'Facts can no longer be concealed': Labor's renewables push undermined by CSIRO report proving coal is 'king', energy expert claims
Speaking to Sky News, Mr Morrison refuted Labor's claims renewable energy was the best path forward and said the CSIRO's 'own numbers' in its recent GenCost report showed coal was cheaper than firmed integrated renewables.
In the report, black coal cost $111 per megawatt hour at the lowest end of annual forecasts while backed-up wind and solar was $116 MWh under the cheapest model.
Last year's report had black coal in second place at $107 MWh compared to firmed renewables, which were in first place at $97 MWh.
Energy Minister Chris Bowen, however, said the CSIRO report showed renewables, backed by batteries and transmission, was the cheapest form of energy.
'Much cheaper than nuclear and the Liberal Party remains committed to nuclear, the most expensive form of the energy, rejected by the Australian people,' he said.
Mr Morrison said the headline from the GenCost report should be: 'Coal is the king of low cost energy'.
'CSIRO's own numbers in this report actually say that coal is now cheaper to build than firmed integrated renewables,' he said.
Mr Morrison claimed the CSIRO demonstrated coal was now the cheapest form of electricity for consumers, but had 'bent over backwards' to conceal the truth.
'In particular, the estimation for the cost of firm renewables, that is providing all the gas and the transmission and the storage to make that intermittent feast and famine energy into reliable electricity,' he said.
'Last time they told us that that was between $42 and $48. This time they're saying it's between $48 and $64. There is literally no overlap between draft and final between those two different estimates for how much it costs to firm renewables."
Mr Morrison said the CSIRO had 'moved the goalposts' by adding 'caveat words' to its website such as 'low-carbon electricity', referring to renewables.
'They are literally shifting the goal posts in front of our eyes when they are no longer able, in their own analysis, to sustain the argument… that renewables are not just environmentally virtuous but also economically virtuous,' he said.
'The facts can no longer be concealed.'
Mr Morrison said the CSIRO's report could not be 'taken seriously'.
Earlier on Tuesday, the CSIRO refused to reveal its modelling on the cost of the renewable energy transition, sparking transparency concerns over the Albanese government's push for net zero.
Among those voicing their concerns was shadow energy minister Dan Tehan, who pointed to the final GenCost report released by the CSIRO in which it said the modelling on its renewable integration costs was 'not suitable for general release'.
Mr Tehan said the government needed to release the information given its broken $275 power bill reduction promise.
'Why? This is our leading scientific organisation and it will not release the modelling on these costs they are putting forward,' Mr Tehan said.
'Nothing in this report goes to that fact. As a matter of fact, all we see now is our leading scientific organisations saying they cannot release that model. Well, I think the government needs to explain why.
'The cost is being hidden by this government.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Canberra Times
31 minutes ago
- Canberra Times
Australia's road toll hits 15-year high
In fact, rather than reducing the road toll by 50 per cent, the strategy agreed to by all Australian governments in 2021 led to a 21.1 per cent increase in road fatalities over the following four years, with road deaths up 3.3 per cent in the year to June 2025, and at their highest level for any year-to-June period since 2010.
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Australia holds onto 10 per cent tariff rate from the US
The Albanese government is claiming victory after US President Donald Trump's deadline passed. The Australian government has secured rare certainty, locking in a 10 per cent tariff rate from the US. Countries who failed to strike a deal with Washington ahead of the negotiation deadline are facing significant tariffs, such as India and Taiwan, which received levies of 20 per cent and above. Israel, Japan, and the EU have been slapped with a 15 per cent tariff rate. The government maintains it doesn't want to stop here, arguing Australia should be trading under a reciprocal rate of zero. Tariffs are likely to disrupt global supply chains, leading to less spending, particularly on investment.
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
Markets plummet as Trump issues more steep tariffs
US President Donald Trump's latest wave of tariffs on exports from dozens of trading partners sent global stock markets tumbling and countries and companies scrambling to seek ways to strike better deals. As Trump presses ahead with plans to reorder the global economy with the highest tariff rates since the early 1930s, Switzerland, "stunned" by 39 per cent tariffs, sought more talks, as did India, hit with a 25 per cent rate. New tariffs announced on Friday also included a 35 per cent duty on many goods from Canada, 50 per cent for Brazil, 20 per cent for Taiwan, which said its rate was "temporary" and it expected to reach a lower figure. The presidential order listed higher import duty rates of 10 per cent to 41 per cent starting in a week's time for 69 trading partners, taking the US effective tariff rate to about 18 per cent, from 2.3 per cent last year, according to analysts at Capital Economics. US stocks took a hit. By afternoon on Friday, the Dow Jones Industrial Average had dropped 1.46 per cent to 43,486.45, the S&P 500 1.8 per cent to 6,225.55 and the Nasdaq Composite 2.42 per cent to 20,610.91. Markets were also reacting to a disappointing jobs report. Data showed US job growth slowed more than expected in July while the prior month's data was revised sharply lower, pointing to a slowdown in the labour market. Global shares stumbled, with Europe's STOXX 600 tumbling 1.89 per cent on the day. Trump's new tariffs have created yet more uncertainty, with many details unclear. They are set to take effect on August 7, a White House official said. Trump administration officials defended the president's approach saying the uncertainty was "critical" for him to be able to leverage a better deal. "The trade deals we've seen over the last few weeks... have been nothing short of monumental," Council of Economic Advisers Chair Stephen Miran said on CNBC. Trump's tariff rollout also comes amid evidence they have begun driving up prices of home furnishings and household equipment. Australian products could become more competitive in the US market, helping businesses boost exports, Trade Minister Don Farrell said, after Trump kept the minimum tariff rate of 10 per cent for Australia. The European Union, which struck a framework deal with Trump on Sunday, is still awaiting more Trump orders to deliver on agreed carve-outs, including on cars and aircraft, EU officials said, saying the latest executive orders did not cover that. Switzerland said it would push for a "negotiated solution" with the US, with industry insiders saying they were "stunned" by the 39 per cent tariffs. South Africa's Trade Minister Parks Tau said he was seeking "real, practical interventions" to defend jobs and the economy against the 30 per cent US tariff it faces. Southeast Asian countries largely breathed a sigh of relief after the US tariffs on their exports that were lower than threatened and leveled the playing field with a rate of about 19 per cent across the region's biggest economies. Thailand's finance minister said a reduction from 36 per cent to 19 per cent would help his country's economy. While India is in talks after being slapped with a 25 per cent tariff, which could impact about $US40 billion ($A62 billion) worth of its exports. Trump issued a separate order for Canada that raises the rate on Canadian goods subject to fentanyl-related tariffs to 35 per cent, from 25 per cent previously, saying Canada had "failed to cooperate" in curbing illicit narcotics flows into the US. This is contrast to his decision to allow Mexico a 90-day reprieve from higher tariffs to allow time to negotiate. Businesses and analysts said the impact of Trump's new trade regime would not be positive for economic growth. "No real winners in trade conflicts," said Thomas Rupf, co-head Singapore and CIO Asia at VP Bank. "Despite some countries securing better terms, the overall impact is negative."
