Lawyers criticise Maggie Chapman's comments on Supreme Court gender ruling
'Beyond the pale'
The Scottish government is to make a statement in Holyrood on Tuesday afternoon setting out its response to the unanimous ruling that a woman is defined by biological sex under equalities law.Protests were held at the weekend by pro-trans campaigners, with First Minister John Swinney saying he understood why the trans community would feel "uncertain and anxious" over the ruling.Chapman - a long time supporter of trans rights - attended a protest in Aberdeen and told the crowd: "We say not in our name to the bigotry, prejudice and hatred that we see coming from the Supreme Court and from so many other institutions in our society."Roddy Dunlop KC said the comments were "beyond the pale" and that Chapman should consider her role as deputy convenor as her remarks conflicted with Scottish Parliament guidance on impartiality.He said her comments "fail to respect the rule of law" and "constitute an egregious breach of Ms Chapman's duties to uphold the continued independence of the judiciary".He added: "But they go further than that, and create a risk of danger to the members of the court themselves. "This behaviour is irresponsible and reprehensible."He added that he expected a "swift and fulsome" apology from the MSP.Alba MSP Ash Regan said she had reported Chapman to the Presiding Officer and Standards Committee, adding: "MSPs have a duty to uphold the law, not undermine it."
Speaking on Tuesday morning, Chapman said she would not apologise, and that institutions and laws reflected transphobia and prejudice present in society. She also said the rule of law "still stands", but that it was her role to "stand up and represent trans people".Last Wednesday's ruling was the culmination of a long-running legal dispute between the Scottish government and campaign group For Women Scotland over whether sex-based protections should only apply to people born female. The Scottish government's social justice secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville will outline to Holyrood implications of the ruling and the processes that will follow, including ensuring updated guidance is issued for public bodies on access to single-sex spaces such as female toilets and changing rooms. Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes, who was opposed to Scottish government plans to make it easier for trans people to be granted a gender recognition certificate, told BBC Scotland News she did not feel vindicated by the court ruling but that it had provided "legal clarity". Trans campaigners have expressed concern the ruling would erase protections they have against discrimination in their reassigned gender. The Holyrood statement comes as Bridget Philipson, the UK government's equalities minister, told the BBC's Today programme that trans women should now use toilets according to their biological sex.But she stopped short of explicitly saying trans women should use the men's toilets.She also said that further guidance by the Equalities and Human Rights Commission would be issued, including a statutory code of practice. Philipson said this would ensure "everyone has the ability to access services that are safe and appropriate". Meanwhile, Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer welcomed the ruling in his first comments on the matter, saying it gave "much needed clarity".
The Scottish government argued in court that transgender people with a gender recognition certificate (GRC) are entitled to the same sex-based protections as biological women under the Equality Act 2010.The judges unanimously ruled that the terms woman and sex in the 2010 Equality Act "refer to a biological woman and biological sex" rather than "certificated sex".Michael Foran, a lecturer in law at the University of Glasgow, told the BBC the decision "has profound implications for trans inclusion in those spaces".He added debate surrounding the ruling had been muddied by misinformation and "attempts to delegitimise" the Supreme Court. He added: "It's incumbent on the government to communicate clearly what this judgement does and does not say, and to combat that misinformation."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
41 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Rural Scots are right - it is time to halt onshore windfarms
Of course, the President's antipathy towards wind turbines is well known, which may or may not stem entirely from an offshore windfarm near to his Aberdeenshire golf course. But does he actually have a point – has Scotland become saturated with wind farms and is it time to pause? Certainly, many across rural Scotland would agree with the President. Now an unprecedented movement of 53 community councils are demanding a summit with energy ministers in a fight to pause infrastructure projects in some of Scotland's most picturesque areas. They claim there is a 'barrage' of major renewable energy proposals with more than 700 live applications in the Highland Council area alone, ranging from wind and hydro projects to energy storage and transmission grid plans. They add that they are being 'overwhelmed by multiple, complex major applications, from well-funded overseas developers'. According to the group, it has become 'David and Goliath' experience, with concerns raised that local democracy has been 'overridden'. The convention now wants the Scottish Government to undertake an inquiry to address the cumulative impact of all major renewable energy infrastructure developments on the communities and landscape fearing projects 'may hasten depopulation in some areas'. In June, 300 gathered in Beauly, near Inverness, in a public meeting to discuss concerns over feeling 'disregarded' over the wave of projects. There were delegates from over 50 community councils, collectively representing 72,000 people. Among the most controversial are plans for a so-called 'super-pylon' plan which was to run for over 100 miles across some of Highlands and Aberdeenshire's most picturesque areas to enable 'significant' growth of renewable energy and support transition away from fossil fuels. Nothing about the A9 dualling project suggests momentum