logo
A costly mistake for consumers and the economy

A costly mistake for consumers and the economy

Price caps are often framed as a consumer protection measure – a way to stop touts profiteering and shield fans from exploitative pricing. At first glance, this approach appears to be a straightforward way to make live events more accessible and fair, ensuring that tickets are sold at a price deemed reasonable by policymakers. It is an argument that resonates emotionally, especially when fans are priced out of seeing their favourite artists or teams.
However, while well-meaning, this seemingly simple and fair solution actually obscures a host of deeper issues. In reality, price caps create unintended consequences – not just for the fans they aim to protect, but for the broader UK economy. When we move beyond the rhetoric and examine the practical impacts, it becomes clear that price caps, however well-intentioned, ultimately risk doing more harm than good.
Let's start by examining the evidence: resale price caps can harm fans by pushing them out of safe, regulated marketplaces and onto riskier, unregulated platforms such as social media. Our research shows that 37 per cent of fans would likely turn to social media if they couldn't access a regulated resale option – despite it being one of the riskiest places to buy tickets. In jurisdictions like Ireland and Victoria, Australia, where resale caps are in place, fraud rates are nearly four times higher than in the UK, according to research by Bradshaw Advisory. If mirrored here, that could drive the cost of fraud up from £340m to over £1.2bn. But there's an additional, often overlooked consequence: the broader economic fallout. Resale markets don't just help fans find and sell last-minute tickets; they underpin an ecosystem of spending that spans travel, hospitality, and retail.
At the Centre for Economics and Business Research (Cebr), we've analysed the data. When fans purchase resale tickets via secondary marketplaces, they spend an average of £629 on top of the ticket itself – on hotels, food, transport and merchandise. This secondary spending supports £733 million in annual turnover, contributes £270m to GDP, and sustains more than 7,700 jobs across the UK. If, as expected, price caps discourage reselling – for example, if fans who can no longer attend see no financial value in passing on their ticket – they may simply let their seats go unused. For every 1 per cent of tickets that go unused, the economy could lose approximately £7.3m in revenue. If just one in four tickets on the secondary market were to go unsold, this figure would rise to an estimated £183m.
Year after year, we continue to see the ticketing industry disappoint fans. Last year, the Oasis fiasco. This year, as recently as June 2025, thousands of NFL fans in Ireland were left empty-handed and frustrated after queuing for hours online for Pittsburgh Steelers versus Minnesota Vikings at Croke Park tickets. Strict price cap laws in Ireland mean there is no regulated, safe resale option if they missed out – no second chance to attend, no flexibility to pay what they feel the ticket is worth. Just two days after tickets went on sale, there is evidence of tickets being listed on social media platforms by individuals and suspected fraudulent companies. Desperate fans lured by posts for tickets that look too good to be true risk playing into the hands of the fraudsters who lie in wait.
So, who ends up out of pocket? The fans, certainly, but financial institutions are also on the hook to reimburse defrauded customers. Since October 2024, UK banks have been required to reimburse victims of Authorised Push Payment (APP) fraud, which includes most ticket scams. With resale restrictions forcing more buyers onto risky channels, the financial burden is now spreading from fans to banks – and eventually to the wider economy. With sought-after tickets, fraudsters leverage both the fear of missing out on a unique opportunity and a sense of urgency due to scarcity and high demand. Several financial institutions see social media fraud spike around popular live events – and some have voiced their opposition to price caps. Revolut saw ticket scams increase by 40 per cent in the run-up to Taylor Swift concerts in London in August 2024. The fintech giant has publicly shared its position: banning or capping resale doesn't stop these scams; it simply provides another platform for them to thrive, costing fans and the wider economy through increased fraud. Ultimately, not only do fans suffer unintended consequences, the economy loses.
Yes, we must protect consumers. But price caps – while well-intentioned – are a misguided solution. Anyone familiar with the dynamics of supply and demand understands that capping resale prices will only re-route the fan demand off trusted platforms and into unregulated corners of the internet, where fraud is rife. With its proposed legislation, the UK government risks doing more harm than good – exposing consumers to greater danger and undermining a sector that sustains thousands of jobs and generates millions in economic value. The alternative isn't price control, it's regulation that works. That means transparency, enforcement of existing rules, and ensuring that safe, well-regulated resale platforms remain viable – and continue to contribute to the UK economy.
Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe
Sponsored by Viagogo
Related
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Over half of Scottish firms committed to employee volunteering, research finds
Over half of Scottish firms committed to employee volunteering, research finds

