Abuse victims say they saw progress under Pope Francis, just not enough
DUBLIN (Reuters) - When Pope Francis sat with his head in his hands and listened to accounts of clerical sexual abuse for an hour longer than scheduled during a trip to Dublin in 2018, many of those present were deeply moved.
But not all were convinced that Francis, who died on Monday, was doing enough with his papacy to heal the damage done by decades of stark failures by the Church.
"I don't think anyone can do enough," said Rev. Paddy McCafferty, who was sexually abused as a young adult in the 1980s by a fellow member of the clergy and was one of eight victims to recount their stories that day.
"I think he did his best," he said.
Francis took over a Church whose authority was shattered in many parts of the world by abuse scandals and he made addressing the issue a priority as further historical revelations from Chile to New Zealand pockmarked his 12-year papacy.
But, while he showed a deeper understanding of the toll decades of clerical sexual abuse took on victims, measures to make the Catholic Church more accountable did not live up to the expectations he set, survivors and advocacy groups said.
"The damage is so extensive and massive that it's going to take a long, long time for the Church to go any way towards repairing the hurt and the harm to the Church's mission," McCafferty said.
Francis created the Vatican's first anti-abuse commission, became the first pope to expel a cardinal from the priesthood for sexual abuse and installed a global system for Catholics to report suspicions of abuse or cover-ups by bishops.
Campaigners said more action was needed, however, on things such as naming offending priests and Church officials who protected them.
"He gave survivors a lot of hope when he came into office, promising transparency and change," said Marie Collins, another of the eight who spoke at the 2018 Dublin meeting and was abused by a priest at the age of 13 in 1960s Ireland.
"We did get some but I don't think it has gone any way far enough. Things are not as bad as they were, that is for sure but they also are not as good as they could be."
'TREMENDOUS DISAPPOINTMENT'
Collins was one of the original members of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors that was founded in 2014.
She quit in frustration in 2017, saying it was hobbled by internal resistance, while another founding member, Rev. Hans Zollner, resigned unexpectedly in 2023, citing concerns over the way it was operating.
For some, the commission stands as a stark illustration of what some campaigners say were the shortcomings of Francis' reforms.
It issued an annual report for the first time last year, with recommendations including advocating for more effective punishment of offending clergy, but also highlighting how it struggled to engage some local Catholic communities in the course of its work.
Some changes won wider approval, including two major pieces of legislation enacted in 2019 following an unprecedented four-day meeting on child sex abuse.
The first instituted new reporting procedures and broadened the definition of sexual crimes to include vulnerable adults. The second removed strict confidentiality rules, known as "pontifical secrecy", which Church officials admitted had hindered sharing of information with police in some countries.
Still, criticism remained over the Church's continued insularity on the issue and lack of external oversight.
Anne Barrett Doyle, co-director of the Bishop Accountability abuse tracking group, said Francis' inability to deliver on his promises was "a tremendous disappointment" that would forever tarnish the legacy of an otherwise remarkable man.
"He wanted to quell the outrage, and he did make some modest improvements, but kids around the world are still in danger of sexual assault by Catholic clergy because of what Pope Francis failed to do," said Boston native Doyle, who began her work after a succession of devastating stories in 2002 revealed the city's archdiocese had covered up sexual misconduct for decades.
Juan Carlos Cruz was abused as a teenager in his native Chile by a notorious paedophile priest. He was invited to join the commission in 2018 and remains a member.
He also became a close friend of Pope Francis, who after initially dismissing claims of a cover-up of abuse in the Chilean church as "slander", apologised to Cruz in a tearful, three-hour meeting before dismissing all of Chile's bishops.
Cruz said while he understood other victims' decisions to leave the commission, he wanted to fight from inside the tent.
He highlighted the commission's work in creating safe spaces for abuse victims, and broaching the thorny topic of "economic, spiritual and psychological reparations".
"I remain very hopeful," he said. "Whatever the new pope decides to do is fine, but as a human being I'm going to honour the memory of Francis and keep fighting."
'LIFE CHANGING'
For abuse survivors, Francis' legacy on the issue is a mixed one of powerful words and at times underwhelming deeds.
To many, the words did matter. A third member at the Dublin meeting - which was held during the first papal visit in almost four decades to a country rocked by a series of abuse scandals - described the experience as "life-changing".
Clodagh Malone, one of tens of thousands of babies born in Church-run homes for unmarried mothers and their offspring that a 2021 inquiry found had an "appalling" mortality rate, said it allowed her to share for the first time that she had also been abused by a priest when she was younger.
After the Dublin engagement, Francis met similar groups of survivors during trips to Canada, Belgium and Portugal. Some victims expressed frustration on those visits at a lack of concrete actions.
Bishop Accountability chief Doyle said what was required from Francis' successor was action to permanently remove abusers from ministry, decisively punish enablers and follow through on long-promised transparency by releasing names of offending clergy and complicit bishops.