Ms Hyslop I have walked amongst Scotland's largest seagulls - and they are a menace Alan Simpson: Build more houses for rural Scots, not tax second home owners Alan Simpson: Scotland's tourism sector needs to be heard before it's too late Scottish and Southern Electricity Networks Transmission (SSEN), which owns, operates and develops the high voltage electricity transmission system unveiled the strategy three years ago which it says was a 'critical project of national significance' as it has been identified as 'essential' to deliver government targets for offshore wind. The project at that point was to involve building a new 400kV overhead line connection between Beauly and Peterhead to enable the transmission of renewable power into the network for onward transmission to 'areas of demand further south'. They would transmit the electricity on wires carried on a system of mainly metal towers and large substations. SSEN was asked how big the pylons would be after a previous plan involving 165ft 'super pylons' was mothballed five years ago in the wake of environmental concerns. The new pylons at that point were expected to be on average even taller – at 180ft. Now the convention is now planning a summit for [[Inverness]] and wants Scottish energy secretary Gillian Martin and UK energy minister Michael Shanks as well as deputy first minister Kate Forbes to attend. Highland councillor Helen Crawford, who was a key convention organiser, said communities felt 'powerless' over the projects. She said: 'This is a significant representation of thousands of people across the Highlands and it is fair to expect our leaders to advocate for them at [[Scottish Government]] and UK Government level.' In response, Morag Watson, director of onshore at the industry body Scottish Renewables, said: 'Scotland's renewable energy industry is committed to delivering a lasting legacy for local communities and we will work with all stakeholders to achieve the right outcomes for the country as we build a fairer, cleaner and more secure energy system.' Of course there is a degree of Nimbyism at play here as many people love the idea of renewable energy schemes until they pop up and spoil the view out of their kitchen window. However, you just have to look at the UNESCO world heritage site of the Flow Country in Sutherland and Caithness to see the damage that can be done by onshore windfarms. Many small projects have been approved on the peatlands which will cause incalculable damage to the environment as a whole. Onshore wind farms are not as environmentally friendly as some will lead us to believe, they are made of plastic after all. They are also normally sited in peatlands which will release goodness know how many tonnes of carbon dioxide when they are disturbed to drill holds for the cement to keep the turbines in place. Wind farms have their place in the energy mix and are undoubtedly here to stay – they are also far better than coal and gas fired power stations. However, with the number of offshore arrays currently operational with many more planned, maybe it is time to pause new onshore ones. It is arguable now to see how vital they would be for the UK's electricity supply. Some large wind farms, such as Whitelee in East Renfrewshire, are now hugely popular places for recreation such as walking and cycling, whereas before there was just bleak moorland. Thousands of local communities have also benefitted hugely from wind farm proceeds, but that shouldn't be used as a sweetener to get locals onside in future. Wind farms can already provide more than 100% of electricity supply on certain days, so it is hard to argue that we need any more. Offshore wind will provide even more in the future along with the other more conventional sources such as nuclear and hydro. There have been great strides made in recent decades away from fossil fuel to renewables and that should be warmly welcomed by everyone. Sadly, this has come at a cost to some, though the overall benefits far outweigh the downsides. But maybe it is time to halt onshore wind farms before the downsides outweigh the benefits.
Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
Readers' Letters: Scots blessed with abundant natural resources, are more than capable of creating an enlightened future for their country
Any reference to the Scottish Enlightenment must be an anathema to Jill Stephenson (Letters 25 July) as so many Scots of the past have shaped global thinking today, among them Black, Boswell, Burnett, Burns, Cullen, Ferguson, Hume, Hutcheson, Hutton, Playfair, Reid, Smith and Stewart. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Instead of expressing her gratitude for the high quality of the drinking water provided by Scottish Water and the relatively minimal impact of 'storm overflows' on our bathing waters in rivers and around our beaches, Ms Stephenson embarks on another misguided tirade of denigration of the Scottish Government and the SNP, with this time the performance of Scottish Water the source of her discontent. The facts (omitted by UK Environment Secretary, Steve Reed, in recent TV interviews) are that SEPA reports that 87 per cent of Scotland's rivers are in good health while only 15 per cent of England's rivers are rated at that level with The Rivers Trust reporting that not a single waterway in England is in overall good health. It is of course understood that with England being more densely populated there is a greater level of monitoring in England but most sensible people would rather be taking a shower, never mind drinking the water, in Glasgow or Edinburgh, rather than in London. