
'This is not about tobacco anymore,' said Fawad Khan, spokesperson for Mustehkam Pakistan. 'It is about survival. When lawbreakers take over the market and face no consequences, the whole system starts to collapse. We are rewarding the illegal and punishing the legal—and everyone in the country is paying for it.'
At the same time, the IMF continues to push Pakistan to broaden its tax base and reduce leakages. But fiscal targets cannot be met if entire sectors remain outside the net. Experts argue that unless enforcement expands to include illegal trade, even the most disciplined revenue policies will fall short. The issue is no longer about raising taxes—it is about applying them fairly.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
17-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Wanted 'robbers' shot dead
Two members of an inter-district robbery gang were shot dead in an encounter with the Counter Crime Department (CCD) on Jahanian Road in Khanewal. The suspects, Naveed and Nadeem, were wanted in multiple armed robbery and home invasion cases across Punjab, including in Khanewal, Sahiwal, Vehari, Okara and Lahore. Police said the suspects had been evading arrest for several weeks. They were allegedly involved in a string of high-profile robberies, including a recent incident in W Block, People's Colony, Khanewal, where they held women hostage at gunpoint and stole gold jewellery worth over Rs10 million and Rs270,000 in cash from a banker's residence. They were also accused of looting several shops under the City Police Station's jurisdiction before fleeing while firing indiscriminately. In response to the surge in criminal activity, Khanewal District Police Officer Muhammad Ismail Kharrak and CCD in-charge Mehar Ishaq Sial had deployed special teams and established checkpoints at city entry and exit points. On the day of the encounter, the suspects were seen entering the city on a motorcycle. After breaking into a vacant house in Chowk Maki, they were spotted and fled the scene. They then attempted to rob a shop at Awan Chowk but failed again and continued to flee. The first armed exchange took place near Football Chowk on Stadium Road, where the suspects opened fire on police. The police retaliated, managing to puncture their motorcycle's rear tyre. The suspects continued to flee to Lakri Mandi, where they abandoned the motorcycle, hijacked a rickshaw and headed toward Lahore Mor. At a CCD checkpoint near the MEPCO office, police signalled the rickshaw to stop.
Express Tribune
08-07-2025
- Express Tribune
PAC unearths Rs1.2b bank loan scandal
An audit report presented to the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has revealed that Zarai Taraqiati Bank Limited (ZTBL) employees caused a loss of Rs1.2 billion to the national treasury through a fraud involving forged documents. Audit officials on Tuesday told a meeting of the PACheld under the chairmanship of Junaid Akbar on Tuesdaythat in several cases, loans sanctioned for farmers never reached them as ZTBL employees misappropriated these loans. Appearing before the committee, ZTBL president stated that the bank dismissed 400 employees found involved in altering loan documents. "We have placed personal contact numbers and awareness boards in every branch. We have recovered Rs270 million so far, and recovery efforts are ongoing," he said. The committee asked the president to address the issue in coordination with the audit department. It was also revealed that the ZTBL had failed to recover Rs9 billion in loans with 1,601 borrowers not returning even a single rupee. Audit officials said only 16% of recoverable amounts were collected from borrowers in Quetta, Karachi, and Lahore. They also noted a growing number of loan defaulters across the country. MNA Khawaja Sheraz asked why is the ZTBL constantly sinking when the banking sector is profitable. The ZTBL is a state-owned agricultural development bank that provides agricultural credit and banking services to farmers across the country. It remains the largest public sector agriculture development financial institution in the country. The PAC also took suo motu notice on Jamshed Dasti's request regarding a loss of 1.1 million litres of petrol at the Pakistan State Oil (PSO) due to employee negligence. The PSO managing director (MD) told the committee that the estimated value of the lost petrol is Rs180 million. "We recovered Rs40 million from the responsible employees after dismissing them," he said.
Business Recorder
08-07-2025
- Business Recorder
Illegal cigarette market in Pakistan: Govt urged to prioritise anti-smuggling measures
KARACHI: Fawad Khan, spokesperson for Mustehkam Pakistan, has emphasised that 'Illicit trade is draining the country's resources and undermining its ability to function effectively. We hope the World Health Organization considers that further tax increases could unintentionally encourage the illegal cigarette market in Pakistan.' He further stated that while legal cigarette manufacturers contribute nearly all of the sector's tax revenue, they face growing pressure from untaxed and illicit products, many of which do not carry mandatory health warnings. 'Unless enforcement is strengthened, additional tax hikes may prove counterproductive by driving more consumers toward illicit brands,' he warned. Instead of focusing solely on tax increases, Pakistan must prioritise anti-illicit trade enforcement, as higher taxes without strong implementation may shift more consumers toward illegal products rather than reducing tobacco use. Current data revealed that the compliant tobacco sector generates nearly 98% of total tobacco tax revenue, yet holds just 46% of the market share. Meanwhile, untaxed and illegal products now account for over half of the market, resulting in an estimated annual loss of Rs 415 billion to the national exchequer. While the World Health Organization (WHO) continues to advocate for higher tobacco taxation as part of its efforts to reduce smoking, experts cautioned that ignoring the rampant illicit trade could undermine both public health objectives and revenue gains. If not addressed, further tax hikes may inadvertently fuel the black market for cigarettes. Fawad Khan emphasised that policy momentum must now be translated into action, including the implementation of a robust Track & Trace system, closing legal loopholes, and enhancing coordination among the FBR, Customs, and law enforcement agencies. He noted that similar digital monitoring mechanisms in the sugar and cement sectors have significantly improved revenue collection and could yield similar results in the tobacco sector. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
