Hewlett-Packard lost hundreds of millions in Autonomy acquisition, judge rules
The company claimed at a nine-month trial in 2019 that Mr Lynch inflated Autonomy's revenues and 'committed a deliberate fraud over a sustained period of time', which it said forced it to announce an 8.8 billion dollar (£6.5 billion) write-down of the firm's worth just over a year after the acquisition.
In a ruling in 2022, Mr Justice Hildyard said the American firm had 'substantially succeeded' in their claim, but that it was likely to receive 'substantially less' than the amount it claimed in damages.
He said that Autonomy had not accurately portrayed its financial position during the purchase, but even if it had, HPE would still have bought the company, but at a reduced price.
A hearing was then held last year to decide the amount that Mr Lynch must pay in damages, before the businessman died aged 59 along with his 18-year-old daughter, Hannah, and five others when his yacht, the Bayesian, sank off the coast of Sicily last August.
On Tuesday, Mr Justice Hildyard ruled that HPE suffered losses amounting to £697,876,753 through the purchasing of Autonomy, some of which is set to be paid by Mr Lynch's estate.
He also ruled that Mr Lynch's estate is liable to pay part of around 47.5 million dollars in damages, which is worth around £35 million.
Some of the money is due to be paid by Sushovan Hussain, Autonomy's former chief financial officer, who was also sued by HPE.
He was convicted in April 2018 in the US of wire fraud and other crimes related to Autonomy's sale, and was sentenced to five years in prison.
While he has since settled HPE's claim, he could still be required to pay damages.
A further hearing to deal with matters including interest, currency conversion and whether Mr Lynch's estate can appeal against the decision is set to be held in November.
Handing down his ruling, Mr Justice Hildyard expressed his 'great sympathy' for Mr Lynch's family, calling his death a 'tragedy'.
He said: 'It is a source of anxiety to me that I have to deliver a judgment that will inevitably cause further stress on those involved.'
In the 197-page ruling, he said he considered that HPE's claim 'was always substantially exaggerated' and that the five billion dollars figure claimed 'was not based on detailed analysis'.
Following the ruling in 2022, Mr Lynch, who was also the founding investor of cybersecurity giant Darktrace, was extradited to the US in May 2023 to face criminal charges after his removal was approved by the then-Home Secretary Priti Patel.
He was cleared of accusations that he orchestrated a fraud and conspiracy over Autonomy's sale in the US in June 2024, and was celebrating the acquittal on his yacht at the time of his death.
In a statement written before his death, issued posthumously by his representatives on Tuesday, Mr Lynch said: 'Today's High Court ruling reflects that HP's original five billion dollar damages claim was not just a wild overstatement – misleading shareholders – but it was off the mark by 80%.
'HP acquired Autonomy for 11.6 billion dollars and today's judgment is a view that Autonomy's actual value was not even 10% below the price HP paid.
'This result exposes HP's failure and makes clear that the immense damage to Autonomy was down to HP's own errors and actions.
'An appeal process will be considered later this year.
'The English civil case included hearsay evidence from the US and we were never able to question or cross-examine those witnesses.
'This is in direct contrast to the rights of defendants in the US legal system.
'When in the US criminal trial we were able to cross-examine the relevant witnesses, a very different story emerged. Why is the English legal system so trusting?'
A spokesperson for HPE said: 'We are pleased that this decision brings us a step closer to the resolution of this dispute.
'We look forward to the further hearing at which the final amount of HPE's damages will be determined.'
