18 Highly Rated Shoes That Are So Comfortable, Your Cost Per Wear Will Be Almost $0

Buzz Feed

17-04-2025

We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
Shopping
·
If you calculate how often you'll use these shoes, you'll realize they're basically ✨free✨.
Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women's.
1. A pair of Chelsea Boots to bring that vintage aesthetic to any outfit you throw together. With a footbed that's designed to sculpt to the shape of your foot, these boots are not only ridiculously stylish but comfortable enough to be your new favorite shoes on the days you decide to stroll all around the city.
The company recommends ordering you "boot size," which is a half size lager than your "normal size."
Promising review:"I recommend these boots to everyone and get compliments on them often. I've worn these for full days of walking, and they're pretty comfortable. They also hold up really nicely and still look like new, even after about a year of wearing them. Best of all, they go with everything." — Emma
Get them from Amazon for $160 (available in sizes 5-12 and in 10 colors and fabrics).
2. Madewell court sneakers because you've always wanted a cute, comfy, quality sneaker that didn't have a visible logo branded loudly on the side. It's super versatile, so you'll find yourself wearing these on a daily basis with any number of different outfits.
Madewell
Promising review:"I've had these shoes for a couple of years now, and I am obsessed. They are so comfortable and truly go with everything. I've walked miles in these shoes, and they hold up so well." — CME663
Get them from Madewell for $98 (available in sizes 5–12).
3. Ballet flats with oh-so-freakin'-cute floral cutouts so your feet will be able to breathe without you having to resort to wearing your flip-flops. Reviewers swear there's no break-in period required, so you can wear this cutesy-meets-classy pair with no pain!
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review:"These fit like a dream! So comfortable and stylish. Love them and will probably by another pair in another color." — Amazon Customer
Get them from Amazon for $24.69+ (available in sizes 5–12 and in nine colors).
4. A pair of mesh sneakers with a honeycomb insole design and mesh upper, perfect for those of you who want a comfy pair of sneakers and like your shoes to be a bright reflection of your personality. Just slip these on and get ready to run — these shoes were basically crafted for your athletic self.
Promising review:"They are so comfortable, and they look great. I love the color. They are going with everything and that is hard to pull off. I will be wearing them all the time." — yworks
Get it from Amazon for $32.99+ (available in sizes 5.5–10.5 and 21 colors).
5. Lucky Brand ankle boots — with this timeless design, you'll find yourself reaching for them all year long, for years and years to come, since they'll basically never go out of style. They're made of leather, have a cushioned footbed (hello comfort!!!) and zippers on the side, so they're easy to put on. Truly classic.
Heather Braga / BuzzFeed, www.amazon.com
BuzzFeed shopping editor Heather Braga says:"I have these boots in both black and toffee — I'm actually obsessed. They are my favorite shoes right now because I can wear them through the fall, winter, and early spring. They look fantastic with jeans and adorable with tights. They have just enough heel to create the look of heeled booties without the discomfort of walking around in heels. Basically, they're amazing and everyone should buy them. K, thanks. You can check out my full review on them here (#6)."
Promising review:"Extremely comfortable. I have worn these the past two days since they arrived, and my feet are happy. I am a consistent size 7.5, but I ordered an 8 based on other reviews. The 8 fits perfectly wearing thin/normal socks. Dropped some water on my shoes accidentally, and it beaded right up, so I think these will do well in the rain. I'll be wearing these on a trip to Europe and am excited to have shoes that will be both stylish and comfortable for lots of walking." — Cristina
Get them from Amazon for $9.89+ (available in sizes 5–13 and wide widths, and 56 colors and fabric styles).
6. Over-the-knee boots with an adjustable back tie so you can ensure it fits snugly. Plus, they're specifically designed to fit wide calves! Finally, you're ready to emulate that 2015 Ariana Grande aesthetic.
Torrid
Promising review:"These are comfortable and go with everything! Soft, roomy, and true to fit! Great price! These are my favorite boots! Stay up nicely, and I love the tie-up cross over back at the top" — GREENSLEEVES
Get them from Torrid for $20.99+ (originally $89.90; available in sizes 6–13 and in two colors).
7. Doc Marten combat boots for literally any time of year — your goth gal aesthetic doesn't need to compromise on comfort or reliability; these bad boys do it all.
www.amazon.com
Promising review:"I'm in love. I'm never buying another brand of combat boots again. I'd been hesitant to buy Docs because of the price, but these were absolutely worth it. They have excellent support (comfortable enough to wear for eight-hour shifts on my feet), and they're grippy enough to handle snow, sleet, and New England winters. I tend to wear my shoes to death, but I've been wearing these pretty much daily for four months, and they're holding up well." — R
Get them from Amazon for $76.46+ (available in sizes 5–11 and in six colors).
8. A pair of Rainbow Wave sneakers with a cushy Ortholite insole so you can roam around your day in absolute comfort. Psst, they're so colorful and fun, the waitress at your regular Friday night haunt is bound to compliment you on 'em.
Amazon, www.amazon.com
Promising review:"These are the absolute cutest and soooo comfortable!! I bought another pair in a different pattern because they are truly that great. It's like wearing joy on your feet." — T. T. Robinson
Get them from Amazon for $148.95 (available in sizes 5–7.5).
9. Rhinestone pointed slip-on mules to add a bit of ✨bling-bling✨ to your current collection of plain, simple office flats — even Glinda (or is it Ga-linda?? I can never keep up) would approve.
www.amazon.com
Promising review:"These mules are one of the best I have purchased at a good price. They are so beautiful. They are comfortable, and I can wear them for eight hours without any problem on my feet. I will use them in Paris. It feels like you are just wearing house slippers. I bought another pair." — CA buyer
Get them from Amazon for $15.49+ (available in sizes 5.5–10.5 and in eight colors and patterns).
