logo
The mystery of the princes in the tower: murdid Richard III really murder his nephews or did they survive?

The mystery of the princes in the tower: murdid Richard III really murder his nephews or did they survive?

Malay Mail6 days ago
LONDON, July 19 — It is one of history's most intriguing 'murders' — the mysterious disappearance over five centuries ago of two young princes from the Tower of London.
Nearly 200 years after they disappeared, two small skeletons were found in a wooden box at the historic tower and reburied at Westminster Abbey.
The remains were believed, but never proved, to be those of the two brothers — heir to the throne Edward, 12, and Richard, nine, the sons of King Edward IV of England, who were reputedly murdered at the behest of their uncle, Richard Duke of Gloucester.
William Shakespeare later immortalised him in Richard III as a scheming hunchback who did away with his royal nephews so he could take the crown himself, sealing his reputation as a child killer.
Now British author Philippa Langley, who helped unearth Richard's body from a central England carpark in 2012, has claimed that the princes — far from being killed — actually survived.
The elder prince, Edward, was heir to the throne at the time of his disappearance and would have ruled as King Edward V of England.
Langley decided to delve into the mystery after coming to believe that the conventional narrative in which Richard had the young princes killed smacked of 'history being written by the victors'.
She was finally spurred into action after reading an article about Richard's reburial at Leicester Cathedral in 2015 which questioned whether the nation should honour a 'child killer'.
'I think I'd always realised that the story sort of developed during the reign of the Tudors,' she said, adding that it was then 'repeated and repeated over time' until it became 'truth and fact'.
Tudor mud
The last English king to die in battle, Richard ruled from 1483 until his brutal death at the Battle of Bosworth near Leicester in 1485, aged 32.
Bosworth was the last major conflict in the Wars of the Roses and changed the course of English history because the Tudor dynasty of Henry VII captured the crown from Richard's Plantagenets.
Langley attributes the accepted story that Richard had the boys murdered to King Henry VII, a 'very, very intelligent individual, but suspicious and highly paranoid'.
'He had a massive spy network working for him. And he was able to completely control the narrative,' she said, adding that Richard ended up 'covered in Tudor mud'.
An undated handout picture released on February 4, 2013 from the University of Leicester shows the skeleton of king Richard III found at the Grey Friars Church excavation site in Leicester. — AFP pic
Taking a cold case review approach to the historical 'whodunnit', Langley says she assembled a group of investigative specialists, including police and lawyers, to advise her.
'They said: 'Look, if you haven't got any confirmed, identified bodies, then it has to be a missing persons investigation and you have to follow that methodology'.
'They said: 'You have to actively look for evidence'. That's when it really started to get interesting.'
Langley put out an appeal for volunteers to scour archives, only to be inundated with offers of help from people ranging from ordinary citizens to medieval historians.
The result was the decade-long Missing Princes Project which she says unearthed a significant amount of information pointing to the survival of both young princes.
Survival theory
Langley now believes that it is up to Richard's detractors to disprove the survival thesis, which she outlines in the new book 'The Princes in the Tower: Solving History's Greatest Cold Case'.
'The onus is now on them to find the evidence that the boys died.
'They cannot say Richard III murdered the princes in the tower any more because we found numerous proofs of life everywhere,' she said.
Key to Langley's conviction that both boys survived are documents discovered supporting a rebellion by 'Edward IV's son'.
During the rebellion in 1487, Lambert Simnel, a pretender to the throne who came forward after Richard's death, was crowned in Dublin.
According to fresh references found by the project, the boy was 'called' or said to be 'a son of King Edward', which she believes points to Simnel being the elder prince, son of Edward IV.
The reaction to Langley's research has been mixed.
Michael Dobson, director and a professor of Shakespeare studies at the University of Birmingham's Shakespeare Institute, expressed scepticism.
'Given the ways of dynastic monarchy, I think Richard would have been taking a very big risk in leaving those princes alive,' he said.
'The chances of their having accidentally gone missing while incarcerated on his orders in the Tower of London seem pretty remote.' — AFP
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Soccer-England's Walsh hope Spain can enjoy Euro final after Rubiales controversy
Soccer-England's Walsh hope Spain can enjoy Euro final after Rubiales controversy

The Star

time13 hours ago

  • The Star

Soccer-England's Walsh hope Spain can enjoy Euro final after Rubiales controversy

FILE PHOTO: Soccer Football - UEFA Women's Euro 2025 - Semi Final - England v Italy - Stade de Geneve, Lancy, Switzerland - July 22, 2025 England's Keira Walsh in action with Italy's Manuela Giugliano REUTERS/Denis Balibouse/File Photo ZURICH (Reuters) -England and former Barcelona midfielder Keira Walsh hopes that Spain are able to enjoy the Euro 2025 final on Sunday after the controversy that clouded their 2023 World Cup triumph. Defending champions England meet Spain in Basel on Sunday, two years on from a World Cup final that was overshadowed by then Spanish football federation chief Luis Rubiales kissing striker Jenni Hermoso on the lips after the game. "There's a lot of respect between both the teams and, I think the most important thing for them as a footballer, is that they can enjoy this final – that there's not the controversy surrounding it," Walsh said from England's base camp on Thursday. "The girls deserve to be there to play incredible football. The way our league jumped after we won the (2022) Euros, if you compare it to Spain it probably wasn't the same and they won the World Cup," said Walsh, who played 64 games for Barcelona before joining Chelsea. "After the final there was a lot of controversy and I don't think, for them, there was enough spotlight on how incredible they played. It was all about the other stuff. "As a professional, that was disappointing to see. I have a lot of friends in that team and I think they probably deserved a little bit more than what they got." Rubiales was found guilty of sexual assault for the unsolicited kiss during the World Cup medal ceremony, and fined over 10,000 euros ($12,000). The incident sparked widespread debate about sexism in Spanish society and women's football, fuelling momentum for the "Me Too" movement in the country. ($1 = 0.8500 euros) (Reporting by Lori Ewing)