"I'd like to see the next pope institute real policies with real teeth," Collins said.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CNBC
40 minutes ago
- CNBC
Trump announces 'massive' trade deal with Japan, setting tariffs at 15%
Key Points Trump said that Japan will invest $550 billion into the United States, adding that the U.S. will "receive 90% of the Profits." He also said Japan will "open their Country to Trade including Cars and Trucks, Rice and certain other Agricultural Products, and other things." Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba said that auto tariffs on Tokyo will be lowered to 15%, according to Reuters. Shortly after the deal announcement, Japan's top trade negotiator, Ryosei Akazawa, said "#Mission Accomplished," in a post on X. VIDEO04:39 Pres. Trump announces 'massive' trade deal with Japan: Here are the details President Donald Trump on Tuesday stateside announced a "massive" deal with Japan that includes "reciprocal" tariffs of 15% on the country's exports to the U.S., with auto duties reportedly being lowered to that level as well. In a post on Truth Social, Trump called the agreement "perhaps the largest Deal ever made," while adding that Japan would invest $550 billion in the United States and the U.S. would "receive 90% of the Profits." Trump said that Japan will "open their Country to Trade including Cars and Trucks, Rice and certain other Agricultural Products, and other things." The U.S. president added that the deal would create "Hundreds of Thousands of Jobs." Following Trump's post, Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba said that auto tariffs on Tokyo will be lowered to 15% — from the current 25% that is levied across countries — as part of the deal, Reuters reported. Auto exports to the U.S. are a cornerstone of Japan's economy, making up 28.3% of all shipments in 2024, according to customs data. "A year ago, that level of tariffs [15%] would be shocking. Today, we breathe a sigh of relief," Brian Jacobsen, chief economist at Annex Wealth Management, told CNBC. Japanese auto exports to the U.S. fell 26.7% in June, extending May's 24.7% plunge. The country's overall exports to the U.S. — its second largest trading partner — stood at 10.3 trillion yen ($70.34 billion) between January and June, a 0.8% year-on-year drop. Shortly after Tuesday's announcement, Japan's top trade negotiator, Ryosei Akazawa, said"#Mission Accomplished," in a post on X, and expressed "heartfelt thanks to everyone involved," according to a Google translation of his remarks in Japanese. Trump, in a speech that followed his Truth Social post, said that Japan and the U.S. were also concluding an additional deal involving liquified natural gas. "We have Europe coming in tomorrow, and the next day, we have some other ones coming in," he added, without specifying any details. Political turmoil The trade deal could strengthen Ishiba's leadership as it comes just days after Japan's governing coalition lost its majority in the country's upper house elections. Ishiba had said after the upper house loss that he would stay on as prime minister, but Japan's Mainichi Newspaper reported Wednesday that the prime minister intended to announce his resignation by August, according to a Google translation of the report in Japanese. Japanese media outlet Yomiuri had reported earlier in the day that Ishiba would decide whether to stay on as prime minister after assessing the progress of the tariff negotiations. HSBC said in a note Monday that "For Prime Minister Ishiba, a favourable U.S. trade deal could help stave off a no-confidence motion or internal challenge from the LDP [Liberal Democratic Party]." Japan's markets jumped after the deal announcement, with major auto stocks soaring, some over 10%, while the broader Nikkei 225 gained more than 2%. Shares in Japan's Honda rose over 8%, while Toyota climbed above 11%. Nissan jumped more than 8%, and Mazda Motor surged 17%. Mitsubishi Motors popped 13%. In his tariff letter sent to Japan earlier this month, Trump had threatened 25% levies on the country's exports from Aug. 1, one percentage point higher from the 24% rate announced during his April 2 "Liberation Day" tariffs. Jeremy Schwartz, global CIO at asset manager Wisdomtree told CNBC's "Squawk Box Asia" that the size of the market reaction meant that the market "got very pessimistic on how things were progressing, overly pessimistic."Schwartz also said Trump was using these deals to not just even out the trade deficit, but also to drive strategic spending in the U.S., such as a planned investment by Softbank, OpenAI and Oracle of up to $500 billion in artificial intelligence infrastructure over the next four years.


