2010 CWG 'scam': Delhi court accepts ED closure report in case against Suresh Kalmadi
The acceptance of the closure report brings to end the money laundering angle in the alleged scam, which took place 15 years ago.
The allegations of corruption in conducting the 2010-Commonwealth Games triggered a huge political uproar in the country, leading to filing of several criminal and money laundering cases, including the present one.
Kalmadi and others were accused of misconduct in award and execution of two important contracts for the games.
Special judge Sanjeev Aggarwal noted the CBI had already closed the corruption case, based on which the ED started its money laundering probe and accepted the report, which also named CWG OC's then COO, Vijay Kumar Gautam, its then treasurer, A K Matto, Event Knowledge Service , Switzerland, and CEO, Craig Gordon MeLatchey.
The judge noted ED's submission that the offence of money laundering was not found during its investigation.
"Since during the investigations, the prosecution has failed to make out a offence under section 3 of the PMLA... as no offence under section 3 of the PMLA has been made out or has been committed, despite discreet investigations by the ED, therefore, there is no reason to continue with the present ECIR, as a consequence, the closure report filed by the ED stands accepted," the judge held.
The sole money laundering investigation was initiated by the ED based on the case lodged by the CBI.
According to the CBI, the works contracts related to Commonwealth Games were Games Workforce Service and Games Planning, Project & Risk Management Services .
An undue pecuniary gain was caused by the accused persons to the to the consortium of EKS and Ernst and Young, by way of awarding the two contracts in a deliberate and wrongful manner and caused corresponding loss of ₹30 crore to OC, CWG, the CBI alleged.
The CBI later filed a closure report in January 2014, saying "no incriminating evidence surfaced during the investigation in the matter" and the allegations in the FIR could not be substantiated against the accused persons.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
41 minutes ago
- NDTV
Bhupesh Baghel, Son Move Supreme Court Over CBI, Probe Agency Role In Liquor Case
New Delhi: Former Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel and his son Chaitanya Baghel have approached the Supreme Court, seeking the legal authority and jurisdiction of central investigative agencies-the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and the Enforcement Directorate (ED)-in probing alleged irregularities linked to the multi-crore liquor scam in the state. The petition, according to reports, filed amid escalating political tensions, seeks clarity on whether the agencies have overstepped their mandate under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) and other statutes. The matter is scheduled for hearing on Monday before a bench comprising Justice Suryakant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi. The move comes days after Chaitanya Baghel was arrested by the ED in connection with a Rs 2,160 crore liquor scam that allegedly operated during Bhupesh Baghel's tenure as Chief Minister. The ED claims that a parallel liquor distribution network siphoned off massive sums through unaccounted sales and illegal commissions, implicating several political and bureaucratic figures. Bhupesh Baghel has publicly denounced the arrest and subsequent raids at his Bhilai residence, calling them politically motivated and designed to suppress dissent. "The ED is being used as a tool to target opposition leaders," Baghel said, alleging that the timing of the arrest-on his son's birthday-was symbolic of the Centre's vendetta politics. The Congress party has backed Baghel's stance, staging protests across Raipur, Jagdalpur, and other districts, accusing the BJP-led Centre of weaponising investigative agencies to intimidate political opponents. Chaitanya Baghel, son of former Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel, was arrested by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) on July 18, 2025, which was also his birthday. The arrest was part of an ongoing investigation into a Rs 2,160 crore liquor scam allegedly involving a nexus of politicians, bureaucrats, and liquor contractors operating during Bhupesh Baghel's tenure. ED officials conducted raids at the Baghel family residence in Bhilai, Durg district, early in the morning on July 18. Chaitanya was taken into custody under Section 19 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA). The ED cited non-cooperation during the search as grounds for immediate arrest. Bhupesh Baghel publicly condemned the timing, calling it a "birthday gift" from the Central government and alleging political vendetta. The first ED raid at Bhupesh Baghel's Bhilai residence occurred on March 10, 2025. Baghel claimed that this earlier raid was timed to prevent him from participating in the state budget session, alleging that it was politically motivated and aimed at silencing opposition voices. Between the March raid and the July arrest, Baghel stated that no formal notice or inquiry was issued to his son, raising questions about procedural fairness. The ED alleges that Chaitanya Baghel received Rs 16.70 crore in illicit funds and played a key role in laundering over Rs 1,000 crore through real estate and other channels. The case has since become a flashpoint in the broader debate over the use of central agencies against opposition leaders.
