'I need a scan to see if I'm dying or not': Lung cancer patient queries outsourcing and delays
Up to Thursday, 43-year-old Gillian Ryan, who lives in Bandon, Co Cork, had no date for a scan due six months after her last one in October.
'It is a surveillance scan to see where the cancer's at, how it's behaving. Basically, I need a scan to see if I'm dying or not,' she said.
'I did relay how anxious this was making me, this was my life at the end of the day.'
Her last scan was at a private clinic in Cork City under an arrangement with Cork University Hospital (CUH).
However, she was told this is no longer possible even when she offered to pay.
Last week she was given an appointment for June 7 at Bantry General Hospital.
This caused further distress because last year and in 2023 she experienced problems with reading of scans when this was outsourced by Bantry.
'I was just shocked, just shell-shocked that was even an option to send me back there, as that was the very hospital that outsourced my scans only for them to be unreported on,' she said.
The nodule was allowed to double in size, twice, it went unreported.
She had the top section of her right lung removed previously, this nodule formed on the bottom section going from 4mm in April 2023 to 10mm by November 2024.
Her children are 20 and 17, and she said: 'They still need me, and I'm only 43. I don't want to expire this early.
Gillian Ryan had the top section of her right lung removed previously.
'I appreciate other people are waiting but I can only think of me and my two children, I don't want to leave them motherless.'
She added: 'I was told last April [2024] that I would never have to go back to Bantry, that all my care would be in the CUH going forward.'
She has been told by staff informally there is no resident radiologist in Bantry.
'It just feels like I'm being swept under the carpet, that my life doesn't matter,' she said.
'I do think priority should be given to people who're going through cancer.
We should have learned from the CervicalCheck not to outsource our scans.
Ms Ryan discussed this with the Irish Examiner on Wednesday when she had "no concrete date".
Questions were submitted to the HSE Southwest on Thursday morning.
Later that day after Ms Ryan contacted CUH again, the private clinic said CUH authorised an appointment for Friday morning with it.
'This scan determines the course of my life,' she said afterwards.
'I should never have had to fight, beg. This is your life and your life matters.'
HSE Southwest said cancer care is led the CUH Cancer Centre, with some surveillance scans at Bantry.
'The interval between these scans may vary, depending on each patient's treatment plan,' a spokeswoman said on Friday.
The radiology systems at both hospitals are linked meaning scans taken there can be viewed, read, and reported at CUH.
'We can confirm that an external company provides radiology reporting services at Bantry General Hospital.
"This service is accredited and subject to regular audit,' she said.
The hospital does not comment on individual patients' treatment.
It is understood CUH has been in touch with Ms Ryan and intends to review her care.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
CervicalCheck diagnosed and treated 162 women for cervical cancer in a year
Over the course of one year alone 162 women were diagnosed and treated for cervical cancer through CervicalCheck, a new report shows. The report, covering April 2022-March 2023, also shows that among 269,550 women screened some 11% had HPV - the virus responsible for almost all cervical cancer. These women are monitored so if cancer develops it can be treated early. The report found that 75% of eligible women were tested, while the target is 80% and CervicalCheck clinical director Dr Noirin Russell is keen to see this 80% figure reached. She has raised concerns about 'women who are on the fence' about testing, saying they may not be aware of the benefits of regular testing. "If a woman is diagnosed with cancer after attending for screening, there's an 80% chance she will be diagnosed with stage 1," she said. This early stage can be more treatable. 'In Ireland today your chance of being diagnosed with a late stage cancer, so Stage 2 or above, if you get screened is one in 10,000. If you don't get screened, it's 10 times higher,' she said. This is because screening can help identify early signs of cancer. 'The incidence (of cervical cancer) has gone from 15 per 100,000 down to 10 per 100,000, that's the proof the programme works,' she said. She acknowledged 'this terrible outcome that we see in the newspapers and we really all want to avoid - it's one in 10,000 so that means it is someone'. Dr Russell said she could not comment on individual cases. Concerns around cervical cancer testing were back in the spotlight in June when Cork woman Leona Macken received an apology for failings in her care at the High Court. Ms Macken, who has cervical cancer, sued over two tests, conducted in 2016 and 2020, which it was claimed were incorrectly reported as negative. Sample checking is currently shared between Quest Diagnostics in America and the national laboratory in Dublin. Dr Russell said she is aware of calls to conduct checks only in Ireland. Leona Macken (centre) and her husband Alan (right) settled their legal action against the HSE arising from what they said were failures in the CervicalCheck screening programme in 2016 and 2020. File photo: Collins Courts '(the Irish laboratory) never did more than 10% until this year, and they are on target to get up to approximately 20% of the programme work,' she said. However, she said that interval cancers – cervical cancer found between screening tests – and false negative results can happen in all systems. 'That is not limited to a particular laboratory, that is going to be what we find in cancer cases,' she said. She has worked with advocacy group 221 plus on reforms, saying: 'They felt the programme didn't really explain false negatives and that this is a possible outcome.' She urged: 'It's really important that anyone with symptoms, even if they've had a normal screening test, have those symptoms investigated.' Dr Russell has visited Quest Diagnostics, saying: 'It's done in a particular quarter of the laboratory, so it's a completely different pathway of care. And they follow the Irish standards.' The scientists also do regular skills-tests where they check already-analysed samples and must match the results in 95% of cases. This is assessed by Quest and in Limerick by the National Cervical Screening Programme. Dr Russell said: 'There is an understanding in the cyto-screening community that you can't ask your screeners to get 100% in the proficiency test. If they are getting 95% they are working at the most achievable human level there is but then there will be abnormalities that are missed.'
