Revealed: Couple jailed for neglect of 4-year-old were suspected of his murder
Photo:
Supplied
A mother and her then partner who were jailed for neglecting a four-year-old boy who died after suffering "non-accidental" head and bowel injuries were initially arrested on suspicion of murder, it can be revealed.
However, after continuing to deny their involvement they were jointly charged with manslaughter. The pair would later plead guilty to reduced charges of neglect.
Ashton Cresswell died in April 2017.
RNZ earlier reported
that the cause of his death was deemed to be "non-accidental" head and bowel injuries. A post-mortem found 65 bruises across his small body.
Coroner Mary-Anne Borrowdale found the fatal injuries suffered by Asthon were likely inflicted by Ashton's mother's partner Peter Otuszewski, either through misadventure during rough play, or through a more deliberate act of violence.
In an exclusive interview with RNZ, Otuszewski denied being responsible for Ashton's death.
"It is horrific what happened to him. It is unfair what happened to him. But I didn't cause him to die."
RNZ has obtained several statements connected to Ashton's death under the Official Information Act.
Do you know more? Email
sam.sherwood@rnz.co.nz
Among them is a statement from the officer in charge of the investigation Detective Sergeant Rochelle Ross.
Ross said that after the cause of Ashton's death was established, the investigation moved into a "suspect interview phase".
Both Ashton's mother Alesha Cresswell and Otuszewski were interviewed in the hours after Ashton's death. Ross said the pair provided accounts which were "not consistent with the fact that Ashton had been deceased for some time prior to the emergency services arriving".
No-one was charged with causing the fatal injuries to Ashton.
Photo:
Supplied
On 18 September 2017, Cresswell was interviewed for a second time for nearly three hours.
"Her account differed from her original account and was inconsistent and contrived with her making assertions which were known to be untrue or were later proved to be untrue," Ross said.
Six weeks later Otuszewski was interviewed by police. Ross said he changed his account from that which he gave in the hours after Ashton's death.
"Neither party could offer any explanation for how Ashton sustained the injuries that ultimately caused his death."
The investigation was then summarised and referred to the Crown Solicitor for prosecution advice.
On 29 May 2019 the pair were arrested for the murder of Ashton, Ross said.
Otuszewski and Cresswell were then interviewed for a third time. Both lasted about 15 minutes.
"Both parties continued to deny any knowledge of how Ashton sustained the injuries which led to his death," Ross said.
They were then jointly charged with manslaughter. The charge alleged that, without lawful excuse, the pair neglected their legal duty to provide Ashton with the necessities of life.
Ross said that following further court appearances and in consultation with the Crown Solicitor's office the matter was resolved with guilty pleas on charges of neglect.
Cresswell was sentenced to three years, 11 months imprisonment. Otuszewski was jailed for four years and one month.
In response to questions from RNZ, Central District manager of criminal investigations Detective Inspector Craig Sheridan said the investigation team had "good cause" to suspect the couple had committed the offence of murder when they were arrested.
Following the third interview the decision was made, in consultation with the Crown, to charge the pair with manslaughter.
Charging documents of murder were never filed, he said.
He said it was a "robust investigation".
Sheridan earlier said the evidence supported the resulting charges of neglect.
"Police acknowledge the coroner's findings in relation to Ashton's tragic and entirely avoidable death."
He said there was no ongoing investigation.
Near the bottom of Coroner Borrowdale's report, she says Ashton Cresswell was not a name "well-known to New Zealanders".
"No-one was convicted of causing the non-accidental injuries that led to his death. No government or support agency was involved in the protection of Ashton and his siblings from child abuse.
"Ashton was not attending any pre-school when he died. No-one who had contact with Ashton, his mother, or her short-term partner foresaw that Ashton's life was at risk… no-one saw what was coming."
Borrowdale made damning remarks about the couple's attempted explanations of Ashton's injuries.
"Ashton was 'careless' and 'clumsy' because he was tiny, vulnerable, and had developmental delays.
"These characteristics ought to have led to Ashton being treated with kid gloves, receiving even more protection and care than an ordinarily robust four-year-old. It was grotesquely self-serving of his parent and caregiver, who I find were responsible for his death and its concealment, to have excused their violence and neglect by reference to Ashton's frailties."