Scotsman

time15 hours ago

  • Scotsman

Over half of Scottish firms committed to employee volunteering, research finds

A new wave of workplace volunteering is quietly reshaping how Scottish businesses are approaching productivity and employee wellbeing. Sign up to our Scotsman Money newsletter, covering all you need to know to help manage your money. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... New research commissioned by national charity Royal Voluntary Service found 57% of firms in the country now offer paid volunteering time to staff, with 26% introducing it in the last 12 months alone. The data suggests this uplift in volunteering amongst the Scottish business community is being driven by a desire to tackle employee burnout (36%), engage staff (27%) and boost performance (31%), as well as to deliver social impact – 80% of businesses in the region agree volunteering is important to their company purpose and ESG goals. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 1000 UK companies were questioned for the study, with the findings published in a new repor t Untapped impact: unlocking the 140 million hour opportunity. Volunteering can boost productivity and improve employee engagement The report also features new analysis by the Centre for Economics and Business Research (Cebr), which reveals that increasing participation in employee volunteering could also generate substantial financial gains. Cebr's analysis suggests the UK economy could stand to benefit from productivity gains worth £32.5 billion each year, or £5,239 per employee working in professional and managerial occupations - if workplace volunteering days were fully utilised The study stresses these productivity gains could be higher still, if the voluntary efforts of those in other job roles were also considered and if paid volunteering time was offered to more employees. However, despite the momentum, across all the UK, companies are not realising the full potential of their volunteering programmes. Employers offer an average of 2.3 days annually, but the study showed more than 140 million hours of gifted time went unused last year. Additionally, not all employees are being given equal access to volunteering opportunities - less than one in five (19%) firms with programmes offer it to all their employees. On average, just half of employees receive the benefit. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Reasons businesses cited for not realising the potential of programmes included a lack of flexible one-off volunteering opportunities (28%) and team activities (17%), difficulty finding the right roles (21%), and not knowing where to start (12%). Unlocking the millions of unused hours could breathe new life into civil society at a time when volunteering is in decline and demand on charities hits new highs. In response, Royal Voluntary Service has unveiled a new Volunteering Marketplace – a suite of services designed to help businesses build, embed and optimise their volunteering and social impact activities. The offer will include bespoke programme design, measurement and reporting, expert consultancy and digital badges to recognise success. At the heart of the charity's Volunteering Marketplace, is a new digital volunteering platform, currently in development thanks to a £5 million investment from players of People's Postcode Lottery. Set to launch later this year, the platform is designed to remove barriers to volunteering for all – offering thousands of flexible, inclusive roles to suit modern working patterns. For businesses, it will offer an end-to-end solution: matching staff to relevant opportunities, making volunteering easier to manage, and enabling organisations to track participation and impact. Subscription-based, the platform aims to become the UK's largest digital volunteering community – one that works for businesses, causes and volunteers alike. It will be free for charities and the public to use. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Catherine Johnstone CBE, Chief Executive, Royal Voluntary Service, said: 'Employee volunteering programmes are fast becoming one of the smartest investments a business can make. As our research shows, those who do it are seeing great results – from improved staff wellbeing and motivation to increased productivity. 'If just some of those 140 million lost volunteering hours were used it could be transformational in its effect. With our new Volunteering Marketplace we will help unlock that potential – making volunteering work for more businesses and their employees and enabling them to click and connect to the causes they care about.' Chris Breen, Head of Economic Insight at Cebr, added: 'Business leaders and employees alike may wonder what's in it for them when it comes to volunteering. Our research shows the answer is quite a lot. If every employee in a professional or managerial role offered volunteer days actually used them, it would have resulted in a £32.5 billion boost to UK productivity in 2024 alone.'

