Russia responsible for downing of MH17 over Ukraine, ECHR rules
MH17 was shot down on July 17, 2014 as it flew eastern Ukraine on its way from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur.
Among those killed were 38 Australian citizens and residents.
Russia has always denied responsibility, disputing findings from official investigations that the Russian military had supplied the surface-to-air missiles to Ukrainian separatists.
On Wednesday, the Strasbourg-based European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled Russia was responsible for downing MH17.
The ECHR ruled that Russia had failed to conduct an adequate investigation into the incident, to cooperate with requests for information or provide legal remedies for survivors.
Its lack of cooperation and continued denial of any involvement has caused additional suffering for the victims' relatives, the court said.
The court also found that Moscow had repeatedly and systematically violated human rights in Ukraine by performing indiscriminate military attacks, summary executions of civilians, torture including the use of rape as a weapon of war, unjustified displacement and transfer of civilians and other violations.
The ECHR is an international court of the Council of Europe from which Russia was expelled in 2022 following its invasion of Ukraine.
Russia's parliament then voted in 2023 to end the ECHR's jurisdiction in the country.
Australia and European nations have long blamed Russia for the shooting down of MH17, the second aircraft lost by Malaysian Airlines in 2014.
In 2022, a Dutch court tried and convicted two Russians and a Ukrainian for murder over the shooting down of MH17.
The offenders were tried in absentia, meaning they remain at large, and it is unlikely they will ever serve their life sentences.
And in May this year, the United Nations's International Civil Aviation Organization ruled Russia was responsible and broke international law by using weapons against a civil aircraft.
Responding to Wednesday's ECHR ruling, Dutch Foreign Minister Caspar Veldkamp said: "Nothing can take away this suffering and grief, but I hope the verdict offers a sense of justice and recognition."
A majority of those on the airliner were Dutch.
Ukraine's Justice Ministry, in a statement on the Telegram messaging app, hailed the ECHR ruling as "one of the most important in the practice of interstate cases".
Ahead of Wednesday's ruling, Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said Russia would not abide by any court decisions.
"We consider them null and void," he said.
Reuters/ABC
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
4 hours ago
- News.com.au
Lufthansa CEO's wife investigated for running over babysitter
The wife of Lufthansa airline's billionaire CEO fatally ran down a babysitter while on vacation in Sardinia — then flew home to Germany while under investigation for vehicular homicide, according to reports. Vivian Alexandra Spohr, 51 — the wife of CEO Carsten Spohr — was behind the wheel of a BMW X5 on Tuesday afternoon when she struck Gaia Costa, 24, on a pedestrian crosswalk in the upscale Italian resort town of Porto Cervo, according to Corriere News. Spohr allegedly continued driving until onlookers waved her down — leaving her so shocked that she fainted, Italien News reported. Paramedics spent 20 minutes trying to revive Costa, but the babysitter died from severe head injuries, the reports said. Spohr was formally identified as being under investigation for involuntary manslaughter — but the mum of two had already flown home to Berlin, Germany, according to the reports. However, she was not legally required to remain on the Italian island, and has vowed to co-operate, her lawyer said, New York Post reported. 'Vivian Spohr, who was involved in the tragic death, expresses her dismay and deep regret over this very serious accident,' the lawyer, Angelo Merlini, told La Repubblica. 'She has placed herself at the complete disposal of the judicial authorities for the necessary investigations and, although aware that such a great personal loss cannot be remedied, will take steps to mitigate the consequences.' The CEO's wife tested negative for alcohol or drugs, according to the reports, which said investigators are analysing surveillance footage and Spohr's phone records to see if she was distracted at the time. Porto Cervo is a luxury resort area in Sardinia known for attracting high-profile visitors during the summer season. Italian prosecutors and Lufthansa did not immediately reply to a request for comment from The Post. Carsten Spohr, 58, and his wife share two daughters.
