logo
Gender expert biased towards judge president Mbenenge, lawyer  says

Gender expert biased towards judge president Mbenenge, lawyer  says

Mail & Guardian01-07-2025
Eastern Cape judge president, Selby Mbenenge. (Judges Matter)
Gender expert Lisa Vetten says legal professional Andiswa Mengo's ambiguous responses to Eastern Cape judge president Selby Mbenenge's overtures
The tribunal looking into whether Mbenenge is guilty of gross misconduct for the alleged sexual harassment of Mengo
'When it comes to the complainant, you are prepared to give very sympathetic, long-winded explanations for what she says, but you do not do that when you interpret what the respondent does,' Sikhakhane said on Tuesday in his continued cross-examination of Vetten.
'As an expert, you are not here as an advocate for complainants; you are here to interpret and give objective evidence.'
He said Vetten was blunt when analysing Mbenenge's texts but sympathetic when interpreting Mengo's allegations.
The gender expert had omitted salacious texts sent by Mengo, Sikhakhane added, claiming this showed the complainant was not ambiguous in her feelings and did not regard Mbenenge as a father figure but as a romantic interest. Even when Mengo was clear in her texts, Vetten wrongly interpreted it as an avoidance strategy, he said.
'The assumption of your opinion is that, faced with the words of the complainant, you offered a different interpretation of what she said,' Sikhakhane said.
Vetten said she observed a pattern in the texts in which Mengo said one thing and did another — similar to when she said 'Will do!' in response to a request for naked photos from Mbenenge but did not send them.
Sikhakhane argued that Vetten's interpretation of Mengo as a childlike victim who could not speak up for herself
Vetten responded that her opinion of Mengo and her responses within the power dynamics was consistent with similar cases of gender-based violence she had worked on.
'My comments are based on what I read here and how I understand or see what she says,' said Vetten, adding that she had considered the heads of argument and the context of the case.
Sikhakhane responded that Vetten was making generalisations about women and sexual harassment, which did not apply to the specific case between Mengo and Mbenenge.
He added that Mengo is a 42-year-old woman who is intelligent and capable of standing up for herself when made uncomfortable by sexual advances.
Sikhakhane said Mengo had a history of belligerence in the workplace, including an incident in which she physically attacked her line manager. He said this behaviour showed that she was not timid or afraid of confrontation.
'[This] particular complainant has exhibited a propensity not to fear authority and has physically attacked her line manager.'
Vetten responded that people can shift between aggressive and passive-aggressive behaviour, adding that a history of being extroverted did not mean power dynamics did not affect a person in subtle ways.
Sikhakhane resumed his earlier argument, first made during the tribunal's initial sitting in January, that power relations are not static and that his client's case did not fit a conventional gender dynamic.
He said that power could shift during a relationship and that, during the course of their conversation, the less powerful court secretary had held power over the judge president.
Sikhakhane said Vetten lacked an understanding of cultural and linguistic nuances and was therefore unable to analyse what is appropriate during courtship between two African people.
Vetten responded that her observation was that the conversation between Mengo and Mbenenge was inappropriate for the workplace.
While she argued that it was misconduct for a judge president to pursue a junior employee, Sikhakhane said this did not constitute harassment
Sikhakhane said Vetten was a well-known gender activist who, although she had helped many women, brought bias against his client and showed sympathy for Mengo.
'If I were to testify in matters where I must choose between African people and others, I would refuse, because I would not resist the temptation of not being objective.
'Do you agree with me that a person like me or you, who has strong views about a particular side of things, can actually sacrifice objectivity and present views filled with their own feelings and idiosyncrasies?'
Vetten responded that she had served on panels before and adjudicated cases in which the evidence presented did not fit a finding of sexual harassment.
Sikhakhane argued that since Vetten had admitted to not understanding isiXhosa, her expert analysis lacked insight into prevailing cultural practices around courtship.
'Your analysis is deficient without a cultural understanding of how romantic relationships unfold in an African setup,' he said.
'If you had read the cross-examination, it would have enhanced your analysis and impacted some of the things you said, because you do not know what he said.'
Vetten said she was aware from media reports and the evidence leader's heads of argument that Mbenenge believed the relationship was consensual. However, she was not convinced when she read the WhatsApp messages.
What stood out from the messages was that, while Mengo did not explicitly reject Mbenenge, she refused to commit to any of his sexual advances.
Sikhakhane said Vetten's description of Mengo as a submissive and docile woman was inaccurate and that false claims of sexual harassment risked undermining the experiences of actual victims.
Vetten said she was aware that false claims do occur but noted that women's credibility is often undermined when they do not 'behave well' enough to fit the description of a victim.
Sikhakhane implied that Mengo was making a false claim against Mbenenge and was using the allegation of sexual harassment to attack his character, which he said undermines gender-based violence advocacy.
The judicial conduct tribunal continues until 11 July, with Mbenenge expected to bring his witnesses and testify himself.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ramaphosa hopes diplomacy amid US push for sanctions on SA
Ramaphosa hopes diplomacy amid US push for sanctions on SA

