Brains on Autopilot: ChatGPT May Erode Critical Thinking
Participants using only their cognitive abilities showed the greatest neural activation, stronger memory recall, and more nuanced, creative expression. By contrast, ChatGPT users displayed the lowest brain engagement across neural, linguistic and behavioural measures. Experts described their outputs as 'soulless,' and follow‑up testing revealed that those who started by leaning on AI struggled to regain earlier performance levels when later writing independently.
The U. K. survey of more than 600 users echoed these concerns: frequent AI use was significantly linked to reduced critical thinking—especially among younger individuals who offloaded mental effort rather than utilising AI as an aid. Researchers warn this pattern may foster 'cognitive off‑loading,' a dependence that could diminish mental agility.
ADVERTISEMENT
Yet the data also reveal nuance. In a separate high school‑based trial, students who engaged with AI tutors offering iterative guidance rather than complete solutions performed just as well as those without AI assistance. This suggests that when AI is used to supplement learning and not supplant it, cognitive gains remain achievable.
MIT lead researcher Nataliya Kosmyna cautions: 'This study was not measuring intelligence loss, but rather the neural, linguistic and behavioural effects of reliance on generative systems.' She emphasises that the findings remain unreviewed and limited in scope, underscoring the need for long‑term, peer‑validated work before drawing sweeping conclusions.
Cambridge University's Sam Gilbert frames the phenomenon differently: reduced brain activity might reflect a release of mental bandwidth, enabling users to channel attention into higher‑order tasks. But he reminds policymakers and educators that caution is essential when integrating AI in formative environments.
Business and public discourse have responded swiftly. Coverage in the Washington Post highlighted the delicate balance between cognitive off‑loading and the potential to free mental capacity for creative endeavour. Coverage from The New York Post and The Times cited concerns of 'skill atrophy' and warned against passive AI dependence.
Academic literature supports this emerging narrative. An arXiv study dated December 2024 flagged 'metacognitive laziness' among AI‑assisted learners—those who rely on ChatGPT improved essay scores but showed weak knowledge transfer. University of Pennsylvania and Carnegie Mellon faculties likewise document a tension between AI assistance and sustained critical reasoning in student assignments.
Tech industry responses emphasise that AI's strength lies in augmentation, not substitution. Start‑ups such as BioSpark and other 'cognitive‑sparking' interfaces aim to rekindle curiosity and ownership—positioning AI as a creative counterpart rather than a convenience.
Major AI developers, including OpenAI, maintain that generative AI can enhance productivity—citing workforce efficiency gains of up to 15 per cent. Yet they acknowledge that without user agency and deliberate design, those gains may come at the expense of independent thought. With institutional adoption surging—over one billion ChatGPT users worldwide—experts press for frameworks that prioritise mental resilience as much as performance.
The debate reflects a longstanding tension in the adoption of technology. From Socrates' lament over writing to early anxieties about calculators and internet search, each leap in efficiency has triggered reflection on intellectual costs. AI, its proponents argue, is no different: transformation demands vigilance. As Michael Gerlich of the Swiss Business School notes, 'It's become a part of how I think.' But he stresses that training the mind to think with AI, rather than through it, will be critical.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
2 hours ago
- Zawya
Unique Properties, AIR to launch AI-powered real estate platform
Unique Properties, one of the UAE's most prominent real estate agencies, has announced a landmark joint venture with AIR (AI Realtor), an AI-native proptech innovator. As part of the agreement, Unique Properties will invest $20 million into AIR over the next two years to fuel the development and deployment of next-generation technologies in the real estate space. The partnership marks a bold leap forward for the region's property sector, blending years of market leadership with cutting-edge artificial intelligence to reshape how real estate is bought, sold, and experienced. Unique Properties said this strategic alliance comes as the UAE cements its position as a global leader in real estate innovation. Progressive government policies and a world-class digital ecosystem have created ideal conditions for meaningful disruption, particularly in the brokerage space, it added. On the joint venture, CEO Arash Jalili said: "At Unique Properties, we've always been at the forefront of the UAE real estate market, driven by a commitment to excellence and innovation. This joint venture marks the beginning of a new era, where technology and human insight come together to elevate the property experience." "Partnering with AIR allows us to stay ahead of the curve, setting new benchmarks for how real estate is transacted, advised, and experienced in this region," he stated. Milad Monshipour, Founder & CEO of AIR, said: "This is the first time the world will see a fully AI-native real estate platform developed in partnership with one of the most established brokerages in the region. It's an innovation born in the UAE, but its impact will be felt far beyond it." "Together, Unique Properties and AIR are set to usher in a new era for real estate in the UAE, one where technology doesn't just support the industry, it propels it forward," he added. -TradeArabia News Service Copyright 2024 Al Hilal Publishing and Marketing Group Provided by SyndiGate Media Inc. (
Al Etihad
11 hours ago
- Al Etihad
'The ChatGPT of Abu Dhabi': 92,000-member social media community fosters a culture of kindness
