All-Ireland winner ‘whacked' boy on leg with stick during alleged assault, jury told
A jury was told today that former All-Star and Clare All-Ireland winning hurler, Niall Gilligan 'whacked' a 12 year old boy on the leg with a stick during an an alleged assault in October 2023.
At Ennis Circuit Court today, counsel for the State, Sarah Jane Comerford (BL) laid out the State case against Mr Gilligan (48) of Rossroe, Kilmurry, Sixmilebridge in her opening speech to the jury.
Mr Gilligan denies the charge of assault causing harm of the boy.
Ms Comerford said that on October 5th 2023, a then 12 year old and his then 13 year old friend went into the Jamaica Inn hostel in Sixmilebridge.
Ms Comerford said that the two believed that the property was abandoned.
She said: 'They were exploring the building when the accused, Niall Gilligan, who owned the property at the time, arrived to check on it."
Ms Comerford said that the jury will hear that the property was vandalised and broken into in the days leading up to October 5th.
Ms Comerford said that the jury will be told that the two boys were outside the property when they saw Niall Gilligan.
Ms Comerford said that when they saw Mr Gilligan, the two boys ran and the 12 year old will tell the jury that 'he slipped in a puddle and the accused came up behind him and whacked him on the leg with a stick and the accused kept hitting him in the leg, his ribs, his hip, his elbow and his hand'.
Ms Comerford said that the jury will hear medical evidence of the injuries sustained by the boy and see photos of bruising and cuts that the 12 year old will tell them were caused by Niall Gilligan hitting him with a wooden stick.
Ms Comerford said that the boy will tell the jury after the alleged assault Niall Gilligan grabbed him by the jacket and brought him out to the road and asked him his name and who his father was.
Ms Comerford said the the boy will tell the jury 'that he sat on a wall for a while because he has asthma and could barely breathe'.
There he met his 13 year old friend again and that boy will say that he saw Niall Gilligan outside the Jamaica Inn and he ran at the same time as his friend and managed to get away
Ms Comerford said that the 13 year old will say that he heard screaming from his friend 'and he waited in an industrial estate beside the property and while he was relatively safe there, he was still very scared'.
Ms Comerford said that a few minutes later, the 13-year old met up with his 12 year old friend 'and let him lean on him while his friend tried to walk home'
Ms Comerford said that the 12 year old told him to leave in case he was caught by the accused.
Ms Comerford said that the 12 year old made his way to the local GAA club and was given a lift home by a lady there who will give evidence in the case.
Ms Comerford (instructed by State Solicitor for Clare, Aisling Casey) said that once home the boy was brought to a local VHI clinic and was then brought to University Hospital Limerick where he was treated for his injuries and where Gardai where called.
Ms Comerford said that Niall Gilligan was subsequently arrested by Gardai and gave an account of what he said happened on October 5th and his interactions with the 12 year old boy at the Jamaica Inn hostel 'which he told Gardai were in self defence and you will hear that in due course'.
Ms Comerford said that Niall Gilligan denies assaulting the boy with a wooden stick and he has pleaded not guilty to the charge of assault causing harm.
Mr Gilligan is also pleading 'not guilty' to producing a wooden stick capable of inflicting serious injury during the course of a dispute contrary to Section 11 of the Firearms and Offensive Weapons Act at the Jamaica Inn at Sixmilebridge on October 5th 2023.
The trial continues before a jury of seven men and five women.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
5 hours ago
- Sunday World
Ex-gangland criminal and convicted tiger kidnapper cleared of having jail phone
Paschal Kelly (59) was accused of having a phone without permission at Wheatfield Prison in May 2023 Paschal Kelly was cleared of the charge in the district court A former gangland criminal serving an 18-year jail term for his part in a tiger kidnapping has been cleared of having a phone in prison. Paschal Kelly (59) was accused of having a phone without permission at Wheatfield Prison in May 2023. Judge David McHugh dismissed the charge, leaving Kelly without a conviction. The accused, from Dublin but with a previous address at Cootehill, Co Cavan, appeared before Blanchardstown District Court charged with possession of a phone on May 5, 2023. The State had sought to produce evidence of a prison internal disciplinary hearing, where it was alleged that Kelly had admitted to having the phone, but defence lawyer Ciaran MacLoughlin objected. Mr MacLoughlin argued that any alleged admissions by Kelly, within an internal disciplinary process, were inadmissible in a criminal court. It also transpired that the assistant governor of the prison, who was called to give evidence, was not in the role at the time of the alleged offence. The official in charge at the time was out of the country. Mr MacLoughlin argued that the State could not prove the case against his client. Judge McHugh dismissed the charge. In February 2019, Kelly was jailed for a €92,000 post office robbery and tiger kidnapping in which three women were tied up and abducted. Kelly was one of a gang of three men who burst into the post-mistress' Malahide home on September 25, 2014. The gang used cable ties to bind her, her daughter and an Italian student who was staying at the home. The women were brought to a field where they were held overnight before the gang drove them to the Bayside Post Office in Sutton. Paschal Kelly was cleared of the charge in the district court Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 17th
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
The law is deeply flawed when a retailer who asks a customer for ID can be sued for defamation
