Appeals court upholds approval of Willow project on Alaska's North Slope
A federal appeals court on Friday upheld the Biden administration's approval of a major oil development on Alaska's North Slope, even though it identified one flaw with the action.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in a divided decision, said the U.S. Bureau of Land Management largely abided by federal laws when it granted approval to ConocoPhillips to develop the huge Willow project.
Despite one problem that the ruling characterized as 'minor,' the approval shall stand, said the majority opinion, written by Judge Ryan D. Nelson.
The ruling allows ConocoPhillips to keep developing Willow, which holds about 600 million barrels of reserves and is slated to produce up to 180,000 barrels per day and be the westernmost operating oil field on the North Slope. And it rejects arguments from environmental and Native plaintiffs who said the BLM approval violated requirements for considering the cumulative and climate impacts of the huge development, impacts to endangered species and other issues.
The identified flaw stems from the BLM's decision to approve a Willow development plan with three drill pads rather than the five ConocoPhillips had proposed. The scaled-back plan approved in 2023 also required ConocoPhillips to give up leases on about 68,000 acres, almost all of that in the ecologically sensitive Teshekpuk Lake area.
During the environmental study process that led to the approval decision, the BLM had expressed the position that it needed to consider full field development rather than piecemeal development, the ruling said. 'And then when it came time to issue the final approval, it never explained whether its adopted alternative satisfied the full field development standard,' the ruling said.
But that was a 'at heart, a procedural, not a substantive violation,' the ruling said. The development approval is to remain in place, the decision said. Overturning the approval is 'unwarranted because the procedural error was minor and the on-the-ground consequences (of vacating it) would be severe,' the decision said.
In a dissenting opinion, Justice Gabriel Sanchez said the flaw was serious enough to justify overturning the permit. 'BLM's errors were more fundamental than simply failing to explain how it applied the full field development standard among the alternatives it reviewed,' he said. The agency wrongly excluded consideration of smaller alternatives when it was deciding whether to allow 'the largest domestic oil drilling project on federal public lands,' he said.
Willow has been the subject of heated national debate. The discovery, on federal leases that date as far back as 1999, has inspired other exploration in the area, as well as hopes for state officials for a development renaissance on the North Slope. Oil production in the region is now less than a quarter of the 2 million-barrel-a-day peak hit in 1988.
Environmental activists, however, have described the project as a 'climate bomb' that will pour substantial new amounts of planet-heating carbon gases into the atmosphere.
Friday's ruling is the latest in a yearslong series of legal challenges that have created roadblocks to Willow development. In 2021, U.S. District Court Sharon Gleason overturned a prior approval of Willow. She ordered the BLM to complete a formal supplemental environmental impact statement to better analyze climate impacts and impacts to threatened polar bears. The 2023 project approval is the product of that supplemental study.
ConocoPhillips, which is already well into Willow construction and plans to spend at least $7 billion on development, described Friday's ruling as good news.
'ConocoPhillips welcomes the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decision, which allows construction on the Willow project to continue. We recently completed another significant winter construction season, and the project remains on track for first oil in 2029,' company spokesperson Rebecca Boys said by email.
'We look forward to continuing the responsible development of Willow, which will enhance American energy security while expanding local employment opportunities and providing extensive benefits to Alaska Native communities and the State of Alaska.'
Over the past winter season, crews delivered modular structures and worked on road, pad, bridge, work camp and pipeline construction, Boys said.
That work was allowed to proceed because the 9th Circuit Court in December denied the plaintiffs' motion for a restraining order blocking it.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs in the case had mixed responses to Friday's decision.
Some were highly critical.
'This decision is bad news for the planet and anyone who cares about the impacts of industrialization on communities now and in the future,' Bridget Psarianos, an attorney with the environmental law firm Trustees for Alaska, said in a statement.
'The bureau is required under the law to protect the western Arctic's sensitive ecosystem and the subsistence users who rely on them. But the agency did not minimize the harm from this project on the Arctic's people, animals, habitat, and the planet in a real way, in violation of the law. There is too much at stake to gloss over the harm this project will do,' said Psarianos, who is representing some of the plaintiffs.
