logo
Unpacking Bryan Kohberger's guilty plea deal to avoid death penalty

Unpacking Bryan Kohberger's guilty plea deal to avoid death penalty

RNZ News4 days ago
By
Emma Tucker
, CNN
Bryan Kohberger, the 30-year-old accused of fatally stabbing four University of Idaho students in their apartment in 2022, has agreed to a plea deal to avoid the death penalty in his quadruple murder case.
Photo:
August Frank/Pool/Reuters via CNN Newsource
Bryan Kohberger appeared expressionless as a judge asked if he murdered four Idaho college students in their off-campus home, answering "yes" to each name called out in the courtroom.
At a change-of-plea hearing before state district Judge Steven Hippler in Boise, Idaho, the courtroom was packed with family members of the victims as Kohberger, a 30-year-old former PhD student of criminology,
admitted his guilt
to all five counts in the indictment and entered a plea deal that removes the possibility of the death penalty.
Kohberger had been charged with four counts of first-degree murder and one count of burglary in Latah County, Idaho, in the fatal stabbings Ethan Chapin, 20; Kaylee Goncalves, 21; Xana Kernodle, 20; and Madison Mogen, 21, in the early morning hours of November 13, 2022, in their Moscow, Idaho, home.
CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez has been closely following the investigation and was in the courtroom when Kohberger admitted guilt.
Here she breaks down some of the key pieces of the case and the plea deal:
Some of the questions and answers have been edited for length and clarity.
Q
: Why did prosecutors decide to strike a plea deal now, despite strong evidence including DNA, surveillance and cell phone data?
A
: I think that's one of the biggest unanswered questions. We don't know. Here's what we do know: Prosecutors hold the key to whether a trial goes forward or whether there is a plea deal. This was a very solid case, and the defense had lost so much - they were not going to be able to present an alibi because they couldn't establish there was anyone who saw him in another location when the killings took place.
I was talking to a prosecutor who told me this case is the case of a lifetime for a prosecutor. But this trial was going to cost a lot of money. This is Moscow's case. Latah County would have to pay for it all. The case had been moved to Boise to ensure a fair trial for Kohberger. So, one can only surmise that judicial economy or saving money went into this, right?
Q
: What do you think tipped the scales toward avoiding the death penalty for both the defense and prosecution?
A
: This was the only bargaining tool. They bargained away the death penalty when he agreed to serve life in prison without any possibility of parole.
In 2003, serial killer Gary Ridgway bargained away the death penalty but there were conditions. He was going to tell authorities where all of the other victims were that he killed and he did that. Here, there are no conditions.
Q
: Without a trial, there's no public adjudication of any motive. How does that impact any closure in this case for the families and the public?
A
: One of the issues with several of the families is that this was just too easy, that he was going to be able to sign the dotted line, done deal, then he can live his life forever. They wanted answers. They wanted to know if anybody else knew about it, where the murder weapon came from, why he went to that particular house, why he went up to the third floor. And those questions conceivably will never be answered.
If you look at what the father of Kaylee Goncalves said, he's very upset because he believes no one is caring about these four young lives that were taken so soon right as they were beginning their adulthood. The family of Madison Mogen spoke outside of court, and they said through their attorney that this could be closure, they can move on and it's alright. But the father of Xana Kernodle is saying it's not alright, that they're not going to ever really know the truth.
Q
: What were the reactions and emotions you could sense in the room when he admitted guilt?
A
:
It was very tense in the courtroom. Very tense but very silent. The media had been told to not show any emotion in the courtroom, and I wonder if the families were told that because they were so intense, they were staring at Kohberger very strongly. They were staring at the judge very strongly, but I did not see actual emotion coming out of them except from Kaylee Goncalves' aunt. That's who I heard it was. She had a Kleenex, she was crying so hard, but it was silent - she wasn't making any audible sounds at all.
When the prosecutor said, "We have still never found the knife, the murder weapon," I looked at Kohberger. I wanted to see if there was a reaction because there's one person that knows where that murder weapon is, and it's him. There was no reaction to that. He didn't move a muscle in his face.
Kohberger never once looked at the courtroom, looked at the people in the courtroom. He was in a stoic gaze with no emotion whatsoever. It was just like he did this every day.
The four University of Idaho students were found dead at an off-campus home in Moscow, Idaho, in November 2022.
Photo:
Angela Palermo/Idaho Statesman/TNS/Getty Images via CNN Newsource
When he had to take the oath that he would tell the truth, Kohberger jumped up and put his hand up. The judge said, "You don't have to stand up. I know you're trying to be respectful to the court, but you don't have to stand up."
Q
: After Kohberger is sentenced, what happens to the gag order that has kept the parties from speaking publicly?
A
: After sentencing, the case is over, so the judge has to lift that gag order because they have a First Amendment right to speak. The gag order was to preserve a fair trial before a jury for Kohberger. Both sides are not requesting a pre-sentencing report, which is normally done before sentencing. Sentencing is going to take place at this point on July 23. The prosecutor said they want to give all family members a chance to speak.
Q
: Prosecutor Bill Thompson choked up a couple of times - most notably as he was finishing his recitation of the facts and said the names of the four victims. What did you make of that and was there any significance behind that moment to you, having covered this case from the beginning?
A
: I've never seen him get emotional in any pretrial hearing. This is the first time, but a prosecutor has empathy for victims because although they represent the people, they indirectly represent the victims. That's who they care about. Maybe it got to him at that moment, but I'm sure that some of the family members would say, 'Well, if that emotion is there for those victims as we saw in court, why didn't you structure the plea deal so he had to provide some answers and tell us why he did this?'
Q
: What were the elements of the plea deal that the families of the victims would have liked to see or leave out?
A
: Steve Goncalves said he wanted more facts. Not only answers to why the killings happened, but did anybody know about it or help? What happened with the knife? Why that house? Why that floor? Because in pretrial hearings, it has been said there was no connection to the victims.
Q
: What can we expect from the upcoming sentencing hearing? Will families get a final chance to address him in court?
A
: The big thing is going to be the victim impact statements. Attorneys don't have to argue because there's nothing to decide. A decision has been made with the agreement, so it's the victims' families. Some courts allow family members to directly look at and address the defendant, while other courts do not. It'll be interesting to see the parameter and it'll be interesting to see what they say.
But here's the big one: Bryan Kohberger should be given a chance to address the court. In a normal sentencing, they are allowed to make a formal statement. Usually, that is to beg for mercy because you're about to be sentenced. In this case it would just be something he wanted to say. Will he speak? Will he say something to the families?
Q
: Can Kohberger appeal some aspect of his plea?
A
: He is waiving his right to appeal, so he will live the rest of his life within a prison in Idaho, managed by the Department of Corrections.
Q:
Some victims' family members complained about how quickly a plea deal was reached. Does it always happen this quickly in similar cases?
A
: No, it doesn't happen as quickly. The family members do not live in Boise. They had to conceivably change plans, take off work, and it's six hours from Moscow to Boise. That's quite the drive right there. They don't all live in Moscow, but they do not live in Boise. So it's highly unusual.
I think it's stunning that when Kohberger was posed the questions with their names: 'Did you intentionally, deliberately and with premeditation murder Xana Kernodle?' And he responded, 'yes.' No emotion at all.
-
CNN
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Sacked Russian transport minister found dead in his car with gunshot wound
Sacked Russian transport minister found dead in his car with gunshot wound

