Judge dismisses Justin Baldoni's $515 million defamation lawsuit against Blake Lively
NEW YORK – A United States judge on June 9 dismissed actor Justin Baldoni's US$400 million (S$515 million) defamation lawsuit against actress Blake Lively, who had accused Baldoni of sexually harassing her while filming the 2024 movie It Ends With Us.
US District Judge Lewis Liman in Manhattan said Lively's claims to a California state agency about Baldoni's alleged harassment during the filming were privileged, and shielded from the defamation claim by Baldoni and his Wayfarer Studios.
In a 132-page decision, the judge also dismissed Baldoni's related US$250 million lawsuit against The New York Times. He said Baldoni can try to file a much narrower lawsuit against Lively focused on contractual issues.
Lawyers for Baldoni did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
'Today's opinion is a total victory and a complete vindication for Blake Lively,' her lawyers Michael Gottlieb and Esra Hudson said in a joint statement. 'As we have said from day one, this US$400 million lawsuit was a sham.'
The Times had no immediate comment.
Baldoni's lawsuit was in response to Lively's lawsuit in Manhattan federal court over the alleged harassment. She still seeks unspecified triple and punitive damages in that case, and a March 2026 trial remains scheduled.
Lively alleges vengeance
The feud began publicly in December when Lively filed a complaint with the California Civil Rights Department (CRD) about Baldoni, followed by her lawsuit.
In response, Baldoni's countersuit accused Lively, her husband and actor Ryan Reynolds, Lively's publicist Leslie Sloane, the Times and others of trying to smear him.
Baldoni said Lively tried to effectively hijack It Ends With Us, which he directed and whose themes included domestic violence, and then blame him when her 'disastrous' promotional approach prompted an online backlash against her.
His case against the Times focused on its Dec 21, 2024 article about them: 'We Can Bury Anyone': Inside A Hollywood Smear Machine.
Lively had called Baldoni's lawsuit a vengeful attempt to weaponise the federal courts, and pursue a sinister campaign to bury and destroy her for speaking out.
The Times, meanwhile, said it should not be punished merely for newsgathering, and said a statement in the article that Baldoni led a smear campaign in retaliation to Lively's complaints was protected opinion.
Judge finds defamation claim implausible
In his decision, the judge said Baldoni alleged at most that Lively communicated the privileged CRD complaint to the Times, while her husband and publicist made what they thought were true statements about Baldoni's sexual harassment.
'The Wayfarer parties' conclusory allegations that Lively, Reynolds and Sloane engaged in a conspiracy to defame the Wayfarer parties by disseminating knowingly false statements cannot substitute for factual allegations supporting a plausible inference that this occurred,' the judge wrote.
He also said that even if the Wayfarer parties laid the groundwork for a negative publicity campaign but never put it into operation, the Times would not have known.
'Freedoms of expression require breathing space, and a publisher must be permitted to publish the story that it believes in good faith to be before it,' he wrote.