She concluded by saying Ashton's death was a "tragedy".
"It is shameful that Ashton died violently and prematurely, in his home and due to the actions - and inactions - of the people who were entrusted with his care and safety. I offer my sincere condolences to those who knew and loved Ashton."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Timaru lumberyard ordered to pay $450k after worker crushed to death
Ethyn McTier. Photo: Supplied A Timaru lumberyard and its sole director have been ordered to pay $450,000 after a worker was crushed to death. Ethyn McTier's family said the loss of the gentle soul has left a gap in their lives that can never be filled. The 23-year-old was killed in the workplace accident at Point Lumber in Timaru on 1 November 2022. Point Lumber and its sole director Sean David Sloper appeared at the Timaru District Court in May for sentencing on charges of failing to provide a duty of care to prevent exposure to risk of death or injury. At the hearing Judge Dominic Dravitzki considered fines of more than $600,000 and emotional harm reparation to McTier's family of $140,000, although the court heard the company had made losses in recent years and such a penalty would jeopardise its future. As a result, Judge Dravitzki decided not to hand down his final sentence in May to await further details about the company's finances. On Wednesday the judge fined Point Lumber $250,000, Sloper $60,000 and ordered $140,000 be paid to McTier's family. The company was previously fined $32,000 in 2020 after three-year-old Felyx Rhys Hatherley died when a stack of wooden posts fell on him while he was visiting his father at the lumberyard. McTier died after becoming trapped and crushed in a conveyor belt drive roller. The conveyor belt that Ethyn McTier was trapped and killed by. Photo: Supplied WorkSafe's investigation found there was no guarding along the length of the conveyor belt to protect workers, nor in the area where McTier was drawn in. A risk assessment had also not been done. A range of other machine safety defects were also found onsite. Point Lumber had also failed to follow a safety consultant's recommendation to safeguard the conveyor back in 2017, WorkSafe said. McTier's family said the sentence marked the end of long and difficult legal process. "We are thankful for the outcome and that Point Lumber and Sean Sloper have been held accountable for Ethyn's death. But at the end of the day, we've lost someone who was a pillar in our family and the hole that has been left in our lives is immeasurable," the family said. "Ethyn was only 23-years-old, he had his whole life ahead of him and his death was 100 percent preventable. "We just hope this serves as a warning to other employers to take workplace safety more seriously, as their decisions and actions, or lack thereof, could mean the difference between life and death for someone else's son or daughter, brother or sister and no family should ever have to go through the pain and loss we have experienced." Point Lumber. Photo: RNZ / Tim Brown During emotional and grief-stricken victim impact statements read to the court at May's hearing, McTier's family described the enormous effect his death had on their lives. "Ethyn was...a true mummy's boy," his mother told the court. "Losing my eldest son at just 23 years of age has impacted my life beyond words. He was my rock, my confidante, my ally. Not a day went by when I didn't see him or talk on the phone." She cried every day and had ongoing nightmares about her son's death. Her three youngest children's schooling had also suffered. "They've been bullied and had Ethyn's death used as ammunition by fellow kids," she said. "Ethyn was always there for me and his other siblings at an instant. Ethyn's death has opened a chasm that will never be filled. The last two-and-a-half years have been horrific for everyone. The family has really been torn apart." Ethyn's father said the call informing him of his son's death still haunted him. "It was the worst day of my life - a day I relive every day," he said. "My family and myself are all victims of his death, but the real victim here is Ethyn. He lost his life and all because of other people's lack of action. "They say time is a healer of pain, but this is not true. Time only doubles my pain and makes me feel numb." He directed his statement at Sloper and told him he hoped he did not forget about his son and the failure that led to his death. "Everyone should have the right to go home safely from work - why was my son denied this right?" he asked. McTier's sister said she wanted to recognise the most significantly impacted victim - Ethyn. "He was a kind, caring, gentle soul - always there for anyone who needed him," she said. "He was goofy and loved to make people laugh. Family was at the heart of everything he did. "He was the fibre that held our family together. He has lost the most. "He had dreams and ambitions he will never fulfill. He will never grow old. "His life was taken before he barely had a chance to live it." Outside court in May, Sloper did not wish to speak but handed RNZ a statement. Point Lumber director Sean David Sloper leaving court. Photo: RNZ / Tim Brown "Business owners should not rely on there [sic] own health n [sic] safety