The Defamation (Amendment) Bill 2024 reaches Seanad third stage on Thursday at 11.45am. High Noon. So far, this deeply flawed Bill has sailed through the Dáil and Seanad, unperturbed by anything other than a few TDs and senators mourning the ending of jury trials for defamation. The fact that the vast majority of defamation litigation takes place in the Circuit Court without juries has so far escaped notice in the Oireachtas. So has the fact that Ireland has a higher number of defamation cases than England and Wales combined. In 2023, courts in England and Wales handled 250 defamation cases; Ireland had 360. That means Ireland has a defamation litigation rate 19 times higher than England and Wales on a per-capita basis. This is because our laws encourage litigation, not resolution. READ MORE Retailers, in particular, are being hit hard. Did you know that asking a customer at an off-licence for ID can be framed as a defamatory statement? Or asking for a till receipt? Or quietly refusing to accept a €50 that failed a counterfeit check? All have resulted in legal actions. This is 'retail defamation': situations where businesses are sued (or threatened with being sued) for doing nothing more than protecting their stock or enforcing their legal obligations. The allegations are often minor, exaggerated, manufactured or plainly unfounded. The cost of fighting them in court is so high that many businesses choose to settle, even when they have done nothing wrong. On legal advice, many retailers now operate a 'no challenge' policy toward suspected shoplifters because it is far cheaper to let them steal than it is to defend a defamation action. [ Proposed defamation law reforms fall short of addressing free-speech concerns, say campaigners ] One major Irish grocery operator budgets losses through theft amounting to between €70,000 and €90,000 annually for each of its convenience stores and between €120,000 and €140,000 for its supermarkets. There is another example where a licensed premises successfully defended a defamation claim in the Circuit Court, only to face a threat of a High Court appeal unless they agreed to cover the plaintiff's legal costs. The business ultimately had to pay €3,000 in the settlement and absorb €12,375 in legal fees, with a subsequent rise in their insurance premium. This case underscores how the system incentivises legal threats against SMEs, regardless of merit. The original General Scheme for amendment in 2023 promised to introduce a defence of 'transient retail defamation', a common-sense measure to protect retailers, pharmacists, hospitality workers and others dealing with the public. That protection has been quietly dropped in this Bill. Instead, the Government now points to an expanded 'qualified privilege' defence, which already exists under the 2009 Act. It is already successfully used by retailers to defend these claims, but these are immediately appealed to the High Court. Retailers are still being threatened. Insurance costs are still climbing. And the legal threats keep coming. Worse still, the Bill does not include a harm test to prevent frivolous cases. This is not reform. It is retreat. Some people have framed this Bill as an assault on the right to a good name, but it is an attempt to rebalance competing constitutional rights. Unfortunately, the attempt falls far short of what is expected by the European Court of Human Rights . Both Article 40 of the Constitution and Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) protect freedom of expression. That right is more honoured in the breach than the observance in Ireland. Why the Irish media has been so quiescent on this issue is a mystery. The International Press Institute published a report in 2023 called Ireland: how the wealthy and powerful abuse legal system to silence reporting . It detailed 19 cases of Slapp (strategic litigation against public participation) lawsuits referred to it by various parties. It could not identify plaintiffs of course; to do so would be viewed as defamatory in Ireland. To suggest that a defamation plaintiff is engaged in a Slapp suit in Ireland is ... defamatory. The Irish Small and Medium Enterprise association ( ISME), retail representative group RGDATA and the Index on Censorship have made direct appeals to senators to amend the Bill. Thirty bodies and civil society organisations, including the National Union of Journalists , RTÉ and the Irish Council for Civil Liberties have also called for amendment of this Bill. It is objectively not fit for purpose as legislation intended to address the legal and constitutional shortcomings in the Defamation Act. ISME has made it very clear to TDs and senators that this Bill falls drastically short of what is required to stop abusive defamation litigation. We have tried to compromise and have sent senators proposals for just two amendments: one on the definition of defamation and the other on the capping of damages. Even these will not close the gaps which the EU Anti-Slapp Directive requires Ireland to address no later than May 2026. This Bill will not vindicate freedom of expression. EU justice commissioner Michael McGrath last week described freedom of expression as 'sacrosanct'. If this flawed amendment is enacted, we will be forced to take the matter to the European Commission's Directorate-General for Justice and Consumers on Article 10 grounds under the ECHR. However, we hope that the prime motivator for the Seanad this week is not the threat of referral of the State to the European Commission. Rather, we would like to think our legislators' greater motivation would come from their desire to ensure citizens' rights granted by the 1937 Constitution. Over to you, Seanad Éireann. Neil McDonnell is chief executive of ISME, the Irish Small and Medium Enterprise association
Irish Times
12 hours ago
- Irish Times
Gardaí renew appeal for information on murder of woman whose body was found eight years ago
Gardaí are appealing for information about the murder of a woman on the eighth anniversary of the discovery of her body. Linda Evans Christian (29) was seen leaving the Ash Ward of James Connolly Memorial Hospital in Blanchardstown, Dublin, where she had been receiving treatment, on June 24th, 2017. Her body was found in Coolmine Woods, Blanchardstown, on July 17th, more than two weeks after she had been reported missing on July 1st. An extensive Garda investigation and a number of enquiries followed, including the arrest of a man in 2018. No one has been brought to justice for the murder. READ MORE Gardaí, as well as the woman's family, have renewed their appeal for those with information to come forward to assist with the investigation, no matter how insignificant their contribution might seem. In particular, any person who may have information on her movements around Coolmine Woods at the time of her disappearance is asked to contact gardaí. Ms Christian had been living in the Dublin 15 area. She was 5ft 3in tall, slim with long brown hair and green eyes. She was wearing a green bomber jacket, blue jeans and carrying a pink gym bag when last seen. Given how much time has passed, people may feel more comfortable sharing information around the incident. Anyone who does come forward to assist the investigation will be treated in a sensitive manner. Anyone with information can contact Blanchardstown Garda station can at 01 666 7000, the Garda Confidential Line at 1800 666 111 or any Garda station.
