LDP's endorsement of Mio Sugita dismays even 'benefactor' after human rights breaches
Japan's legal authorities have recognized statements by Sugita as human rights violations, yet it was recently reported that for some reason she has moved to deny that very recognition, despite previously frankly accepting it in a contribution to a monthly magazine.
Sugita's entry into politics was facilitated by a "benefactor" -- former lower house member Yoshimi Watanabe, 73, who retired three years ago.
Watanabe rose as a young theorist in the LDP, and after serving as minister for administrative reform, he went on to found the now-defunct Your Party in 2009, playing a key role in the "third pole" boom represented by alternative political forces.
Sugita's first book, "Nadeshiko Fukkatsu" (The return of Nadeshiko), published in 2014, mentions that she joined the Your Party while working at the Nishinomiya Municipal Government in Hyogo Prefecture, after being approached by Watanabe.
Watanabe recalls, "The first time we met was around 2007. I remember she was engaged in activities aligned with my aspirations for civil service reform."
At the time there was a "super civil servant" boom, which called for reform in the mindset of public workers. Sugita herself held study sessions under the name "Nishinomiya super civil servant school" and gave lectures nationwide. These activities apparently caught Watanabe's eye.
"That's why I endorsed her as the head of the Your Party's Hyogo No. 6 electoral district branch. However, although we transferred party subsidies, it was discovered that she was not active at all, so I issued a stern warning," Watanabe recalls.
In the 2012 lower house election, Sugita left her "benefactor" and was elected for the first time as a representative of the former Japan Restoration Party, the predecessor to today's Nippon Ishin (the Japan Innovation Party). After spending time in the short-lived Party for Future Generations, Sugita joined the LDP in 2017 at the invitation of then Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. But soon after she put on her Diet members badge, she came under scrutiny for her discriminatory and exclusionary remarks and behavior.
Below are a few examples of these remarks:
"Gender equality is an immoral delusion and can never be realized" (comment made during a lower house plenary session, Oct. 31, 2014). "LGBT couples have no 'productivity'" (contribution to monthly magazine Shincho 45's August 2018 issue). Statues of so-called comfort women conveying the issue of wartime sexual violence "should be blown up one by one" (dialogue book "'Rekishisen' wa Onnna no Tatakai" (History wars are a woman's battle), published in 2016). "Women can tell any number of lies" (LDP meeting, Sept. 25, 2020).
"The Your Party is a political party with no association with far-right ideology. At the time, Ms. Sugita seemed like a strongly reform-oriented, principled public servant. I think her remarks are a kind of outlandish outrage marketing. She was probably not good at steady election campaigning to begin with. I think she got a taste for the fact that her extreme statements would elicit certain reactions," Watanabe comments.
Indeed, Sugita proudly wrote in the aforementioned work "Nadeshiko Fukkatsu," "I got a sense of my role as a Diet member," when there was a stir over an internet video from the lower house budget committee in 2014 in which Sugita blatantly spoke of "China and South Korea, who are saying that if you shout a lie 100 times, it becomes the truth."
Watanabe sharply comments, "Ms. Sugita seems like a 'pseudo-conservative.' Pseudo-conservatives probably target internet right wingers for survival, but I think more people are seeing through their facade."
One statement in Sugita's long list of sexist, xenophobic remarks came in February 2016. On her blog and social media, she disparaged Koreans living in Japan and Ainu women who attended the U.N. Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women wearing traditional attire, stating, "Their mere presence is a disgrace to Japan."
In 2023, the Sapporo and Osaka legal affairs bureaus recognized her statements as human rights violations. However, since being endorsed by the LDP in March this year, Sugita has for some reason started claiming "It is incorrect that I was recognized for human rights violations," saying words to this effect after a party convention on March 9. This stance has been widely reported.
However, no media outlet has pointed out that in the January 2024 issue of the monthly magazine "Hanada," Sugita herself wrote, "In 2023, both the Sapporo and Osaka legal affairs bureaus recognized (my statements) as human rights violations." She also wrote, "There were four comments that were recognized as such." She disclosed in detail which posts were recognized as violations based on the bureaus' notification of their findings.
When confronted about her recent 180-degree turn from her own previous explanation, Sugita's side responded, "The videos on the official website have everything," but the videos do not provide any explanation on this matter.
Sugita's actions have already caused significant harm. Kazue Muta, a professor emeritus at the University of Osaka known for her research on feminism, is probably one of the biggest victims.
