New Plymouth District Council rates blunder caused by lack of financial reporting knowledge
Photo:
Taupō District Council / Supplied
An external review following a
New Plymouth District Council rates GST blunder
- which could've cost it $20 million in lost revenue - indicates key managers may not have a sufficiently sophisticated understanding of the rating process and its impacts.
The Simpson Grierson review found the council lacked financial reporting and modelling capability which "strongly suggests a need for training, and possibly recruitment/restructure and training".
Council chief executive Gareth Green conceded an earlier restructure - which saved the district council $10 million - played a part in the error.
"That necessitated some significant pressure being applied through the business.
"I think that pressure along with other pressure points in the local government sector has contributed to this [mistake] occurring, so certainly the pressure that restructure has applied has had an impact, most definitely."
He was instigating another restructure designed to bring more financial and local government experience to council staff.
Green said this would result in a "small number of job losses" due to new positions being created.
He wasn't thinking about falling on his sword.
"I do take full responsibility for this, but I am not tendering my resignation at the current time.
"My total focus at this point is leading this organisation through this situation and making sure we can resolve it in the best possible way."
The Simpson Grierson review also
uncovered two further bungles
.
It revealed the council hiked average residential rates 12.8 percent rather than 9.9 percent as advertised.
The gaffe equated to $102 per ratepayer or $3.1 million.
The review also identified an annual plan wording error relating to industrial water use which could've cost council a further $1.4 million in lost revenue.
In his report, consultant Jonathan Salter said sophisticated knowledge and understanding of the rating process and rating impacts tended to be the domain of specialist officers with a long-standing understanding of the rating function.
These staff were usually intimately familiar with the council's financial reporting and modelling systems, the valuation and rating information database and the district itself, he said.
"There appears to have been a lack of capability in these two areas. This strongly suggests a need for training, and possibly recruitment/restructure and training."
New Plymouth Mayor Neil Holdom.
Photo:
RNZ / Robin Martin
Mayor Neil Holdom said one reason why he called for an independent review when the GST error was discovered was so council could learn from its mistakes.
"I just want to make it clear the councillors - the governance team - made decisions based on information that was incorrect.
"Our long-term plan was audited by Audit NZ and they also didn't pick up this error in our rating calculation model."
Holdom said the proposed restructure would bolster the financial capability and bring people onboard council with local government experience.
The Simpson Grierson report also recommended an independent legal review be a component of the annual rate setting process, and that council not rely on the Audit NZ review alone.
Holdom said an extra-ordinary meeting on 22 July would consider a proposal for future annual-plan and long-term plan calculations to be externally peer reviewed as part of a parcel of steps to address the recent errors.
Salter also wanted the council to review how it handled documents.
"It appears that document management may have been an issue ... the restricted water supply targeted rate issue appears to have arisen from an incorrect 'cut and paste' from another document."
Holdom earlier described the GST blunder as a "typo" and a "cut and paste" error.
The Simpson Grierson consultant also thought council should consider moving away from an average residential rates model to an overall rates model.
"This would be a more transparent and certain disclosure. If there is reference to the 'average' rather than 'overall' rates increase, this concept should be defined."
At the extraordinary council meeting on 22 July, the mayor would recommend councillors approve a one-off rates refund to all residential property owners to ensure the average residential rates increase equalled 9.9 percent.
That would require council to find $3.1 million in savings elsewhere.
Councillors would also vote on amending the rates resolution wording regarding properties on a restricted water flow - usually industrial users - to ensure council was able to charge $418 for each cubic metre of water as intended.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
19 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Surcharges on PayWave etc to be banned
Tapping or swiping your bank cards is about to get cheaper for shoppers, as the government announced it is set to ban surchages for paywave by 2026. The Commerce Commission estimates Kiwis pay about $150 million in card surcharges each year, including up to $65 million in excessive charges. Commerce & Consumer Affairs Minister, Scott Simpson spoke to Lisa Owen. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
19 minutes ago
- RNZ News
One year, 27,850 jobs gone Stats NZ latest data shows
Photo: 123RF New data shows there were 27,850 fewer jobs in New Zealand in June compared to the year before, and young people are feeling the impact of the weak labour market . Stats NZ's latest data shows the number of filled jobs was up 0.1 percent month-on-month but down 1.2 percent year-on-year. Compared to the year before, construction had lost 12,169 jobs, or 6 percent, manufacturing 5850 jobs, or 2.5 percent, professional, scientific and technical services 5150 jobs, or 2.7 percent, and admin and support services 4860 jobs, or 4.7 percent. Education and training and primary industries added jobs. People aged 15 to 19 had 10 percent fewer jobs, those 20 to 24 had 3.5 percent fewer and those ages 25 to 29 had 3.9 percent fewer. Hugh Hawkins, 23, has been looking for a job since finishing an honours degree last year. "Now we're in late July and I've managed to find a tiny bit of casual work through connections of people I know. Otherwise I've been serially ghosted with absolutely no success." Hawkins had set a target of 10 applications a week. "A couple of jobs I was excited for, I felt genuinely directly qualified for, I've gone for and not reached the interview stage. The rejection email often comes with a total of applicants they've had and one I was qualified for had 630 people apply." It seemed a widespread problem, Hawkins said. "Chatting to my coworkers they're virtually all in the same situation. They have to rely on the benefit to pay rent with casual work on the side. People from different walks of life, most young and very qualified…I worked hospitality roles through uni and took volunteer roles and internships relevant to my degree to set myself up as well as possible… if I'm struggling it must mean terrible things