Is Pakistan's messaging on India convincing anyone?
India and Pakistan went to war in May this year. The military clashes have ceased, but the narrative battle continues.
In this series, a first of its kind on Al Jazeera, journalist Sreenivasan Jain interviews leading voices from both sides of the border and examines what India's new normal – which Pakistan calls a new 'abnormal' – means for both countries.
In this episode, Jain speaks with Hina Rabbani Khar, a former Pakistani minister and a key face of Pakistan's public diplomacy. Jain asks Khar whether Islamabad has been able to successfully convince the world that India acted like a rogue state, or has its messaging fallen short?
You can also watch Jain's interview with Indian politician Milind Deora here:
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Jazeera
11 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
HASINA – 36 DAYS IN JULY
Al Jazeera's I-Unit has obtained covertly recorded phone calls that reveal how the former prime minister of Bangladesh, Sheikh Hasina, ordered the use of lethal force to crack down on student protesters during the July Uprising in 2024. The investigative programme, 'HASINA – 36 DAYS IN JULY, takes viewers inside the former prime minister's inner circle during the final days of her rule. During the three bloody weeks of demonstrations fifteen hundred people were killed, over twenty-five thousand were injured, and more than three million rounds of ammunition were fired by Sheikh Hasina's security forces. The calls made by Sheikh Hasina were recorded by her own spy agency, a ruthless network that helped her rule Bangladesh with an iron grip. The Al Jazeera investigation exposes how the spies who used to protect her recorded evidence of a regime now charged with committing 'systemic atrocities.' In one recording on 18 July 2024, Sheikh Hasina tells the former mayor of Dhaka South, Sheikh Fazle Noor Taposh: 'my instructions have already been given. I've issued an open order completely. Now they will use lethal weapons, shoot wherever they find them .....That has been instructed, I have stopped them so far….I was thinking about the students' safety.' Recordings also reveals her use of helicopters to suppress the protests from the air:'….wherever they notice any gathering it's from above—now it's being done from above—it has already started in several places. It has begun. Some have moved.' In the film, a doctor validates the claims that many protestors were killed and wounded by gunfire from helicopters. The programme further reveals how the Awami League government used threats and bribes to cover up the police killing of student Abu Sayed; his death provoked national outrage. Secret calls reveal how Sheikh Hasina's most powerful ally, Salman F Rahman, tried to obtain Sayed's post-mortem report. We reveal how it was changed five times to erase any mention of guns, and how his family, fearing for their lives, were made to meet Sheikh Hasina on state television. The programme further reveals how the Awami League government resorted to threats and bribes in an attempt to conceal the police killing of student Abu Sayed, whose death provoked national outrage. Secret recordings show that Sheikh Hasina's most influential ally, Salman F Rahman, sought to obtain Sayed's post-mortem report, how it was altered five times to remove any reference to the use of firearms in his death, and how Sayed's family were compelled to meet Sheikh Hasina on state television out of fear for their safety. Leaked confidential documents accessed by Al Jazeera's Investigative Unit exposes the dirty tricks used by Hasina's government to shut down the internet and stop the bloody images of the violence from reaching the world. In a statement to Al Jazeera, an Awami League spokesperson said Sheikh Hasina has never used the phrase, 'lethal weapons', and did not specifically authorise or direct the security forces to use lethal force. It disputes the authenticity of the 18 July 2024 recording. It also said it was sorry if the family of Abu Sayed felt intimidated but the former government's resolve to investigate potential misconduct, including by security forces, was genuine. It stated that Sheikh Hasina believed the internet was shut down by damage caused by protestors. 'HASINA – 36 DAYS IN JULY' will be aired on Al Jazeera English on 24 July 2025 at 12:00 GMT, and will also be available on YouTube at the following link.
