‘Freedom is subject to restriction': Allahabad HC raps Rahul Gandhi for ‘Chinese soldiers beating up Indian Army' remark
The Allahabad High Court dismissed Rahul Gandhi's plea challenging a summons issued by a Lucknow court in a defamation case concerning his alleged derogatory remarks against the Indian Army during the 2022 Bharat Jodo Yatra.
Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Alok Verma had directed Gandhi to appear for hearing on March 24 in the defamation case filed against him. Challenging this, Rahul had moved the High Court.
The complaint was filed by retired Border Roads Organisation Director Uday Shankar Srivastava, whose rank is equivalent to an Army Colonel.
He claimed Rahul Gandhi's statements on 16 December 2022, alleging that 'Chinese soldiers are beating up Indian Army personnel in Arunachal Pradesh,' were derogatory and defamatory towards the Indian military forces.
Rejecting Rahul Gandhi's argument that the complainant was not an Army officer and that he had not defamed him personally, the Allahabad High Court noted that under Section 199(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code, a person other than the direct victim can be considered an 'aggrieved person' if affected by the offence.
Since Srivastava expressed deep respect for the Army and was personally hurt by the remarks, he qualified to file the complaint.
The Allahabad High Court held:
'The trial Court has rightly arrived at the decision to summon the applicant to face trial for the offence under Section 500 IPC after taking into consideration all the relevant facts and circumstances of the case and after satisfying himself that a prima facie case for trial of the applicant is made out.' as reported by Bar and Bench.
The court further clarified that at this preliminary stage, it was unnecessary to examine the merits of the competing claims, as that responsibility lies with the trial court. Consequently, the plea was dismissed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
14 minutes ago
- India Today
Bangladeshi man tries to break glass at Kolkata airport terminal, detained
A 25-year-old Bangladeshi man attempted to break the glass of the International Transit Terminal at Kolkata's Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose International (NSCBI) Airport on Friday, creating a brief moment of chaos before being Mohammad Ashraful from Narayanganj, Bangladesh, arrived in Kolkata from Singapore on an Indigo flight in the afternoon. He was scheduled to board a connecting flight to Dhaka. However, while waiting in the International Transit Lounge, Ashraful suddenly attempted to break the glass wall of the terminal and exit the airport. advertisementThe Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) personnel quickly detained him and began questioning him. During the interrogation, Ashraful reportedly made several incoherent remarks, raising suspicion about his mental state and motives. The CISF later handed him over to the NSCBI Airport Police Station. That evening, Bidhan Nagar Police officially arrested confirmed that Ashraful had been living and working in Singapore. Further investigation is underway to determine the reason behind his Tuesday, the anti-rowdy squad of Kolkata Police arrested a Bangladeshi woman for illegally residing in India. The accused has been identified as Shanta Pal (28), a resident of Barisal in Bangladesh. She was arrested from her rented apartment in the Jadavpur area. Two Aadhaar cards, a voter card and a ration card have also been recovered from a prolonged search at her rented place, several Bangladeshi passports issued in her name, an employee card of Regent Airways (Bangladesh), an admit card of secondary education in Dhaka, two Aadhar cards registered in different addresses, an Indian voter/Epic card and Ration card, all of different addresses were found and seized.- EndsTrending Reel IN THIS STORY#Kolkata#West Bengal
India Today
14 minutes ago
- India Today
May consider dividends to citizens: Trump on tariff revenue disbursal plans
The day the 25 per cent US tariffs on Indian imports came into effect, President Donald Trump said he might consider extending the "dividends" earned through the levies imposed on America's trade partners to its citizens, news agency Reuters reported on the Trump tariff tirade, while most European Union member countries and the UK were hit with 15 per cent levies, Japan with 10 per cent, and South Korea with just 5 per cent, India saw a 25 per cent blanket rate imposed on its products imported by the US. The US cited exponentially high tariffs by India on American products behind its Trump imposed a 35 per cent duty on many goods from Canada, 50 per cent on Brazil, 39 per cent on Switzerland and 20 per cent on Taiwan. Notably, Trump has signed a new executive order that imposes fresh import tariffs on goods from 69 countries and the European Union, which will come into effect on August per the order, Syria tops the list of highest tariffs at 41 per cent, followed by Laos and Myanmar at 40 per cent, and Iraq and Serbia at 35 per cent. Other countries such as Libya and Algeria will now face a 30 per cent China, against whom Trump once ordered tariffs as high as a whopping 145 per cent, is still negotiating with the US, with American officials saying that they are looking at an imminent trade deal. "But it is not 100 per cent done," US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC move is part of Trump's push for what he describes as more "fair and reciprocal" trade relationships. The White House said that some countries had failed to meet US expectations during trade talks, leading to these new Trump's tariff move and the deadline, global stock markets witnessed a slump as investors panicked, fearing a global supply chain disruption and the outcome of their talks with who had grown accustomed to Trump's frequent trade threats may now be facing a reality check, as broad tariffs on numerous countries have taken effect just as the deadline to negotiate trade agreements with the US passed without resolution.- EndsTune InMust Watch
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
14 minutes ago
- First Post
'Avoid deserted areas': Indian embassy in Ireland issues safety advisory amid rising racist attacks
The advisory by the Indian embassy in Ireland comes in the wake of several reported incidents, including a brutal assault on a 40-year-old Indian man in Tallaght. read more Following a troubling surge in physical assaults targeting Indian citizens, the Indian Embassy in Ireland has issued a public advisory urging its nationals to prioritise personal safety. The advisory, shared via a post on X, specifically recommends avoiding isolated areas, particularly during late or unusual hours, and taking reasonable precautions to ensure personal security. Embassy issues statement The Embassy's statement highlighted the growing concern: 'There has been an increase in the instances of physical attacks reported against Indian citizens in Ireland recently. The Embassy is in touch with the authorities concerned of Ireland in this regard. At the same time, all Indian citizens in Ireland are advised to take reasonable precautions for their personal security and avoid deserted areas, especially in odd hours.' To support its community, the Embassy provided emergency contact details: Phone: 08994 23734 Email: Racist attacks on Indians The advisory comes in the wake of several reported incidents, including a brutal assault on a 40-year-old Indian man in Tallaght. Jennifer Murray, an Irish woman who assisted the victim, described the attack in a video posted on July 20, noting its apparent racial motivation. She stated, 'At least four Indian men and another man have been facially stabbed by this gang of teenagers in the last four days in Tallaght. How many of you knew that or saw it on the news? (sic)' Murray added that the victim required a brain scan and was left 'completely scared for life.' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD In another incident, Santosh Yadav, a 32-year-old man of Indian origin, was attacked near his Dublin apartment last Sunday. The assault, carried out by six teenagers, left Yadav with a fractured cheekbone and multiple injuries. He echoed concerns about a rising tide of racist attacks targeting Indians across Dublin. Migrant advocacy groups have amplified these concerns, pointing to systemic issues in addressing hate crimes. Teresa Buczkowska, CEO of the Immigrant Council of Ireland, noted that while the Indian community appears to be a specific target, such attacks are not exclusive to them. She criticised the lack of adequate training for Irish police, which has created barriers for victims attempting to report hate crimes, exacerbating the challenges faced by affected communities.