Jeremy Sandelson, who was appointed by the court as administrator of Mr Lynch's estate, said he would be 'examining the judgment carefully', including whether to appeal both the 2022 ruling and the judgment on Tuesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Rhyl Journal
7 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
It's great to be here, I love standing on the soil of Scotland, Trump says
Ian Murray told the PA news agency what the US President's first words were after disembarking from Air Force One in Prestwick. The UK Government minister was the first person to greet the president in Scotland as he begins his visit to the country. Speaking after meeting the American leader, Mr Murray told PA: 'The president came off the flight, and I said, 'Mr president, welcome to Scotland – the home country of your dear mother', and he said, 'It's great to be here, I always love standing on the soil of Scotland'. 'I said, 'I hope you're looking forward to a bit of downtime with some golf this weekend', and he said, 'Yes'. And I said, 'Well, we've whipped up a bit of a wind for you to make it a bit more competitive', and he went, 'I'm looking forward to it'.' Mr Murray said Mr Trump was given a warm reception as he got off his presidential plane. Hundreds gathered on the Mound overlooking Prestwick Airport for the president's arrival. A Trump flag was flown while a few spectators wore 'Make America Great Again' hats, although many of those attending were locals and aviation enthusiasts, including some who had travelled from England. Mr Murray said: 'Spotters hills, as it's called, where all the plane spotters come to Prestwick, was absolutely full. 'You could see that from the tarmac and as Air Force One came in, people were snapping away on their photographs. 'To see all that happening is quite a spectacle in itself. 'It's really good to have that kind of focus on Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during his trip to discuss the UK-US trade deal as Britain hopes to be spared from the president's tariff regime. The Scottish Secretary said: 'Really, the purpose of this weekend, the purpose of greeting the president off the plane, the purpose of the Prime Minister's relationship with the president is to build that close relationship, to make sure that that old alliance is nurtured, and to do that for the benefit of the national interest, which is about jobs and growth here in the UK, and particularly Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Scottish First Minister John Swinney during his trip as he opens a new golf course in Aberdeenshire. Before flying to Prestwick, Mr Trump said in Washington that he was 'looking forward' to meeting Mr Swinney, describing him as a 'good man' – the same phrase he used for the Prime Minister after landing in Scotland. Asked about the president's relationship with the UK, Mr Murray said: 'The Prime Minister has taken a very pragmatic approach to the relationship with the president of the United States, because it's in our national interest to do so, whether it be on defence, security, trade, cultural, historic ties. 'It's a historic alliance, and that alliance has to be nurtured and continue through to the future, because it's quite clear that our relationship with United States is good for jobs and growth here in Scotland and across the UK. 'The Prime Minister knows that, and knows that working very closely with the US is in our national interest.' Asked about protests, which are expected across the country, Mr Murray said people had a right to demonstrate, adding: 'Freedom of speech, freedom of assembly and freedom to protest is a key cornerstone of both countries, America and the UK, and the right to be able to protest if they so wish to so.'
South Wales Guardian
7 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
It's great to be here, I love standing on the soil of Scotland, Trump says
Ian Murray told the PA news agency what the US President's first words were after disembarking from Air Force One in Prestwick. The UK Government minister was the first person to greet the president in Scotland as he begins his visit to the country. Speaking after meeting the American leader, Mr Murray told PA: 'The president came off the flight, and I said, 'Mr president, welcome to Scotland – the home country of your dear mother', and he said, 'It's great to be here, I always love standing on the soil of Scotland'. 'I said, 'I hope you're looking forward to a bit of downtime with some golf this weekend', and he said, 'Yes'. And I said, 'Well, we've whipped up a bit of a wind for you to make it a bit more competitive', and he went, 'I'm looking forward to it'.' Mr Murray said Mr Trump was given a warm reception as he got off his presidential plane. Hundreds gathered on the Mound overlooking Prestwick Airport for the president's arrival. A Trump flag was flown while a few spectators wore 'Make America Great Again' hats, although many of those attending were locals and aviation enthusiasts, including some who had travelled from England. Mr Murray said: 'Spotters hills, as it's called, where all the plane spotters come to Prestwick, was absolutely full. 'You could see that from the tarmac and as Air Force One came in, people were snapping away on their photographs. 'To see all that happening is quite a spectacle in itself. 'It's really good to have that kind of focus on Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during his trip to discuss the UK-US trade deal as Britain hopes to be spared from the president's tariff regime. The Scottish Secretary said: 'Really, the purpose of this weekend, the purpose of greeting the president off the plane, the purpose of the Prime Minister's relationship with the president is to build that close relationship, to make sure that that old alliance is nurtured, and to do that for the benefit of the national interest, which is about jobs and growth here in the UK, and particularly Scotland.' Mr Trump will meet Scottish First Minister John Swinney during his trip as he opens a new golf course in Aberdeenshire. Before flying to Prestwick, Mr Trump said in Washington that he was 'looking forward' to meeting Mr Swinney, describing him as a 'good man' – the same phrase he used for the Prime Minister after landing in Scotland. Asked about the president's relationship with the UK, Mr Murray said: 'The Prime Minister has taken a very pragmatic approach to the relationship with the president of the United States, because it's in our national interest to do so, whether it be on defence, security, trade, cultural, historic ties. 'It's a historic alliance, and that alliance has to be nurtured and continue through to the future, because it's quite clear that our relationship with United States is good for jobs and growth here in Scotland and across the UK. 'The Prime Minister knows that, and knows that working very closely with the US is in our national interest.' Asked about protests, which are expected across the country, Mr Murray said people had a right to demonstrate, adding: 'Freedom of speech, freedom of assembly and freedom to protest is a key cornerstone of both countries, America and the UK, and the right to be able to protest if they so wish to so.'
