Drimonis: Children's book club is latest target of CAQ's identity politics
It was this club that Quebec Francization Minister Jean-François Roberge decided to criticize on social media for the simple reason that one of the many illustrations it uses to promote its cross-country activities features a girl in a hijab.
'Many Quebecers have expressed their discomfort with this poster for a book club held in a public library,' Roberge said on X last month, 'which depicts a young girl wearing a hijab. This type of poster does not promote the coexistence we want to promote in Quebec. The principles and foundations of the new law on integration into the Quebec nation must ultimately guide us to avoid this kind of blunder.'
How many Quebecers 'expressed their discomfort,' we'll never know, but what 'blunder' is Roberge alluding to exactly?
A little girl being interested in reading? Improving her French? Feeling like she belongs to a larger, inclusive Quebec? Making friends with other cultural communities?
Or does Roberge only see a hijab?
Some people's vision of vivre-ensemble appears limited to an 'ensemble' that only looks like them. In an effort to erase what the government considers undesirable from public spaces, the Coalition Avenir Québec is not above scapegoating children. I fail to see how that strengthens state secularism.
Mouvement laïque québécois and the secular feminist organization Pour les droits des femmes du Québec shared their discomfort, noting the illustration depicts a minor wearing the hijab, not an adult with full agency. Yet the same groups and various pundits made no such distinction last year when they denounced an illustration of a woman in a hijab at Montreal City Hall's entrance, demanding the city remove it. The hijab is what ultimately bothered them. Disappointingly, the city caved.
If organizers — receiving pressure to conform to the CAQ's limited vision of inclusion — simply pull the book club from Quebec, what would be accomplished other than depriving thousands of Quebec kids of a free reading program? Do Quebec's public libraries belong to all Quebecers or do they not? Only months ago, a Montreal public library told a writer trying to book a space to host his English book club that he couldn't, because Quebec's vague new language law was creating unnecessary confusion. Why are we making access to culture more difficult for some Quebecers?
With the Legault government slashing school budgets and last year's reports of problems accessing francization courses, and with literacy rates lagging, one would think a francization minister would not only welcome outside assistance, but praise it.
No such luck.
Identity politics above everything else. Once again, the CAQ has chosen to single out a religious minority in order to showboat secularism. It's performative at best.
While I don't support hijabs on children, neither do I believe that targeting those who wear them supports state secularism. It's just bullying.
The CAQ says the book club's illustration 'does not promote the coexistence we want to promote in Quebec.' What kind of coexistence is that?
The kind that marginalizes religious and cultural differences to such an extent that we can no longer even tolerate a mere illustration of a hijab for a free book club? The kind that selectively chooses to focus on some religious traditions while conveniently ignoring others?
All young Quebecers — without qualifiers — should feel welcome in our public spaces and cultural institutions. That's the kind of coexistence I can get behind.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Montreal Gazette
23 minutes ago
- Montreal Gazette
Josh Freed: Celebrate Canada and Quebec by swatting bugs and jumping in a lake
Our two national holidays have come and gone, but like most Montrealers I hardly noticed them, which is usually a sign that all's well in Quebec. The two days are barometers of our political times, so here's my post-holiday review of Canada Day and St-Jean. Canada Day has never been an overly patriotic or nationalistic day, one of many advantages of being Canadian. Most Canadians traditionally celebrate by going to the country for the long weekend to smack bugs and jump in a lake. But this year Canada Day was on steroids in much of the country as people belted out the anthem, unfurled supersized U.S.-style Canadian flags and wore T-shirts saying 'Canada is not for sale' and 'Never 51!' Here in Montreal, the Canada Day parade was cancelled at the last minute, as usual. But a small informal 'march' happened in Old Montreal that attracted so many sympathetic American and European tourists, they probably outnumbered us locals, who don't always attend these things. Canada's new nationalism has also infected Quebec, where recent polls show most Quebecers are very proud to be Canadian, even more so than people in some other provinces. Many francophones are suddenly feeling sappy about maple syrup, Mounties and moose, while humming the national anthem in the shower. The secret glue that's cementing our country is U.S. President Donald Trump, who's made us all appreciate what he's threatened to take away. From coast-to-coast we're taking pride in boycotting U.S. goods and discussing where in the States we aren't going. 'So where are you NOT going this summer?' 