Archaeologist refuses to revise Keeladi report, writes back to ASI quoting excavation's integrity
More than two years after Ramakrishna submitted his 982-page final report in January 2023—after previous preliminary and interim submissions in 2016 and 2017, respectively—the ASI had written to him on May 23, 2025, asking for corrections to 'make the report more authentic'. In response, Ramakrishna offered a point-by-point rebuttal in a letter that stops short of confrontation but leaves little room for reinterpretation.
'After a gap of two and half year of my submission,' Ramakrishna wrote, 'you have again raised some query on my final report…In this regard, it is informed you that already accepted nomenclatures of the changes in the period was agreed and accordingly the changes of the same was communicated', referring to a letter in April 2023. Responding to the ASI's request for fresh justification of the earliest dating—spanning 8th to 5th century BCE—Ramakrishna wrote: 'It is to inform that regarding the period of Keeladi excavation has been evaluated (as per) the archaeological excavation procedure. Here the period of the site was reconstructed as per the stratigraphic sequence, cultural deposit available with material culture and with AMS date found during the excavation. Based on the findings and facts the final outcome of the observation of the excavator was incorporated in the final report with all documentary evidence, and the chronological sequence of the Keeladi site was clearly explained in the report. The view expressed by you for further examination of sequence is against the well reasoned conclusive finding of the excavator of the site.'
'The tone of Ramakrishna's reply is notably formal, but his words make clear he sees the ASI's intervention as redundant and unnecessary,' said a source known to the letter's content.
Agreeing to minor procedural updates, he wrote'layer numbering will be done if it is found missing'. On the issue of visual data, which the ASI had previously said needed replacements or were missing, Ramakrishna clarified: 'All relevant maps, plates and drawing were given in high resolution format in soft copy as well as in hard copy to the H.Q. at the time of submission of the report. Hence there is no chance of any missing happens, however if anything is found missing will be corrected.'
The ASI's original letter, dated May 15, had asked for a reassessment of the site's chronological brackets, particularly the proposed 8th century BCE dating. It had suggested the earliest date 'can be, at the maximum, somewhere in pre-300 BCE', citing concerns that the three cultural periods required 'proper nomenclatures or re-orientation'. It also cited feedback from two unnamed experts, which sparked disquiet among several independent scholars who viewed the delay and revisions as attempts to dilute Keeladi's significance.
Keeladi has long been politically charged. Following Ramakrishna's sudden transfer to Assam in 2017, ASI closed the excavation citing 'lack of significant findings'. Only after a Madras High Court intervention was the Tamil Nadu State Department of Archaeology allowed to resume digging. Later findings—including over 13,000 artefacts—strengthened Keeladi's claims of being a significant urban settlement from the Sangam era or earlier.
When contacted, Ramakrishna told The Indian Express that he was not allowed to comment on his official transactions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Lord Jagannath's Ratna Bhandar safe, repair work almost complete: Puri's titular king
Puri, The 'Ratna Bhandar' of Lord Jagannath Temple is safe, and the repair work of the chamber is almost complete, Puri's titular king, Gajapati Maharaja Dibyasingha Deb, said on Thursday. Lord Jagannath's Ratna Bhandar safe, repair work almost complete: Puri's titular king The Gajapati Maharaja inspected the Ratna Bhandar repair work being carried out by the Archaeological Survey of India, the custodian of the 12th-century shrine, for 11 months. Besides him, Shree Jagannath Temple Administration Chief Administrator Arabinda Padhee and technical team members of the ASI entered the Ratna Bhandar and supervised both the outer and inner chambers of the treasury, which were in a dilapidated state. Deb said the structural revamp and aesthetics of the Ratna Bhandar reflect Odisha's timeless temple architecture. Around 600 stone slabs were replaced with new ones, replicating traditional design while reinforcing safety, the titular king told reporters outside the 65-metre tall imposing temple. 'Whatever little work is left is expected to be completed by Niladri Bije on July 8,' he said. Deb said that after completion of the repair work, the SJTA, with permission of the state government, would undertake an inventory of valuables. The Ratna Bhandar was reopened on Sunday after 46 years for an inventory of valuables and the repair of its structure, officials said. The ASI began working inside the Ratna Bhandar in July 2024, when it was reopened after 46 years to prepare an inventory of valuables and repair its structure. Sources said that a total of 14 beams have been repaired. More than 80 skilled craftsmen are engaged in the repair work of the Ratna Bhandar. Padhee said that interior repairs are nearly complete, with final touches to the outer treasury expected within the next two days. The outer and inner parts of Ratna Bhandar are being preserved by applying chemical coatings, he said while replying to a question. He said there have been additions like new stainless-steel and Burma Teak wood security gates. The gate will have silver cladding later on, he said. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Time of India
13 hours ago
- Time of India
Sheesh Mahal's Splendour Back To Life After Major Restoration
New Delhi: The historic Sheesh Mahal in northwest Delhi's Shalimar Bagh was on Wednesday reopened to visitors after comprehensive restoration. Lieutenant governor V K Saxena, chief minister Rekha Gupta and Union minister for culture and tourism Gajendra Singh Shekhawat were present at its inauguration. The magnificent 17th-century palace, constructed under Emperor Shah Jahan's reign, showcases exquisite Mughal architectural elements. The structure is a significant component of the expansive Mughal garden complex. Shalimar Bagh was built in 1653 by Shah Jahan's third wife Izz-un-Nissa. It was intended to be a replica of Shalimar Bagh in Kashmir, which was created by Emperor Jahangir in 1619. The place is one of the few remaining Mughal-era pavilions still intact in Delhi outside of Red Fort and Humayun's Tomb complexes. You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi Sheesh Mahal's mirror mosaic work, though heavily damaged and hardly visible now, once reflected the opulence of Shah Jahan's vision. The garden layout and water channels in front of the palace were meant to evoke paradise, offering both respite and a display of dominion over nature. Although now largely abandoned, the garden retains its shaded trees, majestic parterre and several ruined structures, including Sheesh Mahal and the garden pavilion. