Breakingviews - US can squeeze Russia without ‘secondary tariffs'
This would be to persuade India, Russia's second biggest customer, to stop buying its oil while convincing Saudi Arabia to pump more. Doing so would ensure global crude prices do not jump as Moscow's exports fall. The U.S. could also effectively slash the price that Russia gets for its foreign oil sales – going even further than the cut the European Union agreed last week. Together these measures would heap more trouble on President Vladimir Putin's economy, which is already facing strains from a mounting budget deficit, slowing growth, rising bad debts and still high inflation.
What's the problem with going the whole hog and stopping all of Moscow's oil exports? That is what Trump's threat to impose secondary tariffs on countries that trade with Russia is designed to achieve. He said last week that, if Putin did not end the war in Ukraine in 50 days, he would slap 100% tariffs on U.S. imports from states that buy Russian exports.
Such blanket secondary tariffs would have so many drawbacks that financial markets do not believe Trump will carry out his threat. Russian equities and the rouble rose after his comments, while the crude price fell – exactly the opposite of what would have happened if investors thought he was serious.
Putin's country is the world's third biggest oil producer after the U.S. and Saudi Arabia. It exported 7.2 million barrels a day of crude and refined products such as diesel in June for $13.6 billion, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA), implying an annual rate of just over $160 billion. Removing all this supply from the global market would push prices sharply higher. Among other things, that would hurt U.S. consumers, damaging Trump's popularity.
Another problem is China, which bought, opens new tab almost a third of Russia's crude exports by volume from January to May, according to data from the Kyiv School of Economics Institute. Beijing is Moscow's most important ally. So if Trump slapped 100% tariffs on Chinese imports into the United States, he probably would not change its behaviour. He would merely further inflame a trade war with the world's second largest economy and push up inflation at home.
In theory, Trump could exempt China from secondary tariffs, while imposing them on other countries. India and Turkey, which respectively buy about a quarter and a tenth of Russian crude, would be the main targets. The president might have more luck twisting their arms. But a policy that penalised friendly countries while exempting the People's Republic, the United States' most serious long-term rival, would be geopolitical folly.
Fortunately, there are alternatives. Trump could use carrots as well as sticks to persuade India and Turkey to stop buying Russian oil. Washington has extensive relationships with New Delhi and Ankara on defence, trade, technology and energy. By using multiple levers, Trump could craft win-win deals with both countries.
One carrot could be to secure alternative supplies of crude oil to global markets. This would reassure India and Turkey that they would not be paying more for their energy. It would also protect U.S. consumers from higher fuel prices.
Putin would struggle to find buyers to fully take the place of India and Turkey. By contrast, Trump has a realistic chance of getting other suppliers to fill the production gap. This would be impossible if China stopped buying Moscow's oil too.
The U.S. president's first ports of call should be Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, as he has close relations with their leaders. They have excess oil production capacity of 3.2 million, opens new tab barrels a day between them, IEA data shows, which is more than what India and Turkey buy from Russia. Both are keen to increase their share of the global market.
Trump might also be able to persuade U.S. producers, with whom he has good relations, to ramp up oil production. If there was a temporary shortfall in the market, the United States could even release oil from its strategic reserves, opens new tab. It could commit to refill that stockpile as new production came onstream, giving drillers confidence to increase supply.
Cutting the amount of oil Russia can export should be only part of Trump's plan. He should also squeeze the price at which Moscow sells its crude.
The EU last week cut the level at which Russia can export oil from $60 to $47.60 a barrel, taking advantage of the fact that prices have fallen since the Group of Seven wealthy countries agreed the original cap in 2022. If Trump throws his weight behind this initiative, it would be possible to go significantly lower.
To evade the cap, Moscow built up a "shadow fleet" of tankers that did not obey the price limit to transport its oil. G7 countries then imposed sanctions on some of these ships, making it harder for them to operate.
The U.S., which has stronger sanctions than the EU, could penalise all the tankers in Russia's shadow fleet rather than just some of them. If it can get India and Turkey to stop their Russian oil purchases, that would further drive down the price Moscow can charge.
With these measures, a price cap of around $40 a barrel may be achievable. If the volume of Russia's oil exports also fell significantly, it might be possible to halve its revenues from the black stuff.
Putin is defiant, so emptying his war chest may not be enough to force him to the negotiating table. But Trump has also promised to ramp up arms supplies to Ukraine, provided European countries pay for them. If the U.S. president keeps his promise and Europe finds the cash, perhaps by using Moscow's $300 billion of frozen assets, Russia may eventually stop the war.