It Ends With Us garnered mixed reviews, but grossed more than US$351 million worldwide, according to Box Office Mojo, an American website that tracks box-office revenue. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
14 hours ago
- Straits Times
Love-struck trucks and diggers: Estonia's take on 'Romeo and Juliet'
Heavy machinery are seen Shakespeare's \"Romeo and Juliet\" theatre adaptation, where heavy goods vehicles and cars take on the roles of the famous characters, in Rummu, Estonia, July 31, 2025. REUTERS/Janis Laizans RUMMU, Estonia - A production of "Romeo and Juliet" in Estonia uses a cast of vehicles to tell Shakespeare's story of star-crossed lovers, with a red Ford pickup taking on the role of Juliet, while her Romeo is a rally truck. 'I must say I came into it expecting it to be really silly, but it was really good. I really liked it," said Maia Maisate, a spectator, after the show. A disused limestone quarry in the Estonian countryside is the backdrop as more than a dozen vehicles, including city buses, fire engines, a lorry and a cement truck with hearts painted on it, drive around in front of makeshift viewer stands. Two excavators waved their mechanical arms at each other threateningly in a recreation of the fatal sword fight between Tybalt and Mercutio, and a car was thrown from a cliff. 'I would still say that even though it was cars, it felt really sweet and cute. Like when you had the scene where the cars were, you would assume, kissing, the energy was captured really well. The sweetness and the love," said Maia Pussim, another spectator. The production, which continues until Sunday, is without dialogue, although it is accompanied by fireworks and music, including the track "Lovefool" by Swedish group The Cardigans. "It's basically a big experiment about what it means to do Shakespeare today and whether we can find new ways to do it," said co-director Paavo Piik of Kinoteater, which put on the play. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Tech Reporting suspected advanced cyber attacks will provide a defence framework: Shanmugam Business Singapore's US tariff rate stays at 10%, but the Republic is not out of the woods yet World As China-US tariff truce talks drag on, what are prospects for a 'big deal' for Trump? Singapore Thundery showers expected on most days in first half of August Singapore SPH Media awards three journalism scholarships to budding newsroom talent Singapore Synapxe chief executive, MND deputy secretary to become new perm secs on Sept 1 Singapore 5 women face capital charges after they were allegedly found with nearly 27kg of cocaine in S'pore Business Sumo Salad had valid insurance coverage for work injury claims: MOM "We wanted to be very gentle with these big machines. This contrast is interesting for us. Is it possible to deliver emotions like love (with big vehicles)?" REUTERS
AsiaOne
18 hours ago
- AsiaOne
Blake Lively accused of harassment and intimidation, Entertainment News
Blake Lively has been accused of trying to "harass and intimidate" a YouTuber. Content creator Lauren Neidigh, who posts under the username LethalLauren904 has sought a protective order against the former Gossip Girl star after the 37-year-old actress attempted to subpoena her as part of her legal battle with It Ends With Us co-star and director Justin Baldoni, who she is suing for sexual harassment and retaliation. Lauren slammed the subpoenas that Blake's team had sent to Google and X in an attempt to gain information, even though the one against her had been dropped, Us Weekly reports. The YouTuber claimed she had tried to speak to Blake's lawyers but they were "largely unresponsive" and could not explain why her banking information was relevant to the case. She wrote in a letter to the judge: "[Lively's] Subpoena targeted creators who have expressed unfavourable opinions about her online. The Subpoena was not supported by any evidence. "It served to intimidate, harass, chill constitutionally protected free speech, and threaten the safety and privacy of non-parties who are not involved in this litigation." And though the Another Simple Favor star had dropped the subpoena, she left it open-ended, meaning it could still be reissued in the future, which Lauren argued placed "an undue burden on [her] and [served] to harass and intimidate [her] for her lawful expression of her unfavourable opinions of [Lively] online." The content creator requested a protective order prohibiting Blake from issuing any further subpoenas for her information due to the "ongoing threat" of "further abusive discovery requests" down the line, which she argued were designed to "intimidate" her for her "lawful expression". She also asked for sanctions. The subpoenas had sought information on the accounts of several content creators, including financial detail on some of them, with Lauren, Kassidy O'Connell and others opposing the legal demands, insisting Blake had no authority to obtain their private information. At the time, the actress' representative insisted the requests were not "accusations of wrongdoing" but simply "tools for gathering admissible evidence in federal