
Special Intensive Revision: As hearing starts, recalling a key case from 1977
The petitioners in the present challenge have questioned the ECI's power to conduct the SIR, as well as the procedure for it. Under Article 326, every citizen above the age of 18 has the right to vote. The SIR has shifted the burden of proof of citizenship on electors in some cases. The ECI has issued a new enumeration form, which is not prescribed in the Representation of the People Act, 1951, which governs the conduct of elections.
The court began hearing the challenge on Thursday.
The 1977 case
The ruling by a five-judge Bench of the Supreme Court (Mohinder Singh Gill v. The Chief Election Commissioner) came after the post-Emergency Lok Sabha election of 1977. Following violence and the destruction of some ballot papers during counting of votes for one segment of the Ferozepore (Firozpur) seat, the ECI cancelled the entire process and ordered a re-election at the seat.
Gill was leading the count at the time, and challenged the decision in Punjab and Haryana High Court under Article 226, which gives HCs the power to issue writs for the enforcement of fundamental rights and provide legal remedies for violations of law.
The court considered three questions: first, whether the ECI is empowered to order a re-poll for the entire constituency; second, whether the ECI's order violated the principles of natural justice; third, whether the HC was competent to intervene under Article 226, given the bar placed by Article 329(b) on judicial interference in election matters.
It upheld the ECI's order and dismissed the petition, saying that it lacked jurisdiction to intervene in electoral matters through a writ petition. On appeal, the Supreme Court too upheld the ECI's decision and clarified the extent of its powers.
The SC's ruling
The SC underlined the ECI's plenary powers over the 'superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of the electoral rolls for, and the conduct of' elections to Parliament and state Assemblies under Article 324.
It said that if laws enacted by Parliament and state Assemblies under Articles 327 and 328 respectively, are silent on any aspect, the ECI must act independently and decisively to ensure free and fair elections.
The court also held that the ECI can take proactive decisions, including ordering a re-poll, if it believes that the integrity of the election has been compromised. While natural justice is an important procedural safeguard, it must be 'pragmatic and flexible', the SC said.
The court underlined that the powers of the ECI are subject to judicial review, but judicial review came into play only after the election was complete. It clarified that Article 329(b) places a 'blanket ban' on courts from intervening during an ongoing election process, although it has 'large enough powers to give relief to an injured candidate' afterward.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
.jpg%3Frect%3D0%252C48%252C1280%252C672%26w%3D1200%26ar%3D40%253A21%26auto%3Dformat%252Ccompress%26ogImage%3Dtrue%26mode%3Dcrop&w=3840&q=100)

Deccan Herald
9 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
No names can be deleted from draft rolls without due process: EC
The EC underlined the due process involved in the exercise amid allegations by opposition parties that crores of eligible persons will lose their voting rights for want of documents due to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the voter list in Bihar.


Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
Abhishek to head to Delhi as TMC intensifies SIR stir
Kolkata: national general secretary is expected to reach Delhi this week as the party intensifies its stir in Parliament, demanding an assurance from the Centre "on the floor of the House" that the special intensive revision (SIR) in Bihar will be discussed. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Trinamool Congress has been consistently opposing SIR, questioning Election Commission's powers to conduct citizenship checks and disenfranchise voters. The party has said SIR requirements mirror Section 3 of the Citizenship Act, 1955, which makes the exercise "NRC in disguise." Over the last week, the party has been hamstrung by the absence of its floor leaders in Lok Sabha. Trinamool's leader in Lok Sabha Sudip Bandyopadhyay and senior MP Saugata Roy are not in Delhi due to health reasons. The party's chief whip in Lok Sabha, Kalyan Banerjee, is representing Bengal govt in cases and shuttling between Supreme Court and Calcutta High Court. On Friday, the party's deputy Lok Sabha leader Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar attended the all-party meeting convened by Speaker Om Birla. Banerjee is likely to remain in Delhi and work on party strategy. The Diamond Harbour MP, who was part of Centre's outreach abroad after Pahalgam attack, is also likely to be a keynote speaker if Operation Sindoor discussions take place in Parliament. A senior MP said: "Trinamool is not opposed to discussions on Operation Sindoor. In fact, we want some answers. But this cannot be at the expense of SIR. Here we are talking of mass disenfranchisement of people who had voted in the 2024 Lok Sabha, based on arbitrary reasoning. We want a clear assurance from the Centre on the floor of the house that SIR will be discussed threadbare in Parliament."


Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Justice Dhulia goes down memory laneat alma mater
Lucknow: Supreme Court Judge Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia on Sunday emphasised the growing need for students to read books, memoirs, biographies, and books based on war strategies. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Captain Manoj Kumar Pandey Uttar Pradesh Sainik School hosted Justice Dhulia where he inaugurated the school's girls hostel, renamed as Rani Laxmi Bai Hostel. School officials said that Justice Dhulia was a cadet of the institution in 1972. Justice Dhulia, who was accompanied by his wife Vaishali Dhulia, got emotional remembering the old days spent at the school. Addressing students, he spoke on the importance of reading books and discussed the growing influence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in our daily lives. "AI has many benefits in facilitating modern life, but its destructive side effects are not only dangerous but can also be life-threatening," he said. Other distinguished cadets like IAS Raj Kamal Yadav, director, industries, Sudhir Tyagi were also present. Justice Dhulia paid floral tributes to all the martyrs at the War Memorial in the school.