Judges' recommendation to hike personal injury awards will not be implemented by the government
The recommendation to increase personal injury payouts by 17% came earlier this year from the Judicial Council, with the rationale being to raise payouts in line with inflation.
The issue was raised today during Leaders' Questions in the Dáil by Social Democrats acting leader Cian O'Callaghan, who asked the Taoiseach for clarity.
O'Callaghan said the proposed changes are 'reckless' and would lead to increased insurance premiums for people, sports clubs and small businesses.
He argued that Ireland already has much higher personal injury awards than other countries, stating that they can be four times higher than in the UK.
Advertisement
In response, Taoiseach Micheál Martin told O'Callaghan: 'Don't believe everything you read in the newspapers'.
He said the Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan will be laying the recommendations of the Judicial Council before the Oireachtas, but that he will not be seeking their approval.
O'Callaghan said he welcomed this clarification from the Taoiseach.
The Taoiseach then said that there will be implications for the Personal Injuries Assessment Board due to the decision not to implement the recommendations.
He said this could lead to consequences in the courts, and in cases, and may ultimately undermine the work of the assessment board.
'So we do need to reflect on this. I get the short-term politics…but we need as an Oireachtas to deal with this more soberly,' he said.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
a day ago
- Agriland
Planning guidelines for biomethane plants a 'key priority'
The development of centralised planning guidelines for biomethane plants to support local authorities is a "key priority", according to government. Minister of State Marian Harkin, speaking in the Dáil on behalf of government recently, said that the "urgent need" for the introduction of these guidelines for suitable locations for biomethane plants is recognised. "Priority deliverables under the National Biomethane Strategy include actions which will see the development of planning guidelines to support local authorities when assessing anaerobic digestion (AD) plants with planning applications and a review of resourcing requirements of key government agencies to support development of the industry," the minister said. "We need a clear understanding of AD technology and consistency of approach by our planning authorities when they are assessing AD projects to improve our planning and permitting processes." These planning guidelines will be developed by the biomethane implementation group, comprised of relevant key government departments and agencies, as well as sectoral representatives. Minister Harkin has said that while a timeline cannot be provided, guidelines are already being developed by the biomethane implementation group. Labour TD Alan Kelly has said it is "absolutely incredible that in 2025, we do not have planning guidelines or regulations regarding this technology". "I actually believe in these renewables and in this whole technology but given that we are going to have between 200 and 250 of these plants all over the country, we have to start asking serious questions about why we have not got regulations on this before we start doing it," deputy Kelly said. "However, we also need to ensure communities understand and have rules around which they can engage on where these plants are going to be put in place, and that is not happening. "The locations where some of these plants have been proposed are being fought across the country because there is a lack of public and community engagement. "We really need to look at how we are going to ensure there is a system in place for the regulation and planning of these." He added that there needs to be a plan that outlines spatially and geographically where Ireland needs to put all of these plants, along with "what size we need to put in each place, what tariff will be in place to make it economically viable, and what type of waste is going into all of these plants". "We need to do so through a regulatory framework that exists, an economic framework that is viable and planning guidelines," he said. Minister of State Marian Harkin said that biomethane will play a "crucial role" in Ireland reaching its decarbonisation targets and security of energy supply. "Ireland is uniquely positioned to develop a sustainable biomethane sector due to the nature of the agricultural sector in our country," she said. "Government has committed to deliver up to 5.7 TWh of indigenously-produced biomethane per annum by 2030. "The national biomethane strategy is Ireland's first major policy statement on biomethane and is an important milestone in the development of this indigenous sector." Harkin said it is recognised that these AD plants are "significant infrastructure and require a full planning and permitting process to ensure consideration of a range of factors". "These include location, visual impact, land zoning plans, ecology, economies," she said. "As such, a key priority is the development of centralised planning guidelines for AD plants to support our local authorities. When finalised, these will be available on the biomethane information hub."