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Perhaps Ms Stephenson should draw some positivity from Scottish history (as it seems that confidence in her fellow 'Scots' is not yet flowing through her veins) and recognise that the people of Scotland, blessed with Scotland's abundant natural resources, are more than capable of creating an enlightened future for their country. Stan Grodynski, Longniddry, East Lothian Tax tipping point The economy of the UK may have passed a tipping point where increased taxation results in reduced tax revenue and higher benefit payments. The result of the various increases in the cost of employing staff is becoming apparent. Many companies do not have the income to be able to retain so many semi-skilled staff. My suggestion is medium sized companies and charities together with those such as supermarkets that employ large numbers of semi-skilled staff have been forced to reduce head count by say 5%. Those no longer employed are no longer paying tax and newly draw benefits. Increasing the tax burden by whatever means will continue this avalanche effect reducing GDP progressively. Scotland may be able to avoid some of the effects of this economic deterioration. Firstly Scotland must stand up to the EU and the London Government by insisting on the same economics ties to the EU as northern Ireland has obtained. Shelve independence, this will eventually come anyway and concentrate on this objective with the grim determination needed to avoid an economic collapse. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Secondly encourage profitable companies to relocate to Scotland by building reasonably priced decent housing in areas with access to economically successful regions such as Glasgow and Edinburgh and offering this to key workers as has been done in the past. Reinforcing success will inevitably allow all areas to benefit from the overall rise in economic activity even if it is just concentrated in the central belt. Above all do not reinforce failure. I suggest governments must realise that they cannot continue to magic money out of thin air by endlessly increasing the tax burden on the people and companies which they represent. In the end they must spend within their means just as every member of our population is forced to. Ken Carew, Dumfries Trump Hypocrisy Gerald Edwards (Letters, 26 July) claims that, unlike Swinney and Starmer, Trump makes good on his election pledges. Ending the Ukraine War within 24 hours was pure hyperbole and failure to recognise that Putin was 'tapping me along' earlier was extremely bad judgement. Our leaders may be ailing but they are not arrogant and incompetent. As Trump landed in Scotland he may have reflected on his presbyterian upbringing from his Scottish mother. 'Blessed are the peacemakers..' (Matthew 5:9). Trump may believe he deserves the Nobel Peace Prize but his track record suggests otherwise. The Gaza War is so one sided the idea that Hamas could end it tomorrow as Mr Edwards claims, is without foundation, they are well beaten and have little influence. As your editorial states Trump is in a unique position to help Gaza by championing humanitarian aid. He could also end the war by withdrawing arms to Israel but allows Prime Minister Netanyahu to string him along with talk of ceasefires to save himself from facing trial for war crimes. Instead Trump is complicit in mass starvation and murder of innocent civilians at US/Israeli food points, some would argue ethnic cleansing. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad As for releasing the Epstein files Trump continues to act with rank hypocrisy as his MAGA base are starting to realise. It's unlikely, however, that our leaders will do anything other than play to Trump's ego given there's a trade deal to sign. Contrary to Mr Edwards view, Swinney should raise Gaza as he pledged to do, just don't mention the windmills John! Neil Anderson, Edinburgh Inquiring minds Stephen Jardine's negative views on public inquiries are spot on (Opinion, July 26). My only criticisms of them is that they are too mild and too measured. Remedying what has become a very expensive British disease is needed. To assuage politicians who need a mechanism to kick issues into touch, and to keep lawyers happy for years to come, I suggest a remedy. A Public Inquiry into public inquiries should be established. Hugh Pennington, Chair, Public Inquiry into the September 2005 Outbreak of O157 in South Wales, Aberdeen Write to The Scotsman
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Donald Trump announces ‘biggest of all deals' between US and EU after crunch tariff talks at Scots golf resort
A high-profile security operation remains in full swing, with police and military on patrol in the grounds of Turnberry DON DEAL Donald Trump announces 'biggest of all deals' between US and EU after crunch tariff talks at Scots golf resort Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DONALD Trump has struck a trade deal with the European Union during his visit to Scotland. The US President made the deal as he sat down with EU Commission president Ursula von der Leyen this afternoon. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 Donald Trump has struck a trade deal with the European Union 4 Trump waves to the press as he tees off on Sunday for his second round at Turnberry Credit: Reuters 4 The President is being protected by a huge security operation Credit: Getty 4 Hundreds of protesters gathered in cities across Scotland on Saturday Credit: Alan Simpson The agreement sets the US tariffs on goods at 15% across the board. He said the EU will make $600bn in US investments, will buy $150bn in US energy and will purchase US military equipment. Speaking to reporters at his golf resort in Turnberry, Mr Tump said:"We have reached a deal. It's a good deal for everybody, "It's going to bring us closer together... it's a partnership in a sense." EU chief Ursula von der Leyen also hailed it as a "huge deal", which came after "tough negotiations". It comes before the American leader is set to be pushed by Sir Keir Starmer on how to end the starvation of kids in Gaza. Earlier today Mr Trump teed off on his second round in Turnberry after landing on Friday night, accompanied by a massive security team. The US President landed in Scotland in a party mood after revealing his plans for a trade deal celebration with Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and First Minister John Swinney. Mr Trump said: "We're going to do a little celebrating because we get along very well." He was welcomed by Scottish Secretary Ian Murray before being whisked to his luxury Turnberry resort 20 miles down the Ayrshire coast. He declared: "There's no place like Turnberry. It's the best course in the world."
