BMI of 1 million ethnic minority adults in England wrongly classified
A million ethnic minority adults are wrongly classified as weighing below the thresholds for being overweight or obese due to official figures not using up-to-date guidance, a leading charity has warned.
Analysis by Nesta has found that, while official statistics class 64% of adults in England as being overweight or living with obesity, the correct figure should be 67%.
The 3% difference between Nesta's analysis and Health Service for England data represents around a million people, and is explained by Black and Asian adults being underrepresented in the data.
Nesta found that recorded rates of Black adults being overweight or living with obesity should be 13 percentage points higher. For Asian adults, the figure should be 18 percentage points higher.
The error in the official figures is the result of government statistics not using new body mass index (BMI) calculations. Earlier this year, The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice) updated its BMI measurement guidelines to recommend lower thresholds for adults from Black, Asian and other ethnic minority backgrounds.
Nice's revised thresholds reflect the fact that people from certain minority backgrounds have a greater risk of some chronic health conditions – such as cardiovascular disease or type 2 diabetes – at a lower threshold than their white counterparts.
The updated guidance also addresses how body composition, which includes variations in fat and muscle mass, varies across ethnic groups. People from Black, Asian, and other minority backgrounds are more prone to central adiposity, which occurs when excess fat accumulates around the abdomen and is a risk factor for cardiovascular diseases and related mortality.
Nesta, a charity that promotes innovation, said that the government should make sure the updated Nice thresholds are adopted in future publications of the Health Survey for England.
Parita Doshi, deputy director of healthy life at Nesta, said: 'Reducing Britain's obesity levels is achievable, but only with a clear-eyed understanding of the size of the problem and levels of inequality.
'NHS England and DHSC [the Department of Health and Social Care] should look to ensure these guidelines are adopted in future health data publications, to provide a clear picture of the challenge of reducing obesity in the country.'
Sign up to First Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
Jabeer Butt OBE, the chief executive of the Race Equality Foundation, said: 'The analysis carried out by Nesta shows the urgent need for better guidance and training for healthcare staff on assessing health risks for people of Black, Asian and minoritised ethnic backgrounds.
'However, this analysis should also make the government prioritise action on drivers of poorer health, such as insecure employment [and] poor-quality housing in economically deprived areas, amongst other issues. Those who will conclude that it is individuals' choices about diet and exercise that needs to change will have misunderstood Nesta's analysis.'
The DHSC was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
14 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Cup of golden milk a day 'could keep cancer and Alzheimer's at bay'
This popular Asian drink features a common spice which scientists say has been linked to many health improvements – here's all you need to know A classic Asian drink is gaining traction in the West, thanks to its myriad health benefits. Health experts are singing praises for "golden milk", a concoction made by adding a spoonful of turmeric to a glass of milk. The health-boosting properties of golden milk can be attributed largely to curcumin, the active ingredient in turmeric. This powerful compound has such potent anti-inflammatory effects that some research equates it to pharmaceutical drugs. In addition to its anti-inflammatory prowess, as underscored in this research paper in the medical journal Foods, curcumin also enhances the body's antioxidant capacity. It effectively combats oxidative damage and free radicals, which can accelerate ageing and contribute to chronic diseases. Curcumin plays a pivotal role in mitigating oxidative stress and harmonising various bodily functions. It can decrease intracellular lipid peroxidation and bolster the body's antioxidant capabilities, potentially leading to increased longevity. Research even suggests that curcumin could aid in treating Alzheimer's disease (AD) as it helps shield the hippocampus, the brain region responsible for learning and memory functions. A study by Brazilian scientists, published in the journal Current Neuropharmacology, concluded: "The administration of curcumin demonstrates to be effective for the treatment of AD. These studies help to elucidate the mechanism of action of curcumin, where they suggest that it partially reverses the neurotoxic and behavioural damages in animals with AD and other cell lines." Golden milk recipes often incorporate curcumin, cinnamon and ginger, all of which are known for their potent antioxidant properties. Research has shown that ginger can enhance brain function by improving reaction time and memory, while animal studies have suggested that it may protect against age-related decline in brain function. Both ginger and cinnamon have been linked to lower blood sugar levels. A scientific