It will probably be fairly simple for the BLM to address the court-identified flaw, Psarianos said in a follow-up email. The agency could submit a report or a memorandum explaining its reasoning, leaving the approval unaffected, she said.
Other plaintiff representatives portrayed the ruling as a vindication, albeit a partial one.
'Today's ruling is a significant step forward for Alaska's North Slope,' Hallie Templeton, legal director for plaintiff Friends of the Earth, said in a statement. 'We hope that this will push BLM to heed the significant risks that Willow poses and deny it for good. While this should be the final straw for the doomed Willow Project, we will continue fighting to prevent this carbon bomb project from destroying one of our last remaining wild places.'
A spokesperson for the BLM declined to comment, citing the agency's policies on litigation.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
Trump in midst of his own ‘Golden Age' as list of accomplishments wows critics: ‘Nothing short of remarkable'
WASHINGTON — President Trump is at the height of his political power following Thursday's passage of his 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' – capping a remarkable two-week streak of domestic and foreign policy feats that even Democrats are calling impressive. Trump, 79, will sign the bill fulfilling his major campaign pledges – including to cut taxes on tips, overtime and Social Security benefits – at a pre-fireworks Independence Day party on the White House lawn. B-2 stealth bombers will fly over the celebration in recognition of their role in the Trump-ordered June 21 US airstrikes on Iran's nuclear program, which was followed two days later by an equally unprecedented Trump-brokered cease-fire between Israel and Iran. 3 President Trump poses before boarding Air Force One en route to a Thursday night rally in Iowa. AFP via Getty Images The commander in chief, riding high on that diplomatic coup, strong-armed NATO nations at the alliance's annual conference to boost military spending to 5% of their GDP by 2035, after complaining for years that US allies were freeloading off American taxpayers. He returned home to good news from the Supreme Court, which handed him wins on deporting illegal immigrants to third countries and restricting nationwide injunctions by district court judges — while CBS's parent company agreed to fork over $16 million for deceptively editing an interview last year with Trump's election rival, then-Vice President Kamala Harris. Over the weekend, Canada scrapped a digital services tax against US internet giants under pressure from Trump, followed days later by the University of Pennsylvania stripping honors from transgender swimmer Lia Thomas and the announcement of a pending trade deal with Vietnam – as major stock market indices notched record highs and illegal border crossings hit new record lows. The Big Beautiful Bill Act also includes $25 billion in funding for Trump's 'Golden Dome' missile defense program, spends more on immigration enforcement, allows tax deductions for domestic car loan interest and — in a major win for New York and New Jersey Republicans — lifts the cap on the amount of state and local taxes that can be deducted from federal returns to $40,000 from the prior $10,000. 'I didn't vote for him and I'm not always aligned with his approach, but his success on the domestic and international front in such a compressed period of time is nothing short of remarkable and it's all due to his impressive use of political and executive power,' Michael LaRosa, a former Biden White House spokesman, told The Post. 'The last two weeks of his presidency are a throwback to the strong leadership styles reminiscent of LBJ or Reagan, both of whom engendered such personal and political loyalty within their parties, that they could muscle through historic success out of sheer goodwill.' A different Biden White House official, who served all four years in the Democratic administration, said Trump has 'hit a stride' and marveled at his ability to pressure holdout Republicans into voting for the major legislation despite centrist reluctance over Medicaid and SNAP cuts and conservative demands for deeper spending reductions. 3 House Republicans celebrate the passage of Trump's 'One Big Beautful Bill Act' Thursday. Getty Images 'You voted for it because you're scared of the guy. And frankly, that's impressive, given that Biden never invoked fear in anyone,' the former Biden aide said of the GOP holdouts, all but two of whom eventually backed the bill. 