10. Or a ballet flat if you want a more minimalistic look. These shoes have more than 49,000 5-star reviews, so if you're looking for a new closet staple — look no further. Plus, they're so affordable that you'll want to grab one in every color!
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review: "These are seriously the best flats I've ever owned (and believe me, I've tried a lot of them). These were super comfortable the first day I wore them, and NO blisters! Great shoes for work or casual attire. I will be purchasing these in every color!" — Casey
Get it from Amazon for $13.79+ (available in sizes 5–15, including wide sizes, and in 22 colors).
11. Hoka sneakers beloved by nurses, doctors, and teachers (really anyone who finds themselves on their feet for most of the day) everywhere. They're super cushiony, so it'll feel like you're walking on clouds as you strut around, sporting the dreamy colors of your choice.
Hoka
Promising review:"This is my first time buying a pair of Hoka shoes, but it won't be my last. They have quickly become my go-to and favorite sneakers. The toe box gives plenty of room. They run true to size and are amazingly comfortable. Love them." — Gizzys mom
Get them from Hoka for $115.99 (originally $165; available in sizes 7.5–9.5).
12. Woven huarache flats that'll basically mold onto your feet so you can be as comfy as physically possible. Boho chic and comfortable to wear all day??? Time to add to cart.
Macarena Collection / Etsy
Macarena Collection is a small business based in Buena Park, California! All of the shoes are handmade by Mexican artisans. Since they only make whole sizes, they suggest sizing down if you're in between as the shoes will stretch and mold to your feet as you wear them.
Get them from Macarena Collection on Etsy for $46.49 (originally $61.99, available in sizes 5–10).
13. A pair of pointed-toe mules you can simply slip on to achieve that Jess Day vibe you've always strived for. These are incredibly sophisticated while staying incredibly comfortable — perfection? I certainly think so.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review:"I was so happy to find stylish shoes to fit my small feet! Size 5. That is not an easy feat these days. I love the shoes. When I first put them on, I did not think they were going to be comfortable. However, after I had worn them for just a short while, I realized they were actually very very comfortable. They are also not smooth on the bottom but have a sole that has slight ridges, and therefore are not slippery, which you find with some flats. I purchased the brown, which is a really pretty color and goes well with so many styles. I will definitely be purchasing additional pairs in different colors." — Karen Hulshouser
Get them from Amazon for $36.97+ (available in sizes 5–12 and five colors and patterns).
14. Or some bow mules to add a cutesy twist to your brunch look — because that adorable dress deserves an equally adorable pair of shoes to match. Plus, they're so comfy you can wear them all throughout the mall with your friends afterward, no problem.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review:"Second pair of these mules (bought the mustard-colored ones first) and they are just as cute and comfortable as the first pair! I have a wider bridge so I was worried about these being too tight or snug but they are perfect! Will be buying in more colors, can't beat the price either!" — KG
Get them from Amazon for $18.99+ (available in sizes 5–11 and in four colors).
15.
Reebok Women's Club C 85 vintage sneakers because your Gen Z cousin has been clowning you over not owning a pair of classic white sneakers for the last six months. These have made an ultimate comeback since their last height back in the '90s — because they literally match everything! Sneakers are not just for the sporty anymore — you can pair these with leggings or dresses for all-day comfort!
www.amazon.com
Promising review:"Love these shoes! I saw them in store at Urban Outfitters, but they didn't have my size. Obviously, I turned to Amazon because what doesn't this site sell, and lo and behold, y'all had it. I try to pair these with almost every outfit because they're so comfy and stylish! Recently went to Philly, where I had to walk everywhere because we didn't rent a car and these were the only pair of shoes I brought (I travel light). These didn't cramp up my feet at all as I walked over seven hours daily over the course of five days. Definitely recommend!" — Alli J
Get them from Amazon for $51.32+ (available in 5–11 and six colors and styles).
16. Naturalizer slingbacks with a teensy tiny heel and classic pointed toe so you can look oh-so-elegant during work and date nights while staying as comfortable as possible. They're made of leather and have a nonslip outsole, so you can get ready to break these out for every one of your outings.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review:"With all my foot problems, I was resigned to only wearing sneakers with orthotics and sandals. I am happy to say these shoes are buttery soft and comfortable. I got the wide fit and am searching for the next cute pair to purchase. They are pricey, so I have to pace myself, but so worth it!" — Vivian
Get them from Amazon for $31.19+ (available in sizes 4—13, narrow, wide, and in 19 colors).
17. Platform sneakers if you find yourself most comfortable with a bit of height but still crave the casual sneaker look. They've got durable, anti-slip soles and cushioned insoles — all while being incredibly stylish!
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review:"I've never been much of a sneaker person except for when working out, but I've seen this style all over social media and I really liked them. I waited months before finally ordering these and now I'm kicking myself for doing so! They are not gym shoes, but rather trendy athleisure shoes, and I'm all about comfy and cute." — Kerbear74
Get them from Amazon for $27.16+ (available in sizes 5.5–11 and in 20 colors).
18. Tioseban sneakers you can basically slip on like a pair of socks to make it feel like you're wearing nothing at all on your feet. These have a memory sole insole, and the best part?? The day they get dirty, you can simply toss them into the washing machine!
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Sizing up a half size if you have wide feet is recommended.
Promising review:"I like these shoes so much I bought two pairs. My feet are very narrow, and I have trouble finding shoes that fit without coming off my heels. These have the comfort band that makes them very comfortable." — Jane from MA
Get them from Amazon for $19.99+ (available in sizes 5–13, wide, and in 32 colors).