Public servant who nicknamed German colleague 'Helga' is reprimanded after workplace clash
Nikki Hornberg took the Department of Transport and Main Roads in Warwick to the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (QIRC) after being pulled up on her behaviour on March 11.
She argued the reprimand and extra training she was given after 'mocking' her 'abrupt' German colleague and using the phrase 'Nein, Nein' was unfair.
But QIRC Commissioner John Dwyer disagreed with Ms Hornberg and ruled the reprimand was fair in a decision handed down on July 17.
He stated Ms Hornberg, who worked as a 'project costing officer', had been racially stereotyping her German co-worker.
The colleague in question reportedly spoke with a strong German accent, but was not named Helga.
'The use of the name 'Helga' when referring to the co-worker in question is enough, of itself, to justify the sanction imposed,' he concluded, as reported by the Courier Mail.
Ms Hornberg did not deny that she referred to her German colleague as Helga behind her back.
The colleague has not officially complained about the nickname or was unaware of it.
TMR managers who knew about the nickname were said to be 'inept', Mr Dwyer stated.
He also said the claim Ms Hornberg used the phrase 'Nein, Nein' was not 'particularly strong'.
However, the allegation would stand as Ms Hornberg had not appealed that finding.
'Taking into account a permissive attitude or management ineptitude, it is plain from the evidence (including Ms Hornberg's own concessions) that she was using the name 'Helga' discourteously and disrespectfully,' he wrote.
Mr Dwyer said Ms Hornberg should have been aware of the negative connotations of the nickname and should not have needed a manager to tell her to refrain from using it.
'There can be no doubt the choice of the name 'Helga' is a form of racial stereotyping,' Mr Dwyer added.
The judge ruled that the simple reason Ms Hornberg chose not to address her colleague with the nickname proves that her intention was one of 'mocking'.
Witnesses interviewed during the investigation alleged Ms Hornberg clashed with her German co-worker over a particular entry in a time sheet.
Ms Hornberg's behaviour towards her colleague changed following this disagreement.
The judge noted witnesses agreed the German colleague was also 'abrupt in her communication style'.
Several witnesses, including a manager, did not think Ms Hornberg's use of the name 'Helga' was offensive, which Mr Dwyer described as 'concerning'.
Ms Hornberg argued the conduct issue should have been dealt with by TMR as a 'performance issue' at a local level and should not have been escalated to a disciplinary issue.
Mr Dwyer stated this proved Ms Hornberg's 'troubling lack of insight … into the objective seriousness of her conduct'.
It also showed she was oblivious to the potential legal consequences for TMR as her name-calling created a risk her colleague could sue TMR for discrimination.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Jaw-dropping discovery revealed at the lavish penthouse of mysterious 23-year-old woman accused of crashing her Tiffany blue Rolls Royce into Kyle Sandilands' chauffeur while drunk
A young woman who crashed her luxury Rolls-Royce 4WD in Sydney 's eastern suburbs while allegedly drunk is the owner of a second Rolls-Royce - that's parked in the garage of her ritzy penthouse apartment. LanLan Yang, was involved in a high-speed, head-on collision at 3.30am on Saturday along New South Head Road in Rose Bay, when she smashed her Tiffany blue Rolls Royce Cullinan - understood to be worth about $600,000 - into a Mercedes. NSW Police allege the 23-year-old veered onto the wrong side of the road and slammed into a Mercedes van driven by George Plassaras - the 52-year-old chauffeur to radio shock jock Kyle Sandilands, who was not inside. Daily Mail Australia can reveal Yang also owns an unregistered White Rolls Royce Ghost Convertible parked in her modern apartment building's underground carpark. The garage uses a car lift that can only take 3,000kg, which is likely why she opted to park her other luxury vehicle - that costs more than many people's houses - on her residential street instead of keeping it undercover. While very little is known about Yang or how she obtained her substantial wealth, neighbours from her upmarket building in Sydney's east described her as 'polite' and 'shy' when they were approached by Daily Mail Australia. They also added the young resident, who occupies the building's prized penthouse apartment, decorated her car with the mega-exclusive Labubu toys. 'She decorates the front of the car with those Labubu's - it's cute,' the neighbor revealed. Another neighbour added she was rarely seen at the property. On Monday, radio shock-jock Sandilands revealed on KIIS FM's Kyle & Jackie O show that his chauffeur was the man involved in the collision and that he was left with 'multiple broken bones'. 'You may have seen over the weekend, it was all over the news, a head-on collision in Rose Bay in Sydney with a Rolls-Royce and a Mercedes,' he told listeners. 'Well, that was my driver, George.' The 54-year-old added that while the Rolls-Royce driver walked away 'unscathed', George was left with serious injuries. These included a broken spine, broken ribs, a ruptured spleen and diaphragm, a torn open abdomen, two broken hips and two broken femurs. Kyle said that George was the 'greatest employee ever' thanks to his actions following the accident. 'What did [he] say when he was taken away in the ambulance? He asked for his mobile phone so he could do what?' he added. 'This is a guy at 4.30 in the morning after he has been cut out of his vehicle, he's been trapped in his van for an hour, this poor bloke. 'And he tells the ambo: ''Get my phone so I can make sure Kyle's all right for the week.'',' he said. George, who runs Dakota Limousines, was trapped in the wreckage as witnesses rushed to call triple zero. He could be heard yelling for help inside the crushed vehicle, as emergency crews from NSW Police Rescue and Fire and Rescue NSW worked to free him. The crash was captured on nearby CCTV which appeared to show Yang's luxury SUV allegedly veering into oncoming traffic before the violent collision. Police allege Yang carried out a roadside breath test, which returned a positive result, and she was arrested at the scene. At Waverley Police Station, she allegedly refused to undergo a breath analysis. Yang was charged with causing bodily harm by misconduct, being in charge of a motor vehicle, and refusing or failing to submit to breath analysis. She was granted conditional bail and ordered to surrender her passport. Under the strict conditions, she has been prohibited from driving a car and must remain at her home in Sydney's east between 8pm and 6am daily. The vehicle and his are being held in a secure lot in Alexandria pending a police investigation Yang is scheduled to appear at Downing Centre Local Court on August 15.
