Should it be illegal to pay for sex in Scotland?
An attempt is being made at the
Scottish Parliament
to reverse this and shift the focus onto buyers.
There is no ban on the sale and purchase of sex. But soliciting in public and running a brothel are against the law.
Buyers face sanctions for kerb crawling.
An approach known as 'the Nordic Model'. It was pioneered in Sweden. Other countries, including Norway, Canada and Northern Ireland, have adopted variations of it.
It shifts the focus of criminalisation from those selling sex to those buying it.
Services and support are offered to those who wish to exit the sex trade.
Some women who sell sex say criminalising clients will put them more at risk of violence by driving the industry underground.
Channel 4 News has spoken to women who are fighting for full decriminalisation instead.
Laura Baillie from Scotland for Decrim told us the bill does not address why people go into the industry.
'The underlying reasons of people entering sex work are not being discussed by this bill. Things like poverty, homelessness, the cost of living crisis.'
Others welcome the proposals. Fiona Broadfoot was trafficked as a teenager and now helps other women leave the industry.
'Come out of the dark shadows, men, admit what you are doing,' she says.
'It is violence against women and girls, it is not a job like any other. It is not sex and it is not work.'
Alba MSP Ash Regan was able to introduce this bill to the Scottish Parliament after securing initial support from 24 MSPs across different parties. No Lib Dem or Scottish Green MSP backed the proposal.
'I'm not trying to put loads of people in prison. What I am trying to do is change the culture so it acts as a deterrent and men no longer feel it is acceptable to go buy sex.'
Currently, the bill is only at stage one, which means it is being looked at by the Criminal Justice Committee at the Scottish Parliament. Ash Regan believes there is time for it to be voted on before May 2026, when the next Scottish Parliament election is due.
Number of deaths in Scottish prisons hits record high
Head of Scottish prisons says service should not be immune from prosecution
UK's first drug consumption room set to open in Glasgow
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
31 minutes ago
- The National
Devolved relations reset with Labour has 'failed', says SNP official
The Scotsman reports that a senior Scottish Government source has criticised the UK Labour Government's approach to intergovernmental relations since the 2024 general election. Following the election last year, Prime Minister Keir Starmer spoke of the need to 'reset' the relationship with the Scottish Government in his first meeting with John Swinney. But now, UK ministers have been accused of repeatedly cancelling meetings, not providing documents or sharing information, and 'presenting things as a fait accompli'. READ MORE: New poll predicts Reform Westminster win with no Scottish MPs The UK Government also agreed a new fisheries deal with the EU without consulting Scottish ministers, despite the area being a devolved matter. SNP ministers are now understood to be seeking assurances this is a 'one-off' of Westminster trying to legislate in devolved areas. The newspaper reports that Scottish officials were only told about a meeting with data protection and telecoms minister Chris Bryant (below) 'late on Friday'. This meant there was not enough time to prepare for the meeting on creative industries strategy, officials said, with documents published online half an hour before the meeting took place. 'We were told there would be a reset and we have worked hard to make that a reality, but we have now run out of road because there has been no reset,' the source told The Scotsman. 'It is comparable to the bad, old habits of the last UK Conservative government, which we had an appalling relationship with. (Image: House of Commons) 'It is simply not working.' They claimed the Scottish Government is the 'grown-ups in the room' when dealing with the UK Government. A spokesperson for the UK Government said in response: 'Whoever this senior Scottish Government source is, they appear to be contradicting the comments of John Swinney himself, who hailed relations as 'incomparably better' compared to the Tory government. 'The UK government has indeed legislated in devolved areas with the Scottish Government's express consent - on better rights in the private rented sector, ensuring ScotRail is kept in public hands, keeping young people safe online, as well as tougher rules on knife sales.' They added that both governments are working together on issues including Grangemouth, Alexander Dennis and the 'clean energy mission'. 'This government has reset the relationship between the UK government and the Scottish Government,' the spokesperson added. 'That doesn't mean we will agree on everything, but where we do agree we should work together. READ MORE: First Minister John Swinney on 10 things that changed his life 'The vast majority of Scots just want to see their two governments work together to get things done, and will take a dim view of people complaining they don't have enough time to prepare for a meeting rather than get on with it.' In May, the First Minister said the relationship between the UK and Scottish Governments was 'deteriorating', in the wake of Starmer announcing the deal with the EU. "It does appear that the Scottish fishing industry has once again been negotiated away by the UK Government, demonstrating that Scotland is an afterthought for the UK Government,' Swinney said at the time.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Scottish arm of Corbyn party set to run in Holyrood elections
The former Labour leader confirmed plans to form a new party earlier this week, suggesting he would be at the helm of a 'left independent party of socialist view[s]'. Following an announcement that suspended Labour MP Zarah Sultana had quit to join the new party, Govanhill writer and poet Jim Monaghan wrote on Twitter/X that he is part of the "interim Scottish Secretariat" of the group, which has been working to prepare for the new party. More details have now emerged of the Scottish arm of Corbyn's new project, after several figures – including Monaghan – shared a statement by group Collective Scotland which indicated it was looking to build "a full-fledged electoral alliance of the Scottish left" to run in next year's election. Jeremy Corbyn and Zarah Sultana (Image: Stefan Rousseau/PA) While the statement did not mention Corbyn directly, it said that "as the left across Britain comes together to form a new political party, the Scottish left now has a similar opportunity to unite". It added: "With the SNP stagnant after 18 years of government, with the Labour party a hollow shell of itself, and the looming threat of Reform and the far-right, the time is ripe for a new progressive, left-wing consensus to form in Scotland. "Collective Scotland is already engaged in discussions towards a conference of progressives and socialists to take place on October 4th in Glasgow. We invite all those groups and parties not already engaged in this project to join us. "At that conference, we will look to build a full-fledged electoral alliance of the Scottish left to run in the 2026 Scottish Parliament elections, and build towards longer-term campaigns in our local communities for the 2027 Scottish local elections. "In partnership with our left allies, we will seek to present a programme which takes away greed and personal enrichment from Scotland's political structures, and gives renewal to our local public services and democracy." READ MORE: 'Stupid': Journalists blast BBC after binning 'high risk' Glastonbury shows The statement continued: "A trend that must be broken in our political traditions is to assume that all politics happens at just Holyrood or one's local council chamber. We want to be more than just an electoral alliance for Scotland's left; we want to be the link to a wider progressive social movement. "We look forward now, as an autonomous party of Scotland's progressives and socialists, to the coalition and partnerships we must build for all of Scotland's left to succeed, not just as a set of parties, but as a wider movement." Other figures to have shared the statement include pro-independence outlet Bella Caledonia and the Scottish Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition.