The Guardian
8 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Trump says it's ‘no time to be talking about pardons' for Ghislaine Maxwell as he lands in Scotland ahead of UK and EU talks
Update: Date: 2025-07-25T22:32:08.000Z Title: Ghislaine Maxwell Content: US president tells reporters 'don't talk about Trump' in relation to Jeffrey Epstein furore as he is due to visit golf course and meet leaders Epstein revelations threaten to derail Trump's trip to Scotland Robert Mackey (now); Lucy Campbell, Maya Yang and Shannon Ho (earlier) Sat 26 Jul 2025 00.32 CEST First published on Fri 25 Jul 2025 13.45 CEST From 9.58pm CEST 21:58 Speaking to reporters at Prestwick airport, Trump denied reports that he was briefed about his name appearing in the Epstein files. Asked about the justice department's questioning of , Trump said: 'I don't know anything about the conversation, I haven't really been following it.' 'A lot of people have been asking me about pardons [for Maxwell]. Obviously, this is no time to be talking about pardons' he went on. 'You're making a very big thing over something that's not a big thing.' He then deflects further, suggesting the media should talk about Clinton and the ex-president of Harvard, but 'don't talk about Trump'. Updated at 10.03pm CEST 12.32am CEST 00:32 The Federal Emergency Management Agency (Fema) is preparing to send $608 million to states to construct immigrant detention centers as part of the Trump administration's push to expand capacity to hold migrants. The funds from Fema's 'detention support grant program' cover the cost to states and local governments building temporary facilities, according to an agency grant description. The agency has been accepting applications for funding since 9 July and states have until 8 August to apply for the funds, according to the grant description posted online. The Trump administration has been encouraging states to build their own facilities to detain migrants. This program provides a way for the administration to help states pay for it. The funds will be distributed by Fema in partnership with US Customs and Border Protection, according to the agency. Florida's governor, Ron DeSantis, said on Friday that the state would apply for Fema reimbursement to pay for its new Everglades immigrant detention center it calls 'Alligator Alcatraz.' The facility will cost an estimated $450 million annually, according to homeland security officials. Kristi Noem, the homeland security secretary, has said her department will tap Fema's $650-million shelter and services program to fund Florida's facility. Congress during the Biden administration directed the department, which includes Fema, to distribute the money to state and local governments to cover the cost of sheltering migrants. That funding stream was separate from money Congress set aside for Fema to cover disaster relief. 'Secretary Noem has been very clear that the funding for Alligator Alcatraz can be a blueprint for other states and local governments to assist with detention,' a Fema spokesperson told Reuters. The grant program began accepting applications just days after lawyers for the department argued in court that the federal government could not be sued over Alligator Alcatraz because no funds from Fema had been used to pay for it and 'DHS has not implemented, authorized, directed, or funded Florida's temporary detention center'. News of the new Fema grants for detention facilities came as Maryland's Democratic governor, Wes Moore vowed to take Donald Trump to court after the president denied the governor's request for Fema disaster assistance relief following massive floods in May, calling it 'not warranted'. 'It's an insult to Marylanders and the community still suffering in the aftermath of this storm,' Moore said in a video response to the decision he posted on social media. In recent weeks, Trump has boasted of approving Fema funds to flood victims in Texas and other Republican-run states that voted for him in the 2024 election. 11.23pm CEST 23:23 Donald Trump has arrived at his Turnberry golf resort on the coast of Ayrshire, in south-west Scotland. His motorcade, escorted by Police Scotland vehicles and ambulance crews, drove past a small group of protesters, and at least one supporter. While Trump has spoken fondly of Scotland, where his mother was born and raised, the country has not always returned his warmth. During a previous visit, in 2018, Trump was greeted at his Turnberry resort by a Greenpeace activist who paraglided directly over his head trailing a banner that read: 'Trump: Well Below Par'. Ahead of his visit, one local newspaper, the National, which supports independence for Scotland, ran a preview of the visit with the headline: 'Convicted US felon to arrive in Scotland – Republican leader, who was found liable for sexual abuse and defamation, will visit golf courses'. Tomorrow's front page📰 Convicted US felon to arrive in Scotland 10.52pm CEST 22:52 In his remarks to reporters at Prestwick airport earlier, Donald Trump was asked about his scheduled talks with UK prime minister Keir Starmer, which the White House has used to portray his mainly golf-themed truip as a working visit. 