court." The spokesperson added: "There is no silencing of content creators, they are obviously making their views known. This is a sexual harassment and retaliation lawsuit against Justin Baldoni and a number of other Wayfarer defendants and we are simply seeking information to aid in our fact gathering. "Remember [Baldoni's crisis PR rep's] own words: to shield Justin Baldoni from the possibility that Blake Lively might publicly reveal he sexually harassed her and others, [Baldoni's rep] planned an 'untraceable' media campaign designed to 'bury' Ms. Lively. "The subpoenas to social media companies are one piece of the puzzle to connect the evidentiary dots of a campaign that was designed to leave no fingerprints." Days later, the investigation into Lauren, Kassidy, and a third social media star was dropped but Blake is still in the process of gathering information on other content creators who had spoken about her and Justin, who she has alleged arranged a smear campaign in retaliation for her complaining about his conduct on the set of It Ends With Us. Justin has denied the allegations against him. [[nid:720863]]
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
YouTube's Lofi Girl finally finishes homework and ‘graduates' after 8 years
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Jade, better known as Lofi Girl, announced that she had finally graduated on July 30. An online personality that has accompanied millions across the globe through hours of study, work and chill sessions has finally finished her homework. Jade, better known as Lofi Girl, the face of the popular French YouTube channel of the same name, announced on X on July 30 that she had finally graduated. In a video animation, Jade is holding up a laptop with the words 'The End' on the screen. Initially in her signature red and green outfit with headphones, she is seen donning a navy-coloured graduation gown and mortarboard once the laptop is shut . 'Finally finished with all my homework. I don't know what I learned, but I know I'm done learning.' she laughs, recreating the dialogue from a a teen sitcom that has become a trend on TikTok. Since its inception in 2015, the YouTube channel has amassed more than 15 million subscribers, racking up more than a billion views through its videos – the most popular of which is the constantly-running 'lofi hip hop radio beats to relax/study to' stream, which features Jade in an animation loop over music. Fans were quick to congratulate her on her graduation. 'All of that studying paid off! Congrats' said live-streaming site Twitch . Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Asia US-Malaysia tariff deal set for Aug 1 after Trump-Anwar phone call Asia Malaysia PM Anwar says Trump to attend Asean Summit in October Singapore Underground pipe leak likely reason for water supply issues during Toa Payoh fire: Town council Singapore Driver in 2024 Tampines crash that killed 2 set to plead guilty in October Multimedia 60 years, 60 items: A National Day game challenge Asia US CDC weighs travel notice for China as chikungunya cases rise Singapore Wegovy and beyond: Will weight-loss drugs change the way people look at obesity? Singapore 'Switching careers just as I became a dad was risky, but I had to do it for my family' 'She's been studying since September 2017. Just to put it into perspective, it's been 7 years 10 months and 28 days 2861 days 68,673 hours 41,20,419 minutes HARDWORK AND DEDICATION!' said YouTube user kabirmalek5488 . It is unclear what this may mean for the future of the channel. So far, despite her graduation, it seems to be business as usual on the popular stream, with Jade still doing what she has done for the past eight years: Writing in her notebook and occasionally looking out the window as her cat lounges beside her, through a never-ending stream of lo-fi music. Lofi Girl first appeared in her first iteration in November 2017, while the channel was still known as ChilledCow. Although the channel's most famous videos are the 24/7 lo-fi streams, it also features short animation clips. Lo-fi music, according to Forbes , has roots dating back to the 1960s, but is best known today as a 'subgenre of downtempo electronic music containing hip-hop beats with a relaxed aesthetic'. The Lofi Girl channel has cemented its place in pop culture, with myriad of memes inspired by its content. A multitude of similar streams - which include a central animation looping as lo-fi music plays - have spawned on YouTube and other video streaming platforms. Lofi Girl has even found her way into politics. In the 2019 UK general election, the Conservatives YouTube channel released a video featuring then-prime minister Boris Johnson titled 'lo fi boriswave beats to relax/get brexit done to'. Taiwanese President Lai Ching-te in 2023 called for members of the public to submit their lo-fi music for his '2024 Healing Music Submission Project' , describing the subgenre as 'an essential healing companion for modern people'. His channel, called Lofi on Lai, features 'healing, vocal-free versions of the Democratic Progressive Party's presidential campaign songs from 1996 to 2024'.