RNZ News

time7 hours ago

  • RNZ News

Sacked Russian transport minister found dead in his car with gunshot wound

Roman Starovoit pictured in May 2025 Photo: AFP / Pool / Dmitry Astakhov By Gleb Stolyarov and Andrew Osborn , Reuters Russia's sacked transport minister has been found dead in his car outside Moscow with a gunshot wound and the principal hypothesis is that he took his own life, state investigators said, hours after President Vladimir Putin fired him. A presidential decree published earlier on Monday (local time) gave no reason for the dismissal of Roman Starovoit, 53, after barely a year in the job, though political analysts were quick to raise the possibility that he may have been dismissed in connection with an investigation into corruption in the region he once ran. Reuters could not independently confirm these suggestions, though a transport industry source, who declined to be named due to the sensitivity of the matter, said Starovoit's position had been in question for months due to questions about the same corruption scandal. That investigation centres on whether 19.4 billion roubles (NZ$405 million) earmarked in 2022 for fortifying Russia's border with Ukraine in the Kursk region was properly spent or whether some of that money was embezzled. Russia's Investigative Committee, which probes major crimes, said in a statement it was working to establish the precise circumstances of Starovoit's death. A pistol belonging to Starovoit, who was divorced with two daughters, had been found near his body, various Russian media outlets cited law enforcement sources as saying. Some Russian media, citing law enforcement sources, also said his body had been found with a gunshot wound to the head in bushes near his car, a Tesla, rather than in the car itself. The vehicle was left near a park not far from his home in the Moscow region. Before being appointed transport minister in May 2024, Starovoit had been governor of the Kursk region for nearly five years. Three months after he became transport minister, Ukrainian troops crossed the border into Kursk in the biggest foreign incursion into Russian territory since World War II and were only pushed out earlier this year after fierce fighting and widespread destruction. In April this year, Starovoit's successor as governor and his former deputy, Alexei Smirnov, was charged with embezzling money earmarked for defence purposes amid accusations that funds intended for border defences had been stolen, leaving Kursk more vulnerable to Ukrainian attack. Various Russian media outlets reported on Monday that Smirnov had told state investigators that Starovoit had also been in on the fraud. Reuters could not confirm that, and a lawyer for Smirnov - who has pleaded not guilty to embezzlement - told the state RIA news agency that he couldn't comment. Starovoit's dismissal comes at a time of significant challenges for Russia's transport sector as the war in Ukraine drags on for a fourth year. Russia's aviation sector is short of spare parts and Russian Railways, the country's largest employer, is grappling with soaring interest costs as high rates - needed to curb higher inflation exacerbated by the war - take their toll. Long-range Ukrainian drones also frequently force Russian airports to suspend their activities for safety reasons, sometimes causing major disruption. The Kremlin said Andrei Nikitin, a former governor of the Novgorod region, had been appointed acting transport minister, and it published photographs of him shaking hands with Putin in the Kremlin. Asked about Nikitin's swift appointment, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Putin thought Nikitin had the right professional qualities and experience for the job. The transport ministry declined to comment. At his meeting with Putin, Nikitin spoke about working to digitise Russia's transport industry in an effort to reduce cargo bottlenecks and ensure smoother cross-border flows of goods.

Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide and there's no ‘client list,' Justice Department says
Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide and there's no ‘client list,' Justice Department says

RNZ News

time11 hours ago

  • RNZ News

Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide and there's no ‘client list,' Justice Department says

By Hannah Rabinowitz , CNN An undated photo obtained courtesy of the New York State Sex Offender Registry shows Jeffrey Epstein. Photo: AFP / New York State Sex Offender Registry handout After months of touting the impending release of new, blockbuster information on accused sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein, the Justice Department is set to announce Monday that there is no evidence he kept a "client list" or was murdered, a department official said. The admission would renege on promises from President Donald Trump, who previously spoke about releasing more governmental files on the disgraced financier, as well as go against years of conspiracy theories pushed by the right wing. The Justice Department does not plan to release any new documents in the matter. Axios was first to report details of the DOJ and FBI's decision. The department has also released 10 hours of jailhouse security footage that shows no one entered Epstein's jail cell on the day he died by suicide. Right-wing media figures have, for years, suggested that the government is hiding secrets relating to Epstein, who died by suicide in 2019 while awaiting trial on federal sex-trafficking charges. Some of those individuals breathlessly pushed the theory that Epstein kept a "client list" as blackmail against powerful figures who he helped commit similar crimes. After being confirmed as attorney general earlier this year, Pam Bondi quickly embraced those theories, saying in a February interview on Fox News that a client list was "sitting on my desk right now to review." She continued, "that's been a directive by President Trump. I'm reviewing that." Soon after, in conjunction with the White House, the Justice Department released a series of documents related to the Epstein investigation - almost all of which were already available in the public domain. The administration even invited influencers to get a "scoop" on the documents at the White House, and photos from the day show those influencers walking out of the White House with white binders labeled "The Epstein Files: Phase 1." Bondi promised more information would be coming, and FBI agents - many of whom were assigned to work on national security matters - were ordered to work around the clock in a frantic effort to review documents and other evidence for public release. But soon the department stopped mentioning the release, much to the chagrin of supporters who inundated the DOJ and FBI's social media with demands for new information. FBI Director Kash Patel and Deputy Director Dan Bongino, both of whom publicly questioned the investigation before being tapped for their roles, even started mentioning in interviews that there was no evidence Epstein was murdered. Bongino in May said the jailhouse video, now posted online, is "clear as day." - CNN

Jury reaches verdict in Australian mushroom murder trial
Jury reaches verdict in Australian mushroom murder trial

RNZ News

timea day ago

  • RNZ News

Jury reaches verdict in Australian mushroom murder trial

Photo: AFP / PAUL TYQUIN Jury members will deliver a verdict today in the trial of an Australian woman accused of killing three lunch guests with toxic mushrooms, court officials said. Erin Patterson, who has steadfastly maintained her innocence, has been charged with three counts of murder and one of attempted murder. The 50-year-old is charged with murdering her estranged husband's parents and aunt in July 2023 by spiking their beef-and-pastry meal with death cap mushrooms -- the world's deadliest fungi. She is also accused of attempting to murder a fourth guest - her husband's uncle - who survived after a long stay in hospital. Jurors must reach a unanimous verdict - guilty or not guilty - for each of the four charges Patterson faces. - AFP

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store