'Successful campaigns and successful operations excel when they are provided clarity in mission from their leader — in this case President Trump,' said Chris LaCivita, who ran Trump's 2024 campaign alongside current White House chief of staff Susie Wiles. 'Elections matter because you now have one of the greatest realignments in political history happening and being backed up by policy. If you work, pay taxes and aspire for a better tomorrow, you are voting Republican,' LaCivita said, describing the working-class reforms encompassed in the bill, which also made permanent Trump's 2017 tax cuts to all brackets. 'If you're dour, rich and generally hold people that don't agree with [you] in contempt – and you don't know what a woman is – you're a Democrat. This transformation in political power is because of the leadership and determination of one person — President Trump.' 3 B-2 stealth bombers will fly over the Fourth of July bill-signing celebration on the White House lawn. AP Kellyanne Conway, senior counselor to Trump during his first term, declared 'these have been the most consequential two weeks of Trump's second term, as he makes peace deals, trade deals and tax deals, everywhere all at once.' 'And he's just getting started. America is in its Golden Age,' Conway said. 'The snark and bark of his petty critics is muted and meaningless. If you can't beat him, join him. Sit back and enjoy a nation that is sovereign, secure and prosperous. We are the envy of the world and Trump is just getting started.' 'President Trump is on a roll,' said Vivek Ramaswamy, the former Republican presidential candidate and current contender for Ohio governor. 'By 2026, it will be up to the states to lead the way on other critical fronts, like solving the educational achievement crisis in our country.' Trump's trail of triumphs precedes a significant deadline next week for the sealing of bilateral trade deals to avert 'reciprocal' levies on foreign countries — which could dramatically increase US consumer costs and drive up inflation, which has cooled this year. Trump has given countries until July 9 to reach agreements to avert high rates, but thus far has only announced the outlines of deals with China, the UK and Vietnam, along with a 'roadmap' with India. Publicly, the president has brushed off concern about the rate of dealmaking and said he will decree new rates when next week instead of pushing the deadline. Trump also has thus far failed to cajole Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell into lowering interest rates — causing the cost of homes, credit card balances and loans to remain high despite inflation nearing the Fed's target of 2%. Trump has said he will allow Powell to remain in his role until his term expires next May, and that he intends to appoint a replacement who will promptly drop rates by at least 2 percentage points. But for now, Trump's series of successes offer momentum – with polling showing he's getting credit for a strong economy, typically a top concern of voters, ahead of next year's midterm election, which will determine whether the later half of his term is plagued by probes by congressional Democrats. 'It's becoming increasingly evident that Donald Trump is the dominant political figure so far of the 21st Century,' said American University professor Leonard Steinhorn, who teaches public communication and history courses. But Steinhorn added that Trump's administration contrasts with other powerful American presidents who – at least fleetingly – held broad-based national support. 'As dominant as Donald Trump is today, he's especially dominant over the Republican Party … But let's not forget that he presides over half a country that believes that he is taking us on a very bad path, and to many people on a path to authoritarian or autocratic rule.' LaRosa, the former Biden White House aide, said he hopes that fellow Democrats will learn from Trump's unexpected political abilities. 'Even though I may disagree with him substantively, his effective use of power as an executive and party leader, despite congressional margins or ideological diversity, is something to admire for those of us who are practitioners of politics,' LaRosa said. 'Instead of reflexively ridiculing his style and the fact that he uses the latitude he's been afforded so skillfully, Democrats should learn from him and replicate it the next time we have the keys.'


Politico
8 hours ago
- Politico
Why smuggle chips when you can remote in?