ABC News
9 hours ago
- ABC News
Ukrainians live through record strikes as Russia ramps up new drone tactics
Eight-year-old Andrii and his six-year-old brother Maksym's wooden fort is covered with cloth netting. Protection, they said, from the drones fired from Russia. The children, who live just 15 kilometres from the Russian border in the north-eastern Kharkiv region, play with plastic guns. They scamper through abandoned trenches and the charred shells of armoured vehicles, and keep watch from their makeshift fort. When fighting intensifies, their mother Varvara Tupkalenko takes them back to the family's apartment in nearby Kharkiv, the regional capital. But Ukraine's second city itself is a major target, and the swarms of drones that pound it at night terrify the boys. Europe's largest land conflict since the Second World War is now in its fourth year and does not appear to be easing. The rhythm of attacks has been increasing in recent months since diplomatic efforts to end the war have stalled. Air strikes targeting cities are getting worse, with record numbers of drones and missiles flying overhead. Analysts say Russia appears to have a new tactic: launching hundreds of weapons simultaneously from different altitudes and directions, encircling a city. "This is an obvious escalation of terror by Russia," Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy wrote in a post to social media. Russian forces launched 728 drones and 13 missiles on the night of July 8, according to US think tank the Institute for the Study of War. It was the largest combined drone and missile strike of the war, and about a 34 per cent increase from the previous record high of 550 earlier this month. Lutsk, a city that's home to airfields used by the Ukrainian army, was the hardest hit, according to Mr Zelenskyy. It lies near the border with Poland in western Ukraine, a region that is a crucial hub for receiving foreign military aid. Another 10 regions were struck, killing one person in the Khmelnytskyi area, and wounding two in Kyiv, officials said. Kyiv's military downed almost all the drones, but some of the six hypersonic missiles caused unspecified damage. The attack came just days after US President Donald Trump announced that arms shipments to Ukraine would resume, and aimed unusually sharp criticism at Russian President Vladimir Putin. A day later, hours before a conference in Rome at which Kyiv won billions of dollars in aid pledges, Kyiv was struck with a record bombardment. It lasted for nearly 10 hours, killing two people and wounding 26, according to figures from the national emergency services. The Institute for the Study of War assessed that recent major attacks have occurred off the back of diplomatic efforts, such as the US and Ukraine offering a 30-day ceasefire in March. Russia also launched more than 500 drones in the early hours of July 4, American Independence Day, just hours after Mr Trump and Mr Putin had a telephone conversation. Russia expert Matthew Sussex from the ANU's Strategic and Defence Studies Centre said the Russian president was sending a message. Russian authorities have also reported dozens of attempted Ukrainian drone attacks over the last week, including four bound for Moscow. The Ukrainian capital of 3 million people has endured several consecutive weeks of escalating Russian attacks. Civilians say they face nightly terror, kept awake by air raid sirens and endless booms of explosions. "Most people don't even sleep in our beds anymore," Kyiv-based journalist Emmanuelle Chaze told ABC The World. Russia's defence ministry said it had hit "military-industrial" targets in Kyiv as well as military airfields. It denies targeting civilians although towns and cities have been hit regularly in the war and thousands have been killed. June saw the highest monthly civilian casualty count in Ukraine since the Russian invasion began in February 2022, according to UN data. It said it reflected a "worsening trend", with 6,754 civilians killed or injured in the first half of 2025 – a sharp 54 per cent rise compared to the same period in 2024. Professor Sussex said attacks had been "really bad" and the situation was becoming more difficult for Ukrainians. He described that Russia was conducting "double taps" where a target would be struck twice — usually once firefighters had arrived. "First of all they attack a target, then wait until the first responders get there and then attack it again," he told the ABC. "And they've started to also target recruitment centres for the Ukrainian armed forces when people are basically lined up waiting to get their call up." Russia has been ramping up local production of drones, increasing both the quantity and quality of their supply. Maksym Beznosiuk, a strategic policy expert and director of UAinFocus, an independent platform connecting Ukrainian and international experts, said Russia was producing new drones with a range technological upgrades. "This is making it possible to launch massive bombardments of Ukrainian cities that overwhelm Ukraine's limited air defences and terrorise the civilian population," he wrote in analysis for the Atlantic Council. The mix of new drones with hypersonic cruise missiles was making barrages more difficult to defend against. Professor Sussex said Russia's Khinzhal missiles were particularly hard to counter. Russia was also now flying its Shahed attack drones at much higher altitudes. Ukrainian Air Force spokesperson Colonel Yuriy Ihnat reported that Russian forces used more than 400 decoy drones in a record strike on July 8 in order to overwhelm air defences. Professor Sussex said improving the situation for Ukraine would depend on how much Europe could come to the table, and whether Russia could keep its economy on a war footing. This week, Ukraine's allies pledged more than 10 billion euros ($17.8 billion) to help rebuild the country, and the EU announced another 2.3 billion euros in support. Mr Trump has signalled willingness to send more Patriot air-defence missiles, which have proven critical to defending against fast-moving Russian ballistic missiles. Mr Zelenskyy said the record strikes called for "biting sanctions" to be imposed on Moscow. Mr Trump also said he was considering supporting a bill that would impose steep sanctions on Russia, including 500 per cent tariffs on nations that buy Russian oil, gas, uranium and other exports. "Even if Trump does it partially (import the sanctions bill), that still puts pressure on the Russian economy at a time that inflation remains very high, interest rates remain very high, and there are also ruptures going on within the Putin elite," Professor Sussex said. Analysts say Russia's massive bombardments are largely aimed at demoralising the Ukrainian population and breaking morale. But often it can instead harden their resolve, with many residents determined to hold on to some normality. When 24-year-old translator Kateryna emerged after the record strikes on Kyiv this week, she got on with her daily routines. "I took a cold shower, drank two coffees, sat and thought for a bit, realised that for now I can't change anything, then went to work," she said while waiting at a bus stop. "That's it."