Al Jazeera
2 days ago
- Al Jazeera
Pakistan arrests 13 suspects as ‘honour killing' video goes viral
Islamabad, Pakistan – Pakistani authorities have arrested at least 13 individuals, including a tribal leader, in connection with the killing of a couple in the southwestern province of Balochistan. The arrests followed nationwide outrage over a video depicting the murders went viral on social media, with many calling it yet another case of 'honour killing' – a phenomenon reported from across South Asia. The first information report (FIR) filed by the police on Monday identifies the couple as Bano Bibi and her husband Ehsan Ullah, and says they were likely killed in May near Balochistan's capital Quetta. Honour killings, mainly reported from Pakistan and India, often arise from perceived family, tribal or caste dishonour, especially in love marriages, in which the two partners marry without the consent of their families or tribe, or elope. Many such killings go unreported. Balochistan police official Syed Suboor Agha told Al Jazeera they are investigating the matter and are likely to make more arrests, including Bano's brother, who is suspected of the murders and 'is still at large'. The viral videos of the killings show a group of armed men gathered around vehicles in a deserted area. Bano is ordered by the crowd to stand away from the vehicles as the couple is pumped with bullets, even on their motionless bodies lying bleeding on the sand. The FIR names eight suspects while also listing 15 other unidentified suspects involved in the incident. According to the FIR, the couple was allegedly brought before local tribal leader Sardar Sherbaz Khan, who declared them guilty of engaging in an 'immoral relationship' and ordered that they be killed. 'Tyranny of medieval practices' Pakistan has a dismal record on 'honour killings' and other forms of violence against women. According to Sustainable Social Development Organisation (SSDO), an Islamabad-based independent organisation, more than 32,000 cases of gender-based violence were reported nationwide in 2024, including 547 instances of 'honour killings' – 32 of them in Balochistan and only one resulting in conviction. Harris Khalique, general secretary of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), the country's leading rights watchdog, said the killings in the name of honour confirm the 'tyranny of medieval practices' still entrenched in many parts of Pakistan. 'The state, instead of establishing the rule of law and ensure the right to life of its citizens, has protected the tribal chiefs and feudal lords who guard such practices to perpetuate their power over local people and resources,' Khalique told Al Jazeera. Mineral-rich Balochistan, Pakistan's largest but least populous province, has also witnessed decades of conflict between the government and ethnic Baloch separatists, who demand secession from the country. Rights activist Sammi Deen Baloch, also a member of a Baloch women's rights group, said killing of women has become 'a matter of routine' in the province. 'In Balochistan, women are murdered for love, disappeared for protest, and buried under layers of tribal authority and state-backed silence. These are not isolated tragedies. They are the cost of a system designed to keep Balochistan obedient, and its women expendable,' she told Al Jazeera. Baloch said the government would not have acted on the murders had the video not gone viral. 'Baloch women are trapped between two forms of violence: the brutality of tribal patriarchy, and the cold repression of the state. One kills in silence, the other kills in the name of law,' she said. 'The state's refusal to democratise Balochistan isn't accidental. It is policy. By outsourcing governance to feudal strongmen, the state keeps the region controlled, its women disposable, and its dissent criminal.'
Al Jazeera
3 days ago
- Al Jazeera
Pakistan arrests over a dozen suspects as ‘honour killing' video goes viral
Islamabad, Pakistan – Pakistani authorities have arrested at least 13 individuals, including a tribal leader, in connection with the killing of a couple in the southwestern province of Balochistan. The arrests followed nationwide outrage over a video depicting the murders went viral on social media, with many calling it yet another case of 'honour killing' – a phenomenon reported from across South Asia. The first information report (FIR) filed by the police on Monday identifies the couple as Bano Bibi and her husband Ehsan Ullah, and says they were likely killed in May near Balochistan's capital Quetta. Honour killings, mainly reported from Pakistan and India, often arise from perceived family, tribal or caste dishonour, especially in love marriages, in which the two partners marry without the consent of their families or tribe, or elope. Many such killings go unreported. Balochistan police official Syed Suboor Agha told Al Jazeera they are investigating the matter and are likely to make more arrests, including Bano's brother, who is suspected of the murders and 'is still at large'. The viral videos of the killings show a group of armed men gathered around vehicles in a deserted area. Bano is ordered by the crowd to stand away from the vehicles as the couple is pumped with bullets, even on their motionless bodies lying bleeding on the sand. The FIR names eight suspects while also listing 15 other unidentified suspects involved in the incident. According to the FIR, the couple was allegedly brought before local tribal leader Sardar Sherbaz Khan, who declared them guilty of engaging in an 'immoral relationship' and ordered that they be killed. 'Tyranny of medieval practices' Pakistan has a dismal record on 'honour killings' and other forms of violence against women. According to Sustainable Social Development Organisation (SSDO), an Islamabad-based independent organisation, more than 32,000 cases of gender-based violence were reported nationwide in 2024, including 547 instances of 'honour killings' – 32 of them in Balochistan and only one resulting in conviction. Harris Khalique, general secretary of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), the country's leading rights watchdog, said the killings in the name of honour confirm the 'tyranny of medieval practices' still entrenched in many parts of Pakistan. 'The state, instead of establishing the rule of law and ensure the right to life of its citizens, has protected the tribal chiefs and feudal lords who guard such practices to perpetuate their power over local people and resources,' Khalique told Al Jazeera. Mineral-rich Balochistan, Pakistan's largest but least populous province, has also witnessed decades of conflict between the government and ethnic Baloch separatists, who demand secession from the country. Rights activist Sammi Deen Baloch, also a member of a Baloch women's rights group, said killing of women has become 'a matter of routine' in the province. 'In Balochistan, women are murdered for love, disappeared for protest, and buried under layers of tribal authority and state-backed silence. These are not isolated tragedies. They are the cost of a system designed to keep Balochistan obedient, and its women expendable,' she told Al Jazeera. Baloch said the government would not have acted on the murders had the video not gone viral. 'Baloch women are trapped between two forms of violence: the brutality of tribal patriarchy, and the cold repression of the state. One kills in silence, the other kills in the name of law,' she said. 'The state's refusal to democratise Balochistan isn't accidental. It is policy. By outsourcing governance to feudal strongmen, the state keeps the region controlled, its women disposable, and its dissent criminal.'