Follow @Hugodixon, opens new tab on X
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
25 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Former MSNBC anchor makes startling admission about Trump despite recent polling
Ex-MSNBC star Chris Matthews believes 'the country is moving toward' Donald Trump as he suffers some negative polling. The former Hardball host had toed the liberal line as recently as April, when he drew a mocking tweet from a White House spokesperson for criticizing Trump's tariff plans. However, in a weekend interview with disgraced former PBS anchor Charlie Rose, Matthews believes the American people are more aligned with the president than ever. 'To be honest with you, the country is moving towards Trump,' he said, dismissing polls showing he's losing popularity. 'These polls, they come out and show him not doing well — I don't buy that. His strength is still greater than the Democratic strength. He is a stronger public figure than the Democratic people,' Matthews added. Matthews showed what he meant by having to go all the way back to former President Barack Obama to name a Democrat as popular as Trump is. 'Obama still has tremendous charisma — but Trump has strength. And I think that's what all voters look for,' he said. 'They want a president who is a strong figure. And he's got it. It's just there. And half the country buys it.' He also praised what Trump has done on immigration, as well as his foreign policy with regard to the drone strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities. Matthews did dampen ideas of Trump running for a third term but noted that the president was easily more popular and influential than Elon Musk, dismissing any idea of Musk's America Party succeeding. '[Musk] plays the same role as Ross Perot,' he said, referencing the infamous third party candidate who hurt Republicans in the 1992 and 1996 elections and consider those who vote for his party unserious. While some polls have shown Trump on a downward slope, the president improved a hair with voters according to a new exclusive Daily Mail/J.L. Partners poll, even as they give him failing grades for his handling of the Jeffrey Epstein files. Forty-nine percent of voters now approve of Trump's job performance as president, up one point from the tracking survey conducted earlier in July. But he remains underwater as 51 percent disapprove of Trump's job performance, down one point from earlier in the month. The margin of error in the survey of 1,007 registered voters is 3.1 percent. The poll numbers suggest Trump is surviving politically during a punishing news cycle consumed by the Epstein files and his administration's failure to disclose them as he promised during his presidential campaign. The president's job approval is up one percentage point from June and remains his highest rating since May. 'The news saga might have seemed terrible for Trump in the last few days, but it isn't having an impact on his approval rating,' James Johnson, JL Partners co-founder told the Daily Mail. 'In fact, we think it's going up, from 48 percent to 49 percent, making this his best approval rating since May. His ratings with the base is holding up too, unchanged on 91 percent with Republicans,' Johnson continued. But Trump's strong job approval ratings does not carry over to his handling of the Epstein files. Forty-two percent of voters disapprove of his handling of the issue while just 27 percent approve. A significant number of voters, 20 percent, did not appear to care about the case as they neither approved nor disapproved Trump's handling of the issue. In the Oval Office on Wednesday, Trump referred to the ongoing saga as a 'witch hunt' indicating he was tired of answering questions from the media about it. Despite the president's best efforts to put the issue behind him, few voters believe in the administration's assessment of the case. Only fifteen percent in the poll said they believed the Justice Department's memo released by Attorney General Pam Bondi concluding that Epstein committed suicide in prison and that the infamous pedofile did not have a 'client list' they could release. Forty-seven percent said they did not believe the administration's account of the Epstein case, and that they believed there was more secrets to uncover. Twenty-three percent said they believed the Trump administration memo, but that there was more to uncover in the case. 'This is despite voters disapproving of his handling of the Epstein scandal. What explains the difference? Voters simply do not rate it highly on their list of priorities,' Johnson said. Ninety percent of the Republican voter base continue to grant the president solid approval ratings, despite their misgivings about the Epstein files. The poll was conducted as Trump furiously contested a Wall Street Journal report that he had signed a letter to Epstein for his 50th birthday which concluded: 'Happy Birthday - and may every day be another wonderful secret,' and featured a hand-drawn image of a naked woman as well as his signature. Trump decried the news article as 'fake' and filed a $10 billion lawsuit against the company. 'They are judging Trump on other issues - such as the economy, the southern border, and how he is actually running the country. Their grumbles on the Epstein handling are not enough for them to turn on their man,' Johnson said. While the majority of Republicans, 52 percent, give Trump a passing grade on his handling of the Epstein files, just 13 percent of Independent voters feel the same way. Fifty percent of independent voters in the survey said they disapproved of the way the Trump administration has handled the Epstein files case.