News.com.au
14 hours ago
- News.com.au
Minister's death spooks Russian elite amid corruption clampdown
The reported suicide of Russia's transport minister hours after he was dismissed by President Vladimir Putin, sparking speculation he would be arrested on corruption charges, has shaken the country's elite. Roman Starovoyt was buried in Saint Petersburg on Friday, with his family weeping at his open coffin before it was lowered into the ground. The 53-year-old was found dead in his car on Monday in an elite Moscow suburb -- hours after Putin issued a decree to fire him, with no explanation. Russian investigators say he shot himself. Media reports said he was being investigated for corruption and could have been arrested within days. While government departments sent flowers and some ministers attended a memorial ceremony in Moscow a day earlier, there was unease over the fate of Starovoyt, who had climbed the ranks of Russia's bureaucracy to a seat in the cabinet. Many who came to the ceremony in Moscow refused to speak to AFP. "It's a great loss. Very unexpected," said Valentina, a 42-year-old translator whose husband worked with Starovoyt. "He was very active, cheerful and loved life very much. I don't know how it happened." - 'Scapegoat' - Starovoyt had been governor of Russia's western Kursk region before being promoted to Moscow, just a few months before Ukrainian troops captured dozens of border settlements in a surprise cross-border incursion. His successor was arrested in the spring for embezzling funds intended to beef up the fortifications that Ukraine ended up slicing through with ease. "They tried to make him the scapegoat... It's easier to put the blame on a civilian official," political commentator Andrey Pertsev told AFP. The case is one part of a wider crackdown on officials alleged to have enriched themselves at the expense of the Russian army during the Ukraine offensive. The crackdown is a Kremlin campaign that has ripped up previous norms about what is acceptable for Russian officials. "There used to be rules, where people knew that once you climbed up high enough, they wouldn't mess with you," Pertsev said. "But they do not work any more." In a sign of how out of favour Starovoyt had become, Putin has not publicly commented on his death. Asked if Putin would attend the ceremony in Moscow, his spokesman told reporters: "The president has a different work schedule today." At the funeral in Saint Petersburg on Friday, two regional governors were the highest-ranking officials to show face. - 'Holy war' - While Putin has criticised corruption and vowed to stamp it out throughout his 25 years in power, his rule has been characterised by systemic graft, critics say. The smattering of high-profile arrests has more typically been used to target opponents or come about as the result of infighting among those lower down Russia's chain of power. But the military offensive against Ukraine has changed that. "Something within the system has started to work completely differently," analyst Tatiana Stanovaya wrote after Starovoyt's death. "Any action or inaction that, in the eyes of the authorities, increases the state's vulnerability to hostile actions by the enemy must be punished mercilessly and uncompromisingly," Stanovaya said. In such a climate, it was inevitable that heads would have to roll over the Kursk failings. Nina Khrushcheva, a professor at The New School, a university in New York City, said Starovoyt's apparent suicide showed the Russian elite was "scared". The current climate is such that "it is impossible to leave the top brass", said Khrushcheva, who is also the great-granddaughter of Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev. "This is something we have not really seen since 1953," she told AFP, referring to Joseph Stalin's execution of a close ally. To the Kremlin, the Ukraine military campaign is a "holy war" that has rewritten the rules of loyalty and service. "During a holy war, you don't steal... You tighten your belts and work 24 hours a day to make the weapons you need." That atmosphere, said Stanovaya, has created a "sense of hopelessness" among officials in Moscow that is unlikely to fade. "Going forward, the system will be ready to sacrifice increasingly prominent figures," she warned.