'Can you explain', a reporter asked Trump on the tarmac outside Air Force One, 'what is missing in the UK deal that you have to work out?' 'Nothing', Trump replied. 'I think it's more of a celebration than a workout. It's a great deal for both, and we're going to have a meeting on other things, other than the deal. The deal is concluded'. Trump previously suggested that the talks were to 'refine' the US-UK trade deal. Starmer told Bloomberg News in an interview on Thursday that the UK is still pressing for 'full implementation' of the deal with the US. The sticking point appears to be that while Trump agreed to cut US tariffs on steel imports from the UK that currently stand at 25%, the tariffs have not yet been lifted. 10.21pm CEST 22:21 Chris Stein In response to the House ethics committee's report into Democratic congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's attendance of the Met Gala four years ago, her chief of staff Mike Casca said: 'The Congresswoman appreciates the Committee finding that she made efforts to ensure her compliance with House Rules and sought to act consistently with her ethical requirements as a Member of the House. She accepts the ruling and will remedy the remaining amounts, as she's done at each step in this process.' 10.07pm CEST 22:07 Chris Stein The House ethics committee has ordered progressive Democratic congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to pay nearly $3,000 to resolve an investigation into her attendance of the 2021 Met Gala in New York City. The inquiry began in 2022 following an allegation that Ocasio-Cortez accepted impermissible gifts when she attended the annual gala wearing a white floor-length gown with 'Tax the Rich' written on the back. In its bipartisan report released today, the ethics committee determined that despite making 'significant attempts' to comply with congressional rules around accepting gifts, Ocasio-Cortez failed to do so 'fully' by 'impermissibly' accepting free admission to the gala for her partner, and did not pay full market price for some of what she wore to the event. The committee found that a former campaign staff member tried to lower the congresswoman's costs for attending the gala and made late payments to vendors involved. While it faulted Ocasio-Cortez for not properly supervising the staffer, the committee 'did not find evidence that she intended to seek to lower the cost of goods provided to her or to delay payment for those goods and other services received.' The committee determined that they will close the matter and Ocasio-Cortez will not face sanctions if she donates the $250 cost of her partner's meal, and pays $2,733.28 to the designer from which she rented the dress and accessories. 10.05pm CEST 22:05 Sam Levine A former Department of Justice lawyer has provided evidence to a justice department watchdog corroborating explosive claims that Emil Bove and other top officials wilfully and knowingly defied court orders, according to Whistleblower Aid, a non-profit representing the person. A top department official and Donald Trump's former defense attorney, Bove is currently being considered for a lifetime seat on the federal bench. Whistleblower Aid said it was not identifying its client. They said the person had turned over ' substantive, internal DoJ documents' to the justice department's inspector general. The evidence, the organization said, corroborate allegations from Erez Reuveni, a fired DoJ employee, who has publicly said that Bove told DoJ lawyers to defy the courts. 'What we're seeing here is something I never thought would be possible on such a wide scale: federal prosecutors appointed by the Trump Administration intentionally presenting dubious if not outright false evidence to a court of jurisdiction in cases that impact a person's fundamental rights not only under our constitution, but their natural rights as humans,' said Andrew Bakaj, chief counsel at Whistleblower Aid. 'Our client and Mr Reuveni are true patriots – prioritizing their commitment to democracy over advancing their careers.' Updated at 10.34pm CEST 10.01pm CEST 22:01 Trump also said a trade deal with the European Union would be a big agreement and repeated his view that there was a 'good 50-50 chance' for it. 'With the European Union, we have a good 50-50 chance,' he told reporters. 