Fury at ‘goodies' for Independents who voted against the Government
Extra.ie has learned of growing frustration among the Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael rank-and-file as NDP negotiations intensify, with all TDs 'anxious' to see the needs of their constituents addressed.
Many have voiced their discontent with the fact that Barry Heneghan, Gillian Toole and Danny Healy-Rae still 'have the ear of ministers' and what might be perceived as greater leverage in securing NDP commitments despite voting against the Government in recent weeks. Independent TD Barry Heneghan. Pic: Tom Honan
One Fianna Fáil TD said: 'This can't be an a la carte arrangement where they support the Government when it suits.
'They have the ear of ministers, they're getting more goodies than backbenchers and they're apparently allowed to vote whichever way they want. They can't have it both ways.'
A Fine Gael TD added 'We went through all of that strife at the beginning of the Dáil term over the speaking rights for them to turn around and start voting against [us]. It is not right. Independent TD Gillian Toole. Pic: Facebook
'The whip has not been cracked firmly enough.'
The NDP is a ten-year plan encompassing all the State's capital spending. The current plan will run between now and 2030 and has been allocated a record budget of €165billion.
Upon the formation of the current Coalition, it was announced that the NDP will be reviewed this year, with the revised plan set to be published in the latter half of this month. Independent TD Danny Healy-Rae. Pic: Alan Rowlette/RollingNews.ie
One source close to the Regional Independents said previously that the NDP review will provide an opportunity for the cohort to begin 'horsetrading' for constituency projects which did not form part of the Programme for Government negotiations.
An additional €35billion will come on stream in that review, the source said in January, to be spent on projects across all Government departments.
The source added: 'That is when the Healy-Raes can try to get their goodies for Kerry – likewise for other TDs across the Regional Independents, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.'
In a radio interview at the beginning of the year, TD Michael Lowry, who led Government formation talks for the Independents, said the group's 'input' to the review of the NDP and the HSE Capital Plan will be 'central' to their work in Government. Independent TD Michael Lowry. Pic: Leah Farrell/RollingNews.ie
Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers began discussions with his Cabinet colleagues over additional funding for their departments last month, with Government figures saying the allocations are currently being finalised by civil servants.
Regional Independents have kept tight-lipped about their engagements with Mr Chambers and Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe in relation to the NDP. However, one source was adamant that the decision taken by members of the group to vote against the Government has not impacted their position to negotiate in NDP talks.
They said: 'We only have to vote with them on matters of the economy and confidence.' Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers. Pic: Fran Veale
However, 'eyebrows were raised' in the two main Government parties after Dublin TD Barry Heneghan and Meath TD Gillian Toole voted with the Opposition motion to ban the sale of Israeli 'war bonds' through Ireland twice last month.
Further questions about the strength of the Coalition surfaced when Danny Healy-Rae took the 'unprecedented' step of calling for a vote against a People Before Profit-Solidarity Bill to ban fox hunting at the 'first stage' of the Dáil.
Typically all pieces of legislation are allowed to proceed to 'second stage' where they can be debated, with the Government voting to allow the legislation to progress.
A senior Government source repeatedly told Extra.ie that 'constituency deals will play no role in NDP negotiations' – despite Mr Lowry's comments from the beginning of the year.
Speaking to the Extra.ie last night, Ms Toole said: 'I am unaware of any adverse commentary by backbench colleagues. I'm an Independent TD committed to the Programme for Government; this puts me in the best place to deliver for the people of north Dublin who elected me.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
2 hours ago
- The Journal
Foreign Affairs Committee recommends inclusion of services in Israeli settlements trade ban
A COMMITTEE HAS 'unanimously' recommended that services should be included in the Government's proposed ban on trade with illegal Israeli settlements, a TD has said. The Oireachtas Foreign Affairs committee is making the recommendation after hearing evidence from expert witnesses in relation to the Israeli Settlements (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill 2025. The report containing the recommendation is expected to be published next Wednesday. The Irish Government has said it will legislate to ban the trade of goods with illegal Israeli settlements following an advisory opinion from the UN's top court. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) said last year that countries should 'take steps to prevent trade or investment relations' that maintain illegal Israeli settlements on Palestinian land. Although the opinion does not differentiate between types of trade, government figures have indicated a ban on services is more legally complex. Sinn Féin TD and member of the committee Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire said the 'vitally important' recommendation to include services received 'no push back' from any committee member. He said that could encompass services across financial, tech and accommodation sectors. Advertisement 'Clearly, morally, the same issue arises whether it is goods or services, you're still trading with illegal settlements that are undermining the potential for peace in the Middle East.' He lamented the humanitarian disaster and widespread starvation in Gaza in what he called 'human rights abuses upon human rights abuses' in the Palestinian enclave. The foreign affairs committee's recommendation has been welcomed by Christian Aid Ireland as 'hugely significant'. The charity's head of policy Conor O'Neill said: 'Despite all the spin, misinformation and threats, TDs and senators from both Government and opposition spent weeks looking at the Occupied Territories Bill in detail, weighing up the evidence, hearing from experts and considering the impact. 'They have said unequivocally: it is time to ban all trade with the illegal Israeli settlements, both goods and services, in line with international law. 'This is a crucial vote of confidence and a clear message to Government that we must do this right. 'Ultimately it doesn't matter whether you're importing a box of olives produced on stolen Palestinian farmland, or booking a holiday rental in a stolen Palestinian home on a service platform like Airbnb. 'A euro of support is a euro of support, and the ICJ was clear that all of it has to end. The Oireachtas Foreign Affairs Committee have upheld this very strongly today, and Government must listen. 'We need to pass a full, effective Occupied Territories Bill as a matter of urgency.'
