Lord of the Rings says burger chain name shall not pass
The rights holder of the Lord of the Rings novels and films, Middle-earth Enterprises, has launched another attack to take its precious title.
It follows an unsuccessful bid in March, where the franchise attempted to block an Australian vegan hamburger chain from trademarking the words "Lord of the" in its name.
Lord of the Fries has been selling items under its name since 2004 and sought to offer plant-based macaroni and cheese under the trademark in 2022.
The case came before a registrar of trademarks in the federal government agency, IP Australia.
Middle-earth argued it had been successful in other similar trademark applications made globally, and used the mark to sell various items including boardgames, clothing and toys.
But Lord of the Fries said there were many examples of similar marks including Lord of the Pies and the business operated as a niche in an entirely different reputation to the Middle-earth franchise.
The registrar delegate, Nicholas Smith, found the names were not deceptively similar and that Middle-earth had cherry-picked evidence in suggesting the connection.
The matter has since been escalated to Sydney's Federal Court, after Middle-earth's lawyers filed an appeal against the IP Australia decision on March 25.
The grounds for appeal were many and varied, the franchise's lawyer Shauna Ross told Justice Michael Lee.
"My client's case is that Your Honour find the mark should be refused," she said on Thursday.
The grounds for appeal included that Lord of the Fries does not own the trademark and that the IP Australia decision was adverse to Middle-earth, who is the true owner of the mark, Ms Ross said.
Justice Lee ordered both parties attend a mediation before June 20.
If the case is not resolved through mediation, Justice Lee said he would assign the matter to a referee, who would then prepare a report for the decision.
"The reality is I don't have time to look at this matter this year," he said.
Lord of the Fries and Middle-earth Enterprises have been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
31 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Major hurdle cleared for ‘best Games ever'
Brisbane's Olympic dream is now a step closer to reality, with billions in federal funds secured to fast-track critical Games infrastructure.A landmark funding agreement between the Australian and Queensland Governments has officially unlocked $3.4bn in federal contributions. The deal, announced on Thursday, will help deliver the infrastructure needed for the 2032 Olympic and Paralympic Games, setting the stage for one of the largest sporting investments in Australian history. An artist's impression of Brisbane Stadium in Victoria Park for the Brisbane 2032 Olympics. Queensland government. Credit: Supplied The deal confirms a combined $7.1bn Games Venue Infrastructure Program, with both governments now committed to delivering 17 new or upgraded sporting venues across Queensland, including a world-class 63,000-seat main stadium at Victoria Park and a National Aquatic Centre. These venues will form the heart of the Games precinct and serve as lasting legacy infrastructure well beyond 2032. The Victoria Park stadium, set to host the Games' opening and closing ceremonies as well as athletics events, is designed to become the future home of major sporting teams like the Brisbane Lions, Brisbane Heat, and Queensland Bulls and will be capable of hosting major events such as Test cricket and international concerts. Early site works, including geotechnical and environmental assessments, are already under way, with the Queensland government also working on cultural heritage agreements with First Nations groups. Deputy Premier Jarrod Bleijie said while efforts were being made to reach an agreement with First Nations groups over the Victoria Park redevelopment, state laws 'will override' if consensus cannot be reached. Queensland Deputy Premier Jarrod Bleijie and federal Infrastructure Minister Catherine King confirm an agreement for the 2032 Brisbane Olympic Games. Dan Peled / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia Procurement for work to begin at four key 'minor venues', the Logan Indoor Sports Centre, Moreton Bay Indoor Sports Centre, Sunshine Coast Stadium upgrade and an upgrade of Barlow Park in Cairns, was also launched on Thursday. These projects will begin shortly, with the Queensland government promising shovels in the ground and fast-tracked delivery. The updated venue delivery plan replaces Labor's former proposal for a new indoor arena in Brisbane's CBD. Under the LNP government's revised approach, the private sector will deliver an arena at Woolloongabba, while taxpayer funds are redirected to other legacy projects, including a Toowoomba Equestrian Centre, a dedicated para-sport facility, and an expanded Queensland Tennis Centre. Speaking at a conference at the Brisbane Convention & Exhibition