Spain's Power Utilities Lay Blackout Blame on Grid Operator
Red Electrica didn't ensure a sufficient number of plants were available on standby, industry group AELEC said in a report on Monday.
The April 28 blackout, which cut power to more than 50 million people on the Iberian Peninsula for several hours, has triggered a fierce blame game between political parties and energy companies. Earlier this month, the government faulted Red Electrica for failing to ensure enough backup generation, as well as power-plant operators for not fulfilling their commitments on the day.
The grid operator has accused the power companies of failing to help keep voltage steady, a charge not addressed by AELEC in Monday's report. The group said only that its members, which include Iberdrola SA and Endesa SA, 'acted in accordance with the requirements' set out in current regulation, 'fully complying at all times with the orders issued by the system operator.'
A Red Electrica spokesperson wasn't immediately available to comment on Monday. The grid operator on June 18 said it managed the network properly on the day of the incident.
The new study follows the publication last week of two more reports on the blackout, and adds one more chapter to the recriminations between power companies, the grid operator and the cabinet.
Monday's report said that only 11 thermal stations were operating on the day of the blackout, the lowest number this year, and that only one was operating in southern Spain when over-voltage was recorded. Still, AELEC didn't respond specifically to accusations that almost all of those plants didn't perform properly by helping the grid operator manage voltage with what's known as reactive power, as the government and Red Electrica had previously found.
Data on whether plants performed properly are confidential and are currently being analyzed by Spanish competition watchdog CNMC, said AELEC's Head of Regulation Marta Castro.
AELEC's document claims that steps taken by Red Electrica ahead of the blackout worsened the electricity system's voltage control issues. The decision to connect various transport lines from noon — about half an hour before the blackout — ended up 'weakening the system' and 'worsened the over-voltage existing minutes before the blackout.'
The report also said that the interconnection with France may have been mismanaged, and questions why Red Electrica decided not to rely on five available hydropower plants to stabilize voltage in an effort to avert the outage.
--With assistance from John Deane.
(Updates with more details from report starting in seventh paragraph.)
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
24 minutes ago
- First Post
Europe, America in no-deal deadlock: EU envoys to discuss plan ahead of Trump's Aug 1 deadline
With a trade deal with the US looking less likely and the deadline approaching, the EU is preparing contingency plans for swift action if talks fail read more EU diplomats are gearing up to convene as early as this week to devise strategies for a potential no-deal outcome with US President Donald Trump, whose tougher stance on tariffs looms large before the August 1 deadline. Negotiations with Washington remain the EU's priority to resolve the deadlock by next month. However, Bloomberg has reported, citing sources familiar with the matter, that last week's talks in Washington have not produced any desired progress. Discussions are set to continue over the next two weeks. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD US pushing for near-universal tariff on EU goods According to the report, the US is pushing for a near-universal tariff on EU goods exceeding 10 per cent, with limited exemptions for aviation, certain medical devices, generic medicines, select spirits, and specific manufacturing equipment critical to the US. Earlier this month, Trump warned the EU of a 30 per cent tariff on most exports starting August 1. He has already imposed a 25 per cent levy on cars and auto parts, 50 per cent on steel and aluminium, and recently announced a 50 per cent levy on copper. Additional duties on pharmaceuticals and semiconductors are threatened for next month. The EU estimates these US tariffs already affect €380 billion ($442 billion), or roughly 70 per cent, of its exports to the US. The EU is seeking broader exemptions and protection from future sectoral tariffs, acknowledging that any deal will likely favour the US. Bloomberg previously noted that the EU will evaluate the overall imbalance of any agreement before considering retaliatory measures. EU prepares for no-deal outcome With a deal looking less likely and the deadline approaching, the EU is preparing contingency plans for swift action if talks fail, the report said. Retaliation would likely require approval from EU leaders due to the high stakes, potentially widening the transatlantic trade rift, especially given Trump's warnings that countermeasures would trigger harsher US responses. The EU has already greenlit potential tariffs on €21 billion of US goods, targeting politically sensitive states like Louisiana—home to House Speaker Mike Johnson—with products like soybeans, poultry, motorcycles, and other agricultural goods. A further €72 billion in US products is lined up for tariffs in response to Trump's reciprocal and automotive levies. Last week, Bloomberg reported growing support among EU member states to deploy the anti-coercion instrument (ACI) if no acceptable deal is reached and Trump follows through on his threats. The ACI would allow the EU to impose measures like taxes on US tech giants, restrictions on US investments, or limits on US firms' access to EU markets and public contracts. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Designed as a deterrent, the ACI targets deliberate coercive trade actions by third countries. While the European Commission can propose its use, EU member states decide if coercion exists and whether to activate it.
