Hong Kong appeal court rejects early release for first security law challenger
domestic national security law has lost an appeal to overturn a decision barring his early release from prison.
Advertisement
The Court of Appeal ruled in a judgment delivered on Tuesday that the Correctional Services Department was not obliged to consider granting an early discharge to Adam Ma Chun-man after he was 'lawfully' sentenced to a term of imprisonment for inciting secession.
The three presiding judges stressed that any sentencing reduction was discretionary and that denying a prisoner's early release would not violate his right to liberty.
The court also rejected the appellant's contention that the definition of national security was 'inherently vague' and prone to 'subjective value judgment', saying a broad definition offered 'flexibility' to allow the notion to 'evolve with time and adapt to changing realities'.
'It is broadly framed for good reasons,' Chief Judge of the High Court Jeremy Poon Shiu-chor, the judgment's author, wrote.
Advertisement
'Although it is broadly framed, the definition has a sufficiently and clearly formulated core to enable a person, with advice if necessary, to understand what national security covers and to regulate his conduct accordingly.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong education chief puts onus on schools amid competition for students
Hong Kong's education minister has said that schools struggling with insufficient student enrolment must evaluate their own performance in meeting parents' expectations rather than relying on government intervention. Advertisement Secretary for Education Christine Choi Yuk-lin also said the education sector should not insist on keeping the existing number of schools and emphasised a need for 'metabolism' to ensure its vitality. In an interview with local media last Friday, she said that the recent policy allowing schools that managed to operate four Form One classes to apply to run one more in the coming academic year was to 'address parents' needs and choice'. Choi urged those schools with insufficient enrolment to reflect on their own performance, instead of simply hindering the development of more popular institutions. 'Schools finding it difficult to admit students throughout many years could not address parents' and students' needs. Why do they define themselves as weak schools and only ask authorities to take care of them? It should not be like this,' she said. Advertisement 'Have they thought about the needs of the parents in their districts? What are the students' needs and what could they provide for them and get their votes for the schools?'
South China Morning Post
3 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
With bold reform, Hong Kong can embark on new chapter with confidence
The 28th anniversary of Hong Kong's return to China was marked yesterday with ceremony, celebration and much-needed contemplation of the challenges that lie ahead. Hong Kong is at a critical stage of its development. The city has steadily emerged from the anti-government protests of 2019 and the pandemic. A new chapter has begun. Now, it is about seizing opportunities. The word on everyone's lips is reform. Beijing's liaison office chief, Zhou Ji, set the tone , calling on the city to move with the times, focus on people's needs and unleash potential with new ideas. Innovative reform is required, he said. Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu reiterated the theme yesterday. He set out achievements made in his first three years in office, including changing the culture of government to one which is 'result-oriented', passing domestic national security laws, tackling the housing shortage and taking steps to revive the economy. Credit is due for the work done. But Hong Kong cannot afford to rest on its laurels. High expectations have been set. With two years of this administration left, Lee must deliver. Bold measures are needed. The structure of the government, inherited from the British, is ripe for reform. Lee has rightly advocated a new accountability system for civil servants. But further and more far-reaching change is needed to boost the government's efficiency.
South China Morning Post
3 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong public universities to seek more top-notch overseas students: minister
Hong Kong's public universities will push to enrol more 'quality overseas students' to ensure greater diversity on campuses, a minister has said, after mainland Chinese candidates made up more than 70 per cent of their first-year, non-local undergraduates in the 2024-25 academic year. Secretary for Education Christine Choi Yuk-lin also said that four local universities had sent 36 offers to those affected by the United States' recent policy changes for international students, noting they had received about 850 related inquiries. In an interview with local media outlets last Friday, she said the non-local student admission quotas for the city's eight publicly funded universities, which are currently capped at 40 per cent and total about 30,000 places, could be gradually increased. She said that local authorities would negotiate with China's Ministry of Education, adding that the 40 per cent threshold was 'not a limit'. 'In the long run, if our supporting facilities are ready and all admission spots are full, similar to the keen competition this year, we will look at the situation and move forward step by step,' she said. Choi said there was no time frame for increasing the proportion of non-local students at public universities, noting the institutions had yet to use up the current quota.