Centre, Mr Bleijie said the agreement represented the beginning of a new partnership between state and federal governments to deliver the 'best Games ever'. He confirmed that $5.15bn in state funds had already been allocated in Queensland's latest budget to support the delivery of the venues. Plans for a world-class 7000-seat Games arena, athlete village and five-star hotel on the Sunshine Coast have been revealed by Walker Corporation in their Horizon Centre proposal. Credit: Supplied Mr Bleijie also addressed recent speculation that a new Olympic Park train station could be built near the new stadium site, stating that while the idea may have been explored in early discussions, no such plan has been formally announced. However, he reaffirmed the government's broader commitment to infrastructure, including upgraded roads and rail networks. 'I'm not ruling anything in and out,' he said. Federal Infrastructure Minister Catherine King said the Games would be a transformative moment for the state, drawing comparisons to the legacy of Sydney 2000 and describing the investment as the largest contribution the Commonwealth has ever made to sporting infrastructure. In addition to Games venues, the federal government has committed $12.4bn to major transport upgrades across Queensland, including the Bruce Highway, faster rail to the Gold Coast, and the Sunshine Coast Direct Rail project. Sport Minister Anika Wells and Queensland's Games Minister Tim Mander also reaffirmed their commitment to ensuring the Games delivered benefits for all Queenslanders, not just in the southeast but statewide. Mr Bleijie wouldn't rule 'anything in or out'. NewsWire / John Gass Credit: News Corp Australia This includes investing in grassroots sporting programs and doubling federal investment in Australia's Paralympians ahead of 2032. Games Infrastructure Authority chairman Stephen Conroy said work was progressing across all 17 authority venues, with significant input from technical experts during the 100-day review. A new chief executive will soon be appointed to oversee the rollout of the delivery program. Mr Bleijie said the government also remained committed to include Rockhampton as the host location for Olympic rowing events. With legislation already passed to exempt Games infrastructure from major planning laws and procurement officially under way, both governments said the path was now clear to deliver a Games that would not only unite the nation but redefine Queensland's sporting and infrastructure landscape for generations to come.
7NEWS
31 minutes ago
- 7NEWS
Two fashion names and a design guru have just made millions on a cult Byron hinterland hotel
A group of Australian fashion and lifestyle creatives has sold Byron Bay's globally acclaimed Sun Ranch hotel for more than $15 million, just two years after purchasing the hinterland site for $3.9 million. The 22-hectare retreat in Coopers Shoot, a rural pocket 20 minutes from Byron, was bought in 2021 by an investment collective of like-minded women under the name Rolling Thunder. Heading the consortium were Jamie Blakey, founder of cult denim brand One Teaspoon, travel entrepreneur Julia Ashwood, and Claire Tregoning, co-founder of streetwear powerhouse P.E Nation. Together, the trio transformed the property - originally a 1980s brick home with grazing cattle - into a celebrated, design-led destination that blends sustainable architecture with high-end hospitality. The luxury California-ranch-meets-modern-bohemian haven was originally listed in 2024 with a $20 million guide, and then was dropped to $15 million. Selling agent Will Phillips of Sotheby's International Realty handled the campaign, and while the final price has not been disclosed, the deal was reportedly secured for just above $15 million. Despite fielding interest from both residential and commercial buyers, the sellers say they're thrilled that the new owners are committed to continuing the Sun Ranch vision. "We received national and international interest, from hoteliers or people wanting to get into the game, but we couldn't have wished for buyers who were more closely aligned with our business," Ms Ashwood told Australian Financial Review. The new buyers are understood to have bought the Sun Ranch brand and will keep on staff and management. The centrepiece of the estate is the Rambler Longhouse (the former '80s brick pad); a five-room lodge rebuilt from the slab up with eco builder, Balanced Earth. Surrounded by native bushland, the Longhouse includes access to a private mineral pool and outdoor showers, with rooms renting for around $2,500 for two nights. A full property buyout for up to 34 guests comes in at approximately $35,000 per night. Six additional two-bedroom, off-grid barns offer more accommodation on the sprawling property, which also features two infinity-edge mineral pools, a wood-fired sauna and ice bath, and access to the creek that meanders through the estate. With