Maryland teacher claims in lawsuit he was falsely branded ‘racist' over seating chart dispute
Dan Engler, a former health and English teacher and head coach of the rowing team at Bethesda-Chevy Chase High School (B-CC) in Montgomery County, filed a lawsuit against Principal Shelton L. Mooney and the Montgomery County Public School Board, accusing them of defamation and violating school policy in their handling of a February 2023 classroom incident.
According to the complaint, two students in Engler's first-period health class asked to sit next to their friends instead of in their assigned seats.
Engler, citing the importance of using a seating chart to learn student names and avoid confusion, asked the students — who are Black — to return to their assigned seats. The students refused and remained where they were.
Later that day, the students reported the interaction to the assistant principal, alleging Engler told them he would not be able to tell them apart from other students, believing this to be a racial comment.
4 Dan Engler is a former health and English teacher and head coach of the rowing team at Bethesda-Chevy Chase High School (B-CC) in Montgomery County.
Dan Engler / Facebook
'Part of the misunderstanding may have stemmed from an incident in Engler's English class the previous spring,' his attorney wrote in the opposition to the defendants' motion for summary judgment.
The filing explained that Engler had read a quote from Muhammad Ali containing a racial slur, which offended some students. Engler apologized, and an investigation determined it was not a 'hate bias incident.' The students involved in the health class had reportedly heard about the English class incident and had previously asked not to be placed in Engler's class, believing him to be racist.
Following the students' report, Principal Mooney was instructed by his superiors to follow the 'hate bias incident' protocol. The next day, he informed Engler that he would be placed on paid administrative leave for one day while the incident was under investigation.
4 Engler, citing the importance of using a seating chart to learn student names and avoid confusion, asked the students — who are Black — to return to their assigned seats. The students refused and remained in place.
Dan Engler / Facebook
Two days after the incident, Mooney sent a community-wide email to parents, teachers, staff and students reporting that a 'hate bias incident' had occurred at the school.
The message said that 'several African American students' were told by a teacher that he was 'unable to distinguish them from other African American students' in the classroom and that the Montgomery County Police Department had been notified as an internal investigation was ongoing.
'Let me be clear, discrimination of any kind must not be tolerated,' Mooney wrote before citing the school policy against 'insensitivity, disrespect, bias, verbal abuse, harassment, bullying, physical violence or illegal discrimination toward any person.'
Although Engler was not named in the email, he said he was quickly identified by students, parents and colleagues. He maintains that he did not make the statement attributed to him in the letter and he 'did not do anything that could reasonably be classified as a 'hate bias incident.''
4 Engler is suing Principal Shelton L. Mooney and the Montgomery County Public School Board.
Shelton Mooney / Linkedin
The complaint alleges that Engler had his 'reputation destroyed by the malicious acts of B-CC's Principal, Defendant Shelton L. Mooney, who falsely accused Engler of racism in a thoughtless, half-baked community-wide email.'
The lawsuit further claims that Mooney and the school board violated MCPS policies and procedures by sending the community-wide email before an investigation was completed and that they refused to issue a retraction or apology.
When Engler returned to work the following week, Mooney allegedly 'refused to discuss the matter' with Engler. Upon returning to his classroom, Engler said he was 'upset' to find MCPS and B-CC staff holding a 'restorative justice' circle in his classroom that they excluded him from joining.
Engler told Fox News Digital that the experience took a heavy toll on his mental health. The same day, he went on disability leave for a year and a half before resuming teaching at another school in the district.
4 Following the students' report, Principal Mooney was instructed by his superiors to follow the 'hate bias incident' protocol.
Google St View
'I love teaching. I love coaching,' he said. 'And I really care a great deal about the relationships I have with those kids and helping them learn how to become adults in the best way possible. To lose the confidence of the kids, the trust of the kids, based on what the kids' leadership had to say about me, was devastating. It was identity stealing.'
According to the complaint, Engler ultimately faced no disciplinary action and the defendants' investigation allegedly failed to find sufficient evidence that the classroom incident constituted a 'hate bias incident.'
'However, the damage to Engler had already been done. Mooney's malicious email falsely branded Engler a racist, destroying his reputation in the B-CC community, causing him deep emotional distress, making it impossible to continue teaching at B-CC, and causing the loss of his position as Head Coach of the B-CC Rowing Team,' it continued.
Engler criticized the school's handling of the incident as 'a tremendous opportunity for virtue signaling.'
'It really was, and I'm paying the price,' he told Fox News Digital. Engler said his reputation has been damaged, and the legal fight has cost his family over $300,000.
After attempting to resolve the dispute through administrative proceedings, Engler filed a lawsuit in Montgomery County Circuit Court in August 2023.
Engler's case proceeded to trial on Monday.