Edinburgh Reporter
2 hours ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Thousands claim their drinks have been spiked
Almost 8,000 people may have been spiked by drink or drugs on nights out in Scotland over the last five years. Police Scotland data shows 760 spiking incidents have been recorded since 2020 with campaigners warning these are just the 'tip of the iceberg'. Research by the Drinkaware charity has found only one in 10 spiking incidents are actually reported, meaning the true figure in Scotland may be closer to 7600 incidents. Police Scotland say 78 spikings reported involved 'administering a substance for sexual purposes' with the remaining 682 recorded as 'druggings'. The Scottish Government is under increasing pressure to follow the UK Government lead by making spiking a standalone offence in a bid to increase public awareness and encourage victims to report incidents. Scottish Conservative Dumfriesshire MP David Mundell said: 'Having long campaigned for spiking to be a standalone offence, I am very supportive of the provisions within the UK Crime and Policing Bill and of the calls by my constituents, Colin and Mandy Mackie and their Spike Aware UK charity, that an equivalent law should be introduced in Scotland. 'While completely respecting the devolution settlement, I am strongly of the view that there should be a common approach across the UK. 'It should not matter whether somebody is spiked in Glasgow, Manchester or Cardiff, the effect and the impact should be the same wherever people are, and the criminality should most certainly be the same.' Scottish Liberal Democrat Liam McArthur MSP said it can often be 'difficult and confusing' for victims to report spiking incidents. He said: 'It doesn't help that currently there are multiple laws which cover cases of spiking. 'The Scottish Government should explore whether creating a specific criminal offence would help potential victims come forward to report and help the police identify patterns of offending.' Charities say spiking is premeditated and far more common than understood, leaving victims traumatised and in some cases seriously harmed. Perpetrators secretly administer knock-out drugs to victims with some leading to sex offences, robbery or thefts, rendering victims disorientated with no memory of the event. There is also growing concern over the rise of 'spiking for fun', where victims are spiked in a sick game dubbed 'Take Them Down' purely for entertainment. Colin Mackie who, together with wife Mandy, launched charity Spike Aware UK following the tragic sudden death of their 18-year-old son Greg in a spiking incident, said the data masked the true scale of the problem in Scotland. He said most offences were going unreported due to embarrassment or fear of not being believed. Mr Mackie also called on the Scottish Government to make spiking a specific criminal offence for the first time. He said: 'Police Scotland's data is only the tip of the iceberg as the majority of spiking attacks go unreported. 'This is usually because victims have been drinking alcohol and are fearful of not being believed and accused of drinking too much. 'Many of the victims cannot actually recall the detail of what happened to them due to the effects on their memory.' Mr Mackie added: 'There are increasing incidents of victims being targeted for spiking for the sake of it or for fun with no theft or assault taking place. 'A lot of perpetrators are doing it because they think it's something funny to do and that they won't face any repercussions.' Data shows Glasgow and Edinburgh had the highest number of spiking reports with 240 and 168 respectively, with the lowest numbers coming from Argyll and West Dunbartonshire at 12 and Ayrshire and Dumfries and Galloway at 13. Police Scotland say they continue to investigate reports of 'spiking' and warn adding drugs or alcohol to someone's drink, or by injection, without their consent 'is a criminal offence'. A spokesperson said: 'Every report is taken seriously and investigated robustly. 'We are working in communities, with licensees, pubs and clubs, to provide advice and support and to offer bystander training to help spot the signs of when someone may be at risk. 'We would encourage anyone who believes they have had their drink spiked or who has been assaulted in this way to contact Police Scotland.' The Scottish Government said there were 'comprehensive laws in place that allow Police Scotland to effectively tackle perpetrators of this crime'. A spokesperson said they were aware of the provisions within the UK Crime and Policing Bill which were 'specific to England and Wales'. They added: 'We will continue to engage with Spike Aware UK, the Home Office and other stakeholders through our roundtable on spiking to assess the need for a similar approach in Scotland.' Photo by Marcus Herzberg on Like this: Like Related