'Oh, we're not going to Vermont or Old Orchard, like we usually do. We'll be staycationing in Snowdon instead. And where WON'T you be going?' Meanwhile, in Ottawa, our new PM, Mark Carney, gave a brief speech on July 1 about Canada being a kind, caring nation, and it rang true given that our southern neighbour has officially abandoned those virtues. Instead, the U.S. has embraced a new motto: 'Nice guys and countries finish last.' As much of the world turns crueller and more selfish, Canada is managing to look good, by just not changing much. Our PM was elected as a Liberal, but he's a former banker who's pushing his party to the centre, talking pipelines, business, and 'Build baby, build,' while still sounding liberal about social policy. So he's kind of a Liberal Conservative. Until a few decades ago, we had a party like that called the Progressive Conservatives, under leaders like Joe Clark and Brian Mulroney. But then Western 'reformers' turned it into the more radical and shrill Conservative party that Pierre Poilievre now incarnates. Lately, with Trump threatening, many Canadians were ready to move to the political centre, so the Liberals did, stealing economic policies from the Tories but staying socially liberal. Thus we elected Carney, an old-fashioned Progressive Conservative. Our new Liberal PM is actually a Red Tory. St-Jean: Canada Day's new patriotism may have stolen some thunder from Quebec's Fête nationale this June 24, though nationalism has been on the decline here for years. There was a big Rachel Ave. parade and hundreds of low-key block parties and concerts, but most Quebecers celebrated the day like other Canadians — by going to the country to swat bugs and jump in a lake. Much of the francophone media's June 24 coverage was about remembering a famous St-Jean night 50 years ago, in 1975, when more than a million people celebrated atop Mount Royal in a great wave of nationalism. One of them was me, curious to see a remarkable event that symbolized the times. I still remember the scene: There were vast mobs of people swathed head-to-toe in fleur-de-lis, and giant bonfires being lit everywhere you looked, occasionally barbecuing Canadian flags. Gilles Vigneault had just written 'Gens du Pays' for the occasion, which quickly became Quebec's unofficial national anthem, and also its Happy Birthday song, even for many anglos. The crowds sang it again and again along with 'le Québec aux Québécois' until dawn, when the police broke up the party. But as usual in Quebec, as an anglo I felt totally welcomed as part of the gang by nationalists delighted I was there to celebrate. The intensity of the nationalism was awesome and remained so for several years. Compare that with more recent St-Jean activities: genteel neighbourhood block parties attended by all ethnicities and outdoor concerts that are dwarfed by the jazz festival, which is practically Quebec's modern national holiday. Like Canada Day, June 24 has become more of a national day off. This St-Jean I didn't even see many fleur-de-lis flying on homes in my Plateau neighbourhood, which was once festooned with them. These days people are proud to be Quebecers, but proud to be Canadians, too. Quebecers aren't heading to Mount Royal in millions, but we are all thrumming proudly, pleased our province and our country feel like a refuge against a threatening world. Quebecers are still fighting for sovereignty, but like most Canadians, that's now sovereignty from the U.S. So let's thank Donald Trump for making our national holidays great again.
Winnipeg Free Press
3 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Authors aplenty in Order of Canada award recipients
Manitoba-born, Toronto-based novelist Miriam Toews wasn't the only Canadian author appointed to the Order of Canada in recent days. Toews was appointed on June 30 along with 82 other Canadians — a group that included a handful of other writers and illustrators. B.C. provincial health officer Bonnie Henry was among the appointees — she penned 2021's Be Kind, Be Calm, Be Safe, published by Allen Lane, in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. Elbows Up! Buy on Ottawa lawyer Maureen McTeer was also appointed; her books include 2022's Fertility: 40 Years of Change and 2004's In My Own Name. Buy on Montreal appointee Marianne Dubuc is a French children's author whose books include the Mr. Postmouse series as well as Devant ma maison and the Governor General's Award-winning Le lion et l'oiseau. Buy on Fellow Montrealer Élise Gravel is a prolific children's author and illustrator in both French and English whose 50 picture books include Club Microbe, the Disgusting Critters series and It's My Brain! Buy on Ottawa's David Pelly has written extensively about Canada's North, including books such as 2017's The Old Way North: Following the Oberholtzer-Magee Expedition and Ukkusiksalik: The People's Story. Buy on For a complete list of the most recent appointees to the Order of Canada, see ● ● ● A collection of Canadian authors have come together in a collection being published on Oct. 14 in response to recent aggression shown by the U.S. Elbows Up!: Canadian Voices of Resilience and Resilience was edited by Elamin Abdulmahmoud and features essays by Manitoba writers David A. Robertson, Niigaan Sinclair, Jillian Horton, Peter Mansbridge and the late Margaret Laurence as well as Margaret Atwood, Dave Bidini, Omar El Akkad, Ann-Marie MacDonald, Carol Off, Jen Sookfong Lee, Canisia Lubrin and others. Buy on ● ● ● Montreal author Chanel Sutherland has been named the winner of the 2025 Commonwealth Short Story Prize, an award worth £5,000 (around $9,147). Neuromancer The prize is awarded to the author who has penned the best piece of unpublished short fiction between 2,000-5,000 words. One finalist from five different regions (Canada and Europe. Africa, Asia, Caribbean and Pacific) wins the top prizes, with each of the other finalists receiving £2,500 (just over $4,500). Sutherland has a debut story collection, Layaway Child, forthcoming from House of Anansi Press in spring 2026. ● ● ● South Carolina-born, Vancouver-based sci-fi author William Gibson's seminal debut novel, 1984's Neuromancer, has been announced as being in production for a streaming series coming to Apple TV+. In a very brief teaser trailer released July 1 online, little is revealed about the series, which is based on Gibson's novel that follows a computer hacker and which introduced the work 'cyberspace' into the vernacular. The series will star Callum Turner along with Briana Middleton, Joseph Lee, Peter Sarsgaard, Dane DeHaan and others, and will be created for TV by Graham Roland (Dark