Fox News Digital reached out multiple times to the lawyers for the defendants on the allegations and did not receive a response. The MCPS Board of Education said it was unable to comment on pending litigation. Mooney did not return a request for comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
2 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
Today in History: B-25 bomber crashes into Empire State Building
Today is Monday, July 28, the 209th day of 2025. There are 156 days left in the year. Today in history: On July 28, 1945, A U.S. Army B-25 bomber crashed into the 79th floor of New York's Empire State Building, the world's tallest structure at the time, killing 14 people. Also on this date: In 1794, Maximilien Robespierre and Louis Antoine de Saint-Just were executed by guillotine during the French Revolution. In 1914, World War I began as Austria-Hungary declared war on Serbia. In 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson announced he was increasing the number of American troops in South Vietnam from 75,000 to 125,000. In 1976, an earthquake devastated northern China, killing at least 242,000 people, according to an official estimate. In 1984, the Los Angeles Summer Olympics officially opened; 14 Eastern Bloc countries, led by the Soviet Union, boycotted the Games. In 1995, a jury in Union, South Carolina, rejected the death penalty for Susan Smith, sentencing her to life in prison for drowning her two young sons (Smith will be eligible for parole in November 2024). In 1996, 8,000 year-old human skeletal remains (later referred to as Kennewick Man) were discovered in a bank of the Columbia River in Kennewick, Washington. In 2004, the Irish Republican Army formally announced an end to its armed campaign against British rule in Northern Ireland. In 2015, it was announced that Jonathan Pollard, the former U.S. Naval intelligence analyst who had spent nearly three decades in prison for spying for Israel, had been granted parole. In 2018, Pope Francis accepted the resignation of U.S. Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, the emeritus archbishop of Washington, D.C., following allegations of sexual abuse, including one involving an 11-year-old boy. Both died in April of 2025. In 2019, a gunman opened fire at a popular garlic festival in Gilroy, California, killing three people, including a six-year-old boy and a 13-year-old girl, and wounding 17 others before taking his own life. Today's Birthdays: Music conductor Riccardo Muti is 84. Former Senator and NBA Hall of Famer Bill Bradley is 82. 'Garfield' creator Jim Davis is 80. TV producer Dick Ebersol is 78. Actor Sally Struthers is 78. Architect Santiago Calatrava is 74. CBS TV journalist Scott Pelley is 68. Actor Lori Loughlin is 61. Jazz musician-producer Delfeayo Marsalis is 60. UFC president Dana White is 56. Actor Elizabeth Berkley is 53. Basketball Hall of Famer Manu Ginobili is 48. Actor John David Washington is 41. Actor Dustin Milligan is 40. Rapper Soulja Boy is 35. England soccer star Harry Kane is 32. Pop/rock singer Cher Lloyd is 32. Golfer Nelly Korda is 27.
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
Ryanair passenger drops to her knees in tears after being denied boarding over large luggage
A Ryanair passenger was brought to tears after being denied boarding her flight because her luggage was too big. A video shows a female passenger attempting to fit her luggage into a holdall at Sofia Airport in Bulgaria on July 24, according to The Sun. When it became apparent that her bag wouldn't fit, the staff explained to her that she would need to pay for extra baggage, which she refused — insisting that she could get it to fit. 4 A female Ryanair passenger was left sobbing on her knees after being banned from boarding her flight. Facebook / Nikolay Stefanov The unnamed passenger is seen trying to force her bag to fit by slamming and eventually getting it to fit. Despite her successful attempt to fit the bag, staff still refused to let her board the plane. She begins to break down in tears as she pleads with a member of the border police to allow her on the flight while dozens of other passengers watch on from behind a glass door that separates them from the weeping woman. Still determined to board, she started banging on the door and asking for help as her pleas grew louder and more staff quickly surrounded her. Exhausted from her efforts, the woman is seen dropping to her knees while tears stream down her face. 4 Footage shows her trying to force her bag into the luggage rack by slamming it in after being told she had to pay extra. Facebook / Nikolay Stefanov Nikolay Stefanov, the witness who recorded the distressing ordeal, said the situation 'escalated quickly.' 'She was pleading with us not to leave, but we were threatened that the entire flight would be canceled if we didn't get on the bus, so passengers became frightened and left,' he said. Stefanov said that fellow passengers were left in shock by how the staff were treating her with no compassion, as they denied her permission to board the flight due to her large luggage. The viral video garnered the attention of Bulgaria's parliament, prompting Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Transport Grozdan Karadjov to order an inspection of the airport's security cameras due to the employees' 'outrageous' behavior during the chaotic ordeal, according to the Bulgarian news outlet 4 Exhausted from her efforts, the woman is seen dropping to her knees while tears stream down her face. Facebook / Nikolay Stefanov Karadjov assured citizens that the leading ground operator would be identified and receive the 'highest fine' and a verbal warning following an investigation. Goldair Handling Bulgaria issued a statement in response to BNT News, insisting that their employees acted 'professionally and without any physical contact with the passenger.' 'All rules regarding passengers' baggage, its permissible size and the fees payable for baggage are determined solely, entirely and unilaterally by the airlines,' the handling company said. 4 Ryanair is 'aggressive about eliminating the scourge of passengers with excess baggage,' the airlines CEO said in a recent interview. AFP via Getty Images 'Goldair Handling Bulgaria OOD is solely obliged to monitor compliance with these rules by the airlines. This also applies to hand luggage, as Goldair Handling Bulgaria OOD is obliged to monitor the dimensions of this baggage and collect excess baggage fees. [Staff] acted professionally and without any physical contact with the passenger.' The shocking viral video comes as Ryanair's Michael O'Leary confirmed earlier this month that its agents who identify and charge for oversized bags receive a bonus of around 1.50 euros per bag (or $1.75). Ryanair is 'aggressive about eliminating the scourge of passengers with excess baggage,' the CEO told RTÉ's Morning Ireland, adding that his company is 'thinking of increasing' the agent commission. 'We're flying largely full flights, about half the passengers can bring two bags and the other half can only bring one – because that's all that fits in the plane,' O'Leary said. He is the only airline CEO to have commented on agent commissions.