Economic Times
2 hours ago
- Economic Times
ED makes first arrest in loan fraud case linked to Anil Ambani
New Delhi: The Enforcement Directorate (ED) late Friday evening arrested the managing director of an Odisha-based company - its first arrest in an alleged bank loan fraud case involving the Anil Dhirubhai Ambani Group (ADAG). Partha Sarathi Biswal, MD of Biswal Tradelink Pvt Ltd (BTPL), is accused of arranging a fake bank guarantee of ₹68 crore for an ADAG firm. According to the ED, its investigation has revealed that BTPL fraudulently arranged and submitted the fake bank guarantee along with forged SBI endorsements and fabricated confirmations on behalf of Reliance Nu Bess Ltd for a tender floated by Solar Energy Corporation of India Ltd (SECI). For this, BTPL received ₹5.40 crore from Reliance Nu Bess' parent, Reliance Power Ltd, ED has ED carried out searches against Biswal Tradelink on Friday. Agency sources said the evidence gathered by ED confirmed the use of fake documents in the name of certain banks and fake email IDs in the name of SBI."Probe reveals BTPL, a small company incorporated in 2019, maintained multiple undisclosed bank accounts and carried out transactions disproportionate to its declared turnover. Many violations of the Companies Act are found," the probe agency said in a news release on Saturday. Statutory records such as books of accounts and shareholders' registers were not found at the registered address, it said, adding: " Dummy directors are found to be used just to sign the documents."At least seven undisclosed bank accounts of the company were found and "proceeds of crime, of crores of rupees, have been traced to these accounts", it claimed. Biswal was produced before a Delhi court, which sent him to ED's custody till August 6. ET was the first to report on Friday that the ED had summoned Anil Ambani for questioning in connection with its investigation into the ₹17,000 crore alleged loan fraud case. Ambani has been asked to appear before the agency on August 5. According to the Enforcement Directorat, Biswal Tradelink ran a racket that issued fake bank guarantees to business groups. As per the agency, the Delhi Police filed the first information report in the case based on a Reliance Nu Bess company, accusing Biswal Tradelink of cheating it by promising to arrange bank guarantees for a fee and then providing a fake bank guarantee. According to the ED, Reliance Nu Bess wrongly claimed that it was cheated. "Documentary evidence reveals that apparently the two parties acted in collusion. The directors of Biswal Tradelink were found to be previous directors of Reliance group," a senior official had told ET.A statement issued by the Reliance Group on Friday said: "The company and its subsidiaries acted bonafidely and have been a victim of fraud, forgery and cheating conspiracy. The company has made due disclosure on this to the stock exchanges on November 7, 2024," it further said "a criminal complaint in this regard has already been lodged with the Economic Offences Wing (EOW) of Delhi Police against the third party on October 16, 2024" and that the "due process of law will follow".
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
ED arrests MD of Biswal Tradelink in fake bank guarantee case
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has arrested Partha Sarathi Biswal, managing director of Biswal Tradelink Private Limited (BTPL), in connection with an alleged fake bank guarantee case. The arrest was made following searches in Bhubaneswar and Kolkata. The probe is based on a first information report registered by the Economic Offences Wing of the Delhi police, BTPL, its directors, and others, for allegedly providing a fake bank guarantee, which was purportedly submitted to Solar Energy Corporation of India Limited (SECI). 'In a related matter, evidence seized earlier during searches on July 24 in the case of Anil Ambani group companies has direct linkage with the present investigation. A bank guarantee of ₹68.2 crore submitted to Solar Energy Corporation of India Limited (SECI) on behalf of Reliance NU BESS Limited/Maharashtra Energy Generation Limited has been established as fake,' an official had earlier alleged. According to the agency, BTPL fraudulently arranged and submitted fake bank guarantees of ₹68.2 crore along with forged SBI endorsements and fabricated confirmations for a SECI tender. 'For providing this bank guarantee, ₹5.40 crore has been received by BTPL from Reliance Power Limited,' the agency alleged. Multiple accounts 'Evidence confirms the use of fake documents in the name of certain banks and fake email IDs in the name of the SBI. The probe reveals that BTPL, a small company incorporated in 2019, maintained multiple undisclosed bank accounts and carried out transactions disproportionate to its declared turnover,' it said. The ED is alleged to have detected many violations of the Companies Act. Dummy directors were used just to sign documents. At least seven undisclosed bank accounts of the company have been found, according to the agency sources.