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like One of the Most Successful Investors of All Time, Warren Buffett, Recommends: 5 Books for Turning... Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Click Here Undo Over time, the complex witnessed many historical events and rulers, gaining political prominence when Aurangzeb held his imperial coronation here. It also served military purposes during the 1857 Uprising when British forces camped in the garden and damaged parts of the structure. As part of its restoration plan, while Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) restored Sheesh Mahal's heritage elements, Delhi Development Authority (DDA) developed a Mughal-style Char Bagh landscape design facing the palace to complement the monument. The huge lawn and ornamental lights added a majestic touch to the place. Originally constructed of bricks and red sandstone, with entry gates in the east and west, the palace has an archway, flanked on either side by a three-arched dalan. Beyond the archway is a central hall with a compartment at each wing. Phase I of the restoration, carried out in 2024, included stabilising the structure. Under Phase II, which began this April, intricate floral painting and designs on the roof have been restored beautifully. ASI has also replaced damaged red sandstone with new ones closely resembling Mughal-era structures, undertaking lime punning with a mixture matching the original composition and redesigning fading patterns of walls. A spot visit by TOI revealed that the walls and roof have been neatly repaired. In the palace's central hall, however, the flooring continues to wear a raw look. Officials said the restoration was undertaken on the initiative of and under the direct supervision of LG Saxena. "After taking serious note of dilapidated and crumbling heritage structures, buried under silt and overgrown vegetation due to decades of neglect, during his visit to the site in Jan 2024, he tasked DDA with restoring the heritage site under the technical supervision of ASI," said a DDA official. Apart from the main complex, existing lawns have been enhanced with sandstone pathways and seating aligned with the heritage monument. To enhance the aesthetics, discreet landscape lighting has been provided, stated DDA. The official said the heritage fountain near the main structures will also be revived. After the inauguration, LG Saxena urged the people of Delhi to become stakeholders in maintaining the restored sites "to ensure that these priceless heritage monuments do not get encroached upon again and that they remain forever clean and green". CM Gupta took a jab at her predecessor Arvind Kejriwal, saying, "The former chief minister built a 'Sheesh Mahal' for his own comfort, but this govt has made a Sheesh Mahal for the people. This is the difference between the current and previous govts." Meanwhile, DDA has also restored a near-decayed historic baradari and three heritage cottages within Shalimar Bagh. "The structures were carefully restored using traditional materials like lime concrete, lime surkhi, lakhauri bricks, and natural binders such as gud, belgiri and urad to ensure authenticity and strength," stated DDA. After restoration, two of the cottages have been adaptively re-used for community-focused purposes. Readers Café Corner, a book café aimed at fostering literary engagement, and Café Shalimar, a cafeteria for park visitors, now occupy these spaces, reviving their relevance and making them hubs of cultural and social interaction. A smaller third cottage has also been restored and repurposed for contemporary usage for official purposes while preserving its unique architectural legacy. According to Shekhawat, the ministry is proactively working to protect and promote the country's rich heritage. "We are also assuring full support to DDA in protecting these heritage jewels."
Indian Express
a day ago
- Indian Express
In 17th-century Mughal-era Shalimar Bagh, palace complex, 3 heritage-era cottages unveiled after restoration
Once in a dilapidated condition, the palace complex in the 17th-century Mughal-era Shalimar Bagh in North Delhi has now been restored to its former glory. Union Culture and Tourism Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat, Lieutenant Governor VK Saxena, and Chief Minister Rekha Gupta on Wednesday threw open to the public the revived Sheesh Mahal, a baradari (pavilion), and three heritage-era cottages. Of the three restored cottages, two have been adaptively reused — one now houses the 'Readers Café Corner', facilitating literary engagement, while 'Café Shalimar', the other, is where the visitors can come, eat, and enjoy with their loved ones. The third cottage has been repurposed for official use while maintaining its heritage character. The restoration was carried out by the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) under the technical supervision of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI). The work began following the L-G's visit to the site in January 2024. During that visit, the L-G had taken note of the dilapidated condition of the structures, which were buried under layers of silt and overgrown vegetation, according to the DDA. The Shalimar Bagh, DDA underlined, was built in 1653 and has witnessed multiple phases of Delhi's history — from the Mughal period to the British rule. As part of its restoration, while the ASI worked on conserving the architectural elements of Sheesh Mahal, the DDA redeveloped the surrounding garden in the traditional Char Bagh or a Persian-style garden layout. The baradari and cottages were restored using traditional material such as lakhori bricks, lime surkhi, lime concrete, and organic binders like gud, belgiri, and urad. Speaking at the unveiling event, Shekhawat said the Centre was committed to supporting conservation efforts in Delhi in line with the Prime Minister's vision of 'Vikas Bhi, Virasat Bhi' (development with heritage). Hitting out at the previous AAP government, Shekhawat said, 'When this restoration project was first taken up by L-G Saxena, there was a repulsive government in Delhi. Now, there is a double-engine force multiplying government in Delhi, and CM Gupta, this will transform Delhi into 'New Delhi' soon.' L-G Saxena said the project would help preserve Delhi's architectural legacy and urged citizens to safeguard such restored spaces from future neglect. Meanwhile, the Chief Minister gave credit to the L-G for taking the lead in protecting heritage sites across the Capital and thanked him for his 'constant guidance' in developmental work. DDA said the latest project follows its recent conservation work at sites such as Mehrauli Archaeological Park, Hazrat Nizamuddin Basti, St. James Church, and Anangpal Tomar Van.