Indianapolis Star
7 hours ago
- Indianapolis Star
Autographed Patrick Mahomes, Tom Brady jerseys faked in Westfield sports memorabilia scam
A woman in North Carolina tipped off Westfield police in February to a possible sports memorabilia scam being run in the town. That woman, who police didn't name, reported she had received fraudulent merchandise from Mister Mancave, LLC, a company run by a 45-year-old Westfield man named Brett Lemieux. What no one could have known at the time was just how massive the counterfeit ring Lemieux was running would allegedly be. Among the big names Lemieux allegedly made his fortune on — which Lemieux claimed in a Facebook confession was $350 million – were Tom Brady, Kobe Bryant, Russell Wilson, Patrick Mahomes and Aaron Judge. After the woman's tip, Westfield police began a 5-month investigation into Mister Mancave, a business allegedly selling counterfeit autographed sports memorabilia through its online store and other platforms. As the case progressed, additional victims of Lemieux were found, each claiming to have purchased autographed memorabilia from Mister Mancave that was later determined to be counterfeit, Westfield police said in its latest public statement on the case. On July 15, police executed a search warrant at the Mister Mancave business location in connection with the suspected fraudulent scheme. The following day, the investigation extended to a residence in the 300 block of Hoover Street. "Upon arrival at the residence, officers discovered an individual deceased from an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound," the statement says. "That individual has been identified as Brett Lemieux, 45, of Westfield, the founder of Mister Mancave LLC and the primary suspect in this case." Police say they collected "a significant quantity of evidence during the searches, including documentation and items related to the alleged counterfeit operation. Investigators say they are aware of a social media post made by Lemieux shortly before his death in which he gave specific details about how he pulled off what he said was a crime that kept him awake at night. "I always took it as a challenge. I spent sleepless nights planning what items to counterfeit next," he wrote. Lemieux said he would illegally gain access to reputable sports memorabilia company's holograms, a security feature used to authenticate autographs and other collectible items with a serial number. Among the companies he replicated were TriStar Sports, Mounted Memories, Steiner Sports, Fanatics and Mill Creek Sports, Lemieux said in his post. He would then replicate items, using an autopen, which copies signatures, to forge autographs and then sell signed items – jerseys, footballs, baseball bats, photographs – by the thousands, Lemieux wrote. One of the biggest items Lemieux replicated were Brady jerseys, said those in the sports memorabilia industry. "We had started seeing these really weird looking Tom Brady (jerseys) and we kept saying, 'These don't look right. There's something really off here,'" Steve Grad told IndyStar. Grad appears as an expert on the television show "Pawn Stars" and is with Beckett Authentication Services, a third-party company in Plano, Texas, that authenticates autographs. "Well, it turns out, we were right," Grad said. "He did this with Aaron Judge. He did this with anybody you could really think of, Derek Jeter. These are all really big names." In his Facebook post, Lemieux named other individuals who may have been involved in the counterfeit scheme, which police said they are aware of. "This will require additional time to carefully review and investigate all evidence and leads," police said. "We are working with various authenticators for technical assistance and the authentication of all seized items." In its statement, Westfield police said the department "acknowledges that any loss of life is a tragedy, and we extend our condolences to Mr. Lemieux's family and friends during this difficult time." Anyone with information related to the case should contact Detective Don Bennett of the Westfield Police Department at dbennett@