study proposed that a small daily intake of ginger could potentially reduce haemoglobin A1C levels (a long-term measure of blood sugar control) by up to 10 per cent. Research also suggests that the spices found in golden milk may have anti-cancer properties. One study, published in the journal Mini-Reviews in Medicinal Chemistry, discovered that 6-gingerol, a compound abundant in raw ginger, exhibits anti-cancer characteristics. Another study, conducted by scientists in the US, posited that curcumin has the capacity to kill isolated cancer cells in laboratory tests. It might also inhibit the growth of new blood vessels in tumours, thereby limiting their proliferation, according to Gloucestershire Live. Golden milk could also be beneficial for brain health. Research from Iran indicated that curcumin might boost levels of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), a substance that aids in the formation of new brain connections and promotes the growth of brain cells. There is also some evidence suggesting that curcumin, a compound found in turmeric, could help ease symptoms of depression, as per a study published in the Scientific World Journal. However, further research is required. For those who aren't fans of strong spices, fear not – the taste of this drink has been likened to chai tea or a chai latte. Its main purpose is to provide comfort rather than stimulation, making it a perfect evening beverage. The basic recipe of turmeric and milk can be customised with various additions to suit your palate and nutritional needs. Consider enhancing your drink with other spices like nutmeg, which is rich in magnesium, or sweeten it with a dash of maple syrup or honey. Adding a few grinds of black pepper can unlock additional health benefits. This common table spice contains piperine, a natural compound that boosts the absorption of curcumin by 2,000 per cent, according to this report. There are numerous recipes available online for this naturally sweet beverage. Traditionally, turmeric milk is made with cow's milk, but you can substitute with alternatives such as oat, soy, or almond milk. Once you've gathered the base ingredients, you can start experimenting to find your perfect blend of golden milk. Here's a simple method to try at home: Pour 250ml of your preferred milk into a saucepan and bring to a simmer over medium heat Add in 1tsp of ground turmeric, a pinch of black pepper and any other spices and sweeteners you fancy Add to the mixture and let it simmer for 10 minutes, allowing the flavours to blend and fully mature Pour into a mug, let it cool slightly, then drink To turn your warm turmeric milk into a latte, gently whisk it with a hand whisk or a milk frother over low heat to 'froth' the milk once it's in the saucepan. Some people enjoy the drink chilled, similar to an iced coffee, as there is no evidence that serving it over ice diminishes any health benefits.
Daily Mail
20 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Supermarkets could be forced to ensure shoppers make healthier food choices in a bid by ministers to tackle the obesity crisis
Supermarkets could be forced to ensure shoppers make healthier food choices in a bid by ministers to tackle the obesity crisis. Plans are being drawn up for supermarkets to promote fruit and vegetables to customers instead of fattening items like crisps and chocolate, according to the i newspaper. This will be done using nudge tactics to convince shoppers to make healthier choices during their weekly shop. The proposals are believed to be part of Health Secretary Wes Streeting 's ten-year NHS plan which is due to be published next week. Under the shopping policy, the largest retailers will be forced to record data which shows how successful they are in convincing consumers to swap out fattening items for healthier alternatives. It could result in supermarkets adjusting the layout of their stores so healthy items are displayed more prominently. Retailers have the ability to reformulate their own-brand products to make them more healthy as well as change signage and marketing to make nutritious foods look more appealing, according to policymakers. Details of the proposal are yet to be completely signed off but officials believe that providing supermarkets with clear targets on encouraging shoppers to make better choices could help reduce obesity levels in the country. The plans are based on a ten-year obesity blueprint which was developed by think tank Nesta. 'We urgently need to reshape our food system so that the healthier option is the easiest option for everyone, regardless of where you buy your food,' it said in its report. 'By implementing ambitious yet achievable mandatory health targets for retailers, we can make real progress towards these goals and start turning the tide on obesity once and for all.' Labour MPs have been asking the Health Secretary to adopt the proposals privately and all major supermarkets have been briefed on it. One Labour MP, who supports the policy, said: 'These are really simple things that you can change, and it may mean giving supermarkets a bit of a hit. But it's how you get people to make changes to their behaviour. 'It's a bit like the smoking in pubs. People were dead against it and then when they did it, even smokers supported it - that switch in behaviour that is seen as unthinkable, but that's how you change things.'