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Footy fan is hailed as a hero after helping save the life of player who dodged death by MILLIMETRES in horror on-field incident
A footy fan has been labelled a hero after helping save the life of a 25-year-old player who broke his neck in a tackle during a rugby league match in Central Queensland. Matthew Broomham escaped death by a 'matter of millimetres' according to one neurosurgeon, after being tackled just moments into the second half of a reserve grade match between Wallaby Rugby League Football Club and Norths at Rockhampton's Gymmy Grounds last week. The fullback was left lying motionless on his back but thanks to the quick thinking of first aid officer Gary Churchward, he may have been saved from suffering a more serious injury. The medic quickly rushed onto the field despite not having seen the incident take place. He took immediate action realising the seriousness of the situation after Broomham had told him he had some pain in his neck and had heard a crack during the tackle. Churchward, who had gained his Level One first aid certification just six months ago, quickly immobilised Broomham's neck and head as they waited for paramedics to arrive. The first aid officer remained by the 25-year-old's side for over 30 minutes, and was later praised by Matthew's dad, Jason, for his quick thinking that 'saved him from being paralysed'. 'Thankfully, Gary being so vigilant in keeping Matthew on the ground and not letting his head move, even a millimetre, has saved him from being paralysed… or worse,' Jason Broomham told The Daily Telegraph. Gary recounted what happened, revealing that Matthew was 'calm and chatty' despite the horror incident. 'I ran out to Matt and he told me briefly what happened. He said he had a sore neck and he'd heard a crack,' Churchward told the outlet. 'As soon as you hear that, you don't take any risks, and I immediately immobilised his neck. 'You lie down head to head, put your arms up beside his head and across his ears and you almost grip his shoulders and squeeze your arms together very gently on the side of his head to keep it still.' Fortunately, Matthew said to Gary he had no numbness and was able to move his toes and fingers. While they waited for the paramedics, Gary spoke to the 25-year-old about his work, his family and even his tattoos. Upon arriving at the footy pitch, paramedics fitted Matthew with a neck brace before taking him to the Rockhampton Hospital. An MRI revealed that Matthew had broken his C2 vertebrae, with doctors telling his dad Jason and wife Jodie that their son had suffered what's known as a 'hangman's fracture'. 'The neurosurgeons that we spoke to, in Rockhampton and here (in Brisbane), said he was lucky to be alive,' Jason said. 'If he had any more artery damage, he would have died on the field. 'The way that he was hit in the tackle resembled a car crash injury. He was hit down, as well as across. We're very, very lucky to have him here. 'Every time we speak to a neurosurgeon, they say it was a matter of millimetres.' Matthew was later flown to the Royal Brisbane Women's Hospital, where he underwent further examinations. Jason told the outlet that because of Matthew's age, doctors opted against surgery, instead fitting the 25-year-old with a halo vest. 'Hello everyone. Matthew has been placed into a halo vest. He will be in this for at least three months while his neck heals,' Jason, who was at the match, wrote on Instagram. 'This is great news as he didn't have to have surgery. 'Thank you to everyone who has helped Matt, this is the first step in a long recovery process, but we will do it together.' A halo vest is a device that attaches itself around a person's chest and shoulders. Several supports rise up from the vest and are attached to a halo ring, which positions itself around a person's skull using several metal pins. The device is designed to immobilise the spine by preventing any damaging movement of the head and neck, allowing the spinal bones to heal. Jason revealed that while Matthew has a 'long road ahead', he added he was 'grateful that Matthew should be able to make a full recovery' following treatment. In an inspiring turn of events, Matthew was discharged five days after being admitted to hospital and has been walking with assistance. Meanwhile, the Wallaby Rugby League Football Club have started a GoFundMe page to support Matthew and his family while he recovers from the injury. Brendon Hunt, the president of the club, began the appeal online, which has, at the time of writing, raised $10,790, to help cover the burden of the footy player's rehabilitation expenses, inability to work and his travel and accommodation for treatment. 'Matt has sustained a fractured neck and now faces a long and challenging road to recovery, including extensive rehabilitation and ongoing medical appointments,' Hunt wrote. His dad, Jason, delivered an update that Matthew would not be needing surgery on the injury 'Sadly, this also means he will be unable to work for the coming months, placing a significant financial burden on him and his family.' He added: 'Matt is a tough competitor, a loyal teammate, and a valued member of our club and community. Now it's our turn to rally around him. 