New research shows changing consumer attitudes towards second-hand economy
New research shows changing consumer attitudes towards second-hand economy

Fashion United

time3 days ago

  • Fashion United

New research shows changing consumer attitudes towards second-hand economy

New research from Amazon, compiled by the Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR), has revealed that two-thirds of British consumers bought second-hand goods online last year, with pre-owned online shopping set to grow to 4.8 billion pounds in the UK this year. The changing consumer attitudes towards the second-hand economy are being driven by clothing and fashion, with the research stating that British consumers saved a collective 5.6 billion pounds in 2024 and kept 199 million products in circulation. The key factors for consumers turning to pre-owned products include increasing cost-of-living pressures, wider availability of second-hand goods, and heightened consideration of environmental issues among shoppers. Demographics also reveal an evolving market, with 74 percent of people aged 34 and under embracing second-hand shopping compared to 52 percent of over-55s. CEBR also noted that average monthly spend on pre-loved goods has more than doubled over five years, increasing by 113 percent from 58.40 to 124.80 pounds a month, and second-hand products now account for 34-45 percent of UK spending within some of the most popular categories, including tech, fashion and home appliances. Despite growing popularity, barriers remain, with the report identifying key concerns from consumers, including product condition (43 percent), lack of warranties (39 percent), and seller trust (29 percent) preventing wider adoption.

Marcus Rashford endures journey from hell as Man Utd star's transfer to Barcelona is almost scuppered by OASIS
Marcus Rashford endures journey from hell as Man Utd star's transfer to Barcelona is almost scuppered by OASIS

The Sun

time3 days ago

  • The Sun

Marcus Rashford endures journey from hell as Man Utd star's transfer to Barcelona is almost scuppered by OASIS

MARCUS RASHFORD endured a journey from hell today - after his trip to Barcelona was almost scuppered by Oasis. The Manchester United striker had hoped to travel by private jet from Manchester airport on Sunday to Spain ahead of a medical today. 3 3 3 But officials were unable to give him a slot as the Manchester City -loving brothers Noel and Liam Gallagher had taken up all the space. Liam is believed to have had a private jet on standby at the airport to take him to his home in the south of France after the band's final gig at Manchester's Heaton Park. Rashford, 27, and his team of advisors were instead forced to drive 80 miles to East Midlands airport instead. The player was then delayed an hour before boarding a private jet which was due to land shortly after 8pm on Sunday. He is due to undergo a medical on Monday and all being well, seal a season-long loan deal. A source said: 'Marcus' travel plans were disrupted so it was all a bit stressful but he would have walked to Barcelona to sign for them. 'Noel and Liam can have a laugh that they accidentally put a spanner in the works.' The private terminal at Manchester airport is also understood to be busy with Oasis fans from around the world jetting in to enjoy the gigs. The Sun told in February while Rashford was on loan at Aston Villa how his No 1 target if he was to leave Old Trafford was the Catalan giants. His team agreed a deal on Thursday that suited both United and Barcelona given the forward would not feature again for United under manager Ruben Amorin. Barca will cover 100 per cent of Rashford's £325,000-a-week wages to bring the forward to LaLiga and also have an option to buy. The deal does not allow United to recall the striker. United will save £15million in wages, which would be vital funds for Amorim to overhaul his squad. Rashford hopes to travel with Barcelona when the Spanish club departs this week for its pre-season tour of Asia, which begins next Sunday. The England international spent the second half of last season on loan at Aston Villa after a move to Spain became too complicated in the January window. He has remained steadfast that he wanted to move to a club playing Champions League football. Should the move go to plan and Rashford seal a permanent move next summer, it would end his 20-year association with United. The United academy product scored 138 goals since his debut in 2015 and has made 426 appearances for the club, the last of which came against Viktoria Plzen in December.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store