'That would be the biggest deal of them all if we make it.' He is due to meet with European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen on Sunday to discuss trade. Updated at 10.08pm CEST 9.58pm CEST 21:58 Speaking to reporters at Prestwick airport, Trump denied reports that he was briefed about his name appearing in the Epstein files. Asked about the justice department's questioning of , Trump said: 'I don't know anything about the conversation, I haven't really been following it.' 'A lot of people have been asking me about pardons [for Maxwell]. Obviously, this is no time to be talking about pardons' he went on. 'You're making a very big thing over something that's not a big thing.' He then deflects further, suggesting the media should talk about Clinton and the ex-president of Harvard, but 'don't talk about Trump'. Updated at 10.03pm CEST 9.53pm CEST 21:53 The US president was greeted by Scottish secretary Ian Murray as he walked off Air Force One at Prestwick airport. The pair could be seen shaking hands at the bottom of the aircraft stairs before Donald Trump walked across to a group of journalists to answer questions. 9.32pm CEST 21:32 Air Force One has just landed in Scotland. I'll bring you any key lines here if Donald Trump speaks to the media. Updated at 9.34pm CEST 9.24pm CEST 21:24 Disgraced former US representative George Santos reported to a federal prison in New Jersey earlier today to begin serving a seven-year sentence for the fraud charges that got him ousted from Congress. The federal Bureau of Prisons confirmed to the Associated Press that the New York Republican was in custody at the Federal Correctional Institution in Fairton, in southern New Jersey. Santos pleaded guilty last summer to federal wire fraud and aggravated identity theft charges for deceiving donors and stealing people's identities in order to fund his congressional campaign. Lawyers for Santos didn't respond to phone and email messages seeking comment. The ever-online Santos, 37, hosted a farewell party for himself on X last night. 'Well, darlings … The curtain falls, the spotlight dims, and the rhinestones are packed,' he wrote in a post afterwards. 'From the halls of Congress to the chaos of cable news what a ride it's been! Was it messy? Always. Glamorous? Occasionally. Honest? I tried … most days.' In a Thursday interview with Al Arabiya, a Saudi state-owned news organization, Santos said he'll serve his sentence in a minimum-security prison 'camp' that he described as a 'big upgrade' from the medium-security lockup he was initially assigned to. In April, a federal judge declined to give Santos a lighter two-year sentence that he sought, saying she was unconvinced he was truly remorseful. In the weeks before his sentencing, Santos said he was 'profoundly sorry' for his crimes, but he also complained frequently that he was a victim of a political witch hunt and prosecutorial overreach. Santos lied extensively about his life story both before and after entering the US Congress, where he was the first openly LGBTQ+ Republican elected to the body. He was ultimately convicted of defrauding donors. He has apparently been holding out hope that his unwavering support for Donald Trump might help him win a last-minute reprieve. The White House said this week that it 'will not comment on the existence or nonexistence' of any clemency request. Updated at 10.32pm CEST 8.57pm CEST 20:57 A senior justice department official has told NBC News that attorney general Pam Bondi is still healing from a torn cornea, but it has not prevented her from doing day-to-day work and meeting with staff. The update comes after Bondi abruptly canceled a scheduled appearance on Wednesday at CPAC's anti-trafficking summit in Washington, citing recovery from a health issue. As all the political firestorm over the Epstein saga continues to dominate the news cycle and consume Washington, there has been much online chatter about Bondi's whereabouts. She was last seen on Tuesday morning swearing in the new DEA administrator Terry Cole at the justice department. 8.09pm CEST 20:09 NewsNation reports that following the conclusion of the DOJ interviews, David Oscar Markus, 's attorney, said they were 'very grateful' for the opportunity. Markus said: This was a thorough, comprehensive interview by the deputy attorney general. No person and no topic were off-limits. We are very grateful. The truth will come out. 8.07pm CEST 20:07 Some more detail on that from the Tallahassee Democrat. David Oscar Markus, 's attorney declined to say whether Donald Trump was the focus of any of the Department of Justice's questions during the interviewing sessions that have taken place behind closed doors at the federal courthouse in Tallahassee over the last two days. 'I'm just not going to talk about the substance,' Markus said. Deputy attorney general Todd Blanche had asked Maxwell 'every possible question', Markus said. 'He did a really good job and asked her a lot of things.' Updated at 8.20pm CEST