'Any contribution, no matter how small, will make a meaningful difference in helping Matt focus on his recovery without the added stress of financial hardship.' Gary, meanwhile, did not want to take credit for his heroics, instead urging other people to become medical officers. He had retired from playing rugby league last year but wanted to stay around the club by becoming a first aid officer. 'I definitely can't take credit for it, I just happened to be the first one there,' he said. He also praised the club's Level Two first aid officer Amanda Twigge, who had initially raised his attention to the injury. 'I was just doing what I signed up to do and what I was trained to do. 'If I wasn't there, Amanda would have done exactly the same thing.' Paramedics subsequently fitted Matthew with a neck brace and took him to
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Real estate agent turns on his industry to blast 'fake' tactics being used to fool buyers and drive up prices
A real estate agent has hit out at the 'fake' tactics used by some industry colleagues, which has led to Aussies having a less than flattering perception of the sector. Jordan Bulmer, 30, is a sales agent at McGrath in Terrigal, on the NSW Central Coast, and he's set on exposing some of the hated tactics used by his colleagues. First and foremost, the agent took to TikTok to address the 'fake offer' strategy. He blasted the trick as being increasingly used by some in the industry to drive up the price of a property. Mr Bulmer said he's 'not into this' as he hit out at those who use this tactic. 'The minute a person makes an offer there is suddenly another offer on the table, I don't know why agents do this,' he said. 'If someone comes to me and says, 'Has there been an offer on the property?' and there hasn't, I say, 'No, there hasn't'. I haven't found the right person, there doesn't have to be an offer on every property.' Mr Bulmer said he would then discuss with his client the options if they were interested in buying the property. He stated he would want to find a price where 'everybody's happy' and warned other agents against 'fake offers'. The agent was flooded with comments from Aussies who have subjected to this underhand tactic. One commented: 'We had an agent try that scam so we told the particular agent great sell it to them. 'Then for the next couple of days they kept calling saying come on let's make the sale. We them blocked their number.' 'I had this,' another agreed. 'I made an offer. Was told there was a better offer. Kept being 'Outbid'. That was the first time I got scammed by an agent. 'Funnily enough, after about a week after I realised what was going on and pulled out. I got a call asking if I was still interested at my last offer amount. Nope.' Someone else wrote: 'I put an offer in the agent said there are two other buyers so I kept upping the offer and they kept pushing till I said I'm out. 'They ring back the next day saying the other buyers have dropped out so do you want the property. Yeah nah I'll pass thanks.' Mr Bulmer said there's 'no need' for agents to use 'fake' tactics when selling a property. 'I don't understand why some agents do some of the things that frustrate the living daylights out of people. I just don't get it,' he told 'Like as if real estate agents, after all this time, can't tell that people know that they're playing games. It blows my mind sometimes. 'I find that just such a silly thing to do, but it seems to happen so much.' Mr Bulmer said he's trying show his clients they can trust him by being transparent and hopes to proof that not all real estate agents use underhand tactics to make a sale. Fellow real estate agent and auctioneer Tom Panos agreed that fake tactics are unnecessary and only serve to damage perceptions of the industry. He pointed out the tactic of 'catfish homes' in which real estate agents post edited images of properties on their website listings to make them look better than they do in person. 'A real estate agent has an ethical responsibility to get the best price for the vendor (seller) who is their client and pays them. So it really is buyer beware,' he said. Another tactic he said was to door-knock a street where there is an auction set to take place and invite the neighbours to stop by on auction day, thus building an illusion that the property is more hotly contested. Similarly, when buyers register to bid on auction day they might give them bidding numbers that are higher than the actual bidders. 'So instead of one, two, three they might say 10, 11, 12,' he said. He encouraged buyers to undertake their own research before agreeing to purchase a property by looking at comparable prices on property sites like Corelogic and consulting with building inspectors who can check for defects. 'People often more research planning a holiday or buying a car than they do buying a property.'
