A ‘small scratch' on a rental leads to a whopping $1,800 bill
I called Enterprise's customer service. The United States representative couldn't find any record of the damage and couldn't help me. Three months later, Enterprise charged my credit card for the full amount of the damage. I disputed the charge with my credit card company, but they are siding with Enterprise.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
How can I defend myself against this false claim?
Advertisement
ERIC WEIMAN,
San Diego
A.
You shouldn't have to pay for damage that didn't exist when you returned the vehicle. You're responsible for the car from the time you pick it up to the time you return it. But after you return it? That's on the company.
You did the right thing by taking a video of the car when you returned it. This gives you some evidence to support your claim. I also recommend taking 'before' photos and videos of the vehicle, just to establish a baseline.
Advertisement
The most confusing part of your case is that you showed the rental location a video of the car you rented, and it appears the car didn't have a scratch. Meanwhile, the photos they showed that allegedly proved you had damaged the car did not identify this particular car as the car you had rented. In other words, it could have been any vehicle in the company's fleet. And when you asked for clarification, Enterprise seemed to double down on its claim.
I think you had one more option: an appeal to an executive at Enterprise. I list the names, numbers, and email addresses of the top customer service executives at Enterprise on my consumer advocacy site, Elliott.org.
I contacted Enterprise on your behalf.
'We take seriously any concerns brought to us by customers and investigate them thoroughly,' a representative told me. 'In this particular instance, damage to the vehicle was not present when the renter took possession of the vehicle, yet was clearly present when the vehicle was processed for return.'
Enterprise says it has a photographic tunnel that is operated by a third party. Vehicles from all rental companies pass through the tunnel in and out of Munich Airport and are photographed for damage. The photos suggest that you returned your car with damage.
'Because of this, we do intend to stand by our charge in this case and pursue the renter for damages,' the Enterprise spokesman said.
Christopher Elliott is the founder of Elliott Advocacy (elliottadvocacy.org), a nonprofit organization that helps consumers solve their problems. Email him at chris@elliott.org or get help by contacting him at elliottadvocacy.org/help/.
Advertisement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
3 days ago
- Boston Globe
American Airlines promises compensation for delay, to no avail
JOSEPH MUSKOVICH, Schaumburg, Ill. A. That's some delay you had. American Airlines did the right thing by providing you with food and overnight accommodations, but you should have also received your legal compensation. Advertisement American is obligated to pay you under the Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up Fortunately, you received a promise in writing from American. (By the way, you did a great job with keeping a paper trail that shows you were owed the money.) When you contacted American, an agent confirmed your request and said that you would receive compensation. Then you followed up, and the agent said the checks were issued, but you never received them. The airline then stopped responding to your requests. Advertisement What's going on? Unfortunately, the European consumer regulations have no provision for requiring a timely payout of compensation. So, American could have theoretically waited as long as it wanted to before sending you the checks. I know, it's a big loophole — and the reason God made consumer advocates. How do you speed things up? Calling can be helpful, but sending a brief, polite email to one of the American Airlines executive contacts might have done the trick. I list all of them on my consumer advocacy site, I contacted American Airlines on your behalf. The airline investigated your case and found that it had made a mistake. The checks were issued but never delivered. American Airlines canceled the old checks and reissued new ones. You received the money a few weeks later. Christopher Elliott is the founder of Elliott Advocacy ( ), a nonprofit organization that helps consumers solve their problems. Email him at chris@ or get help by contacting him at .
New York Times
3 days ago
- New York Times
Help! I Dinged a Rental Car in Europe, and My Credit Card Won't Cover It.