With help from Mohar Chatterjee In the global race to control the most powerful new technologies, America has used aggressive export controls to cut off China's access to high-end microchips. And smugglers have grown ever more creative in evading them: paying students to pack them alongside clothes in luggage, mislabeling shipments as toys or tea, stowing them in container trucks filled with an assortment of other electronics. But there's an easier way for China to tap into the computing power of those microchips: just access them remotely with cloud computing. Last year, Reuters found that at least 11 companies or state-backed entities from China had sought out U.S. cloud services as a back-door way to access the computing power of restricted chips. 'This was always a gaping blind spot that policymakers are waking up to,' said Barath Harithas, a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. 'What's the point of spending all these efforts on smuggling of chips if you can just access the computing capacity remotely?' Lawmakers are trying to close this loophole by extending export controls to cloud computing services. But that effort is about to get a lot trickier — thanks to none other than President Donald Trump. The giant data center deals Trump recently announced in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates could make it even harder to restrict China's access to computing power by basing providers outside the U.S. 'These countries in the Gulf maintain close relationships with Chinese counterparts and maintain a political position between the U.S. and China,' said Janet Egan, a senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security (CNAS). 'That concerns me when I think about Chinese actors accessing vast amounts of compute.' Controlling computing overseas goes back to the Cold War, and it's been evolving in the AI age. The Biden administration blocked the export of AI chips to China in 2022. It's since tightened the throttle with controls on more chips and on chipmaking equipment. Compared to that push to control hardware, the U.S. has taken a much less focused approach to remote cloud access for AI. The Biden administration packed 'know your customer' rules into its AI diffusion framework issued in January; Trump scrapped that rule in May. Trump's Commerce Department is currently working on a replacement rule, though it's unclear whether it will include cloud provisions. 'It sounds like the administration is still figuring out [the cloud] as it tries to determine what it wants a diffusion rule to look like,' said Michael Horowitz, who served as a deputy assistant secretary of defense under former President Joe Biden and is a scholar on emerging technologies. The Commerce Department did not respond to DFD's questions about the replacement rule. Congress has yet to pass a bill on remote cloud access. In 2024 security report on DeepSeek, the House Select Committee on China recommended 'remote access controls' on all data centers. A bill from Rep. Mike Lawler (R-N.Y.) to extend export controls to the cloud, and block 'CCP-aligned companies' from accessing U.S. technology remotely, advanced out of the House Foreign Affairs Committee in April. 'Closing this loophole is essential to preventing our adversaries like China from accessing restricted technology,' Lawler's communications director Ciro Riccardi told DFD. There's a tension embedded into the cloud computing question. Some Chinese customers use U.S. cloud services for innocuous purposes, like storage or video games, rather than military or AI development – and that can be a good thing, said Sam Winter-Levy, a fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. 'So long as the world's AI computing activities stay tethered to the U.S. cloud, policymakers can bake some degree of transparency into the system,' he said. At the same time, Chinese users have been documented trying to set up accounts on Amazon Web Services and Microsoft Azure to access the advanced computing power needed for training AI models – not illegal but also not desirable in light of U.S. policy. In the absence of a government rulebook, cloud companies have implemented some safeguards like 'know your customer' standards on their own – for example, Amazon may require appointing a legal representative and submitting certain identity documents and financial information, depending on the type of use. Where remote access gets dicier is overseas, according to Egan of CNAS. 'As we start to export more chips around the world, particularly in regions like the Gulf, we need more guidelines,' she said. In May, Trump announced a series of AI deals while on a tour of the Middle East, which would result in the sale of tens of thousands of the U.S.'s most advanced AI chips to build data centers in Saudi Arabia and the UAE. The Trump administration has cheered on these ventures, including their implications for cloud computing. 'American companies will operate the data centers and offer American-managed cloud services throughout the region,' Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said in a statement. 'These are America First deals that drive investment into the U.S., improve our trade balance, and lock in American technology as the global standard,' White House AI and crypto czar David Sacks wrote in a May post on X. Critics including House China Chair John Moolenaar (R-Mich.) called for scrutiny of the deals, especially in light of Gulf countries' alliances with China. But it's unclear what guardrails exist on the deals, for the chips themselves or the data centers they will power. When asked about the security of the Gulf data centers, the White House pointed DFD to a fact sheet stating that agreements in the UAE include 'strong protections to prevent the diversion of U.S.