Sugita repeatedly defamed Muta on social media and other platforms from around 2018, falsely claiming there had been a "misuse of research funds" for studies supported by an education ministry-affiliated group via a grant-in-aid for scientific research between fiscal 2014 and 2017.
"The University of Osaka received protest calls from people who believed Ms. Sugita's statements. The university staff handled it calmly and did not inform me directly about the calls, but it caused them a significant burden," Muta said.
In a lawsuit Muta filed, a court found Sugita's conduct unlawful and ordered the legislator to pay compensation in a ruling. This was finalized in 2023.
"Ms. Sugita's actions are political interference in academia itself, similar to the problematic bill on (overhauling) the Science Council of Japan. My research was probably targeted because it included the comfort women issue, which Sugita claims is 'fabricated.'' If a man were to say, 'Comfort women were just prostitutes,' it could be perceived as misogynistic. But coming from Ms. Sugita, who is a woman, it could produce an atmosphere of acceptance with people pointing out, 'Look, even a woman is saying it.' I imagine she recognizes the role and position expected of her," Muta adds.
Many women who were made into comfort women were trafficked by contractors chosen by the Japanese military or deceived and illegally taken abroad under military control to be placed in so-called comfort stations. This process is referred to as forced abduction by experts.
"Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba also expressed 'strong discomfort' with Sugita's words and actions (in the March 21 upper house budget committee), which makes her endorsement all the more disappointing, if not absurd. I even think the bottom has fallen out of ethics," a disconcerted Muta says.
The bottom has fallen out. This sentiment was echoed by Mitsuhiro Kimura, the leader of Issuikai, a prominent ethnic nationalist group. From a nationalist standpoint, he fights against hate speech directed at foreign residents in Japan.
"Prime Minister Ishiba likely endorsed Sugita due to the situation within his party and the election strategy. But that represents a defeat of political ethics. The bottom has fallen out," Kimura comments.
I have interviewed Ishiba numerous times and heard him criticize the discriminatory and exclusionary climate that exists within some corners of the party.
Kimura adds, "It's fine to discuss various domestic and international issues. But Sugita's actions are not like that. Japanese people are inherently tolerant, but I don't feel that virtue at all. Recently, there have been too many politicians, both within the ruling and opposition camps, attacking foreigners and domestic minorities with ulterior motives like 'it will get votes' or 'I want to wear a (Diet member's) badge.' This issue goes beyond a single parliamentarian. I think the LDP might as well aim for the extreme right and rename itself the Japan Exclusion Party."
The upper house election is still ahead of us. Mr. Ishiba, how about rethinking your stance?
(Japanese original by Riki Yoshii, Opinion Editorial Department)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Mainichi
21 minutes ago
- The Mainichi
Editorial: Sanseito party must end its fear-mongering 'Japanese First' politics
Right-wing populist political party Sanseito campaigned on a "Japanese First" platform and significantly increased its contested seats from one to 14 in the July 20 House of Councillors election. This development has garnered international attention as an indication of Japan's rightward shift. The party advocates for caution in accepting foreigners, calling for a ban on land purchases by foreigners in principle and ending welfare benefits for them. These positions align with the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump, which is strengthening regulations on immigrants, as well as the rise of populist parties in Europe. Globalization has led to diminished international competitiveness of industries in developed countries, resulting in rising prices and low wages. Many people feel they have been left behind. Sanseito's appeal to "enrich Japanese people" resonated with voters anxious about the future, acting as a political home not only for conservatives who had previously backed the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) but also for unaffiliated voters. Sanseito's surge is closely linked to the historic defeat of the LDP and its ruling junior coalition partner Komeito. It reflects dissatisfaction with the established parties' failure to effectively address issues such as inequality and ease the burden on the middle class. However, Sanseito's pledges to reduce taxes and social insurance premiums could weaken the income redistribution system. It is questionable whether these measures will actually help reduce disparities and solve other problems. The party also pushes for making end-of-life care, including life-sustaining treatment, entirely self-funded. Careful debate is necessary as this is an issue of life or death. Sanseito also opposes the introduction of a selective separate surname system for married couples and same-sex marriage, and calls for a repeal of the LGBT understanding promotion law. These policies run counter to efforts toward gender equality and could diminish society's vitality. The draft for a new Japanese Constitution the party released in May omits many basic human rights guaranteed by the current Constitution, such as equality under the law and freedom of thought, conscience and expression. The slogan "Japanese First" will be interpreted as a divisive message that builds barriers based on nationality. There are concerns that such rhetoric will foster a climate of excluding the weak and promoting discrimination. With the ruling coalition having lost its majority in both chambers of the Diet, Sanseito says it will decide its stance on each policy individually, potentially giving it the casting vote. The party apparently aims to increase its seats further in the next House of Representatives election and seek to join the reins of government. The growing fragmentation of the political landscape is increasing political instability. Politicians must refrain from methods that stoke social anxiety and deepen divisions. The stance of building consensus by listening to diverse voices without falling into exclusionism is needed in politics.