In April 2024, my wife and I reserved a one-day car rental to travel from Lisbon to the Shrine of Fátima, about an hour north. We made the reservation through Enterprise, but it turned out to be with Guerin, a partner. I declined the optional collision damage waiver because my American Express card includes a similar waiver as a benefit if I pay with the card. At some point during the trip, the rear of the car was damaged — I'm not sure how — and Guerin charged me 1,205 euros, then worth just under $1,300. That May, I filed a claim with AMEX Assurance for reimbursement. Among the documents it requested was an 'itemized repair estimate,' but despite my repeated requests, Guerin did not provide one. American Express closed my case in August, though I was told it could be reopened. I continued to try, but by November, I had given up on Guerin and started trying Enterprise in the United States. I called eight times, speaking to eight different representatives between Nov. 4 and Dec. 9, but no one ever got back to me. Can you help? Steven, Nashville I know from painful experience that cajoling a foreign rental car agency to produce the documentation most U.S. credit card benefit programs require can be maddening. And we are not alone. Let's add another example that landed in the Tripped Up inbox soon after yours. In March 2024, Troy from Philadelphia rented a vehicle from Europcar in Zihuatanejo, Mexico, declining the insurance as recommended by his Barclays-issued American Airlines Mastercard. He damaged the car to the tune of $1,671, which seemed to include both the repair and the agency's 'loss of use' while the car was out of service. His claim was handled by Sedgwick, a third-party administrator, which asked him to provide an itemized repair estimate and, later, a fleet log to corroborate the dates the car was out of service. According to a trove of email exchanges he sent me, both he and Sedgwick staff pressured Europcar for months to provide the documents, to no avail. I couldn't quite figure out how to divide up the fault here: Does it lie with the insurance companies for requiring too much documentation, or the car rental agencies for failing to provide it? So I tried to contact everyone: Guerin, Enterprise and Amex (which owns AMEX Assurance) for your case, and Europcar, Barclays and Sedgwick for Troy's. Let's start with you, Steven. Though Guerin never responded to my emails, Enterprise did. Michael Wilmering, a spokesman, emailed to let me know the company had now reached out to you to provide the requested itemized repair estimate, 'which was not available upon his initial request,' he wrote. (I know you made far more than an 'initial' request, but we'll get to that later.) 'While international differences in insurance and repair documentation can create complexities, we are committed to doing our best to assist travelers in navigating these requirements,' he continued. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Motor 1
15-06-2025
- Motor 1
'Hertz Would Never:' Man Gets Pulled Over In a Rental. Then He Reaches For the Enterprise Car's Registration
This man was pulled over by police while driving. But he says it's clearly Enterprise's fault. When you rent a car, you know to inspect the vehicle beforehand for any scratches or damage that you don't want to end up getting blamed (or forced to pay) for. But it wouldn't cross your mind to think twice about the car's paperwork, like whether the inspection is up to date, the car is properly registered, or if it's recently been reported stolen. These rental places are legit businesses after all, and you'd expect everything to be above board. Right? This customer found out the hard way that some rental car companies aren't as responsible as you'd expect them to be, and people jumped in the comment section to back him up. What Happened With Enterprise Rent-A-Car? In a viral video with more than 780,000 views and hundreds of comments, content creator Staś (@staseatsstuff) shared the terrible experience he had with Enterprise Rent-A-Car. Enterprise is one of the largest car rental companies in the world, with more than 9,500 branch offices in nearly 100 countries, according to its website . You can rent anything from a practical SUV to a luxury vehicle for just a weekend or up to a long-term rental. Despite its general reputation for good service, some customers have reported issues like overbooking, lack of vehicle availability, unnecessary upselling, and bad communication. And Staś is here to add another glaring issue to the list. 'What rental place gives you a car with a registration expired?' Staś said. In the background, you could see that there was a cop car pulled up behind him. 'Hertz would NEVER,' he added in the caption. Though commenters assured him that Hertz would do him just as dirty or worse. Can You Auto-Renew Vehicle Registration? Some commenters mentioned that it may be the case that the registration had automatically renewed, but that the car just didn't have the updated sticker on it. Most states make it easy for you to renew your car registration online, by mail, or in person. However, automatic renewal is only offered in some states. Some places require supplementary information, like an inspection or smog test, before re-registering, which makes auto-renewal unfeasible. Check your state's Department of Motor Vehicles website or give them a call to confirm your options. This Happened to Another Person—It Temporarily Ruined Her Life In 2022, a Baltimore woman was given a ticket for driving an Enterprise rental car with expired tags, the Baltimore ABC station WMAR 2 News reported . While the manager at Enterprise assured her that the issue would be taken care of, a couple of months later, she got mail letting her know her license would be suspended if the ticket went unpaid. Corporate then said they'd take care of it, yet a few months later, the woman was pulled over and informed that her license was suspended over the ticket. 'I apparently got a court date that I didn't get in the mail, so I had missed that and got a failure to appear and got a warrant,' she told the television station. Between a lawyer, fees, and court costs, the Enterprise issue ended up costing Bell $3,000 and more than a year of headaches. Commenters React to the Enterprise Headache Several people in the comment section shared their own similar horror stories. 'Enterprise gave me a car they reported stolen the previous day and I was pulled over at gun point. Still suing,' a person shared. 'Enterprise is also known to scam people by claiming damages when there is none,' another alleged. There have been disputed claims of this nature in the past. 'Yep they did the same thing to me! Half way to our vacation, and stopped for gas and noticed it. Called the local office and they said they would take care of the ticket if we got one!' a commenter wrote. It's unclear what came of this creator's experience. Motor1 reached out to Staś for comment via email and Instagram direct message and to Enterprise via email. We'll update this article if either party responds. Now Trending 'Can't Unsee It:' Why Are Drivers Flipping Their Ford Logos Around? 'Watched Too Much Fast & Furious:' MK4 Toyota Supra Evades Police on Highway. Then a Trooper Conducts 'Insane' PIT Maneuver Get the best news, reviews, columns, and more delivered straight to your inbox, daily. back Sign up For more information, read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use . Share this Story Facebook X LinkedIn Flipboard Reddit WhatsApp E-Mail Got a tip for us? Email: tips@ Join the conversation ( )