Winds, Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan). ● ● ● Every Second Friday The latest on food and drink in Winnipeg and beyond from arts writers Ben Sigurdson and Eva Wasney. Speaking of adaptations, a second version of Stephen King's The Running Man is heading for the big screen in the fall. The dystopian novel follows a character named Ben who must survive a reality TV show with all manner of dangerous, often-fatal challenges and deadly pursuers. The first version of The Running Man was released in 1987; it starred Arnold Schwarzenegger and was directed by Paul Michael Glaser. The new version stars Glen Powell (in Schwarzenegger's role), Colman Domingo, William H. Macy and others and was directed by Sean of the Dead's Edgar Wright. The film is slated to land in theatres in November 2025. books@ Ben SigurdsonLiterary editor, drinks writer Ben Sigurdson is the Free Press's literary editor and drinks writer. He graduated with a master of arts degree in English from the University of Manitoba in 2005, the same year he began writing Uncorked, the weekly Free Press drinks column. He joined the Free Press full time in 2013 as a copy editor before being appointed literary editor in 2014. Read more about Ben. In addition to providing opinions and analysis on wine and drinks, Ben oversees a team of freelance book reviewers and produces content for the arts and life section, all of which is reviewed by the Free Press's editing team before being posted online or published in print. It's part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Montreal Gazette
10 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
Letters: Bilingual greetings shouldn't be shamed by CAQ government
Re: ' Language complaints soar in Quebec as English service eclipses concerns about signs ' (The Gazette, July 4) I often travel to Ottawa for work. When I stop in Casselman, a Franco-Ontarian bastion, I am greeted with 'Hello-Bonjour.' It's one thing to say everyone in Quebec is entitled to be greeted and served in French, as previous governments have, and quite another to attempt to shame businesses for also wanting to welcome clients in another language, as the Coalition Avenir Québec is doing. English is not a foreign language in Quebec, as much as some nationalists may like it to be. Jordan Black, Rosemont A caring response to an urgent need Re: ' 'I'm happy': From homeless to housed, tenants grateful for new Lachine facility ' (The Gazette, July 3) It was a pleasure to read about the Old Brewery Mission's Tenaquip Place. In a world where stories of hardship often dominate the headlines, it is deeply uplifting to see a project focused on compassion, community and hope. This complex is not just a structure — it's a sign we are capable of thoughtful, humane responses to urgent needs. We are at our best when we look out for one another. To those who made Tenaquip Place a reality, thank you for your vision and humanity. Elizabeth Bright, Côte-St-Luc Patriotism is a personal matter Re: ' Canadian pride isn't a betrayal of being a Quebecer ' (Robert Libman, June 28) It is infuriating that a nationalist commentator, as reported by Robert Libman, would try to negate what another person believes in by stating 'Canada is an artificial political structure.' The commentator also claims we can't be Canadian and Québécois at the same time. Perhaps they missed a recent Association for Canadian Studies poll that showed 82 per cent of Quebec respondents — believing a nation's 'members share a common culture, language and history' — felt 'they were part of the Canadian nation.' To harbour strong patriotic feelings for one's nation is fine, but to dismiss another's pride in a country you don't identify with is wrong-headed. Goldie Olszynko, Mile End NATO spending goal needs a rethink Re: ' Trump hedges on NATO pledge ' (NP Montreal, June 25); ' Ottawa pledges to ramp up NATO defence spending ' (NP Montreal, June 26) NATO's decision to raise member countries' defence spending to five per cent of GDP will pose serious difficulties for spending on domestic needs. The chief reasons given are the need to counter the increased threat posed by Russia and other hostile countries, and to match U.S. military expenditure in NATO. Yet according to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, Russia spent only US$149 billion on the military in 2024, while NATO countries collectively spent US$1,506 billion, with European NATO countries at US$454 billion. The U.S. spent only 3.38 per cent of GDP on defence in 2024. President Donald Trump has said the five per cent goal shouldn't apply to the U.S., but only to other NATO countries. For Canada to reach five per cent, it would have to increase its annual defence to $150 billion. This would probably result in significantly increased taxes, debt or severe cuts in domestic spending. Canada and other NATO countries should seriously reconsider this increase. Robert Hajaly, Montreal Submitting a letter to the editor Letters should be sent by email to letters@ We prioritize letters that respond to, or are inspired by, articles published by The Gazette. If you are responding to a specific article, let us know which one. Letters should be sent uniquely to us. The shorter they are — ideally, fewer than 200 words — the greater the chance of publication. Timing, clarity, factual accuracy and tone are all important, as is whether the writer has something new to add to the conversation. We reserve the right to edit and condense all letters. Care is taken to preserve the core of the writer's argument. Our policy is not to publish anonymous letters, those with pseudonyms or 'open letters' addressed to third parties. Letters are published with the author's full name and city or neighbourhood/borough of residence. Include a phone number and address to help verify identity; these will not be published. We will not indicate to you whether your letter will be published. If it has not been published within 10 days or so, it is not likely to be.