Agriland
a day ago
- Agriland
Govt to Invest E3 5 Billion Into Irelands Electricity Infrastructure
The government has announced a landmark €3.5 billion investment in Ireland's electricity grid infrastructure, as part of the National Development Plan. The Taoiseach, Micheál Martin published the plan yesterday (July 22), which will see a total investment of €275.4 billion from 2026 to 2035. As part of the investment, €1.5 billion will be allocated to ESB Networks, and €2 billion will be allocated to EirGrid. This will enable both companies to significantly increase capital investment to expand Ireland's onshore and offshore electricity transmission, and distribution network infrastructure. According to the Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment the enhanced grid will be crucial to deliver on key commitments in the programme for government, including achieving 80% renewable electricity by 2030. This requires building 9GW of onshore wind, 8GW of solar power, and 5GW of offshore wind in construction by 2030 – targets that are only possible with a world-class electricity network. The department claims that the scale of investment is reflective of expenditure required in most European countries as they seek to increase connections of renewable energy, interconnect with neighbouring countries, and provide reliable networks for the increased electrification of the energy system. The Minister for Climate, Energy and the Environment, Darragh O'Brien said: "This €3.5 billion investment is about building the energy infrastructure that Ireland needs for the future. "It's about ensuring every home and business has a reliable and secure source of electricity, creating thousands of jobs, and making Ireland a more attractive place for international companies to invest and grow." "A modern, resilient electricity grid is the backbone of everything we want to achieve — from powering the 300,000 new homes we've committed to build by 2030, to attracting the foreign investment that creates jobs in communities across Ireland," Minister O'Brien added. Meanwhile, the Minister of State with responsibility for the Marine, Timmy Dooley believes that Ireland's offshore energy potential is "enormous". "Our Atlantic coastline offers some of the best offshore wind resources in the world, and with the right infrastructure, we can transform Ireland from an energy importer to an energy exporter," he said.
Agriland
a day ago
- Agriland
Heydon: 'Impactful measures' on water quality being developed for next NAP
Government officials are engaging with members of the the Agriculture Water Quality Working Group to "develop a list of impactful measures from a water quality perspective" for the next Nitrates Action Programme. That is according to the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon, who has confirmed that officials from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage are currently working on the next NAP, which is due to apply from January 2026. Minister Heydon told the Dáil yesterday (Thursday, July 3) that Ireland's current NAP "introduced significant changes and is providing the strongest protections to date nationally for water quality from an agricultural perspective". However he was asked by the Cork North-Central TD, Pádraig O'Sullivan, if he was satisfied that the 6th NAP "would ensure no further erosion of the maximum organic manure limits from 220 kg N/ha". According to Minister Heydon the government has a twin objective of "improving water quality and retaining Ireland's nitrates derogation post-2025". "I am confident a combination of current and future measures under the NAP, combined with a continuation of the existing significant commitment and engagement by the entire agri-food sector will translate into improved water quality," the minister told Deputy O'Sullivan. Minister Heydon also told the Dáil that the latest water quality monitoring report from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), published this week, showed a "significant reduction in nitrates levels in our rivers last year". The EPA's 'Water Quality Monitoring Report on Nitrogen and Phosphorous Concentrations in Irish Waters 2024' provides an update on the results of water quality monitoring to support the assessment of the impact of the nitrates derogation on Irish waters. However in the report the agency warned that 'nitrate concentrations remain too high in many parts of the country'. The EPA also acknowledged that there was a 10% national reduction in river nitrate concentrations during 2024, 'with reductions observed in all regions'. According to its analysis overall nitrogen levels in rivers also reduced nationally in 2024 compared to 2023. Minister Heydon has warned that "having a robust NAP in place, is an essential component in our case to justify continuation of our nitrates derogation". He said: "Along with my colleagues in government, I will continue to engage over the coming months with the objective of giving the commission the assurances it needs to justify granting a continuation of our nitrates derogation. "Ultimately the European Commission will decide the conditionality attached to that derogation, including that maximum permitted stocking rates. "However, in accordance with the Programme for Government, the government will continue doing everything in its power to make the case at EU level to secure the best outcome post-2025."