The Citizen

time8 hours ago

  • The Citizen

Ramaphosa hopes diplomacy amid US push for sanctions on SA

The US House Committee on Foreign Affairs passed a bill tabled by Republican Ronny Jackson calling for a full review of US relations with South Africa. President Cyril Ramaphosa says South Africa is in the dark about the United States' push to ban ANC leaders, hoping that diplomacy will prevail. The US House Committee on Foreign Affairs this week passed a bill tabled by Republican Ronny Jackson in April, calling for a full review of US relations with South Africa. Sanctions bill The Committee voted 34-16 on Tuesday to send the 'US-South Africa Bilateral Relations Review Act' to the full House of Representatives, where it could be subject to a vote. Jackson introduced the US-South Africa Bilateral Relations Review Act, providing tools to impose sanctions on 'corrupt South African government officials' who support America's adversaries like China, Russia and Iran, among others. ALSO READ: US Congressman Ronny Jackson introduces bill to hold SA accountable He introduced a bill that would mandate a comprehensive review of the bilateral relationship between the United States and South Africa. Jackson said Representative John James was co-leading the US-South Africa Bilateral Relations Review Act legislation. Ramaphosa responds The bill comes as relations between the US and South Africa are at an all-time low after US President Donald Trump cut financial aid to South Africa, citing Pretoria taking Israel to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and 'strengthening ties with Iran, which supports terrorism globally'. Speaking to the media after his visit to the BMW plant in Rosslyn, Pretoria, Ramaphosa said he and his administration had taken note of the passing of the bill, adding that it would not impact South Africa's approach to dealing with the United States. 'We have heard what has happened in the US House committee, and that whole process still has a long way to go,' he said. 'Discussions will be ongoing, and we don't know exactly what is driving all this.' 'Our bilateral discussions and dealings with the United States will continue, and we will talk about all manner of things, including precisely this issue and many others. We've got good diplomatic relations with the US, and we want to enrich them and make them better. So, we are very positive,' Ramaphosa said. [WATCH] President Cyril Ramaphosa says South Africa is in the dark about the United States' push to ban ANC leaders. He adds that he is positive about the outcome of engagements between the two countries.#Newzroom405 — Newzroom Afrika (@Newzroom405) July 24, 2025 ALSO READ: Is Trump about to slap sanctions on SA for misguided 'white genocide?' US tensions South Africa's relationship with the US sharply deteriorated during Donald Trump's second term, during which he has accused the government of anti-white racism and started a refugee programme for white farmers and Afrikaners. Relations were further strained following the remarks of former South African Ambassador to the US Ebrahim Rasool on Trump. Rasool was expelled by US Secretary of State Marco Rubio after he claimed in a webinar that US President Trump (and, later, Elon Musk) are leading a global white supremacist movement. Rasool was not replaced, and it was recently revealed that the US had, several months ago, rejected the South African government's appointment of Mcebisi Jonas as a special envoy to its country. The Presidency said that while Jonas, as special envoy, does not present diplomatic credentials to host countries in the way designated heads of mission or other diplomats do, he had helped facilitate trade and international relations efforts 'to reset diplomatic relations and all areas of cooperation between South Africa and the United States'. Tariffs Ramaphosa met with Trump in May amid the rapidly deteriorating relationship between the two countries. Earlier this month, the US hit South Africa with 30% tariffs 'on any and all South African products sent into the United States'. The tariff will take effect on 1 August. In a letter to Ramaphosa, Trump claimed that the steep tariffs were necessary to correct what he described as 'a persistent trade deficit between the two countries'. However, this was challenged by Ramaphosa, who said the decision was based on a flawed interpretation of trade data. ALSO READ: WATCH: Donald Trump ambushes Cyril Ramaphosa in Oval Office

Pastor accused of murdering 12-year-old family member denied bail
Pastor accused of murdering 12-year-old family member denied bail

The Herald

time19 hours ago

  • The Herald

Pastor accused of murdering 12-year-old family member denied bail

A man accused of kidnapping, raping and murdering his 12-year-old sister-in-law in Motherwell has been denied bail. It is alleged that on June 24, the 39-year-old, who is also a pastor and founder of the Holy Burning Fire Ministries of God, kidnapped Lithaliyanda Ntoni and took her to bushes in NU6, Motherwell, murdered her and set her body alight. She was reported missing after she failed to return home from a nearby shop earlier that day. Her burnt body was discovered in the bushes in the early hours of June 27. 'The state opposed bail because the murder was [allegedly] premeditated, there was a likelihood of him evading trial and he could use his influence to threaten witnesses,' National Prosecuting Authority regional spokesperson Luxolo Tyali said. The matter was postponed to August 28 for further investigation. 'The NPA remains resolute in its commitment to ensuring that justice is served for victims of violent crime, especially those who are most vulnerable in our society,' Tyali said. The Herald

Finance MMC job in Jozi a political hotbed
Finance MMC job in Jozi a political hotbed

Mail & Guardian

time19 hours ago

  • Mail & Guardian

Finance MMC job in Jozi a political hotbed

Who's next?: Johannesburg mayor Dada Morero. (X) The delay in appointing a finance MMC in the City of Johannesburg stems from the perception that the position is seen as a stepping stone to the mayoral seat, making it a hotly contested post, ANC regional sources the party due to hold its Johannesburg regional conference in September, two factions — referred to […] This content is restricted to subscribers only . Join the M&G Community Our commitment at the Mail & Guardian is to ensure every reader enjoys the finest experience. Join the M&G community and support us in delivering in-depth news to you consistently. Subscription enables: - M&G community membership - independent journalism - access to all premium articles & features - a digital version of the weekly newspaper - invites to subscriber-only events - the opportunity to test new online features first Already a subscriber?

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store