-origin technology.' Amazon and Microsoft have also inked deals to help those Middle Eastern companies develop their cloud services. Asked about their cloud security measures for those Gulf projects, Amazon said 'AWS complies with all applicable U.S. laws, including trade laws.' Microsoft pointed DFD to a press release stating that its UAE partnership includes a commitment 'to world-leading standards in AI safety and security.' Chris Miller, a Tufts University semiconductor historian and author of 'Chip War,' said the current approach leaves Big Tech companies largely responsible for policing who uses their cloud services, especially when it comes to the data centers planned for the Middle East. 'Different countries and governments have different interests,' Miller said. 'This seems to me to be just as important, if not more important, as where physically the chips and servers are.' EU firms want an AI moratorium too European companies are pushing for a pause on AI regulations, and what they're asking sounds an awful lot like the failed effort backed by Silicon Valley to pause state AI law enforcement in the megabill. As POLITICO's Eliza Gkritsi reports, 46 leaders of the European Union's biggest firms – including Airbus, Mistral, and Mercedes-Benz – sent an open letter Thursday asking Brussels for a two-year delay on implementing its AI Act, which is set to go into effect on Aug. 2. They complain of 'unclear, overlapping and increasingly complex EU regulations' as being a major obstacle to scaling AI systems and competing on a global level. The pause would allow for 'further simplification of the new rules,' they said. The AI Act, which the EU passed last year, includes an overarching set of rules regulating AI systems like chatbots and facial recognition. Those rules include transparency requirements, restrictions on AI-powered surveillance, and a ban on biometric systems that classify peoples' protected characteristics like race. Companies like Meta and Google have criticized the AI Act as unworkable. Henna Virkkunen, the EU's technology chief, told POLITICO that she would decide by the end of August whether to delay enactment of the legislation. THE KOSA POWER PLAY THAT SANK THE AI MORATORIUM At the center of Sen. Marsha Blackburn's decision this week to withdraw support for an artificial intelligence measure she worked on with Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) was her Kids Online Safety Act, according to four people familiar with the situation, POLITICO's Ruth Reader and Mohar Chatterjee report. Those four people, granted anonymity to discuss private negotiations, said Blackburn (R-Tenn.) hoped a compromise to limit the scope and span of the 10-year AI moratorium would allow her to advance her KOSA legislation to markup in the Senate Commerce Committee, which Cruz chairs. The amendment she worked out with Cruz would have allowed states to enforce laws passed in recent years to keep kids safe from online sexual predators, bullying, drug sales and other negative health impacts, but it prevented states from putting 'undue or disproportionate burden' on AI systems. After a coalition of 130 organizations said they opposed that amendment, Blackburn went to Cruz on Monday and tried to get the 'undue or disproportionate burden' language removed from the bill. But Cruz wouldn't budge, one of the people said. By Monday night, Blackburn changed her amendment with Cruz to include KOSA as a symbolic move, three of the people said. She then partnered with Senate Commerce ranking member Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.) to strike the original AI moratorium from the megabill, which lawmakers approved with a 99-1 vote. Cruz's office didn't return a request for comment, and Blackburn's office declined to comment. post of the day THE FUTURE IN 5 LINKS


The Hill
8 hours ago
- The Hill
Biden: GOP megabill ‘reckless,' ‘cruel'
Former President Biden said that President Trump's 'big, beautiful bill' is 'reckless' and 'cruel' after it passed the House on Thursday. 'The Republican budget bill is not only reckless — it's cruel. It slashes Medicaid and takes away health care from millions of Americans,' Biden said on X. 'It closes rural hospitals and cuts food assistance for our veterans and seniors. It jacks up energy bills. And it could trigger deep cuts to Medicare while driving up the deficit by $4 trillion. All of this to give a massive tax break to billionaires,' he added. 'Working people deserve better.' On Thursday, House Republicans passed the core of Trump's domestic policy agenda, featuring sweeping tax cuts, an immigration crackdown, a boost in energy production and significant cuts in Medicaid. The bill made its way through Congress despite fierce opposition from Democrats and a few Republicans. In a post on X Thursday, the House Democrats said on their official account that their GOP colleagues 'just passed their One Big Ugly Bill that rewards billionaires while throwing 17 million Americans off their health insurance.' 'People will get sicker. Hospitals will close. Children and seniors will go hungry,' they added. House Republican leadership reveled in the megabill's passage on Thursday, saying in a statement that 'Republicans in Congress have succeeded in our mission to enact President Trump's America First agenda.' 'And importantly, we did it in record time, so that the effects of this nation-shaping legislation can be felt by the American people as soon as possible,' they added.