Court affirms trio's 35-year jail term for kidnap, murder 10 years ago
Court affirms trio's 35-year jail term for kidnap, murder 10 years ago

Free Malaysia Today

time16 hours ago

  • Free Malaysia Today

Court affirms trio's 35-year jail term for kidnap, murder 10 years ago

The Federal Court today upheld the conviction and sentence imposed on A Malarvili, J Sunil Singh, and C Kavin Mukilan for the kidnapping and murder of Balveer Kaur in 2015. PUTRAJAYA : The Federal Court has upheld the 35-year prison sentence against a former clerk and two others for the kidnapping and murder of businesswoman Balveer Kaur, whose body was dumped from the Second Penang Bridge 10 years ago. A three-member bench chaired by acting Chief Justice Hasnah Hashim dismissed the appeals by A Malarvili, 33, J Sunil Singh, 38, and C Kavin Mukilan, 31, against their conviction and sentence. Hasnah said the apex court had no reason to disturb the concurrent findings of facts made by the courts below. 'We are also satisfied that the trial judge did not commit any error, nor was there a miscarriage of justice,' she said. The bench dismissed the prosecution's cross-appeal to restore the death sentence imposed by the High Court on the three appellants. 'We have no hesitation in dismissing the appeals before us. We hereby confirm the conviction and sentence,' she said. Also on the panel hearing the appeal were Justices Abu Bakar Jais and Hanipah Farikullah. Sunil, a former employee of Balveer, and Kavin were also sentenced to be whipped 12 times as they were below 50 years of age. The trio were sentenced to another 35 years for kidnapping to obtain a ransom from Balveer's family, with Sunil and Kavin sentenced to an additional three lashes of the rotan. Malarvili was spared a whipping as the law prohibits such punishments on female offenders. The jail terms were ordered to commence from the date of their arrest, and will run concurrently, meaning that the trio will serve 35 years calculated from Feb 15, 2015. On Dec 27, 2018, trial judge Zulkifli Bakar convicted the three accused and sentenced them to death for both offences. On March 5 last year, the Court of Appeal upheld the conviction but substituted the capital punishment with jail time following a plea by their lawyers. Lawyers Amer Hamzah Arshad represented Sunil, Jasmine Cheong appeared for Malarvili, and M Visvanathan acted for Kavin. Deputy public prosecutor How May Ling and Iznina Hanim Hashim appeared for the prosecution. The trio were jointly charged with the common intention of kidnapping Balveer at a construction site near Sunway Pyramid in Petaling Jaya, Selangor, on Feb 13, 2015. They were also charged with murdering her at about 3.55am the following day. Balveer, who was 60 at the time of the incident, was involved in a marble and granite business with her husband, Amarjit Singh. Evidence was led during trial that the trio had intentionally caused her death by suffocating her before throwing her body into the sea. A pathologist confirmed that Balveer died of suffocation and not drowning as claimed by the defence.

HP owed over US$940mil by Mike Lynch's estate, partner, says UK court
HP owed over US$940mil by Mike Lynch's estate, partner, says UK court

Free Malaysia Today

time16 hours ago

  • Free Malaysia Today

HP owed over US$940mil by Mike Lynch's estate, partner, says UK court

Mike Lynch died last year when his luxury yacht sank off Sicily. (Reuters pic) LONDON : Hewlett Packard is owed more than £700 million (US$944 million) from the estate of the late Mike Lynch and his former business partner over its acquisition of their British software firm Autonomy, a judge at London's High Court said today. HP was seeking to recoup its losses from Lynch, who died last year when his luxury yacht sank off Sicily – and Autonomy's former CFO, Sushovan Hussain. The US technology giant sued Lynch and Hussain, accusing them of masterminding an elaborate fraud to inflate the value of Autonomy, which HP bought for US$11.1 billion in 2011 before the deal spectacularly unravelled. HP wrote down Autonomy's value by US$8.8 billion within a year and brought a US$5 billion lawsuit against Lynch and Hussain in London, with a judge ruling in HP's favour in 2022. Lynch, once hailed as Britain's answer to Bill Gates, had always maintained his innocence and blamed HP for failing to integrate Autonomy into the company. He was acquitted of criminal charges over the deal in the US and had intended to appeal the High Court's 2022 ruling, a process which was on hold pending today's decision on damages. Judge Robert Hildyard ruled HP sustained losses of over £646 million (US$871.8 million) in relation to the difference between what HP paid for Autonomy and what HP would have paid 'had Autonomy's true financial position been correctly presented'. Hilyard also said HP was entitled to another £51.7 million in relation to 'personal claims for deceit and/or misrepresentation against Dr Lynch and Mr Hussain', plus another US$47.5 million in relation to losses suffered by group companies. HP said at a hearing last year that it was seeking up to US$4 billion. Hussain settled with HP earlier this year.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store