Mint
2 hours ago
- Mint
India Consumer Earnings Key as Markets Hope for Demand Rebound
(Bloomberg) -- Asia's earnings focus turns to India's consumer sector, as investors look for signs that economic momentum is recovering after central bank rate reductions and income tax cuts take effect. Efforts to shore up the Indian economy are under way as it gradually recovers after a consumption slowdown last year. The Reserve Bank of India has cut the key rate by a cumulative 100 basis points so far this cycle, with the governor in June declaring the battle against inflation had been won. The country's two largest private sector lenders HDFC Bank Ltd. and ICICI Bank Ltd. both beat profit estimates on Saturday. India's new tax bill also exempts 11 million more people from income taxes, another move to boost consumption in Asia's third-largest economy. On Thursday, Nestle India Ltd. should show improved volume growth led by a recovery in rural demand, with urban recovery yet to catch up. It's also expected to benefit from a cut to palm oil duty and fall in coffee prices, according to analysts from Nuvama Institutional Equities. Tariff concerns will cloud Infosys Ltd.'s Wednesday update after rival Tata Consultancy Services Ltd. said many American clients were cautious about tech investments given ongoing economic uncertainty. Shares in Tata Consultancy Services, HCL Technologies Ltd. and Tech Mahindra Ltd. all fell after their earnings reports, with the latter two missing estimates. Highlights to look out for: Monday: Eternal's (ETERNAL IN) first-quarter profit is expected to halve on losses at its quick-commerce business Blinkit. The unit is investing in expanding its 'dark stores' network, where it services quick-commerce orders, and analysts will watch for updated guidance on when profits are expected. Strategic steer on its new 'Going Out' business will equally be in focus. Tuesday: No major earnings. Wednesday: Infosys (INFO IN) could lower or pull its revenue growth guidance as demand for new projects deteriorates amid worsening economic conditions, BI said. Watch for commentary on whether clients are canceling projects, especially in industries hit by US tariffs, Kotak Institutional Equities said. Thursday: Nidec's (6594 JP) sales would likely be affected by uncertainties in the auto market, as demand for electronic parts and motors slow in Japan, according to BI. Founder Shigenobu Nagamori said the firm's appetite for takeovers remains intact, following its earlier decision to withdraw a $1.8 billion hostile bid for Makino Milling Machine Co. Friday: No major earnings. More stories like this are available on
Mint
3 hours ago
- Mint
Mozambique Nears Deal to Revive $20 Billion Total Gas Project
(Bloomberg) -- Mozambican President Daniel Chapo said he expects to soon conclude talks with TotalEnergies SE over the restart of a $20 billion natural-gas project that halted four years ago because of an Islamist-militant insurgency. Chapo recently met with Total Chief Executive Officer Patrick Pouyanne to discuss resuming the project that has the potential to transform the economy of one of the world's poorest countries, he said in a July 19 interview. 'I was with Mr. Pouyanne two weeks ago and things are going well,' Chapo said. 'In August, we will close our talks' about when to restart the project, he said. Total halted work on Mozambique LNG, located in the northeastern Cabo Delgado province, evacuated workers and declared force majeure in 2021 after an escalation in attacks in the area by Islamic State-linked militants. The raids by the insurgents — which have since prompted the deployment of troops by both Rwanda and, for a while, Mozambique's neighbors to assist — drained momentum from the development of $50 billion worth of liquefied natural-gas projects, with Eni SpA and Exxon Mobil Corp. also developing plants. 'We have the small problem of jihad, terrorism,' Chapo said. In an earlier interview with Bloomberg in Spain, the president said that the while the region is more stable than four years ago, it isn't 'heaven,' but urged a restart nevertheless. Chapo was scheduled to meet Pouyanne in Maputo, Mozambique's capital, on July 10. Companies working on the construction of Total's plant have begun preparing to resume operations, according to people familiar with the matter, while Eni is said to have awarded a contract to Samsung Heavy Industries Co. to build its Coral North floating plant, adding to its $7 billion Coral South facility, which is already operational. The gas reserves discovered 15 years ago off Mozambique's northeastern coast are among the world's biggest. Sign up here for the twice-weekly Next Africa newsletter, and subscribe to the Next Africa podcast on Apple, Spotify or anywhere you listen. --With assistance from Matthew Hill and Paul Burkhardt. More stories like this are available on