New York Post
41 minutes ago
- New York Post
Felon who allegedly barreled car through LA nightclub crowd faces 37 attempted murder charges
A convicted felon who allegedly drove his car through a crowd of people outside a Los Angeles nightclub over the weekend has been indicted. Fernando Ramirez, 29, of San Clemente, faces 37 charges of attempted murder and 37 counts of assault with a deadly weapon, all felonies, from a crash that left 37 injured outside the Vermont Hollywood nightclub Saturday night. Advertisement 'We understand that this brazen act has shaken the community and, but for the good grace of God, this could have been a mass casualty incident,' LA County District Attorney Nathan Hochman said, according to WPLG. Hochman said eight people suffered 'great bodily injury.' 'When he drove that car onto that sidewalk, he aimed it at a whole sea of pedestrians that were in front of him on the sidewalk at 2 a.m.,' Hochman said. The victims were mostly women waiting to enter the Hollywood nightclub when Ramirez allegedly ran them down in his Nissan Versa. Advertisement 5 Fernando Ramirez faces 37 charges of attempted murder and 37 counts of assault with a deadly weapon from the July 19 crash. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation 5 The victims were mostly women waiting to enter the Hollywood nightclub when Ramirez allegedly ran them down in his Nissan Versa. AXN NEWS via REUTERS The vehicle also traveled over a food vending cart and a valet stand. Adding to the chaos, bystanders reportedly pulled Ramirez from his disabled vehicle and assaulted him. During the altercation, a man pulled a gun and shot Ramirez. Advertisement Police are still searching for that suspect. 5 Fernando Ramirez faces 37 charges of attempted murder and 37 counts of assault with a deadly weapon from the July 19 crash. @LAPDPIO/X 5 Officials search the scene where Ramirez's car crashed outside the nightclub. AP 5 First responders check on injured patrons outside the Vermont Hollywood after the crash. AXN NEWS via REUTERS Advertisement Ramirez has a lengthy criminal history and was out of prison on parole at the time of the crash. KNBC reported he was convicted of felony battery from an attack on a man outside a Whole Foods in 2019 and sentenced to prison the following year. It is unclear whether his parole release was related to that conviction. The report said Ramirez has at least '11 criminal cases ranging from misdemeanors to felonies' since 2014, citing the Orange County District Attorney's Office. The 2014 charge was gang-related, and Ramirez has a pending 2024 drunk driving case and a pending 2022 domestic violence case that are both unresolved. He faces life in prison if convicted on the charges related to the car ramming. Fox News Digital's Greg Norman contributed to this report.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Explainer-Zelenskiy's move against Ukraine's anti-corruption agencies
By Dan Peleschuk KYIV (Reuters) -Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy is under pressure at home and abroad for stripping the independence of anti-corruption agencies whose work is seen as essential to Kyiv's path to join the European Union. Amendments giving his appointed prosecutor more power over the two investigative bodies have drawn criticism from top EU officials and sparked the country's largest wartime protests. Here is what it means: WHAT ARE UKRAINE'S ANTI-CORRUPTION AGENCIES? The National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU) and the Specialised Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office (SAPO) were set up after a 2014 revolution toppled a pro-Russian president and set Kyiv on a Western course. They are responsible for independently weeding out high-level graft, a central requirement for Ukraine to receive billions of dollars in Western aid and join the 27-member EU. The agencies have stepped up their work during Russia's full-scale invasion, producing charges against lawmakers, senior government officials and a former deputy head of Zelenskiy's administration. Last month, they accused a deputy prime minister of accepting a $345,000 kickback. WHY HAVE THEIR POWERS BEEN CURBED? In a late-night address on Tuesday, Zelenskiy said the agencies needed to be "cleansed" of Russian influence and their work strengthened and sped up. A day earlier, Kyiv's domestic security agency had arrested two NABU officials on suspicion of ties to Russia and conducted sweeping searches into agency employees, a move critics described as excessive. The new measures, which were fast-tracked in large part by Zelenskiy's ruling party, allow the general prosecutor to transfer cases away from the agencies and re-assign prosecutors, several lawmakers said. Critics, including an anti-corruption campaigner charged this month with fraud and evading military service, have alleged the crackdown was a politically motivated response to their work. WHAT WAS THE REACTION? After the vote, the EU's enlargement commissioner said she was "seriously concerned" about the measures, and on Wednesday Germany's foreign minister warned Kyiv against hampering its path to the EU. At home, thousands of Ukrainians rallied in Kyiv just steps away from the site of the 2014 uprising, which itself was sparked by a democratic rollback and threats to Ukraine's European integration. Fighting corruption and embracing the West, especially since Moscow's 2022 invasion, are seen as critical to erasing a legacy of Russian rule. Ukrainians are furious at signs of corruption and misrule at a time when tens of thousands of troops have been killed on the front fending off Russia. "My brother didn't die for this kind of future," read a placard at the Kyiv protest. WHAT'S NEXT? On Wednesday, Zelenskiy said he had met with anti-corruption and security officials to hash out a joint plan within two weeks to better combat corruption. Writing on X, he said the officials would aim to "resolve existing contradictions, and eliminate threats". "We all hear what society is saying," he said. "We see what people expect from state institutions." Still, NABU and SAPO said in a joint statement on Wednesday that they wanted their independence restored through legislation. Meanwhile, lawmakers pledged to challenge the amendments while Ukrainians on social media called for continuing public protests. Solve the daily Crossword