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Brain dead pregnant woman's family issue tragic update after baby cut out
The case of Adriana Smith sparked controversy around the world after the pregnant Black woman was kept on life support machines for months after her death, in order for her unborn baby to survive The family of a pregnant brain-dead woman who was kept on life support to incubate her premature foetus will live-stream her funeral to thank the people who donated to her medical funds. Adriana Smith was a 30-year-old nurse who died in February this year after suffering from severe headaches. She was around nine weeks' pregnant at the time, and had a seven-year-old existing son. The day after being sent home from hospital, her boyfriend woke to the sounds of her gasping for air - but when she was rushed back to hospital, the pregnant mum was found to have blood clots on her brain. After she was declared brain-dead - meaning there was zero chance of her ever recovering and regaining consciousness - Adriana was hooked up to life-support machines, which artificially kept blood pumping around her body. Thanks to Georgia's draconian pro-life laws, which ban abortion once a foetal heartbeat can be detected, doctors refused to take Adriana off the machines, instead planning to keep her body as an incubator until the foetus had reached viability in August. Despite Adriana's family's pleas to let their daughter rest in peace,Emory University Hospital in Atlanta said it uses "consensus from clinical experts, medical literature, and legal guidance to support our providers" as they make treatment recommendations "in compliance with Georgia's abortion laws and all other applicable laws". It added: "Our top priorities continue to be the safety and wellbeing of the patients we serve." The foetus, which Adriana's family named 'Chance', was diagnosed in the womb with severe medical problems, and Adriana's mother April Newkirk said at the time they weren't even sure if he would survive the birth. He could, she said, be born with life-threatening disabilities which would affect his quality of life. After four months of being kept on life support, doctors finally delivered Chance via C-section in the early hours of June 13. He weighed just 538g, less than two pounds, but was born living at 27 weeks' gestation. Doctors now say he is in a critical but stable condition. Ms Newkirk wrote six days later, "Baby chance is doing good, keep praying it very early." She added: "I can't believe this I [can't] sleep but my God I serve I trust him I'm going to be strong but I'm hurting so bad inside." She later told press that her daughter was barely six months pregnant when Chance was cut out of Adriana's womb, but he was "expected to be okay". "He's just fighting. We just want prayers for him," she said, adding that Chance was "fighting for his life" in neo-natal intensive care. READ MORE: Legally dead pregnant mum being kept alive on life support as 'incubator' for foetus Shortly after the operation, doctors finally turned off the machines that had prolonged Adriana's bodily functions and returned her remains to her devastated family. The funeral will now be held on Saturday June 28, and Ms Newkirk has agreed to live-stream the ceremony so that the hundreds of thousands of people around the world who've been gripped by Adriana's ordeal can help say their goodbyes. "For everyone around the world. I am very grateful and thankful to you for your support," she wrote on the family's GoFundMe page, which has raised nearly $440,000 (£320,000) in donations for medical fees. "Adriana Smith's funeral will be livestream. And as soon as I get the link, I will share it for everyone to join me and my family. To say our final Farwell until we meet again my daughter," she added. "I want to thank everyone for the support that I received from each and every one of you. I am so grateful to have people from all over the world support. Please continue to pray for me and my family. I will update Monday about baby Chance." Adriana's case has sparked debate around the world about America's clampdown on abortion and women's reproductive rights. Republican lawmakers in Georgia brought in the LIFE bill shortly after the Supreme Court struck down Roe vs Wade, which had allowed women to access abortion for 50 years, which severely restricts women from seeking termination of their pregnancy after around six weeks.