6 July 2025 22:58 KIRSTIN BERNABE (ABU DHABI)Anyone familiar with the Facebook group Abu Dhabi Q&A (ADQA) would agree that it could be the Google or the ChatGPT of the this community page, members can ask just about anything related to life in the UAE capital - from how to get traffic fine discounts and where to find affordable 2-bedroom flats for rent, to restaurant tips, and even parenting and marriage while ChatGPT can deliver answers in seconds, it can't comfort an anxious mother or broadcast a marriage proposal "to any woman". No AI bot can drive out in the middle of the night to help someone find a life-saving feeding tube for a seriously ill ADQA community has done all of this - and much more - over the past 12 years. Now with 92,000 members and counting, the private Facebook group broadcasts dozens of posts every day with members actively helping each other Jaffar, the founder of ADQA, doesn't think ChatGPT can replace the group, even if such bots can answer all essential how-to questions."The magic of the group isn't in the answers, it's in the community. The real people and their real stories," Jaffar, an Abu Dhabi resident for 17 years now, told the Year of Community, ADQA stands as proof of how human connections - even in an online space - can create a culture of kindness and compassion. How It All StartedJaffar founded the online community in January 2013 out of a need for "accurate, real-time information in the city". "Back then, I felt Google 'failed' Abu Dhabi. There was no reliable online space that acted like a local citizen's advice bureau where you could simply ask a question and get a trustworthy answer," she expat, who moved from London to Abu Dhabi in 2008, started the group with 70 of her friends on Facebook."What began as a small, practical solution to a personal challenge grew into something far bigger: a community-powered network of knowledge, kindness and connection," she there are dozens of similar groups on Facebook, ADQA stands out for the values it has consistently upheld through the years: accessibility, transparency and community."What sets ADQA apart is that it was created with no business motive or agenda. I started it purely to help, and I've stayed true to that," Jaffar said. An Unforgettable MomentFor many of the group's members, ADQA is a reminder of the good in humanity. Helena Jordan has seen firsthand how strangers are willing to go out of their way to lend a hand during a difficult a learning assistant who lived in Abu Dhabi with her family for 16 years, clearly recalls a core memory from 10 years ago, when her dad in Serbia was in critical condition and needed a particular feeding tube that was nowhere to be found. She raced against time as she had to catch a flight within hours, at 2am, and bring the life-saving tube to her father."In my panic, the only other thing I could think about was to post in the Abu Dhabi Q&A group," she said. The post garnered almost 200 responses within reached out with ideas on where to find such a tube. There were pharmacists who went back to their sites to check if they had it in stock. One orthodontist quickly drove to Cleveland Clinic Abu Dhabi and coordinated with senior doctors on good Samaritan was able to help Jordan pack two different feeding tubes into her suitcase, in the hopes that one of them would help her father. None of them worked, and by the time the family managed to get one from Croatia, Jordan's father was already in a coma and all they could do was wait."Ten years later, the pain still feels fresh; however, every time I think of my father, I am reminded of the wonderful community of strangers who became friends, of people who sent prayers and offered their help - the amazing people of ADQA," she said. Rays of PositivityAnother group member, Muhil Sureshkumar, turned to the group during a vulnerable moment as a mother and "never expected the overwhelming wave of love, prayers and strength that followed". At that time, her newborn son was battling a rare congenital heart defect. "I was flooded with messages of encouragement and hope from complete strangers who became my pillars of strength," said the expat who hails from Sri will never forget how Jaffar went above and beyond her role as group moderator."She visited me at my home after I returned from the hospital with my baby, just to make sure I was okay. In a city where I had no extended family, her presence was a blessing. It wasn't just her kindness, it was her selfless nature, her genuine care, her quiet strength that held me during a time I was falling apart," said the expat, an AI engineer who runs her own online tutoring academy. Trust as Currency, not AlgorithmsRunning ADQA has completely shaped Jaffar's life as a resident of Abu Dhabi. "Behind every post is a person sometimes in need, sometimes angry, sometimes lost, but always seeking connection. And managing that space has taught me how to read people without ever seeing them," Jaffar a moderator, she makes sure posts are kind, polite and family-friendly, and urges members to be aware of the UAE's cyber the years, Jaffar has learnt that "digital spaces are deeply human"."I discovered that trust is the true currency online and not likes, not reach, not algorithms. And once earned, it's powerful. Once broken, it's nearly impossible to rebuild," she posts are not all SOS entries. Community members do get a good laugh once in a fact, one of the most popular posts in the group was shared in 2017 by a "handsome Lebanese man, aged 32" who was looking for a woman to marry."She must be rich - age and nationality not important," read his post, which received almost 700 comments. He's now 40, and still not married, Jaffar said. While ADQA has changed lives and helped many, some problems are just beyond its reach. Source: Aletihad - Abu Dhabi
The National
11 hours ago
- The National
Mubadala is 'investing in AI and advanced tech to become a leading long-term global investor'
Mubadala 's pioneering investments in fields such as artificial intelligence and advanced technology are aimed at achieving its vision of being a leading, long-term global investor, the company's chief strategy and risk officer has said. Ahmed Al Calily told Wam that, in light of rapid global changes, Abu Dhabi's strategic investment arm is keen to enhance its role and effective contributions to the efforts aimed at building a strong and diversified economic future for the UAE through investments in strategic, future-shaping sectors. Investments in vital sectors such as AI, semiconductors, life sciences, financial markets and energy, as well as the establishment of national companies that compete at the global level, are allowing Mubadala to achieve its goals, he said. Speaking to The National in January last year, Mr Al Calily said that "AI is definitely the next big mover and shaker". "It is the next disruptor for the consumer and for enterprise," he said. "This is the future; you cannot run away from it." Mubadala is continuing to expand its investments in sectors such as clean energy, health care and life sciences. In May, Mubadala launched a new pharmaceuticals company, boosting the UAE's manufacturing sector and further positioning the Emirates' healthcare industry on the global stage. Mubadala Bio will have a manufacturing capacity of more than 2.5 billion tablets and capsules, and 120 million units of intravenous solutions and injectables, the company said in a statement. In its 2024 annual report, Mubadala's assets increased by 9.1 per cent year on year to reach Dh1.2 trillion, and achieved a 33.7 per cent year-on-year increase in investment placement to Dh119 billion, Wam reported.