The Guardian
25 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Moscow starts direct flights to North Korea amid decline in options for Russian tourists
Direct flights from Moscow to North Korea have begun this week, amid a strengthening of ties between the two nations and a decline in options for Russian tourists travelling abroad. The first Moscow-Pyongyang flight, operated by Russia's Nordwind Airlines, took off on Sunday, according to the Sheremetyevo airport's website, and landed in the North Korean capital about eight hours later. The route will initially be serviced only once a month, Russia's transport ministry said, with the first return flight from Pyongyang to Moscow taking place on Tuesday. Nordwind Airlines – which used to carry Russians to holiday destinations in Europe before the EU imposed a ban on Russian flights – had tickets priced at 45,000 rubles ($570). 'This is a historical event, strengthening the ties between our nations,' Oleg, a Nordwind employee managing the flight who did not want to give his full name, told Agence France-Presse at the airport. He also declined to say how many passengers were onboard. Russia and North Korea have been forging closer military bonds in recent years, with Pyongyang supplying troops and weapons for Russia's military operations in Ukraine. They signed a mutual defence pact last year when the Russian president, Vladimir Putin, visited North Korea. 'For the first time in more than 70 years of diplomatic relations, we are launching direct flights between the capitals of our countries,' Russia's deputy transport minister, Vladimir Poteshkin, was quoted as saying on the ministry's Telegram account. It comes as North Korea pushes its own tourism drive, as it slowly relaxes restrictions on overseas visitors introduced during the Covid-19 pandemic. Regular tourism is still effectively banned, although Russian tourists have been allowed to visit certain parts of the country on group tours, and foreign runners competed in a marathon in Pyongyang in April. In June, North Korean leader Kim Jong-un launched a new beach resort located on the country's east coast which authorities reportedly hope will attract 20,000 visitors a year. With Agence France-Presse
Reuters
25 minutes ago
- Reuters
Stocks cheer the art of Trump's trade deals after EU agreement
SINGAPORE, July 28 (Reuters) - Global stocks rose and the euro firmed on Monday after a tradeagreement between the United States and the EU lifted sentiment and provided clarity in a pivotal week headlined by the Federal Reserve and the Bank of Japan policy meetings. The U.S. struck a framework trade agreement with the European Union, imposing a 15% import tariff on most EU goods - half the threatened rate, a week after agreeing to a trade deal with Japan that lowered tariffs on auto imports. Countries are scrambling to finalise trade deals ahead of the August 1 deadline, with talks between the U.S. and China set for Monday in Stockholm amid expectation of another 90-day extension to the truce between the top two economies. "A 15% tariff on European goods, forced purchases of U.S. energy and military equipment and zero tariff retaliation by Europe, that's not negotiation, that's the art of the deal," said Prashant Newnaha, senior Asia-Pacific rates strategist at TD Securities. "A big win for the U.S." S&P 500 futures rose 0.4% and the Nasdaq futures gained 0.5% while the euro firmed across the board, rising against the dollar, sterling and yen. European futures surged nearly 1%. In Asia, Japan's Nikkei slipped after touching a one-year high last week while MSCI's broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan (.MIAPJ0000PUS), opens new tab was up 0.27%, just shy of the almost four-year high it touched last week. While the baseline 15% tariff will still be seen by many in Europe as too high, compared with Europe's initial hopes to secure a zero-for-zero tariff deal, it is better than the threatened 30% rate. The deal with the EU provides clarity to companies and averts a bigger trade war between the two allies that account for almost a third of global trade. "Putting it all together, what we've seen with Japan, with the EU, with the talks which are due to be held in Stockholm between the U.S. and China, it really does negate the risk of a prolonged trade war," said Tony Sycamore, market analyst at IG. "The importance of the August tariff deadline has significantly been diffused." The Australian dollar , often seen as a proxy for risk sentiment, was 0.12% higher at $0.65725 in early trading, hovering around the near eight-month peak scaled last week. In an action-packed week, investors will watch out for the monetary policy meetings from the Fed and the BOJ as well as the monthly U.S. employment report and earnings reports from megacap companies Apple (AAPL.O), opens new tab, Microsoft (MSFT.O), opens new tab and Amazon (AMZN.O), opens new tab. While the Fed and the BOJ are expected to stand pat on rates, comments from the officials will be crucial for investors to gauge the interest rate path. The trade deal with Japan has opened the door for the BOJ to raise rates again this year. Meanwhile, the Fed is likely to be cautious on any rate cuts as officials seek more data to determine if tariffs are worsening inflation before they ease rates further. But tensions between the White House and the central bank over monetary policy have heightened, with Trump repeatedly denouncing Fed Chair Jerome Powell for not cutting rates. Two of the Fed Board's Trump appointees have articulated reasons for supporting a rate cut this month. ING economists expect December to be the likely starting point for rate cuts, but it "may be a 50 basis point cut, if the evidence on weaker jobs and GDP growth becomes more apparent as we anticipate." "This would be a similar playbook to the Federal Reserve's actions in 2024, where it waited until it was completely comfortable to commit to a lower interest rate environment," they said in a note.
