Pride and Black Lives Matter flags ban in Florida: What to know about SB 100

Yahoo

13-02-2025

A potential ban on flags, including those depicting Pride, Palestine and Black Lives Matter, is back in the Florida Legislature.
Sen. Randy Fine, R-Melbourne is once again sponsoring legislation banning banners with a 'political viewpoint' from public buildings, seeing the bill advance in a Feb. 11 committee meeting.
'The government should not be in the business of political viewpoints,' Fine said. 'To be clear, I would never support a private individual in their private capacity not to being able to fly any flag that they so choose, (but) the idea (here) is government doing it.'
Following Fine's announcement of SB 100 in December, several activist groups and politicians have criticized the legislation. The ACLU Florida, PEN America and Equality Florida have penned statements about the bill's impacts on Floridians if passed.
'This bill not only infringes on Floridians' self-expression in violation of the First Amendment but is blatantly homophobic and racist," Florida PEN Director Katie Blankenship said in a statement. "The bill is outright censorship of groups and the ban on symbols and flags being displayed by government and public schools, colleges, and universities would have a chilling effect on these communities."
What does SB 100 entail? Here's what to know.
SB 100, otherwise known as the "Display of Flags by Governmental Entities" bill, prohibits a governmental agency, local government, or other unit of local government from "erecting or displaying a flag thatrepresents a political viewpoint, including a politically partisan, racial, sexual orientation, gender, or political ideology viewpoint."
This ban would also include public schools, colleges and universities. The legislation was approved 5-2 vote by the Governmental Oversight and Accountability Committee chaired by Fine.
According to the Florida Senate website, the bill requires any governmental entity that displays the United States flag must do so in a manner in which it is in a more prominent position than any other displayed flag.
"The bill allows an active or retired member of the United States Armed Forces or National Guardto use reasonable force to prevent the desecration, destruction, or removal of the United Statesflag, or to replace it to a prominent position, except when directly ordered not to do so by a lawenforcement officer who is acting in the scope of his or her employment," the bill's analysis states.
Florida Politics reported Sen. Tina Polsky further explained, 'If you're on your property burning the American flag, this bill would authorize them to exercise reasonable force to stop that behavior."
See critics, supporters of flag ban: Flag ban on public buildings in Florida renewed by GOP
It would not impact private citizens. This bill only impacts government entities.
"The bill further provides that the prohibition on the display of a flag representing a political viewpoint by a governmental entity does not limit a private individual's expression of private speech or viewpoints, or his or her rights otherwise protected by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. Nor does the prohibition limit a governmental entity's ability to display or erect a flag that is required or authorized by general law."
As for public employees, the analysis says their speech of public concern is protected by the First Amendment as citizen speech.
It adds their speech may be restricted only if the state's interest, as an employer, in promoting its efficiency of public services outweighs the employee's interests as a citizen in commenting on a matter of public concern.
Yes. Fine's proposed bill has been filed for consideration by state lawmakers two years in a row and has failed to pass.
While Gov. Ron DeSantis has yet to address the 2025 bill, he has supported previous legislation. According to the Tampa Bay Times, he told reporters at a press conference over a year ago that he agreed with possible restrictions.
'If you take a position that, we're going to fly the American flag and the state of Florida flag, and that's it, it's not targeting anybody. It's basically saying that we're not going to get into this business of doing this. So I think that's totally fine,' the governor said in 2024.
The bill doesn't include penalties for those who fly a banned flag; however, it does include the consequences for mishandling or defiling an approved flag.
The bill's analysis states: "In Florida, a person commits a second-degree misdemeanor if the person improperly uses the state or the U.S. flag by marking the flag, exposing an improperly marked flag for public viewing, or if a person publicly mutilates, defaces, defiles, defies, tramples upon, or by word or act casts contempt upon any such flag."
Continued, it is a first-degree misdemeanor if a person publicly "mutilates, defaces, tramples upon, or burns, with intent to insult, any flags, standards, colors, or ensigns of the U.S. or of Florida."
If passed, the bill would take effect July 1, 2025.
It has two more committee stops before reaching a floor vote. Florida Politics says it will go before the Senate Community Affairs Committee next.
Contributing: John Kennedy, USA TODAY NETWORK – FLORIDA
This article originally appeared on Tallahassee Democrat: Florida flags ban bill targets political 'viewpoints.' What to know