for what other people are also going through." Infometrics economists noted that May's month-on-month increase in filled jobs had been revised down in the latest data to a decline. "June's narrow rise could also be revised to flat or negative growth in future releases." Auckland had a 1.9 percent year-on-year fall in filled jobs and Wellington was down 2.3 percent. Canterbury was up 0.1 percent. ASB senior economist Mark Smith said it had been noticeable in the last year or so that young people were being most affected. He said there were likely to be more job losses than the data indicated because some businesses would have added roles during the year. "This is normally a cyclical phenomenon. The hope is that some will go into training if it's available but it's not available for everyone. "The labour market tends to be the last thing to move." He said it was concerning that the revisions in the data in recent months had all been down. "The trend is still falling. It has dragged on… Covid was huge and there are hangovers from that." He said the unemployment rate was likely to move higher in the coming months. Some people who had lost work had dropped out of the labour market, which meant the participation rate fell. The unemployment rate only counts people looking for work. "If that participation rate did not keep falling we would have a much higher unemployment rate, it would be closer to six. "Really the primary sector and the South Island are the good news stories. There is weakness still in the goods sector and the major centres." BNZ chief economist Mike Jones said he still expected the "mid-year activity air pocket" would pass. "The underlying drivers of the recovery remain in place and should reassert themselves in coming quarters. "But the recent weakness does push back the likely timing of the eventual labour market recovery. We doubt the current undershoot of firms' labour requirements relative to worker availability will change appreciably this side of Christmas. Our forecast peak in unemployment has been shunted out to 5.4 percent in the final quarter of the year. Wage growth should thus continue to slow through to the middle of next year." Green Party spokesperson for social development and employment Ricardo Menendez-March called on the government to "take charge and create jobs that help us build a better future". He said the Green Job Guarantee in the party's alternative budget would create 40,000 jobs to rebuild infrastructure, restore nature and build state housing. "We know people out there need opportunities, instead they are being punished and pushed into poverty."
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
One year, 27,850 jobs gone
Photo: 123RF New data shows there were 27,850 fewer jobs in New Zealand in June compared to the year before, and young people are feeling the impact of the weak labour market . Stats NZ's latest data shows the number of filled jobs was up 0.1 percent month-on-month but down 1.2 percent year-on-year. Compared to the year before, construction had lost 12,169 jobs, or 6 percent, manufacturing 5850 jobs, or 2.5 percent, professional, scientific and technical services 5150 jobs, or 2.7 percent, and admin and support services 4860 jobs, or 4.7 percent. Education and training and primary industries added jobs. People aged 15 to 19 had 10 percent fewer jobs, those 20 to 24 had 3.5 percent fewer and those ages 25 to 29 had 3.9 percent fewer. Hugh Hawkins, 23, has been looking for a job since finishing an honours degree last year. "Now we're in late July and I've managed to find a tiny bit of casual work through connections of people I know. Otherwise I've been serially ghosted with absolutely no success." Hawkins had set a target of 10 applications a week. "A couple of jobs I was excited for, I felt genuinely directly qualified for, I've gone for and not reached the interview stage. The rejection email often comes with a total of applicants they've had and one I was qualified for had 630 people apply." It seemed a widespread problem, Hawkins said. "Chatting to my coworkers they're virtually all in the same situation. They have to rely on the benefit to pay rent with casual work on the side. People from different walks of life, most young and very qualified…I worked hospitality roles through uni and took volunteer roles and internships relevant to my degree to set myself up as well as possible… if I'm struggling it must mean terrible things for what other people are also going through." Infometrics economists noted that May's month-on-month increase in filled jobs had been revised down in the latest data to a decline. "June's narrow rise could also be revised to flat or negative growth in future releases." Auckland had a 1.9 percent year-on-year fall in filled jobs and Wellington was down 2.3 percent. Canterbury was up 0.1 percent. ASB senior economist Mark Smith said it had been noticeable in the last year or so that young people were being most affected. He said there were likely to be more job losses than the data indicated because some businesses would have added roles during the year. "This is normally a cyclical phenomenon. The hope is that some will go into training if it's available but it's not available for everyone. "The labour market tends to be the last thing to move." He said it was concerning that the revisions in the data in recent months had all been down. "The trend is still falling. It has dragged on… Covid was huge and there are hangovers from that." He said the unemployment rate was likely to move higher in the coming months. Some people who had lost work had dropped out of the labour market, which meant the participation rate fell. The unemployment rate only counts people looking for work. "If that participation rate did not keep falling we would have a much higher unemployment rate, it would be closer to six. "Really the primary sector and the South Island are the good news stories. There is weakness still in the goods sector and the major centres." BNZ chief economist Mike Jones said he still expected the "mid year activity air pocket" would pass. "The underlying drivers of the recovery remain in place and should reassert themselves in coming quarters. "But the recent weakness does push back the likely timing of the eventual labour market recovery. We doubt the current undershoot of firms' labour requirements relative to worker availability will change appreciably this side of Christmas. Our forecast peak in unemployment has been shunted out to 5.4 percent in the final quarter of the year. Wage growth should thus continue to slow through to the middle of next year." Green Party spokesperson for social development and employment Ricardo Menendez-March called on the government to "take charge and create jobs that help us build a better future". He said the Green Job Guarantee in the party's alternative budget would create 40,000 jobs to rebuild infrastructure, restore nature and build state housing. "We know people out there need opportunities, instead they are being punished and pushed into poverty."