Asahi Shimbun
21 minutes ago
- Asahi Shimbun
Ishiba denies reports he will resign, says he will focus on trade deal with the US
TOKYO--Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba denied reports he plans to announce his resignation over a historic defeat of his ruling party in a weekend election, saying instead he wanted to make sure a new tariff agreement with the United States is appropriately implemented. Ishiba has been under growing pressure to step down as his ruling Liberal Democratic Party and its junior coalition partner, Komeito, lost their majority in the 248-member upper house, the smaller and less powerful of Japan's two-chamber parliament on Sunday, shaking his grip on power and Japan's political stability. The loss means Ishiba's ruling coalition, which also lost a majority in the more powerful lower house in October, now lacks a majority in both houses of parliament, making it even more difficult for his government to achieve any policy goals and worsening Japan's political instability. Ishiba had announced his intention Monday to stay on to tackle pressing challenges, including tariff talks with the U.S., without creating a political vacuum, sparking calls from inside and outside his own party for a quick resignation to respond to the election results. With the tariff deal with the U.S. paving the way for his possible departure, Japanese media said he is expected to soon announce plans to step down in August. The Yomiuri newspaper, in an extra edition Wednesday, said Ishiba had decided to announce his resignation by the end of July after receiving a detailed report from his chief trade negotiator, Ryosei Akazawa, paving the way for a party leadership vote to choose his successor. Ishiba denied the report and said he wants to focus on the U.S. trade deal, which covers more than 4,000 goods affecting many Japanese producers and industries. Ishiba, who met party heavyweights and former prime ministers Taro Aso, Fumio Kishida and Yoshihide Suga on Wednesday at party headquarters, told reporters afterwards that they did not discuss his resignation or a new party leadership contest. They only discussed the election results, shared the sense of crisis and confirmed the need to avoid party discord, he said. Ishiba welcomed the trade agreement Wednesday, which places a 15% tax on Japanese cars and other goods imported into the U.S. from Japan, down from the initial 25%, saying it was a product of tough negotiations to protect the national interest and that it would help benefit both sides as they work together to create more jobs and investment. But Ishiba declined to comment on his possible move and only told reporters that he has to closely examine the trade deal first. In Sunday's election, voters frustrated with price increases exceeding the pace of wage hikes, especially younger people who have long felt ignored by the ruling government's focus on senior voters, rapidly turned to emerging conservative and rightwing populist parties, like the Democratic Party for the People and Sanseito. None of the opposition parties have shown interest in forming a full-fledged alliance with the governing coalition but they have said they are open to cooperating on policy.
an hour ago
Embattled Japan PM Ishiba to Decide His Fate Soon
Tokyo, July 23 (Jiji Press)--Embattled Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba indicated Wednesday that he will make a decision soon on whether to remain in office or step down, now that Japan and the United States have reached a tariff agreement. A senior official of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party said that Ishiba, also president of the LDP, is seen stepping down after a comprehensive review is made in August on the outcome of Sunday's House of Councillors election. On Wednesday afternoon, Ishiba met with Taro Aso, Yoshihide Suga and Fumio Kishida, all former prime ministers, at the LDP's headquarters. After the meeting, Ishiba told reporters that the four-way talks did not take up the issue of whether he will stay in office or resign. The four shared a "strong sense of crisis" now that the LDP-led ruling pair is short of a majority in both chambers of parliament, Ishiba said, quoting one of the participants as saying, "There should be no division in the party." In the closely watched election, the LDP and its coalition partner, Komeito, suffered a crushing defeat to lose their combined majority in the upper chamber. The ruling bloc lost its House of Representatives majority in last October's general election for the more powerful lower chamber. [Copyright The Jiji Press, Ltd.]