approval for events of up to 150 people, Sun Ranch has quickly become a sought-after venue for brand activations, milestone birthdays, weddings and retreats. Since launching in 2023, the property has received widespread acclaim and was named one of 'the most 'stylish hotels on the planet' by British GQ. The women behind the project have described the experience as a blend of creativity and community, bringing together their expertise in fashion, branding and hospitality. Ms Blakey's One Teaspoon label brought a distinct rock'n'roll edge to Australian fashion through the 2000s; Ms Ashwood was known for her blog The Vista and boutique hotel ventures and curation; and Ms Tregoning's career spans executive and strategic roles in fashion and business. For the women of Rolling Thunder, who built one of the world's most talked-about boutique accommodations from the ground up, the sale marks the end of a transformative chapter with a major financial win. Nearby Byron hinterland estates for sale On the market for the first time in 40 years, this iconic property to the area is a gorgeous 120- year-old heritage home that sits on a total of 11 acres with approximately 3 acres of level land - meaning lots of extra lifestyle potential. Spanning 42 acres in scenic Newrybar, this dreamy property is home to a beautifully updated main residence, charming converted dairy bales and a contemporary art studio. The acreage has a focus on sustainable, eco-friendly living with scope to create the ultimate hinterland sanctuary. This multi-residence estate is the epitome of a sophisticated yet laid-back Byron escape. The almost 30-acre former mango farm now houses four independent dwellings of differing design, from beautiful Tuscany-inspired style to impressive architectural design.
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission warns against deceptive foreign 'ghost stores' claiming to be high quality local retailers that are 'closing down'
Aussies have been warned about a litany of deceptive 'ghost stores' presenting as Australian shops but are actually foreign stores drop-shipping goods to local consumers. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission issued public warning notices about four online wesbites that portray themselves as local high-end fashion businesses that are closing down. Instead, the companies are based overseas, not closing down and are drop-shipping low quality products, according to the ACCC. Drop-shipping is a practice where a retailer acts as a middleman between a customer and the supplier to sell the item. The drop-shipper provides the order and shipping details to the supplier who transports the item to the buyer. The four websites the consumer watchdog warned Aussies about are and ACCC Deputy Chair Cartiona Lowe said the names of these websites were deliberately designed to mislead consumers into believing the stores were Australian. 'We are warning Australians about the risks of engaging with these four websites specifically, which we allege are not based in Melbourne, Adelaide or Double Bay, nor are they imminently closing down,' Ms Lowe said. 'We further allege that the operators of these websites are supplying products which are not of the advertised quality.' Ghost stores often use names similar to existing retailers and buy paid advertisements on social media sites to boost their presence. The prevalence of ghost stores extends greatly beyond these four sites mentioned by the watchdog, the ACCC warned. It said the conduct appears to be widespread and stressed the need for caution when online shopping. 'We urge all Australians to think twice before clicking on ads they see on social media which claim to be from a boutique business based in a local town or city,' Ms Lowe said. 'Often ghost stores will share an emotional story on their social media or website that they are a small, locally operated business, needing to close for financial reasons. 'They will claim they are having a 'closing down sale' as a result, with all stock heavily discounted and available on a very limited basis. 'This conduct preys on the empathy of consumers who have a genuine desire to support local businesses, as well as creating a false sense of urgency.' Both Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, and e-commerce platform Shopify have been contacted by the ACCC to crack down on the ghost stores. The consumer watchdog said shoppers should be wary of websites claiming to be located in Australia despite not having a '. domain. It also cautioned about fake backstories, the use of AI generated images or listed return addresses outside of Australia. Shoppers should also be wary of sites without a contact phone number or physical address for the store. Online retailers that do not provide an ABN or ACN, have a litany of negative online reviews or refer to international laws for the website's privacy policy or terms of service should also be approached with caution.