The Journal
4 hours ago
- The Journal
Government urged ‘not to delay solemn promise' of VAT cut for hospitality sector
THE GOVERNMENT HAS been urged 'not to delay its promise' of cutting the VAT rate for the hospitality sector to 9% in the upcoming budget. Despite election promises and ministerial pronouncements, government this week has been signalling that a cut to the VAT rate for the hospitality sector may not go ahead in Budget 2026. Tánaiste Simon Harris said the government had made a 'solemn' commitment in the election to reduce the VAT rate for the hospitality sector, but this week the government has been sending mixed signals on how it will proceed. Speaking to RTÉ Radio 1 yesterday, junior justice minister Niall Collins said the VAT cut was not a 'done deal'. VAT for the tourism and hospitality sectors was reduced to 9% during the Covid-19 pandemic at a cost of €1.2bn to the exchequer. The previous 13.5% rate was reinstated last August, despite the sector's opposition. Retail Excellence Ireland (REI), the largest representative body for the retail industry in Ireland, has called on the Government to follow through on its 'promise to permanently cut the rate of VAT for the hospitality industry to 9% in Budget 2026'. Jean McCabe, CEO of REI, said that 'after a tough few years, the Government's solemn promise to cut the VAT rate for the hospitality industry was welcome'. 'It would be regrettable for it to delay its promise now,' she added. 'There are too many livelihoods at stake not to introduce a measure as soon as possible that would have such a significant impact on the industry, and on related industries such as retail.' She said the government must do 'everything in its power to strengthen our domestic economy at a time when we need it most'. McCabe also called for the general rate of VAT be cut from 23% to 21% to assist the retail industry. Advertisement Meanwhile, the Irish Hotels Federation (IHF) has criticised the 'deeply misleading' figure of €1 billion per year that was quoted earlier this week regarding the cost to the Exchequer of reducing VAT for hospitality businesses. On Tuesday, during a press conference on the Summer Economic Statement, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe told reporters that the one-year cost for reducing the hospitality VAT rate to 9% for restaurants and hotels would be between €950mn and €1bn. However, later in the press conference, Donohoe said he would need to clarify if that figure did include hotels. A spokesperson for the minister told The Journal today that, based on CSO data, the total one-year cost for restaurants and hotels is actually €810mn. This is split €675mn for restaurants and cafes and €135mn for hotels. The cost for hairdressers would be an additional €40mn. IHF Chief Executive Paul Gallagher said it's time for an 'honest and balanced debate' that 'recognises the economic and social importance of hospitality food service businesses and gives them a fighting chance to survive'. He noted that the 'true cost involved is significantly lower than the widely quoted €1bn figure cited by the Government in recent days' Gallagher added: 'The Government's narrative has had the effect, intended or otherwise, of driving a wedge between the public and the hospitality industry, framing the VAT reduction as a giveaway to businesses. 'This is extremely divisive and simply not true.' He said the 9% VAT reduction sought would apply to prepared food services, such as meals in restaurants, takeaways, commercial kitchens and food served on transport. 'The real beneficiaries are small food businesses,' said Gallagher, 'many of which are operating on the brink of survival due to extreme food cost inflation and shrinking margins. 'Reducing VAT on food services is not a handout to hospitality businesses – it is a vital intervention for a sector that supports over 270,000 livelihoods and contributes significantly to the economy.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Independent
6 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Oireachtas Committee to recommend Government include services in Occupied Territories Bill
The Oireachtas Foreign Affairs Committee is to recommended the inclusion of services as well as goods in the Government's version of the Occupied Territories Bill.