Irish Examiner
5 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Rise in covid-19 cases sees surge in presentations to CUH emergency department
A rise in covid-19 cases has contributed to a near-30% seasonal surge in presentations at one of Ireland's busiest emergency departments (EDs). It comes as Cork University Hospital (CUH) continues to try to ease the pressure on its ED, which reported exceptionally high patient attendances earlier this week. The Irish Examiner has established that there were 585 attendances at its ED from July 27 to July 29 in 2024. However, the presentation figure surged to 761 for the same period this year, with an additional 176 people attending its ED between Sunday and Tuesday of this week, compared to the same period last year. 'It remains difficult to pinpoint the exact drivers of these elevated self-presenting numbers,' a spokesperson for the hospital said. 'However, contributing factors include a rise in the number of people with covid-19 presenting to the ED, and an increase in the number of patients aged over 75 needing admission. 'Today's position shows some improvement, but demand is still above our operational targets.' That 30% increase in ED presentations earlier this week compared to the same period last year prompted hospital chiefs to issue a public appeal on Tuesday for people to consider all care options — including GPs, pharmacists, and SouthDoc out-of-hours services — before presenting at the ED. There were reports of long waits for certain categories of patients in the ED, with an increase in the number of trolleys in the hospital's ED also reported by the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation (INMO) from 40 people on trolleys in the ED on Monday, to 52 on Tuesday, 40 on Wednesday, and 36 on Thursday. "We thank the public for taking note of our request that they consider all care options before attending the ED,' the CUH spokesperson said. 'Their considered use of GPs, pharmacists, and the SouthDoc out-of-hours service is helping us to protect access to emergency care for those who need it most. 'We are working with hospital teams to understand the root causes of these trends and to implement measures that will alleviate pressure on the system.' CUH's chief executive officer, Jennifer Kearney, said given the surge in presentations, it is vital that the hospital reserves its resources for patients with the most critical needs. Patients arriving at the ED are clinically assessed and seen in order of priority, which means those with non-urgent medical needs face a long wait. GPs can now also access a new regional telehealth service, Urgent Virtual Care, which allows them and paramedics to consult directly by phone, or by video call, with a senior medical decision-maker in emergency medicine or geriatric medicine, who can advise someone if they need to attend the ED.
Sunday World
5 days ago
- Sunday World
Funeral details announced for Cork man (68) killed in workplace accident
Pat Corcoran (68) from Boharbue, Macroom, County Cork lost his life in an accident which occurred at the Mid-Cork Pallets premises in Clondrohid village which is close to Macroom The funeral arrangements for a man who lost his life in a workplace incident in Macroom in Co Cork on July 28th have been announced. Pat Corcoran (68) from Boharbue, Macroom, County Cork lost his life in an accident which occurred at the Mid-Cork Pallets premises in Clondrohid village which is close to Macroom. Emergency services were called to the scene and the man was transferred to Cork University Hospital (CUH) where he was pronounced dead. The coroner has been notified, and a postmortem examination will be completed at CUH. An inquest will take place at a later date. The Health and Safety Authority (HSA) has confirmed that a death occurred at a business premises in Co Cork. Mr Corcoran's funeral Mass will take place at 12 noon on Friday Aug 1st at St Abina's Church, Clondrohid, Co Cork with burial afterwards to Clondrohid Cemetery. He is survived by his wife Mary T, daughters Louise and Fiona and sons Jack & Brian. Paying tribute one colleague wrote ''Pat was a wonderful and esteemed colleague and a true gentleman and will be forever missed''. Another wrote ''Dear Mary Theresa and family, we were shocked and saddened to hear about Pat, a lovely man, may his gentle soul rest in peace and may your memories bring you comfort''. Cork North West Fianna Fáil TD, Aindrias Moynihan, said that it was sad to hear of such a tragic event at a local place of work. 'You go to work to do business, and you expect to come home safe. It is very tough for his work colleagues, family and anyone who knows him.' A spokesperson for An Garda Síochána confirmed that gardaí and emergency services attended at the scene of a fatal workplace accident in Macroom . "A male aged in his 60s was taken from the scene to Cork University Hospital where he was pronounced deceased. "The Health and Safety Authority (HAS) has been notified and will conduct an examination.' No funeral arrangements have been made as yet. Pat Corcoran (68) News in 90 Seconds - Thursday, July 31