systems," it said. "They need to be regularly and independently audited and more importantly find competent electricians and engineers that can build robust workable safety systems." WorkSafe acting regional manager Darren Handforth said McTier's death bore similarities to that of Wesley Tomich, who was killed on a conveyor belt at Ballance Agri-Nutrients in Mt Maunganui in July 2023. "Endangering workers in this way is careless in the extreme, because these deaths were clearly preventable. In no way is it acceptable to be able to be killed at work on a conveyor belt," Handforth said. "The manufacturing sector must seize these two deadly incidents as a watershed moment for health and safety. We implore businesses to ensure their machine guarding meets safety standards. If necessary, engage a qualified expert to ensure your machinery is adequately guarded to avoid inflicting further tragedy on other families." In March, WorkSafe conducted 304 assessments in the manufacturing sector and issued improvement notices in 67 percent of cases. It signalled the progress left to be made by the industry, Handforth said. During May's hearing, Judge Dravitzki acknowledged McTier's family's "real and raw" pain and thanked them for sharing their victim impact statements. "It is also helpful for me in terms of giving life to Ethyn and gaining some tiny appreciation of the massive hole his loss has left in all of your lives," the judge said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Suspected extremist content online increases 10 percent
The Linwood Mosque after the Christchurch terror attacks. A new report shows suspected extremist content online has increased, while more than a third of referred content last year related to the attacks. Photo: Sanka Vidanagama / NurPhoto via AFP Suspected extremist content online has increased 10 percent, according to a new report by the Department of Internal Affairs. A total of 974 URLs were flagged last year and 88 percent of the content referred was removed by platforms following intervention by the DIA. The findings were published in the 2024 Digital Violent Extremism Transparency Report on Wednesday, which is meant to help the public better understand how the DIA works to identify extremist content online and prevent exposure to that material. The report specified the most commonly reported ideology type in 2024 was "identity motivated, specifically white-identity". That was seen in the continued presence of content relating to the Christchurch terrorist attacks, with 38 percent of referred content last year related to the attacks. Director of the Digital Safety Group, Jared Mullen, said every one of the URLs that had been issued with informal "take-down notices" contained images and videos promoting or encouraging violent extremism or terrorist attacks. "Much of this content promoted or depicted the violent attack or death of innocent victims for the gratification of others." The report also indicated investigators are continuing to see the cases connected to "hybridised threat groups" - violent online groups who extort minors online into recording self-harm and sexually explicit acts. Those groups often involved terrorist and violent extremism, gore, and child sexual exploitation material, the DIA said. "Online groups such as these are responsible for exploiting the most vulnerable members of society by coercing them to share extreme and egregious content," Mullen said. "These offenders use online platforms to cherry pick vulnerable members of society to systematically victimise. We are working closely with our partners to do everything in our power to apprehend these offenders and safeguard victims." In 2023 the same report indicated it had received 886 referrals and 845 URLs were reported. There was a 25 percent increase in referrals that year compared to 2022, and 54 percent of referred content related to the Christchurch terror attacks . Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Several historic gravestones vandalised at Auckland cemetery
Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER Several historic gravestones have been vandalised at a cemetery in the Auckland suburb of Parnell on Monday. Police said they received a report just after 5pm that at least eight gravestones at St Stephen's Chapel had been pushed over and broken up. Auckland Council area operation manager, Martin Wong, said they were aware of the incident. "This is a disgraceful act and our hearts go out to the descendants of those lying in rest here," he said. "The graves are maintained by volunteers, whose efforts have been helped by two Auckland Council grants over the last six years. "The council manages the land, gardens and trees at this closed cemetery site, but does not look after the graves, as these are private property owned by the descendants. That said, we will assist to sensitively tidy up the damage and assist the police with their enquiries." He said they were also investigating damage to council-owned toilets at the nearby Judges Bay over the weekend, where sinks, taps, and toilets were removed. Anyone with information was asked to report it to police online or call 105 using the reference number 250707/2117. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
